News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by jacquesm on Sunday December 28, 2014 @06:09PM (#8807824)
Makes you wonder how long it will take - if ever - to pay off our current collective debts.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by mkramlich on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:29PM (#8808034)
I think the US gov has become too addicted, structurally and incentive-wise, to this hack which lets them spend more each year than they take in organically through taxes/fees/etc.

I can not realistically picture them ever paying the debt off or going back to a zero deficit. I bet the most likely endgame will be some kind of future war against The Bad Guys (which they'll make sure to do sufficient propaganda demonization against for the low-brow general public) and then they could use that situation to justify "retiring" (not honoring) the debt. There is historical precedent. And while there are many good and honest human beings working throughout the US gov it would be a naive mistake to think the most important decisions are made by "good" people. History suggests the opposite. In (almost) all countries. Throughout history. And again, ignore words. Any words that come out of a politician's mouth just ignore. Only weigh actions, results and tangibles. Looking at those, the weight of evidence suggests they'll never eliminate the yearly deficit or debt. Just keep increasing it until some huge "oopsie!" reset excuse is found. The kind that will likely involve much loss of blood by the working/labor/non-wealthy classes, world-wide

That's the historical record, reinforced many times over millenia.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by themartorana on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:47PM (#8808079)
We did it not that long ago. Not only did the Clinton administration balance the budget but drew a surplus from 1998-2001. [0]

Of course tax receipts were much higher as we were in a bull market and had very low unemployment. Since then, a tech bubble burst, we hopped in to numerous endless wars, and Wall St. sent half the world tumbling in to recession or depression and the housing market collapsed.

But it's not that far fetched that it could happen again.

[0] http://www.factcheck.org/2008/02/the-budget-and-deficit-unde...

Edit: this is speaking to zero deficit, not zero debt.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by minot on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:07PM (#8808277)
I'd go as far as to say that a zero debt situation is worrisome. It'd mean that we don't have anything (such as infrastructure) that we'd like to spend money on... It'd mean that the situation is bleak for everyone.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by bunderbunder on Sunday December 28, 2014 @10:46PM (#8808468)
It wouldn't mean that; the gov't could always just plunk down cash on things like infrastructure development. If the cash on hand isn't available, then run a budget surplus in order to save up money.

But there are arguments to be made that, assuming a healthy economy, it's better to borrow and spend than it is to save and spend for anything that's worth the money.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by logfromblammo on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:23AM (#8810108)
Except you can't assume a healthy economy if no one has any savings to spend.

In a healthy economy, people save their surplus in expansions and spend it in recessions, or for larger purchases.

Interest on debt means that the return on investment for projects financed by debt must be positive even after the interest payments, or the debt cannot be paid off. What I often see is that municipalities will do something stupid, like pay for a new, oversized sewage treatment plant, using bonds, and then the very optimistic growth in the sewer system does not occur, and people end up paying $500/month water bills for a plant running at 10% of capacity.

You can't borrow if no one has anything to lend.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by judk on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:57AM (#8810248)
You can always borrow people's labor. That's all fiat money is.

Print some money, give it out, borrow it, pay idle people to work.

This only fails if everyone is already working but failing to save, because they are only generating subsistence value from their labor.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by judk on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:55AM (#8810244)
You are mistakenly believing that money exists like wool or oil or lumber or stone. It doesn't. Money is imaginary. It is simply an IOU to be exchanged for labor or services. It is subject to inflation if a society amasses too much, unlike durable goods which can be stockpiled until you have enough.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by tempestn on Monday December 29, 2014 @12:26AM (#8808645)
Agreed. Zero debt really doesn't make sense as a goal, and this British bond repayment illustrates the case that if all goes well, inflation eventually reduces a constant debt to irrelevance. (Although it may take a few centuries.) That said, of course debt reduction still certainly has value, as there is obviously such a thing as too much debt.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by jacques_chester on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:41AM (#8809926)
Debt for capital spending has a different character from debt for recurrent spending.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by jlarocco on Sunday December 28, 2014 @11:31PM (#8808549)
He balanced the budget and had a surplus for those years, but the problem is, we'd need to maintain the Clinton era surpluses for 90+ years to actually pay off our current debt.

I'd love to see it happen, but it doesn't seem likely.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by Amezarak on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:01PM (#8808260)
> I can not realistically picture them ever paying the debt off or going back to a zero deficit

"Back" was a long, long time ago. Nevertheless it is probable the deficit will be subsumed by growth nin the immediate future.

> . I bet the most likely endgame will be some kind of future war against The Bad Guys (which they'll make sure to do sufficient propaganda demonization against for the low-brow general public) and then they could use that situation to justify "retiring" (not honoring) the debt.

There doesn't need to be any "endgame" or debt retirement: this is a fundamental misunderstanding. The government is continually paying off old debt and issuing new debt as the US economy grows and government revenues increase. There is no big pile of debt which is continually accumulating and never paid off: the debt is paid off every single time a bond is redeemed. (Nevermind the fact that inflation reduces the amount of debt in the first place! The national debt as a percentage of GDP exceeded its modern numbers in 1945, but it was inflated away.) People often speak of the debt being "called in": this fundamental truth also happens to explain why that can't happen. A bond comes due when it is due, not when you want your money back.

The situation is, indeed, entirely sustainable, unless you disbelieve the evidence of history and mainstream economics. Furthermore, the US government actually owes much of its debt it itself. The government owes itself 5 trillion dollars. This is pretty much just a silly accounting trick: the government could poof all that debt away and nobody would be the wiser so long as the government still funded the programs (such as Social Security) that bought those bonds. And since the government is the sole producer of US dollars, it should not find that too difficult.

There's also the present reality that not borrowing money at the present interest rates would be insane. Real interest rates on federal debt are near-zero and have actually gone negative at some points. People are literally paying the government to hold their money. [1]

You can go even more extreme and consider MMT. There is logic to it, though I suspect human psychology and the general terror of fiat currencies (especially of treating fiat currencies as if they were truly fiat currencies) would hamper any baldfaced implementation of MMT policies. Essentially, fiat currencies can be viewed as being created via government spending and destroyed via government taxation. The only worry the government need consider is the possibility of inflation, which is not (this is predicted by economics and demonstrated repeatedly, including by present experience, in which the Fed has increased the monetary base by 5x[3] while seeing inflation tick between 0-2%[4]) directly correlated only to the money supply and is relatively easily controlled. Governments issuing their own sovereign fiat currencies are working in this system whether they realize it or not.

tl;dr There is nothing to worry about, people don't understand how debt owed in a country's sovereign currency works; there will never be any "reset excuse" necessary unless a future Congress goes absolutely mad and decides to accumulate truly absurd levels of debt (100x GDP) during economic booms or something.

Sidenote: Government bonds provide a secondary, extremely valuable service. They are a safe, stable place to park your money. If the government stopped issuing bonds and only paid them off, there would be a tremendous outcry and people would start either keeping the money in bank accounts or under their mattress (where it does little good) or investing it into the stock market (riskier and probably increases the chances of a bubble.)

References: [1] http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/in...

[2] Debt owed to foreign countries, by amount. Japan will soon overtake China: http://www.treasury.gov/ticdata/Publish/mfh.txt

[3] http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/BASE

[4] http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/current-infla...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by kalleboo on Monday December 29, 2014 @01:18AM (#8808748)
> There's also the present reality that not borrowing money at the present interest rates would be insane. Real interest rates on federal debt are near-zero and have actually gone negative at some points. People are literally paying the government to hold their money. [1]

Except since you're not ever reducing the debt burden, one day that debt will come due and you'll have to refinance it, and who knows what rate that will be. Having a large debt can be somewhat of a time bomb.

(although I agree with the other things you said - and especially the US is in a great situation where its debts are generally in USD which it controls)

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by Spooky23 on Monday December 29, 2014 @08:00AM (#8809559)
This period of runaway debt will end.

It's fairly typical during wartime for countries to adopt out of control fiscal policies. We're somewhat unusual in that we've dumped trillions into other spending (ie Medicare Part D), while simultaneously having to spend federal budget dollars to pay for redeemed bonds held by Social Security.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by nostromo on Sunday December 28, 2014 @08:21PM (#8808167)
I think it's much more likely we'll continue to do what we're doing now: printing money and reducing the value of existing debt via inflation.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by eru on Sunday December 28, 2014 @10:47PM (#8808470)
Wasn't there an American president that paid off all the debt in the 19th century?
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by gargarplex on Monday December 29, 2014 @01:12AM (#8808734)
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by maratd on Sunday December 28, 2014 @06:21PM (#8807869)
We're at a point where it's pretty obvious that the principal will never be repaid. The debt will continue to get serviced, which is all anybody really cares about.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by Amezarak on Sunday December 28, 2014 @06:58PM (#8807961)
I imagine most debt is owed in bonds, the principal of which are paid off any time someone cashes one in. But since (people are always buying|the government is always selling) more bonds, the nominal amount of the total debt rarely if ever decreases.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by usefulcat on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:04PM (#8808272)
A completely balanced budget would probably result in deflation. In the U.S., there are only two ways that I know of that money is created: 1) A bank making a loan and 2) the federal government spending money. Likewise, there are two ways that money is destroyed: loan repayments and taxes. But in the case of loan repayments, the total amount paid/destroyed is always greater than the initial loan due to interest. The extra money for the interest has to come from somewhere. And this is without even considering the effects of increases in GDP.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by logfromblammo on Monday December 29, 2014 @10:42AM (#8810190)
That's how currency notes enter and leave circulation.

Money is created whenever someone provides a good or service that someone else wants to consume. The money value of the currency is the total value of money created by the productive sector of the economy, divided by the number of currency units, with some variation resulting from imperfect knowledge of the market.

The central bank attempts to increase the number of units of the currency faster than money is created, so that the value of an individual unit of currency will remain stable or decrease. If the value of a currency unit were to start increasing, people might be tempted to stop spending it, which would destroy some of the money value of the economy by discouraging trades.

This also has the insidious benefit of allowing the central bank to take some money value from the economy without trading for it, just by creating new currency out of thin air. When they spend the new currency, or loan it to a government that spends it, a fraction of the money value produced by other people suddenly teleports to their own pockets, and they can pretend to be generous and benevolent.

The interest issue is a big problem. Depending on the size and number of outstanding loans, if they were to be paid off, currency would be removed from circulation and the money price of the remaining currency would increase, making it harder to pay off the remaining loans. In order to ease the crunch, the currency-issuing bank would have to actually spend back into the economy without making loans, buying goods and services outright instead of just renting out paper.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by julespitt on Sunday December 28, 2014 @10:57PM (#8808487)
Federal spending does not technically create money, as those dollars were collected by taxes or lent by bondholders.

However, the point of the Federal Reserve Bank is primarily to create money, or destroy it, to affect inflation, deflation, or unemployment.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by Retric on Sunday December 28, 2014 @09:17PM (#8808291)
In the short term your right, but in the long term failed banks create actual currency loans are just bookkeeping.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by nradov on Sunday December 28, 2014 @10:13PM (#8808408)
Loan defaults also destroy money (monetary deflation).
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by swatow on Sunday December 28, 2014 @11:52PM (#8808587)
The US public debt is 72.5% of GDP. This is roughly equivalent to a person owing a debt of 72.5% of their annual income. High, but not impossible to pay off by any means.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by khuey on Monday December 29, 2014 @12:03AM (#8808605)
For a person net worth is a lot more meaningful than debt. I wonder if anyone has ever tried to calculate the net worth of the United States.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by cfallin on Monday December 29, 2014 @02:55AM (#8808894)
Wikipedia [1] says $123.8 trillion, or ~$391k per capita (for the 2013 population of 316M). That's 7.23 years of GDP. That's actually much higher than I would have thought!

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_position_of_the_Unite...

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by matt4077 on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:18PM (#8808000)
GB & Germany are getting closer to a balanced budget (Germany will probably get there next year). It's not impossible to pay off all debt, especially if inflation returns to healthy 3%.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by femngi on Monday December 29, 2014 @08:02AM (#8809563)
It was my understanding that despite cutting their budget deficit spending has actually increased substantially in GB over recent years.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by CamperBob2 on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:48PM (#8808082)
A balanced budget doesn't mean you've paid off your debts.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by furyg3 on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:05AM (#8809779)
It doesn't mean you've paid off your debts, but it does mean you are paying off your debts.

There is no need to pay off your student loans completely if the interest rate on them is low and you can do better things with your income. Making your payments is responsible. Paying them off (partially or entirely) means that you have nothing better to do with your income.

Refinancing your student loans from 4% to 2% is a fantastic idea, however (which is what the UK is doing)

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by tonyedgecombe on Monday December 29, 2014 @01:59AM (#8808801)
I've noticed a lot of the media (in the UK) don't seem to understand this.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by calpaterson on Monday December 29, 2014 @08:25AM (#8809648)
I find the entire concept to be unavoidably confusing. In accounting, to "balance the books" means to complete the process of double-entry bookkeeping. Once the books are balanced you can then determine whether you made a profit or a loss.

The political term "balance the budget" seems to be a corruption of the accounting term, and it means just for the state to break even. It seems likely to me that the coiner of this term had some misconception about double-entry bookkeeping - such as that you break even iff your books are balanced

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by IndianAstronaut on Sunday December 28, 2014 @07:22PM (#8808014)
The situation in Japan is dire. Their debt is more than double gdp.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by JackFr on Monday December 29, 2014 @01:01AM (#8808706)
The situation in Japan is troubling, but it is not as simple as reducing it to a debt/GDP ratio. Great Britain had a debt/GDP ratio of > 250% in the 1820's.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by tonyedgecombe on Monday December 29, 2014 @02:01AM (#8808805)
Isn't most of the government debt held by the population of Japan? Presumably this deters the government from inflating it away.
Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by ucho on Monday December 29, 2014 @09:31AM (#8809889)
That level of debt, even when most of it is internal, can't be maintained when Japan is on edge of demographic catastrophe. Whats worse - recent attempts at reducing budget deficit by raising VAT ended up with recession: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abenomics .

edit: A bit longer article: http://www.businessinsider.com/japan-economy-disaster-2013-5 - it might be a bit old but nothing really changed.

Re:That Debt from 1720? Britain’s Payment Is Coming by tonyedgecombe on Monday December 29, 2014 @12:56PM (#8810881)
I'm not sure I'd call the demographic changes a catastrophe, that seems a little dramatic.

The VAT changes weren't very well handled, if you know the sales tax is going up substantially then you will bring forward any planned purchases.

What Japan really needs to do is modernise the workplace especially in terms of gender equality but also just moving away from so much paper.