News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by debacle on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:32AM (#8792602)
> “Uber does not believe it is appropriate for authorities to seek to punish drivers who are trying to make a living through this service,” Uber said in today’s e-mail.

Uber needs to slow down the spin. It might work in metros in the US, but it's not going to work in Seoul.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by gnu8 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:32AM (#8792776)
The heavy spin is necessary to preserve the image that Uber represents the drivers. Uber really just provides technical infrastructure and marketing, and rakes off most of the profit. Almost all of that wealth should be flowing back to the drivers who provide Uber's actual service.

The drivers need to unionize and break Uber's back before Uber replaces them all with self-driving cars. It shouldn't be too hard for them to organize, since they all have smartphones and they all end up dissatisfied when Uber cuts their rates.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:08AM (#8792865)
>The drivers need to unionize and break Uber's back before Uber replaces them all with self-driving cars. It shouldn't be too hard for them to organize, since they all have smartphones and they all end up dissatisfied when Uber cuts their rates.

As a consumer who would much rather ride in a self-driving car than with a human driver, this notion pains my heart. Using unions to halt the progress of technology hurts us all.

I'm crossing my fingers you were being sarcastic. This is a tech community, after all.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by 67726e on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:13AM (#8792883)
I hope they unionize and demand higher wages. Higher costs for human drivers will increase the incentive for driver-less cars, right?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by adventured on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:47AM (#8792984)
No, if all the services are unionized, those same unions will then use every means possible to get new laws passed that say you can't have a driver-less taxi. They won't just go quietly, as they watch robots take over, just like taxi drivers aren't now when confronted with uber.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by 67726e on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:52AM (#8793001)
Not every union is a political powerhouse capable of doing such. Eventually you'll reach a point where it becomes economically feasible for a company to wholesale fire it's drivers and roll out it's fleet of driverless cars. It's certainly possible that a union could push for a law against such, but that sounds a bit more like fear-mongering and an anti-union bias than anything else.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by TheHypnotist on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:01AM (#8793038)
Not only that but they will drive the whole efficient and affordability premise into the ground just for the betterment of their drivers. In this case, with the competition being what it is, it would be more for the detriment.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by king_jester on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:31AM (#8793136)
This is a lot of anti-union FUD. Unions generally now don't seek to ban or outlaw non-union operations in the same field. Remember there are A LOT of unions and behaviors and platforms of various unions range widely.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by TheHypnotist on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:56AM (#8793017)
As a resident of New Jersey, please, no more unions.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by 67726e on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:14AM (#8793092)
Maybe I'm skewed - I'm from South Carolina - but I don't necessarily view unions as a monstrosity, surprisingly. I do hear the horror stories, but there must be some middle ground.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by forgotpasswd3x on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:20AM (#8793113)
There's definitely a middle ground. I have a couple friends who are in unions, and they're very pro-union. They don't claim they're perfect, just that it's sure better than not having one.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by TheHypnotist on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:11AM (#8793292)
I can certainly imagine why they would love their unions. They are great for the people, but shit for our states economy. Unfortunately, they have such lobby power it's tough to stop them here.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by nyc640 on Thursday December 25, 2014 @04:25AM (#8795897)
I find it amazing how well working-class unions have been demonized in modern American society. Especially when this[1] is happening. There was a comment on another post a few days/weeks ago about how the AMA and bar associations are basically unions for professionals that have avoided this demonization and that the software industry ought to consider something similar to prevent the fixing of wages and the depressing of wages using foreign workers. If such unionization directly benefited you, would you be in support of it then? (honest question)

[1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2014/11/daily-c...

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by TheHypnotist on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @03:44PM (#8816645)
Who wouldn't? But for every good thing about unions I can name you a bad. It's a matter of the individual and how they are effected. As an example, look at Camden, NJ. Most of it's industry vacated for other states because union labor in New Jersey is extraordinarily high (and powerful).

Another example, look at the cost of Metlife Stadium vs. whatever the stadium the Cowboys play in now. it's about 30% HIGHER in cost. Again, no fancy gadgets or beach front property, it's in swampland occupied by highways built by union labor.

Unions historically have done great things for workers and continue to do so. However, they have a habit of forcing corporations to move elsewhere and pissing off non-union laborers as a result.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by rtpg on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:11AM (#8792873)
your "progress of technology" is based off of the exploitation of the lower class. I'd much rather our resources be allocated in a way that doesn't force people to work 3 jobs.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by marvin on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:33AM (#8792952)
This leads to the big philosophical question that has been relevant for some time. If we have the choice, which society is preferrable:

(1) Most services automated away, and those who don't have the skills or abilities to earn money are supported by taxing those who do

(2) technological progress is actively hindered in order to ensure that everyone has the skills to hold a job that pays enough to live on, or

(3) most services are automated away, and those who don't have the skills or abilities to earn enough to live are left to live in poverty (or starve)

And as technologists, which world should we push for? Ethics is not given nearly enough consideration among technologists, and this is one prime example.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:57AM (#8793022)
I believe you are grouping "those who don't have the skills or abilities" as one unit. Seems like a very large container to be making decisions about.

Let's exclude those who cannot learn enough to function in society. If anybody wants these people to starve, I haven't met them.

Suppose you graduate from college with a degree in repairing fax machines. Fax machines are quickly disappearing. Should you:

1) Continue to learn about fax machines while the rest of society pays for your food, shelter, and health care. After all, it's not for us to judge what you do with your life.

2) Expect fax machines to be mandated by law so that you and the other fax machine experts can have a job, or

3) Expect things to change. Try to match your own skills and desires with whatever most people want. That is, try to fit yourself into the society and world you find yourself in and not expect the world to change for you. (Whether or not the rest of us support you during this time is irrelevant, except in terms of whether it helps or hinders the change you need to make)

I believe this is the same set of alternatives you have offered, only looking at it from the individual level instead of as some hypothetical external observer.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by sooheon on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:52AM (#8793217)
You seem to have intentionally misrepresented options 1 and 3. The society originally described includes in option 1 supporting the fax repair man while he dives into founding a startup, starting a homely little cliffside cafe, busking on the streets or whatever else. It does not mandate that the recipient of the support continue to pursue a dead end against all evidence and logic.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by jungsoo on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:36AM (#8793400)
That is assuming the fax repairman has the motivation to do all of those things you have mentioned. Considering that life ideally leads to a comfortable retirement for most individuals (i.e.: doing nothing and spending one's days leisurely is the ultimate goal as opposed to creating value for society). I think it is safe to say that most people, given the opportunity, will opt for this "lazy" style of life.

Now I'm not saying this is inherently a bad thing. When technology and automation improves to the point where laborers are made obsolete, could society potentially adopt an egalitarian system where through taxation, society can afford to let the laborers live in complacency with a satisfying slice of the pie, while the more ambitious (those who continue to push through with scientific and technological advancements) are rewarded with an even bigger piece of the pie? With increasing advancements, will society reach a point where there's more than enough pie for everyone?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by OvidNaso on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:13PM (#8793537)
"I think it is safe to say that most people, given the opportunity, will opt for this "lazy" style of life."

This seems to be the one "fact" that makes all the difference in the entire debate. My question is, how come all of history shows man's drive to explore, build, conquer, discover, organize, etc...yet you conclude the "safe" bet is the oppisite?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:15PM (#8793545)
I don't want to sound rude or heartless, but, about "Let's exclude those who cannot learn enough to function in society. If anybody wants these people to starve, I haven't met them", I am curious as to why one would choose to support them, if they serve no purpose to society?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:08PM (#8794967)
I think to say that humans must serve a purpose in society based on their ability to make money is dangerously utilitarian. As it stands, I'd guess at least 20% of adults in America (shot in the dark) do not make any money and rely on others for food and shelter. These people are kept out of harm, and their safe mental state keeps other people out of harm. They can offer community service, familial or household care, and plenty of other things that do not profit them any cash. Most importantly, these people are spouses, parents, children, and grandchildren. They offer emotion and humility.

I know it seems like I'm doing my best to assert your rudeness or heartlessness, but I'm just trying to raise the point that one's monetary value is not wholly representative of their value in society.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Thursday December 25, 2014 @03:18PM (#8797074)
I wasn't asserting that money is the determining factor in asserting one's purpose.

I was relating to the parent's point that some people cannot learn to function in society. These people couldn't offer things such as community service and some of them might be so separated from society from their handicap as to not have any one caring for them except the government agencies in charge of them.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by sgift on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:26PM (#8793891)
If we go down that line of thought let's skip waiting till they die and allow execution of people who serve no purpose to society. I know whole industries full of people who could be removed ... what a joy. Or not?!
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @04:57PM (#8794674)
I don't think that we have the right to play god on people's life. What I was saying is very different, I am saying that, as a society, it is peculiar that we would choose to support those people.

Ignoring them is not the same as taking their life.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Ensorceled on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:21AM (#8793118)
4) Realize that repairing fax machines is pretty much your intellectual limit and now that fax machines are disappearing you don't have the mental capacity to learn how to fix self driving cars. You are now in the group "those who don't have the skills or abilities".

4) is what is actually happening now. The "bar" is constantly being raised.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:47AM (#8792983)
I don't know that it is the popular opinion in my country (USA) but I'd choose to live in society (1). I grew up being convinced that a successful person is one who "earns" one's keep, but it's becoming clear that by turning our backs to those in poverty, we make the world a much worse place than if instead we normalized the class bracket to keep the poorest at an approximate income value of ~$30k/yr.

Maybe I should just move to Denmark.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by patcon on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:26AM (#8793362)
Or build/support the things that expose the cracks in the prevailing political/social wisdom :)

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:29AM (#8792933)
I understand your point but there's a much less stifling middle ground. Unions can be grand things until a line is crossed. Higher wages for drivers? Sure. Safety and insurance? Absolutely. Prolonging the adaptation of a technology that will replace the dangerous alternative (humans operating cars)? Please, no: this job market is now dead for drivers. It's time to move on.

Or should we go back to horse-drawn carriages in consideration of the unemployed buggy drivers?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by rtpg on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:39AM (#8792962)
I'm sorry, but are we talking about the same company? Uber is not replacing taxi drivers with robots, it's replacing taxi drivers with taxi drivers. It's a dispatch service with a nice payment integration system. No matter how well it is done, there is no quantum leap to it.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:40AM (#8792964)
Did you miss the comment I originally responded to?

> The drivers need to unionize and break Uber's back before Uber replaces them all with self-driving cars

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by alextgordon on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:48AM (#8792986)
If the lower classes are having to work three jobs, it's because of the scarcity of housing, not self-driving cars. Most poor people's biggest monthly expense is rent. An oversupply of housing would go a long way towards helping them.

Of course, the landowning classes will never allow this. We haven't really moved on since the middle ages.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by pkinsky on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:16AM (#8793097)
In the US at least: meanwhile, China overbuilds housing to the point where ghost cities (not just towns, cities) are scattered across the country.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by TheHypnotist on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:58AM (#8793026)
Yeah but in this case no one who works for Uber is forced to actually do any work. This is an ad hoc, "I feel like making a few extra bones" type deal where they provide an affordable and convenient service to the populace. To say they are being exploited is wildly dramatic.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by res0nat0r on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:28AM (#8792924)
If this was a different company in HN people would be clamoring that everyone else needs to get with the times and that this is just our favorite buzzword "disruption" at work. It doesn't apply to uber now, I guess just since they've crossed the invisible HN "us vs. them" threshold now that they have a lot of money.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by wozniacki on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:48AM (#8792816)
I am perfectly aware that we live in deeply partisan times. Partisan in not just political ideologies but also in ways we see the world and our place in it. At times, it seems all middle ground has vanished. But that discussion is for another time.

Unionizing is a contentious issue not just for the employers but also for the consumers, especially when you look at how unions - in the industries and sectors where they have a stranglehold on affairs - seem to always serve the interests of just the union members and in no particular way improve the experience of the consumers.

As a disinterested observer, I ask this in good faith :

Are there documented cases of industries or even governmental sectors where unionizing - whether in America or abroad, say France - has proved immensely beneficial to the consumers and patrons?

Are they not just self-serving instruments and political vote banks?

I am yet to find a single heavily-unionized entity proving to enhance my experience as a consumer.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by justin66 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:26AM (#8792920)
> seem to always serve the interests of just the union members and in no particular way improve the experience of the consumers.

Serving the interests of the union members - representing them in their negotiations with management, to be precise - is a union's reason for being. They might also hold their members to a standard of professional ethics, depending on the union, and that might or might not benefit you as a consumer, but that's not the immediate goal.

> Are there documented cases of industries or even governmental sectors where unionizing - whether in America or abroad, say France - has proved immensely beneficial to the consumers and patrons?

The example that leaps to mind, in part because the comparison is so easy, is the press. In my town the difference in quality of output between journalists who are members of the guild and those who are not is quite noticeable.

Whether you want to credit that to the union, or the fact that better journalists are also better career strategists or something, is up to you. You're focused on the wrong thing vis a vis unions. They are there for the workers, that might or might not play out well for the consumer.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by wozniacki on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:09AM (#8793068)

  "...that might or might not benefit you as a consumer, but 
  that's not the immediate goal."

  "You're focused on the wrong thing vis a vis unions. 
  They are there for the workers, that might or might not 
  play out well for the consumer."
Bah Humbug! Then why am I - as the consumer - should want to foster the growth and strengthening of unions?

To create another entrenched interest group whose influence I cannot hope to counter, using my already significance-dwindled vote, in a state that is already rife with the influence of such powerful unions?

In California, the biggest special interest donor, the California Teachers Association, spent more than $118 million on campaigns in the state during the past five election cycles.[1]

And what do the "consumers" get for that?

The Golden State's fourth-graders ranked 47th in the nation in both math and reading. Eighth-graders ranked 45th in math and 42nd in reading.[2]

Looking at states like California, it is not a stretch to extrapolate that unions - once they reach a critical mass - tend to indulge in a cycle of voracious self-fattening with their growing influence, election cycle after election cycle.

As a consumer, I am supposed to help create more unions and enable this kind of behavior?

[1] http://californiawatch.org/money-and-politics/states-top-100...

[2] http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_24475260/california-students-s...

edit: typo

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by justin66 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:10PM (#8793533)
> Bah Humbug! Then why am I - as the consumer - should want to foster the growth and strengthening of unions?

You're welcome to do whatever you like. The way you continue to phrase things is a little odd, though. If you define yourself purely by your role as a consumer an awful lot of stuff in life is going to look pretty odd because it's a limited point of view.

> As a consumer, I am supposed to help create more unions and enable this kind of behavior?

This is such an odd question. I don't think anyone in the world believes it's your job to create unions. In fact, that's what we all decided at the last meeting. "It is absolutely not wozniacki's job, in his role as a consumer or otherwise, to create unions." We didn't tell you because we were worried you might be offended.

> Looking at states like California, it is not a stretch to extrapolate that unions - once they reach a critical mass - tend to indulge in a cycle of voracious self-fattening with their growing influence, election cycle after election cycle.

Are you claiming that union participation among primary school educators correlates strongly with lack of achievement among students? I'm pretty sure the top achieving states in this regard - Maryland, Massachusetts, Virginia, New York, and so on - have teacher unions.

I lived in California for years and I'm sympathetic to the fact that government there is completely insane. I think an explanation like "it's because of the unions!" is reductionist and too simple.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by username223 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:24PM (#8795401)
> Then why am I - as the consumer - should want to foster the growth and strengthening of unions?

WUT? Do you play any other role in society than that of consumer? Worker, maybe?

Perhaps you're a Titan of Industry, or a self-employed tinkerer, but society depends on big projects (think about the roads you use...), which require big organizations, which have many more workers than bosses. As consumers, those workers may not support unions, but as workers, I'll bet quite a few do.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by rtpg on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:19AM (#8792904)
There's been enough studies showing that people having more than 0 weeks of vacation is beneficial, good for productivity, etc. Unions have secured that for people in the US who would otherwise not have access to this.

A lot of social movements granting more vacation time to people in France happened through generalised strikes caused by unions.

The argument goes that since people can be more productive when well rested and not sick, then companies can in theory pass the savings onto customers. Whether this happens in practice is slightly independent of unions getting health care and vacation for the workers.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by freehunter on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:56AM (#8792835)
Unionizing wasn't such a contentious issue when employers were working their employees to death and paying them in credit to be used at the company store.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by ihnorton on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:26AM (#8792916)
That is incorrect. Unionizing was strongly opposed throughout the industrial revolution. Look up Pinkerton's efforts, the Haymarket incident, many others.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by freehunter on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:37AM (#8793405)
Yeah, of course the bosses didn't want it. It hurt them and their profits. But back then, the people wanted it. The difference between then and now is, now when the bosses say "you don't want a union", the workers actually believe them.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by pc86 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:16AM (#8792896)
Which they're obviously not now, so I'm not sure what your point is.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by cmc31 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:28AM (#8792929)
Isn't this essentially how Wal Mart operates in the US today?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by freehunter on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:39AM (#8793412)
When I was in college I worked at a regional Wal Mart competitor where I made minimum wage (not enough to live on) but got a nice discount if I bought from the store itself (which made my wages about enough to live on). It's as close to the old "company store" as they can legally get away with these days.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by debacle on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:12AM (#8792881)
> I am yet to find a single heavily-unionized entity proving to enhance my experience as a consumer.

Unionization has nothing to do with your experience as a consumer.

> seem to always serve the interests of just the union members and in no particular way improve the experience of the consumers.

That's entirely the fucking point of unions - to serve the members.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by PakG1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:26AM (#8793124)
before Uber replaces them all with self-driving cars

If Uber (or any other company) wants to replace them with self-driving cars, what stops them? My point here is that if self-driving cars have value in the future, they will be a secular trend that will come to pass whether or not a group of drivers are unionized.

The only option a union might have to prevent this is get political power/influence to get lawmakers to prevent new self-driving services from cropping up. But if we go in that direction, you can see what that situation looks like when you see car dealerships and their battles with Tesla.

If self-driving cars become a big reality, no union will save drivers. I sympathize with people losing income opportunities and jobs, but unions do not seem to be a feasible long-term answer here. They might prevent their specific employer from laying them off to replace them with self-driving cars. But they would not be able to stop the overall technological trend.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by notjackma on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:49AM (#8793451)
> Uber really just provides technical infrastructure

Would it be accurate to say centralised technical infrastructure? Simply transferring the data to the US is already probably breaking local data protection laws. I don't think Uber operates a franchise model with local infrastructure so countries are right to be concerned that names, addresses, credit cards and movement of individuals is being stored in a foreign country and open to data-mining and other abuse.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by applecore on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:47AM (#8793199)
Drivers already keep 80% of their fares through Uber.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by mylons on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:51AM (#8793214)
If you were playing poker at a casino, would you be content if the dealer took 20% of every pot?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by freehunter on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:15PM (#8793550)
If I only lost while gambling 20% of the time, I would be ecstatic. Meanwhile in my job as a consultant, I get paid 30% of what my clients are actually billed. Uber takes 20%. My employer takes 70%. I fail to see the outrage.

What percentage do the cab companies take from their drivers?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by readcloserq on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:44PM (#8793693)
You misinterpreted the poker analogy. When 20% is taken out of every pot, that includes the ones you lose. It doesn't mean you win with an 80% rate. When the rake is 20%, basically half the entire table's money is gone after 3-4 hours. (If you're going to criticize an analogy, you better understand the analogy.)
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by notjackma on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:54AM (#8793468)
Many mobile developers defend Apple taking their 30% cut.

Crazy, but true.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by rasz_pl on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:22AM (#8793119)
>they all have smartphones

and they all have UBER app installed, same app that spies on everything that happens on the phone, fancy that :)

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Shivetya on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:34AM (#8792953)
Unionize? What for? They aren't forced to work for Uber. Organize? The very same people, many of whom never did this type of work before, let alone organize, you expect them to step up and try to?

As in, before Uber what were they doing, when Uber leaves what do you think they will be doing. Pretty much what they did before Uber, not be a taxi.

Unions were a necessary part of life when industrialization first took off, now they are not. In heavily regulated countries they are abusive of both the public and private entities they have workers within.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by tim333 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:46AM (#8792982)
There's already been one organised protest when Uber tried to screw the drivers. Uber backed down. Seemed quite effective really.

http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-new-york-city-office-pro...

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by forgotpasswd3x on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:31AM (#8793143)
> Unions were a necessary part of life when industrialization first took off, now they are not. In heavily regulated countries they are abusive of both the public and private entities they have workers within.

All you anti-union people make them out to be the devil. It's ridiculous.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by brokenmusic on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:50AM (#8792645)
It works anywhere. Stupid state monopoly mafia trying to control how people are supposed to make money is scared. That's all there is to it. If I want to drive somebody and make money I don't need no licence. There's absolutely no justification for requiring a licence.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:11AM (#8792711)
Stop this Randian nonsense. There are perfectly valid reasons to regulate taxi services - such as ensuring that passengers are safe, or that they aren't ripped off. Those requirements are beneficial as a whole.

It's perfectly valid to question whether or not the current regime in various places has been effective at achieving these goals. It's also fine to change the way it all works. But dismissing it out of hand like this is purposefully, dangerously ignorant.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by twoodfin on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:33AM (#8792948)
Stop this Randian nonsense.

This is the kind of unnecessarily provocative embellishment that HN guidelines specifically call out:

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is an idiotic thing to say; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:51AM (#8792999)
You're correct, of course. That said, it can be difficult to maintain composure in the face of purposeful ignorance.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by fennecfoxen on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:15AM (#8792722)
On the other hand, a blind devotion to the regulations in question without reference to passengers' overall well-being and ability to afford a ride is equally nonsense, and a common feature of the current regime's defense of itself. (For instance, when all the London taxi drivers were complaining about Uber using boring reasons about taximeters).
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanBC on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:10AM (#8792870)
Your London example is poor: Uber is free to operate in London.

Uber drivers who want to be hailed from the street or use a meter need to i) use the correct meter; ii) use a wheelchair accessible vehicle; iii) "do the knowledge".

Uner drivers have an alternitive. They could operate as minicabs. That allows them to use the app for booking; they don't need to have wheelchair accessible vehicles and they don't need to do the knowledge. But it does mean that they can't use a meter for pricing - they need to be able to agree a price before they journey starts.

"Things that control or store money" (payphones, vending machines, ticket machines, taxi meters, gambling and TOTE machines) are all high profile targets for criminal gangs and for people wishing to commit fraud. It's probably a good thing that a limited range of taxi meters is allowed to be used, although the current system of assessing and approving meters is probably sub-optimal.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by fennecfoxen on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @02:08PM (#8794103)
As if to prove my point, snazzy arguments made without reference to the customer's well-being!

Why must a prospective Uber customer be forced to pay specifically for "the knowledge" (an insane, financially risky, multi-year investment in human capital) to have access to cars running a variable fare business model? How do they benefit from having their choices restricted like this? But with Uber, the case of "unsuspecting user gets ripped off" is a lot harder to make.

I mean sure, when it comes to privileging a set of drivers with the power to take street hails you have a good excuse about protecting random tourists from ostentatious fraud. But requiring that all variable-fare hails have the Knowledge? Seriously? That's incumbent-protection and nothing else.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by justincormack on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:30AM (#8792772)
But London already has deregulated taxis (minicabs) that Uber could perfectly well follow the regulations for (ie quote price upfront).
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:54AM (#8792832)
Agreed that there's a much wider issue to examine, because taxi services could really use an overhaul. Though I don't agree that the London case is particularly boring. The London taxi racket argued that Uber was violating the rules on minicab services not having taximeters (and that's a legitimately arguable point). That's how this sort of thing gets resolved; either we decide "yes, that rule is outdated, let's change it" or "no, we've got that rule for a reason which is still valid, Uber needs to change."
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanBC on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:14AM (#8792887)
"The London Taxi racket"[1] were not just arguing about meters. They were also arguing about wheelchair and guide-dog accessibility.

[1] is language like that useful?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:49AM (#8792994)
Sure, that was just one of the examples. These are all valid points for argument – one of the benefits of regulation is ensuring that taxi services are accessible.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by donatj on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:08AM (#8792863)
IF you don't like Ubers pricing or safety mechanisms take a different taxi. That IS the point. More competition is always better. You don't need mother government to control everything and make the whole world "fair". Grow up and take responsibility for yourself. If there's room for competition there will be cheaper and "safer" alternatived.

Are there cases of uber driver on passenger violence and if so how do they compare to licensed taxi driver on passenger violence statistically? This just feels like fear mo getting from the anxiety ridden to though.

I honestly don't understand how you can be on a news site for start ups and be against fair competition.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:46AM (#8792979)
IF you don't like Ubers pricing or safety mechanisms take a different taxi. That IS the point

This is a reductive and overly simplistic view that invites that total absence of regulation of any services.

The problem is that consumers are unfortunately not well informed, and that 'fair competition' is extraordinarily difficult to maintain in practice. That's why regulation happens in the first place – to prevent the worst excesses of the market.

I honestly don't understand how you can be on a news site for start ups and be against fair competition.

Then stretch yourself a little harder. Nobody's against fair competition - is it that hard to believe that some people feel fair competition is most effectively achieved not through uncontrolled free markets, but through broadly free markets with some state intervention to ensure a fair playing field? That's not too left-field, and it's the principle that every western state is operating on.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by anon1385 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:50AM (#8792996)
If Uber drivers do not have valid insurance[1] then the only "choice" I can make to avoid that is to not use public highways at all (an uninsured Uber driver can crash into me even if I'm not an Uber customer). I'm sorry but arguing for filling the roads with uninsured drives is just sociopathic.

I honestly can't understand how an adult in the 21st century can arguing against vehicle insurance. You don't even own a stake in Uber! You are arguing for adding uninsured drivers to the roads that you use, just to make other people rich. It's not even in your own self interest. Talk about irrational.

[1] e.g. because they have regular non-commercial insurance that isn't valid when operating a taxi, and Uber fails to check that their drivers are insured or educate them about what insurance they need. This has been a common complaint against Uber in various jurisdictions.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by dchest on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @02:00PM (#8794061)
I'm sorry but arguing for filling the roads with uninsured drives is just sociopathic.

It's not sociopathic. There are (and were) countries where driver insurance is not compulsory. I lived in one, and it wasn't that bad. If you want to be sure that you get paid for damage, that's what insurance is for — insure yourself.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by justincormack on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:29AM (#8792767)
Well Sweden does not regulate taxi pricing at all, they have to display prices but there is no price control.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by dchest on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:39AM (#8792793)
How can it be that it's perfectly valid to "question the current regime" and "the way it all works", but not the existence of licenses? Did you just randomly defined bounds of the discussion that we can have, and called everything outside of those bounds dangerously ignorant?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:50AM (#8792820)
No. Blanket rejection of the existence of licenses – "There's absolutely no justification for requiring a licence" – is not useful at all. There are, objectively, justifications for requiring a license.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by pgeorgi on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:45AM (#8793193)
The problem with 'questioning the existence of licenses' is that Uber always plays the same tune, world wide - even if those licenses work very different in different locales.

Not every taxi system works as bad as San Francisco's and in some areas (eg in Germany), when counting by the numbers Uber is the bully: tons of money and international reach vs. regional taxi companies with a handful of cars.

People tend to be quite opposed to 'rent-seeking schemes' on hn. Except when it comes to Uber, which is _the_ example of a rent seeking, as the 20% parasite between customers and drivers while trying to tear down the advantages of the existing system that get in their way (safety regulations, accessibility guarantees).

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:59AM (#8792674)
>If I want to drive somebody and make money I don't need no licence. There's absolutely no justification for requiring a licence.

No but you should be properly insured and bonded to prevent client liability. You can argue Laissez-faire, but we tried that in the 1860-1890's and it really sucked. We collectively decided individual safety is worth more then a fatter wallet.

Your argument works from an Objectivist stand point, but Objectivism doesn't work in the real world.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by humanrebar on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:43AM (#8792802)
Nothing about laissez-faire precludes insurance and bonding. If anything the very non-laissez-faire phenomenon of bankruptcy is what makes an insurance mandate necessary. Not that I'm against bankruptcy laws in general. I'm just pointing out that personal liability is hardly unregulated.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:03AM (#8792853)
Arguing that personal liability laws already exist and can enforce this system is technically true. But you first have to concede that a cash settlement is potentially worth brain damage, loss of vision, loss of limbs, loss of family members, etc.

Therefore a potential liability lawsuit will result in no net economic gain, but restoring what you already had (I.E.: How much is your SO's life actually worth to you?). If you don't concede this fact, then every single instance of the situation correcting itself, I.E.: Crash and law suit, will result in a net loss to the community GDP and private loss of money. The service can have no economic value what so ever to the seller, or purchaser on a macro scale, its just becomes Russian Roulette as a service.

The issue with Randian Objectivism is it normalizes human death to solve micro economic problems.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by humanrebar on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:37AM (#8792959)
No, everyone and every system puts a price on human life. The only question is who decides what cost is worth it.

We could basically eliminate car accidents tomorrow through extreme measures. We could lower speed limits to walking speeds, cover all vehicles in cushions, and require everyone to hire the services of a (licensed and bonded) crossing guard before crossing the street. If it saves one life or debilitating injury, isn't it worth it? Obviously not.

So at the end of the day, someone is balancing things like time, money, and effort with safety. The only question is who should decide what a reasonable cost is. I would argue that, given the right tools, you are better at protecting your family than whoever runs the taxi commission, DMV, or even the city council.

Reasonable people can disagree on what a reasonable cost is. They can disagree on who makes the decision and how. But it's not reasonable to jump into polemics about who has a morally superior worldview.

Disclaimer: I'm not a Randian, so I don't care to defend Randian mistakes, but I disagree with your logic on this point.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:08AM (#8793062)
I failed to correctly express my opinion. You are correct to jump on that. And you are correct in your argument.

I've editted the post to more correctly express my opinion (namely the last sentence).

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by donatj on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:14AM (#8792888)
Replying to the other reply that exceeds the max depth one can reply directly to, to imply "human life" is somehow a magical infinitely valuable commodity is childishly naive. Human life is just an electrochemical reaction and like everything else in the universe has a quantifiable value.

If you're going to vote me down please explain how I am wrong and how not being able to put a price on life is more than just silly romanticism.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:13AM (#8793081)
Counter point: How much do I have to offer you to kill yourself?

The actual answer is I can't. Because your life has infinite value to you, because without which you may not acquire any other wealth. I.E.: Your life is worth all the wealthy you may obtain to yourself, or potentially all wealth in existence.

Therefore, what is the quantifiable value of something with inelastic demand? Economics tells us its infinite (or we have to divide by zero to calculate it). But you say otherwise.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by donatj on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:02AM (#8793257)
Honestly if you could wait until after my children are born, I'd take you up on it should the value be high enough.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:57AM (#8793490)
I'm not that's the point.

You don't have children, this is a thought experiment to demonstrate an argument. You just have you. You're dodging the question.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by hobs on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:09AM (#8793290)
He then makes the same offer for your kids.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by schrodinger on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:13AM (#8793085)
How much can I pay you to give you a lobotomy and chop off your legs?

I find its easier to put a price on the abstract notion of the life of someone you don't know then your own.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by efbbbf on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:54AM (#8792657)
>If I want to drive somebody and make money I don't need no licence. There's absolutely no justification for requiring a licence.

What about the client's rights?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by briandear on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:18AM (#8792734)
I am not arguing this point on licenses or no licenses, however I would say that assuming the client has provided an informed consent, then the client should be allowed to use whatever car service they want. If I hitchhike, I assume the risk with no expectation of protection. Consumers should have a right to use whatever they want -- provided they are aware of what they are consuming.

However the odd thing about Uber in Korea is that taxis are already relatively cheap. It isn't quite the overpriced racket it seems to be in other places. Also I find it odd that suddenly Korea is concerned about safety especially given the overall lack of safety consciousness at the government level (for example overloaded ferries sinking due to government officials looking the other way in regards to permitting and safety inspections.) I lived in Korea for a total of 4 years and, it comes down to this: nationalism and protectionism. This isn't about safety at all -- this is about someone getting (or not getting) paid. The mad cow hysteria a few years ago is a great example -- North American producers were effectively shut out of the market over unsubstantiated government claims of a mad cow risk.. Thus effectively subsidizing a far less efficient domestic market. During the time of their 'concern' over mad cow, not a single American or Candian was harmed by the so-called tainted beef. Yet safety was the propaganda with which they effectively killed beef imports. The Uber situation is no different. The Chaebols own Korea -- to an even far greater scale than large corporations 'own' the US. Korea is almost entirely run by three (perhaps 4) corporations. Everything from media, communications, heavy industry real estate, autos, food production.. All owned by Samsung, LG, Daewoo (and Lotte.) Wrong or right isn't my point, my point is that Uber isn't playing with (or paying) the right people, thus this action by the government. There's a reason the largest Korean banknote was no bigger than 10,000 won ($10) (though now they apparently have a $50 note) -- it was a result of a feeble attempt to reduce large cash payments under the table. Here's a badly written article discussing that idea: http://m.koreatimes.co.kr/phone/news/view.jsp?req_newsidx=15...

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by prostoalex on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:20AM (#8793326)
> assuming the client has provided an informed consent

How would the client be informed on issues such as

* proper vehicle maintenance records

* prior criminal record

* history of accidents and insurance claims

* presence of proper insurance to cover client's medical costs or property loss costs in case of an accident

This is something that is required of properly licensed transportation companies (i.e. anybody working under Uber Black). Until the client has a quick and convenient way to research that information, we can only pretend the consent is informed.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by PKop on Saturday December 27, 2014 @01:42PM (#8803453)
If you ran a taxi service, in a competitive market, would you offer this information to your customers? You know they would want to know about it.

So you would, correct? Probably because you would then earn their business over your competitors, right?

If your answer is no, then why not? What if your competitors did, would you then?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:56AM (#8792838)
Are they being abridged in any way?

If I offer you a ride to the airport for ten bucks,should the state prosecute me criminally? Or is that true only if I use the I Internet to do it? What if I post in an online forum?

The state can certainly require me to purchase insurance to own a vehicle. Clearly in the public's interest. Perhaps that insurance should cover riders. Great discussion. But this is simply crony capitalism. There may be risk, but there is no crime here. At all.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by twoodfin on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:38AM (#8792961)
I wonder how HN'ers would feel if the U.S. government decided to respond to a "cybersecurity crisis" by requiring licensure and fulfillment of a host of legal requirements (such as posting a bond or insurance) before anyone can program or administer any public-facing computer. After all, they'd just be looking out for the public interest. Surely no one wants laissez faire software development!

That's not to say there is no "public interest", but rather that the public interest is something that has to be balanced against other interests, and the freedom to ply a trade is a pretty important one.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by king_jester on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:56AM (#8793231)
> But this is simply crony capitalism. There may be risk, but there is no crime here. At all.

That is where you are quite wrong. The regulations of taxis goes way back to carriage regulations in the 19th century. The reason for this is clear: to ensure that the vehicle is maintained, the driver doesn't have a history of attacking or abducting passengers, and that pricing is transparent and passengers aren't gouged.

Taxis are not private transportation, period. They are a form of public transportation and function more like a transit utility. To not offer basic regulation of taxis is to leave the public at large in significant danger of being ripped off, maimed, and/or assaulted.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:18AM (#8793315)
You are quite right about the reason for carriage laws. They're right out of two centuries ago, where a person who got into a conveyance had no idea what they might be getting into.

Those days are long gone, however. Today I can buy a used car on Ebay, committing thousands of dollars to a sale for a product I've never seen and a seller I'll never meet, all without worrying about the transaction. Why? Because information flows much more freely. The commercial transaction that used to take a government guarantee now just requires an open exchange of information about past history -- which is trivial to accomplish.

The 1800s are long gone. Time to move on.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by FollowSteph3 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:24AM (#8792752)
I shouldn't need a license to drive either, or to do anything I want should I? There's a reason licenses exist.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by dchest on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:32AM (#8792777)
I shouldn't need a license to drive either, or to do anything I want should I?

Correct.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by hobs on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:42AM (#8792801)
You have to have more to say than no one should be licensed for anything, that is a ridiculous proposition.

No licensed electricians? Sorry your house is on fire!

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by happyscrappy on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:51AM (#8792824)
It could work this way. Wiring not done by a licensed electrician then you pay triple for insurance. No insurance no mortgage. Now you can have your house burn down and it is a total loss. Hell NH drivers don't need insurance. Live free or die.

Edit: Actually I just remembered you can wire your own house in NH, but it still has to be inspected. They are not totally crazy.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by king_jester on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:58AM (#8793236)
This is a horrible idea. What will happen and has happened in reality is that those with less scruples or money will simply pay for the cheaper unlicensed work and not pay for extra insurance. Those people or their tenets then suffer by injury and death when an electrical fire starts or an improper wiring job jolts someone.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by brokenmusic on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:51AM (#8792822)
Exactly, my house, not yours. That's why I'm responsible for choosing a reputable electrician, not you.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by noelwelsh on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:08AM (#8792864)
It's a good thing you know everything and your actions never have consequences on others. Fire never spreads, the free market will solve all problems, and the earth is flat.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by valarauca1 on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:17AM (#8792897)
Yes but if your house causes a black out to our city, or a fire that destroys a city block who's held responsible? You, the electrician? What if people die?

The problem with Randian Objectivism is it normalizes human death to solve micro economical problems. I'd rather have micro economical problems then human death.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by orbifold on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @08:40AM (#8792794)
So you prefer a multinational corporation over local small / medium companies? That does really make no sense, this is not same as non licensed drivers operating in third world countries, who at least keep most their profits for themselves.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by bane on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:15AM (#8793093)
The FARC funded a big portion of their operations off of unregulated/poorly regulated taxi service. It's a lot easier to kidnap somebody when they willfully get in the car you intend to kidnap them in.