Edit: Obama's pay-as-you-earn program puts an upper limit on how harsh the debt load can get.
As for pay-as-you-earn, which I believe requires a high debt-to-income ratio (a red flag to begin with), you need to do the actual math. Even with forgiveness, many pay-as-you go borrowers will pay more over the life of their loan.
Your comment about "making sure the monthly amount is doable is really important" is how people who live beyond their means justify purchasing things they can't really afford. This mentality is why we have 72+ month auto loans.
If you purchase a college education using debt and it does not produce monthly income that comfortably enables you to repay said debt within a reasonable amount of time, just how good is the "investment" you're making? Five figures of debt (the national average) should not take two decades to pay off; many people pay off hundreds of thousands of dollars of mortgage debt in 15 years.
The fact that relatively small amounts of debt so frequently become crippling tells you everything you need to know about how college is working out for lots of young people who don't know how to do basic math and are being mislead by adults who lack financial literacy themselves.
As for your other points, going to college is still generally profitable. http://www.npr.org/2014/02/11/275297408/going-to-college-may...
Per the article you provided, "Those with a college degree now make $17,500 more per year than those without." I don't doubt that this is accurate. But here's the problem: not thinking through your decisions and banking on the assumption that you'll have an average outcome based on statistics is a great way to mess up your life.
There are plenty of people in tech who don't have four-year degrees who make multiples more than the median wage of college graduates of a similar age. And lest you resort to the "tech is an exception" argument, there are plenty of professions, from sales to construction to plumbing, in which you can easily find folks without four-year degrees making very good money.
In today's economy, anyone going to college without purpose and a plan expecting to earn $17,500 more per year "because statistics" is at risk of experiencing a rude awakening, particularly when debt is used to finance an education that will offer a piece of paper and little in the way of practical skills.
Making the monthly payment is more important than total nominal cost. That's because missing a payment adds penalties that make it much more difficult to get out of debt. So making sure the monthly amount is doable is really important.
Of course it is, but you can't be so preoccupied with the monthly affordability that you forget about the total cost. (N.B. this is a trick car dealers use every day to get you to pay too much for a car)
In this sense it's not unlike the US healthcare debate where everyone was so preoccupied with how to make hospital bills affordable with government-mandated insurance that we totally forgot to ask why an aspirin costs $75 in the first place.
Best I can tell, all that compounding value gets you one thing: more money in retirement. Therein lies my objection; letting your retirement dictate your first 65 years of life seems like folly.
Your retirement only "dictates" inasmuch as you've decided that your retirement should be one way or the other.
"This spending of the best part of one's life earning money in order to enjoy a questionable liberty during the least valuable part of it reminds me of the Englishman who went to India to make a fortune first, in order that he might return to England and live the life of a poet. He should have gone up garret at once."
A student may benefit from being more mature if they delay college or graduation. But it's unlikely that benefit exceeds the compounding value of finishing the same amount of school two years earlier.
In other words, I strongly disagree with the premise that teenagers should delay college, for the same reason we strongly discourage people to delay saving for retirement.
Investment compounds. So it's confounding he accuses people of making a poor "major investment decision" while advocating a delay in investment. The answer whether to delay or start school unprepared is a math-intensive one, and is likely different for every student. But if you believe the majority of 18 year olds are prepared to continue school immediately for another four years, it seems reasonable to advise them to go to college immediately.
Does maturity compound? I don't know. Education definitely does.
> ...Greek systems that appeal to many affluent families but also incubate cultures of dangerous play... Rethinking the expectation that applicants to selective colleges be fresh out of high school would go far in reducing risk for young people while better protecting everyone’s college investment.
Reducing what risk? Of sexual assault and alcoholism?
I don't know if being young has anything to do with being a violently misogynist psychopath. Maybe being a victim of one does.
But the rest of the world tracks teenagers into either conscription or education at 18 too. There's less of a fraternity culture at Tsinghua for sure. I don't know if there's less sexual assault or substance abuse. Even if there were, we'd sooner indict fraternities than people being young, wouldn't we?