News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by dllthomas on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:47PM (#8835770)
You're assuming that a higher chance of being caught has no deterrent effect. My understanding is that this is very much not the case.

On the flip side, you're also ignoring the opportunity for abuse of surveillance, which it may make sense to consider additional crime.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by jacquesm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:53PM (#8835790)
I don't subscribe to the view of humanity that we'd all be raging maniacs if we knew that we wouldn't get caught.

Most people are decent and most criminals are not smart enough to evaluate their chances of getting caught rationally, if they did then the prisons wouldn't be as full as they are.

The chances of getting caught if you're committing a crime are plenty high as it is, and yet we still have repeat offenders. As rule criminals are not capable of seeing the consequences of their actions, don't know the penalties for the crimes they commit and are frequently not even in control of what they're doing.

It's a complex situation, but surveillance does not seem - to me - to be a major factor. If it were then the crimerate in London would be around 0 today.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by dllthomas on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:20PM (#8835894)
You make two errors of the same form. It need neither be the case that a zero chance of being caught means a 100% (or even "high") chance of committing crime, nor that a 100% chance of being caught means a zero chance of committing crime, for there to be a monotonic relationship between increased chance of being caught and decreased chance of crime.