News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by marvin on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:33AM (#8792952)
This leads to the big philosophical question that has been relevant for some time. If we have the choice, which society is preferrable:

(1) Most services automated away, and those who don't have the skills or abilities to earn money are supported by taxing those who do

(2) technological progress is actively hindered in order to ensure that everyone has the skills to hold a job that pays enough to live on, or

(3) most services are automated away, and those who don't have the skills or abilities to earn enough to live are left to live in poverty (or starve)

And as technologists, which world should we push for? Ethics is not given nearly enough consideration among technologists, and this is one prime example.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:57AM (#8793022)
I believe you are grouping "those who don't have the skills or abilities" as one unit. Seems like a very large container to be making decisions about.

Let's exclude those who cannot learn enough to function in society. If anybody wants these people to starve, I haven't met them.

Suppose you graduate from college with a degree in repairing fax machines. Fax machines are quickly disappearing. Should you:

1) Continue to learn about fax machines while the rest of society pays for your food, shelter, and health care. After all, it's not for us to judge what you do with your life.

2) Expect fax machines to be mandated by law so that you and the other fax machine experts can have a job, or

3) Expect things to change. Try to match your own skills and desires with whatever most people want. That is, try to fit yourself into the society and world you find yourself in and not expect the world to change for you. (Whether or not the rest of us support you during this time is irrelevant, except in terms of whether it helps or hinders the change you need to make)

I believe this is the same set of alternatives you have offered, only looking at it from the individual level instead of as some hypothetical external observer.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by sooheon on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:52AM (#8793217)
You seem to have intentionally misrepresented options 1 and 3. The society originally described includes in option 1 supporting the fax repair man while he dives into founding a startup, starting a homely little cliffside cafe, busking on the streets or whatever else. It does not mandate that the recipient of the support continue to pursue a dead end against all evidence and logic.
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by jungsoo on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:36AM (#8793400)
That is assuming the fax repairman has the motivation to do all of those things you have mentioned. Considering that life ideally leads to a comfortable retirement for most individuals (i.e.: doing nothing and spending one's days leisurely is the ultimate goal as opposed to creating value for society). I think it is safe to say that most people, given the opportunity, will opt for this "lazy" style of life.

Now I'm not saying this is inherently a bad thing. When technology and automation improves to the point where laborers are made obsolete, could society potentially adopt an egalitarian system where through taxation, society can afford to let the laborers live in complacency with a satisfying slice of the pie, while the more ambitious (those who continue to push through with scientific and technological advancements) are rewarded with an even bigger piece of the pie? With increasing advancements, will society reach a point where there's more than enough pie for everyone?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by OvidNaso on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:13PM (#8793537)
"I think it is safe to say that most people, given the opportunity, will opt for this "lazy" style of life."

This seems to be the one "fact" that makes all the difference in the entire debate. My question is, how come all of history shows man's drive to explore, build, conquer, discover, organize, etc...yet you conclude the "safe" bet is the oppisite?

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @12:15PM (#8793545)
I don't want to sound rude or heartless, but, about "Let's exclude those who cannot learn enough to function in society. If anybody wants these people to starve, I haven't met them", I am curious as to why one would choose to support them, if they serve no purpose to society?
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @07:08PM (#8794967)
I think to say that humans must serve a purpose in society based on their ability to make money is dangerously utilitarian. As it stands, I'd guess at least 20% of adults in America (shot in the dark) do not make any money and rely on others for food and shelter. These people are kept out of harm, and their safe mental state keeps other people out of harm. They can offer community service, familial or household care, and plenty of other things that do not profit them any cash. Most importantly, these people are spouses, parents, children, and grandchildren. They offer emotion and humility.

I know it seems like I'm doing my best to assert your rudeness or heartlessness, but I'm just trying to raise the point that one's monetary value is not wholly representative of their value in society.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Thursday December 25, 2014 @03:18PM (#8797074)
I wasn't asserting that money is the determining factor in asserting one's purpose.

I was relating to the parent's point that some people cannot learn to function in society. These people couldn't offer things such as community service and some of them might be so separated from society from their handicap as to not have any one caring for them except the government agencies in charge of them.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by sgift on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @01:26PM (#8793891)
If we go down that line of thought let's skip waiting till they die and allow execution of people who serve no purpose to society. I know whole industries full of people who could be removed ... what a joy. Or not?!
Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by totony on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @04:57PM (#8794674)
I don't think that we have the right to play god on people's life. What I was saying is very different, I am saying that, as a society, it is peculiar that we would choose to support those people.

Ignoring them is not the same as taking their life.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Ensorceled on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:21AM (#8793118)
4) Realize that repairing fax machines is pretty much your intellectual limit and now that fax machines are disappearing you don't have the mental capacity to learn how to fix self driving cars. You are now in the group "those who don't have the skills or abilities".

4) is what is actually happening now. The "bar" is constantly being raised.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by Hytosys on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @09:47AM (#8792983)
I don't know that it is the popular opinion in my country (USA) but I'd choose to live in society (1). I grew up being convinced that a successful person is one who "earns" one's keep, but it's becoming clear that by turning our backs to those in poverty, we make the world a much worse place than if instead we normalized the class bracket to keep the poorest at an approximate income value of ~$30k/yr.

Maybe I should just move to Denmark.

Re:Uber CEO Indicted in South Korea Over Its Taxi Service by patcon on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @11:26AM (#8793362)
Or build/support the things that expose the cracks in the prevailing political/social wisdom :)

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism