It might have been a freudian slip or some kind of intuition, but when I was describing my life plans to my family, I said something along the lines of "I don't want to manage people, I want to stay on the front lines with the code." Except I don't want it to be scary, because I can't take anymore of that in my life. So what I really mean is "deploy knowledge bases" and that I choose to work in education. So I continue to stand on a soapbox of 'ethical coding' and I continue to request the ability to separate the responsibility of the developer from the technological applications to warfare. I just want to code difficult stuff, with intense mathematics and abstractions, and solve hard problems. I don't want people using that to hurt other people, and people who don't code don't seem to get that.
People wonder why I get depressed, and to a lot of people it probably looks super dumb and selfish, and I've lost a lot of friends over the years over things I couldn't really explain. People say I over-analyze things and that I think too much. Maybe I do, maybe I don't think enough. It's pretty easy for me to have these opinions when my life is stable.
The logical conclusion though, is you can either own that problem and spend your efforts on developing and making available countermeasures to code that can kill, or you can let go of the problem. In a similar way when you have kids you want the best for them, but at some point you have to let them be the individuals they will be, for good or ill.
Letting go of that which you don't have influence over is, for me, the hardest part of being an adult.
> A novice asked the Master: "I perceive that one computer company is much larger than all others. It towers above its competition like a giant among dwarfs. Any one of its divisions could comprise an entire business. Why is this so?"
> The Master replied, "Why do you ask such foolish questions? That company is large because it is large. If it only made hardware, nobody would buy it. If it only made software, nobody would use it. If it only maintained systems, people would treat it like a servant. But because it combines all of these things, people think it one of the gods! By not seeking to strive, it conquers without effort."
His goal was actually to provoke Congress to explicitly pass a law against tele-operating lethal robots.
I guess that didn't work out so well...
I wonder where the code that is running inside the drones today comes from. Some one who never meant to be involved in those things must have written either the compiler, specs or actual code that these things use to do their killing, I can't imagine any company (no matter how secure they might want to be) designing a completely new processor architecture and tools and compilers and all that from scratch.
I still love math, and I still love computer science. I just don't want to use it the way the a lot of the world uses it, and I don't know how much thinking I have to do before I can create code that I am satisfied over being both intelligent and humane. It's absolutely ridiculous, sometimes. Sometimes I can just stare at a cursor blinking on an IDE and feel like I'm falling into a void of 'what ifs'. Other times it is like there is no difference between myself and the machine. And then I wonder whether I'm thinking enough, again, or am I letting calculation and logic get the best of me. Have I abstracted this problem too much, too far away from reality? Does anything I think matter at all? My life continues to improve, but suffering still exists, and I feel like it is almost taboo to talk about in this way. But what is the point of existing if you can't actually make real improvements?
I'll say. You could throw it in and go work as a coal-miner, but then you'd have to worry about the coal you mined being used to smelt steel that goes on to be manufactured as bomb casings. And so on. Certainly you shouldn't work on anything that offends you conscience, but the mere fact that something can be repurposed for warfare doesn't create moral responsibility.
This isn't to say that worrying about war or your personal purpose is misplaced GH Hardy opined that ballistics was 'repulsive' both because of the moral purpose and the triviality of the mathematics involved, and there are more musings on the ethics of that sub-branch of math here: http://www.augustana.ualberta.ca/~hackw/mp480/exhibit/ballis...
But as long as you're knowingly working on some sort of combat system, it's folly to beat yourself up over the limitations of foreseeability and the vague possibility that something you craft might turn out to have military utility which you din't intend at the time you conceived it. Instead, look for ways to provide utility in other areas.
But you are right. I look to provide utility in areas where the net effect seems most likely to be positive. When I can't evaluate that entirely I just assume neutral or no effect, it sort of just dissipates over time, like a wave collapse function, assuming entropy, or some manner of mental equality among peers.
Or because you didn't work on guidance systems, you could wonder if that was the reason the near miss which causes a lot of civilian deaths happened.
Or you could note that the use of military power is not really constrained by technical limitations and never has been, but the effect most certainly is, and start voting and advocating politically which would be more effective at stopping wars in every way.
But then you would have some much more direct responsibility for how the various conflicts turned out.
I don't have the energy for that. These situations are so complicated and they never seem to get resolved. As soon as peace comes someone sees that as opportunity to manipulate (or is the perception of that what causes it to happen?)
I'd rather just stare at math and code, seriously, even if it doesn't talk back like a person. At least it's not crazy.
I don't think that it's fair to condemn oneself because his/her ideas could potentially end-up sparking an idea about killer drones in someone-elses mind. In the end we're all very much alike, and it doesn't take much to transfer a few missing links if you know and they don't.
In the end the same laws of nature rule in all our heads, and while it seems like each and every one of us are our own compartmentalized observers, it's not until you think a good long while about the principle of locality(and most of the other fundamental laws) that you understand that it's the other way around.
Thinking this way for me is peaceful. I can't believe in god or another entity but to follow this chain of thought always leads me to consider that I'm part of something greater and more important than one single life can ever hope to be. I guess these days I see humanity more as some sort of super organism . Just as I emerge from individual cells so does humanity emerge from all the humans inside of it. I just try to do my part inside the greater of humanity, and I leave it at that.
I interviewed a candidate for a job once who wrote code for military drones. He didn't think it was bad that they were used to kill innocent people. In fact, he thought it was awesome. There are a lot of coders who have a low moral bar and will code anything for money. These are the people who write this kind of software.
Dr. Rawlins: No it's THEIR runway, Jim! Try not to think so much! Try not to THINK so much!
One of my favorite quotes of all time when I dealt with similar issues myself, from Empire of the Sun.
His servers were taken over by law enforcement. You're free to call them cyberterrorists if you wish. These days it's hard to tell the difference in tactics between malicious rivals and your own government anyway.
First, it has little to nothing to do with the comment posted, which concerns not a "cyberwar" but the possible police seizure of a Tor server. The assumption is it's either a false alarm or a police raid. No one thinks this was done by ISIS.
Second, a post using the word "cyberwar" in a non-ironic manner at the top of HN?! O tempora o mores!
So while your observation about an increased number of scripting attacks is interesting (assuming you did in fact establish a reliable baseline) it's in a strange place.
Did you mean to post elsewhere?
> Did you mean to post elsewhere?
No, I meant to post it here.The author, Thomas White, writes of losing control of his Tor exit node servers, not to this audience but to the folks who read the tor.user newsgroup. Robert, aka chummm, posted it here as being of interest to the community. His was one of a series of articles/notes being posted here that have described potentially state-actor level activity. And there has of course been quite a bit about the Sony hack in the news. I also happen to run a fairly large internet visible infrastructure which acts a weird sort of observation instrument for the network as well.
I presume that Robert submitted it here because he felt it was interesting, and a number of people concurred with him. And after reading the article of yet another person finding themselves on the receiving end of external forces trying to compromise their systems, it crossed some vaguely defined threshold for me between crystallized a thought that has been tugging at my subconscious for probably a month or more. That being that the the number of and frequency of penetration attacks is noticeably higher now than it was before. Yet I don't keep some sort of threat index or anything, I just get to see the number of things my automated defenses have fended off, or the clusters in the datacenter. And I allow that it is entirely possible for the combination of lots of computer intrusion in the news cycle has combined with perhaps a lot of bored teenagers on winter break or something to create something illusory. But as this story brought that observation to the forefront of my consciousness, I thought I would share what I was observing here, in the comments people are making about this story.
Your comment/observation is also very interesting, but had little to do with the Tor issues. So I was confused.
But I get sometimes things trigger tangentially related things, which is as you've said what happened here.
And thanks for addressing my comment is such a polite manner, especially after my snarky critique of your use of the word "cyberwar". Apologies for coming across in a negative manner, if you took it that way (except for the 'cyberwar' bit, I wasn't actually trying to be negative, I was mostly just confused about the comment's context).
Chuck's been around HN for a while, and has insightful comments frequently - that he posts this sort of "radical" comment implies that a non-nut is seriously considering it and quite possibly it's worth pondering as an idea.
Yes, my comment was that I didn't get why ChuckMcM posted it in this particular context, not who he was. I've also been around HN for a while, not always under this username.
http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/mouse_jiggler/
to prevent the computer going to sleep while this is utilized
http://www.cru-inc.com/products/wiebetech/hotplug_field_kit/
These are pretty standard plays in seizing computers these days.
One should note that the grsec linux patchset has functionality to not load drivers for any plugged usb devices, as well as log when it happens, possibly resulting in action being taken.
If the server were configured to sleep unless the mouse is jiggled, it would already be asleep. Thus, using a "mouse jiggler" or similar is pointless, and risks detection.
In this case, I would bet on a firmware compromise, similar to DIETYBOUNCE: https://www.eff.org/files/2014/01/06/20131230-appelbaum-nsa_...
As a countermeasure, I would not fully trust TXT in this particular case. It's likely a state actor who could spoof measurements over the the LPC bus.
If any government agency can break TXT it'll be the NSA and I don't know if they are in the business of handing out their best exploits to random police teams at the moment.
Regardless, this whole thing turned out to be a false alarm due to a KVM device being attached.
That said, very good point wrt grsec.
http://cgit.freedesktop.org/systemd/systemd/commit/?id=7212a...
It runs "loginctl lock-sessions" whenever a USB input device with a name of "Wiebetech LLC Wiebetech" is plugged in.
Has anyone used these in an IT support environment?
http://www.gamespot.com/articles/gdc-panel-tackling-the-emil...
>Will Wright, the creative mastermind behind SimCity and The Sims, spoke last, charming the crowd with a fluid mix of academic design insight and brash humor. "I'm convinced that if she was alive today, she'd be an Internet addict," Wright began. Citing television show Futurama as a key influence, Wright presented his idea for an Emily Dickinson desktop agent. Wright explained that, like a mix between Tamagotchi, the Microsoft Paper Clip, and Seaman, the Dickinson agent would be moody, portable, dependent, somewhat annoying, and observant of all your computer-based actions.
>Wright envisioned that the agent could be sold on USB memory sticks, in order to cleverly "backdoor" the program to unsuspecting customers. "USB Emily," as Wright dubbed the agent, would then interact with the user via IM, e-mail, and pop-up messages. USB Emily might snoop into the user's programs and documents in order to find keywords to comment upon or send poems about. Over time, the user would "slowly bootstrap a relationship with her."
>Referencing some of the emotional problems from which Dickinson suffered, Wright explained, "I want to put the player in the role of her psychotherapist." In one scenario, the player might help USB Emily through her problems and eventually befriend her. But in the two "degenerate cases," USB Emily might either become romantically obsessed with the user (a reference to her often erotic poetry) or fall into a suicidal depression (in which case the program might delete itself).
http://games-beta.slashdot.org/story/05/03/10/1723254/emily-...
>Will Wright's was the final design up for consideration, and was a truly inspired idea. It included such charts as the one to the left, showing the overlap between Emily Dickinson readers and GTA players.
>Then he put forth his goals. He wanted to have the mood dependency and portability of a Tamagotchi, the helpful/annoyance of Clippy, and the relationship and creepy aspects of seaman.
>What he came up with was USB Emily Dickinson. The game would be a small program bundled with a USB memory drive, which is now a large business and an almost impulse buy. The "Emily" program would sit on the drive, and would occasionally interact with you in order to begin to derive an emotional relationship with you. * These interactions would include Instant Messaging, email, and interruptions while writing. Over time, the program would develop a model of behavior depending on how you'd interacted with it. Will's thought was that, while you could eventually get her to a stable state it was more likely that she'd become romantically obsessed with you, or suicidally depressive. In the latter case, he said, she would have the option of deleting herself off the USB drive.
>To respect the license idea, again, Wright opined that the program could be adapted for any famous figure, and to have many different USB individuals operating on the same computer. If you had enough ports you could even have them interact with each other through natural language generation. Thus, you could slot drives to view a conversation between Marx, Twain, and Homer Simpson. While all of the ideas were stellar, Wright took home the first prize for the second year in a row.
When the unskilled highschool grad gets off the plane and signs up, they are going to give him a rifle. When the engineer gets off the plane and announces himself as such, there is a chance that he will be put to better use.
Indeed. And I'll happily concede that point. I (and many other) are just surprised at the thought process...physical hardware attack in (presumably a western data center)...and the thing that comes to mind is the ISIS??? Really if you tell me Russia I would have bought it. Same for China, Korea, Turkey etc...but jumping straight to the cliched CNN "terror org" that is the flavor of the month...please...
[Ace is having difficulty with throwing knives] Ace Levy: Sir, I don't understand. Who needs a knife in a nuke fight anyway? All you gotta do is push a button, sir. Career Sergeant Zim: Cease fire. Put your hand on that wall trooper. PUT YOUR HAND ON THAT WALL! [Zim throws a knife and hits Ace's hand pinning it to the wall] Career Sergeant Zim: The enemy can not push a button... if you disable his hand. Medic!
That being said, they do not look to me like a group that would be using, and generally be interested in, such tactics.
I'm fairly convinced that if we all really tried we could secure things much better than they are today. The personal tripwire I've been watching for is when it finally becomes simply general knowledge that C is completely unsuitable to write security software in and C++ is pretty damned dangerous. (Many people know this, but a large contingent will still push back on that. Once we get serious about security, one of the things that will have to happen is C is going to have be evicted from its current privileged position.)
Lest I sound utopian, yes, this will require immense effort. My point is precisely that we've never really tried that level of effort yet, not that the effort will be low. There's no real reason that the Internet actually has to be made out of swiss cheese, but it will take a significant change of viewpoint before it will be resolved.
What I keep thinking, though, is, what would be the total dollar cost to make security a forethought, with information technology being pretty ubiquitous? I think it might actually have serious economic impact -- is it possible we literally can't afford security, as a society?
But there would have to be some pretty significant changes in our languages and how we program, and it probably would mean things like a certain slowing down of the rate of feature delivery.
In the long term, being unable to afford security is being unable to afford computerization at all, and the efficiency bonus is so great from computerization that it's hard to believe that we couldn't figure out how to make it work.
We'd definitely still be using mechanical computers. But I could easily see lots of eye candy being stripped out to conserve cycles (after all, having a 3D desktop on a Pi isn't all that useful :)
Big blip, though. But at the current rate we're headed for that anyhow, regardless.
There isn't one. There are too many people involved who categorically refuse to consider security, and there is no way to fix that in a reasonable time frame. We'd need to fix the education problem and then wait for a whole generation of new people to go through it.
Now if you go with a weakly typed language like Javascript there are a whole other class of bugs that can bite you:
https://medium.com/@octskyward/type-safety-and-rngs-40e3ec71...
... so don't use those.
Your guess is as good as mine...
Fortunately in this modern version of war you can "kick the soldiers out" of your server by bringing it down and re-imaging it. And they won't turn around and shoot you, but that is not all that comforting somehow.
Until "DeathRay3000" becomes a standard peripheral it is slightly comforting...Overall, I worry more about the hacks I haven't detected than those I have. Re-imaging is a pain, but not as much as not knowing your server is secure.
It is entirely possible it is survivor bias on my part but I get the suspicion that a global sort of 'cyberwar' that has been rumbling along for years is heating up rapidly. I've seen a 10x increase in various scripted attacks being attempted (patch early and often folks!) and a number of APT level compromises of systems either staging malware or deploying it (see the latest bulletin on the Afghan government compromise). And of course the whole Free Syrian Army / ISIS / terrorist nom de jure attacks.
I can't shake the analogy to pictures from WW II where shop keepers were huddled in the back while soldiers fought from the front of the store. I see innocent servers being 'occupied' by enemy malware so that it can launch attacks on other servers further into a protected network.
Fortunately in this modern version of war you can "kick the soldiers out" of your server by bringing it down and re-imaging it. And they won't turn around and shoot you, but that is not all that comforting somehow.