News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by Toenex on Monday December 22, 2014 @03:25PM (#8784986)
Uber have the right idea here; own the platform, not the infrastructure. Lets face it, a cars spends most of its life stationary, waiting for you to drive it. Not so the autonomous vehicle. Autonomous vehicles are freed from the shackles of parking so why not lease your car to Uber and have it earn money as a cab? The future will be a bad time to get into car parking.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by zanny on Monday December 22, 2014 @04:54PM (#8785476)
You won't lease or own self driving cars. That makes no sense. You will just subscribe to a drive service if you drive a lot or just pay per ride and have one pick you up.

I easily see you scheduling regular events (leave for work at 8, for example) and your car will be out front waiting each day.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by randyrand on Monday December 22, 2014 @05:57PM (#8785771)
No way. In the city, yes. But in the somewhat wealthier suburbs many people will spring for the "self-driving" package. It might only be a ~$10k add on or less by my estimates.

Most people will want to be able get in the car without having to request and wait for a ride (most people already have this luxury).

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by erikpukinskis on Monday December 22, 2014 @10:46PM (#8786678)
Sure, at first. But then your daughter has the SUV and your husband has the sedan and you want to get groceries and your sons want to go to two different friends houses, so you end up using sepf-driving cars all the time anyway, and you realize it's actually quite nice not to have to worry about maintenance and cleaning and charging. And you realize you could save $300 a month. And oh, you can just order a 4-wheel-drive vehicle pre-loaded with kayaks for your camping trip? And... and... and.

We haven't imagine half of what cars-as-a-service will entail. Some people will always hold onto their vehicles, but in the end I don't think a hunk of plastic and metal will be able to compete with a fleet of special-purpose vehicles supported by a staff of thousands.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by Chronic30 on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:39AM (#8787325)
Many rich families own (at least) one car per family member. We are talking about luxurious add-ons which is why I bring this up.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by cgriswald on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @04:22AM (#8787428)
In the short term, self-driving is going to be an optional activity, not an always-on activity. So for most drivers who have it, it will simply be a luxury. Certainly there will be services, but it may or may not be cost effective. We already have the option to schedule a car service every day at 8 am, yet most of us drive. Some of us have the option of busses and trains, which is more or less the same thing, but again, we opt to drive.

In the long term, your car isn't going to sit outside your office for 8 hours. It's going to pick up the kids, your take-out order from the Chinese place across town, and deliver your laundry to a laundry service. People aren't going to travel around in taxis that don't even have the benefit of a driver who tries to keep it clean. They're going to want their own space.

There are some caveats and exceptions, certainly. And self-driving vehicles and services may prompt more people to eschew car ownership, but the idea that people won't own or lease these things _in general_ is ridiculous.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by justincormack on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @06:45AM (#8787770)
But everyone wants to drive to work at the same time so there is very little saving from central provision (and thats the main use, at present in the US). It makes the rental model much less attractive.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by mirchibajji on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @08:13AM (#8787967)
For commuters, may be that's all there is to it. If I want to go out on a trip with my little one, I'd rather have a bunch of her favorite things in the car (without me having to lug it around every time), and have the convenience of not having to drive, which also makes it much easier to keep her entertained. I'm hoping she'd grow up by the time these are generally available, but I'm sure there are others reasons to own one.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by millstone on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:03PM (#8786033)
Isn't owning typically cheaper than renting?

Anyways, it makes no sense that everyone on my block owns their own lawnmower, and yet here we are.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by aetherson on Monday December 22, 2014 @09:31PM (#8786536)
Renting a property or object that you are the sole user of is typically more expensive than owning.

Renting a property or object that you are one of many users of is typically less expensive than owning. For instance, you don't imagine that renting one of those steam-carpet cleaners from the grocery store once every year or two is more expensive than owning one, right?

(Renting is more expensive than purely your share of the use -- that is, if the steam cleaner gets rented by 100 people in a year, you expect to pay more than 1% of the yearly total cost of ownership of the cleaner).

So the concept is that say you effectively use maybe 1/5th to 1/3rd of a car's capacity in a ride-for-hire situation, and so you pay say 25%-40% of the total cost of ownership, allowing a reasonable profit margin for the owner. (Or you use much less, but in that case you probably were never going to own a car).

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by millstone on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @02:55AM (#8787243)
This doesn't seem quite right - if I own a car and use only 1/3rd of its capacity, I generally expect it to last 3x as long, so the unused capacity costs me nothing. Even your annual steam cleaner example will favor the purchaser over the renter, given enough time.

So the difference between renting and owning must come down to the cost of unused capacity, which means the fixed costs. Where those fixed costs are high, like a parking space in SF, you want to amortize them by maximizing utilization, which means sharing cars. But where those fixed costs are low, like parking in my driveway, unused capacity may be so cheap that owning costs less than renting, even if the car sits idle most of the time.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by aetherson on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:17AM (#8787283)
Cars degrade in value pretty strongly based on age, not just mileage. For example, a 2009 Toyota Camry with 5,000 miles on it, base 4-Door sedan, in excellent condition, shows a Kelley Blue Book price of about $13k (in my zip). It would've been about $18k new.

But your point is taken, a great deal of the equity burn on a car is mileage-related.

(Especially when you consider that if there are three users of a rented driverless car, it drives more than 3x the distance than would three separate owned vehicles for the users -- it must, after all, shuttle itself between users.)

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by eru on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:01PM (#8786263)
> Isn't owning typically cheaper than renting?

Depends how you account for all factors. Owning usually comes with some hassle and risk. Renting means you pay someone else to discharge those duties. Another factor is the cost of capital for you vs the company that would rent to you.

Having your own lawnmower probably has something to do with transaction costs. Ie it's a hassle to coordinate among people.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by anigbrowl on Monday December 22, 2014 @05:43PM (#8785723)
Assuming Google wants to get into the car business, all it has to do is add a button to google Maps/now. I don't think ther's anything special about the Uber platform, and Google already integrates journey planning through the Calendar and Google Now interfaces (eg telling you that you need to leave in 5 min to catch that train).

You're right on the car parking. I think the City of Chicago actually made a very shrewd decision to sell their street parking revenue to a private operator for a 75 year period in return for a fixed amount of cash up front (obviously I'm oversimplifying). It was excoriated as a terrible deal by most people, but none of them seem to have considered the probability that there just won't be the same sort of demand for parking in even 10 or 20 years.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by thanksgiving on Monday December 22, 2014 @03:34PM (#8785046)
> The future will be a bad time to get into car parking.

Perhaps, this will be the case in the long term. However, until then perhaps we could implement some sort of price surging where rental costs of parking space skyrockets when demands get high. Uber is doing the hard work of making price surging palatable. Everyone else just needs to ride on their coat tails.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by brc on Monday December 22, 2014 @06:17PM (#8785848)
That is already common in most places. Most parking structures I know have different rates for different arrival and stay lengths. A lot of street parking has free and paid times. Demand based parking has been around a long time.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by zevyoura on Monday December 22, 2014 @04:34PM (#8785390)
SF and other cities already have variable, usage based parking fees[0]; I imagine these will only become more widespread.

[0] http://sfpark.org/

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by rtpg on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:04PM (#8786039)
but the jutification for surge pricing doesn't make sense with parking. The entire premise (that I have not seen data to verify, but the premise nonetheless) is that surge pricing increases the number of drivers on the road. Are we going to build more parking spaces for half a day?

"Price surging" would become a fancy word for price gouging.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by eru on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:04PM (#8786276)
Surge pricing also limits demand. And that's a good thing; it's better if there's an expensive spot available, than no cheap spots.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by rtpg on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:14PM (#8786309)
only better for rich people. Rent seeking does not follow free market principles (due to fixed supply), and so loses any form of moral highground in my opinion.
Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by Pyxl101 on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:43AM (#8787075)
Surge pricing is not rent-seeking. If the surge pricing was not warranted by the situation, then it creates a trivial way for competitors to eat the business's lunch by offering the same service at a slightly lower price.

"Uber is surge pricing right now but Lyft is not, so I'll get my ride with Lyft"

Surge pricing is a legitimate function of a properly functioning market. When demand has skyrocketed, or supply is constrained, prices _should_ rise. This is the mechanism by which markets enable resources to be allocated efficiently. Whether someone is poor or rich, if they desire a thing more than other people do (for the sake of argument, other people of similar wealth), then they should have a mechanism by which to express that preference. That preference is the price they're willing to pay.

If the area is congested, and you _really_ want to go somewhere right now, then surge pricing gives you two ways to accomplish this. (1) To the extent that capacity is fixed, the ability to out-bid someone else means that you can take the capacity from someone else who doesn't desire it as much as you do. (2) The higher price incentivizes more supply. Uber drivers who see an exceptional surge price will make themselves available in order to take advantage of higher wages. A higher surge price is pure profit for the driver, if he can make himself available to drive right now versus some other time in the week

Lastly, no supply is fully constrained. If the price of parking in a city skyrockets, then this creates a strong incentive for parking businesses to find a way to make more parking available. This might mean buying existing buildings, demolishing them, and converting them into parking structures; or it might mean that in the routine course of building new structures, the high price of parking will make it economical to dig a few stories deeper and provide a few more levels' worth of parking. Price and incentives always influence the operation of the market.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by rtpg on Wednesday December 24, 2014 @10:19AM (#8793107)
Surge pricing in Uber's case is not rent-seeking if surge-pricing actually increases supply (i.e. more drivers on the road). My gut says it doesn't ( don't think that drivers get out on the road fast enough), but I don't have the data to prove that.

But in the case of parking spaces, I don't see how me being able to out-bid you for the last space makes me a more qualified candidate for that parking space. I'm paying a higher price for the same good, the number of spaces isn't going up, and the owner got richer without adding any value. Textbook definition of rent-seeking if I've ever seen one.

High parking tension means that people will try to make more parking, but is that the most effecient allocation of resources? What about alternative solutions, like mass transit? This is a digression, but you mentioned it with supply.

On a more pragmatic level I don't really think the ultra-rich have that much more of a right to a parking space downtown on a Saturday any more than I do, and a parking space is more or less a public good (and should be shared as such).

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by minot on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @11:28AM (#8819922)
> Surge pricing in Uber's case is not rent-seeking if surge-pricing actually increases supply (i.e. more drivers on the road). My gut says it doesn't ( don't think that drivers get out on the road fast enough), but I don't have the data to prove that.

From what I understand, fear and hatred drive public policy more than objective data does. I doubt it is going to change any time soon.

Re:Google Self-Driving Car Project's first vehicle prototype by eru on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:03AM (#8787255)
Thanks for the explanation!