A video recording taken inside someone's private home is a world away from a single data point of a car's number plate being noted in a public location at a given date and time.
You've actually made public surveillance sound entirely reasonable. This is not the answer I was hoping for! :)
A video camera in a private home would have a far higher chance of catching crimes in progress than a number plate camera ever did.
So he hasn't done anything to make public surveillance sound entirely reasonable but you're just getting out of it what you want to hear.
The scale:
- kill everybody (crimerate: 0)
- lock everybody up (only crimes committed in prison: probably pretty high)
- total surveillance (crimerate: pretty much what it is today but with a higher rate of solved crimes)
- moderate surveillance (crimerate: pretty much what it is today but with a lower rate of solved crimes)
- no surveillance (crimerate: pretty much what it is today but with an even lower rate of solved crimes, good old policework required to solve a crime, or stupidity on the part o the criminal (probably the majority))
I don't see much difference between total surveillance and no surveillance at all when it comes to the actual crime rate, only to the number of crimes solved and in what way they'll be solved.
Assuming that the majority of the crimes is committed by 'first offenders' is probably a mistake on my part so once all the criminals are safely locked up we can get rid of the surveillance, right?
Surveillance never was about crime. That's just how it is slowly pushed so you can't object against it, after all, who in their right mind wants more crime?
On the flip side, you're also ignoring the opportunity for abuse of surveillance, which it may make sense to consider additional crime.
Most people are decent and most criminals are not smart enough to evaluate their chances of getting caught rationally, if they did then the prisons wouldn't be as full as they are.
The chances of getting caught if you're committing a crime are plenty high as it is, and yet we still have repeat offenders. As rule criminals are not capable of seeing the consequences of their actions, don't know the penalties for the crimes they commit and are frequently not even in control of what they're doing.
It's a complex situation, but surveillance does not seem - to me - to be a major factor. If it were then the crimerate in London would be around 0 today.
Like mandatory schooling, starting at school level, going through to public/national mandatory TV time. Lets say 10 minutes a day in public/national TV in prime time. Where 5 could be spent on science and teaching and another 5 on social schooling. Quick facts and information.
And not something like in Europe right now, where everyone is possible predator. Just proper education created by top specialists, not direct blaming and scaring, but using psychological tricks to make people understand what is wrong and where to look for help. There are countries that figured this out, where violence is not tolerated, like Sweden, Norway...
80% of sexual abuse of minors happens within existing social contexts, that is "family and friends".
It would be useful to place cameras in every single private room and have them be automatically monitored and the live feed passed to some on-staff LEO when software considers anything suspect.
Are you at peace with that? If so, why? If not, why not?
(Yes, it's an extreme example. Both in terms of privacy intrusion and in the potential of helping law enforcement with a 'worthy cause'. It's why I think this example is particularly helpful to consider one's position)