News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Warning: Do Not use my mirrors/services until I have rev... by anigbrowl on Sunday December 21, 2014 @08:08PM (#8781526)
Have I abstracted this problem too much, too far away from reality?

I'll say. You could throw it in and go work as a coal-miner, but then you'd have to worry about the coal you mined being used to smelt steel that goes on to be manufactured as bomb casings. And so on. Certainly you shouldn't work on anything that offends you conscience, but the mere fact that something can be repurposed for warfare doesn't create moral responsibility.

This isn't to say that worrying about war or your personal purpose is misplaced GH Hardy opined that ballistics was 'repulsive' both because of the moral purpose and the triviality of the mathematics involved, and there are more musings on the ethics of that sub-branch of math here: http://www.augustana.ualberta.ca/~hackw/mp480/exhibit/ballis...

But as long as you're knowingly working on some sort of combat system, it's folly to beat yourself up over the limitations of foreseeability and the vague possibility that something you craft might turn out to have military utility which you din't intend at the time you conceived it. Instead, look for ways to provide utility in other areas.

Re:“Warning: Do Not use my mirrors/services until I have rev... by drcomputer on Sunday December 21, 2014 @09:14PM (#8781666)
I know. I might as well blame myself for breathing out air that is used by a tree that is used to build a house that houses the person who pushes the red button of destruction. It's like tunnel vision, following one path of articulation that follows the model of a logically sound abstraction. Things may be connected, but, causality with regards to the relations between mind to mind is very difficult to understand.

But you are right. I look to provide utility in areas where the net effect seems most likely to be positive. When I can't evaluate that entirely I just assume neutral or no effect, it sort of just dissipates over time, like a wave collapse function, assuming entropy, or some manner of mental equality among peers.

Re:“Warning: Do Not use my mirrors/services until I have rev... by XorNot on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:52AM (#8782904)
Of course then your country could lose a war because it had insufficient technology, and you'd get to wonder if you contributed to that (you would have, though so would everyone else).

Or because you didn't work on guidance systems, you could wonder if that was the reason the near miss which causes a lot of civilian deaths happened.

Or you could note that the use of military power is not really constrained by technical limitations and never has been, but the effect most certainly is, and start voting and advocating politically which would be more effective at stopping wars in every way.

But then you would have some much more direct responsibility for how the various conflicts turned out.

Re:“Warning: Do Not use my mirrors/services until I have rev... by drcomputer on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:25AM (#8782970)
That's always the problem, is how much and in what way can you dedicate yourself? And is it more a waste to spend idle time analyzing this than actually doing something? But is it the doing that creates the problems?

I don't have the energy for that. These situations are so complicated and they never seem to get resolved. As soon as peace comes someone sees that as opportunity to manipulate (or is the perception of that what causes it to happen?)

I'd rather just stare at math and code, seriously, even if it doesn't talk back like a person. At least it's not crazy.