However, this rate cannot be directly compared with a bond coupon rate. Bond coupons are cash flows that are not automatically reinvested/compounded.
Even if one were to reinvest them, one would have to reinvest at the prevailing yields at the time the cash flows were received, a somewhat more involved calculation. So that 2.5%-4.0% coupon rate does not represent an annually-compounded rate and thus is not directly comparable to a CAGR.
Apples and oranges, so to speak.
The fixed price was set by Newton, btw.
Simple interest, not reinvested: £42.32 Compount interest: £25,622.49
As the parent poster pointed out, the actual return for a bond bought in 1720 depends on what the holder did with the returns.
Whereas with gold, merely holding £4.31 worth of gold from 1720 would yield £768 of gold today.
I found this calculation interesting in that it demonstrates the true power of compound interest if maintained. Of course, such a return is actually very hard to maintain over a 300 century timespan.
You mean 3 century timespan, or 300 years. (Although it would be spectacularly difficult over a 300 century timespan.)
But the way to compare that would have been to look at the "total return", i.e. assuming coupons had been reinvested, etc. (For example, there is an S&P 500 total return index whose growth reflects the theoretical reinvestment of all received dividends) I don't know if there is such a metric for these gilts, but if there is, then that total return rate would be more or less directly comparable to the CAGR for gold.
(Side note: Total return may not always apply in the real world, as the cash flows received may not be sufficient for reinvestment. Simple example: A bond with a face value of $1,000, coupon of 5%, payable each year. Assume that new bonds are issued each year with the same face value and that the face value is also the minimum purchase amount. Your yearly coupon of $50 from the original bond is not enough to buy new bonds and so it remains uninvested. Things like mutual funds/bond funds/bond ETFs attempt to solve this problem by allowing you to reinvest small amounts, albeit at the expense of charging you a management fee.)
The article does not claim that UK bonds have been paying 2.5~4% since 1720. That range refers to the current nominal rate for those bonds. Those bonds have been restructured/refinanced several times along the years. That is, the UK "soft-defaulted" a few times.
Sovereign bonds aren't risk-free, especially not in the very long term.
Related : in the finance industry, there's a term called basis points (written bps, pronounced "bips"). 1 bps = 1/100th of a percentage. So that 0.20% is actually 20 bps, a royal magnitude in this new perspective of compounding :-)
So a 6.7% increase in intrest rate (3.2 vs 3.0) makes a 79% difference in return after 300 years.
I believe you never really own a property in GB. I think you own it for 99 years and then it goes back to the crown.
After a disastrous attempt at a poll tax, the system was renamed "council tax" for residential property. It's banded, so very high value property is under taxed. e.g. http://www.theguardian.com/money/2012/mar/09/council-tax-in-...
You can own a £10m property in the borough, earning upwards of £1m per year in rental income and appreciation, and only have to pay £2k to the local council.
Meanwhile, those living in the absolute worst accommodation in the borough still have to pay £711.19.
Why should someone who's lived in a property for decades be taxed out of their house just because the area they live in has become a desirable area?
To your actual point, to tax someone out of a £10m home in London today the council tax rate would have to be increased many thousands of times over. That is not a realistic danger.
This policy is seeing a resurgence of popular support in the form of the 'Mansion tax', but really all we need is a more equitable council tax.
Note that, in theory, a secondary function of the council tax should be to prevent habitable properties being left unoccupied for extended periods of time.
Unfortunately when the tax amounts to a rounding error on the ROI for a property, it is completely ineffectual. Hence the large number of empty 'investment' properties in London, further inflating an already overheated property market.
Furthermore, there is no moral right to ineritance.
We tried that. It didn't work.
So despite the huge depreciation of the UK pound over almost 300 years, buying UK bonds in 1720 was a much better investment than gold.
And yet buying a property in London probably would have been an even better investment - a 'barrel store' in Picadilly cost about £2,500 [2]. Today it might be worth 10,000 times as much, giving a compound return of 3.2% per year plus a significant rental income.
[1] http://www.measuringworth.com/
[2] http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/review...