News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by carlesfe on Thursday December 11, 2014 @02:47AM (#8733672)
I wrote a bit about this in July, when the law was passed, if you want an opinion from a Spaniard: http://cfenollosa.com/blog/spanish-media-just-shot-themselve...

  Let's summarize what is happening here:

  Big media editors AEDE, most of which pro-government, in collusion with the 
  corrupt Spanish politicians have managed a masterstroke which they think will:

  1. Get them free money
  2. Destroy the discoverability of smaller media competitors, usually critical 
  with the government
  3. Hinder the future of Spanish internet tech business, their main competitor
  4. Get more exposure, since readers won't have access to media agreggation and 
  will resort to reading just one or two outlets

  In reality, what is likely to happen is:

  1. Google will close Google News Spain, no big problem
  2. Spanish media aggregators will move their business abroad and won't 
  contribute taxes to the country
  3. Tech enterpreneurs will realize that Spain is a shitty country to invest money on
  4. Without Google, the aggregators, and thanks to the increasing 
  user boycott to AEDE media, those editors will lose traffic and money.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by SiVal on Thursday December 11, 2014 @04:45AM (#8733969)
According to the article:

This new legislation requires every Spanish publication to charge services like Google News for showing even the smallest snippet from their publications, whether they want to or not.

This sounds as though it won't matter if Spanish news aggregators move abroad, because the law applies to the Spanish news sources themselves, not the aggregator. Unless I'm misunderstanding (and maybe I am, so correct me), if a news publisher inside Spain doesn't demand payment from an aggregator located outside Spain, the publisher in Spain gets punished by the Spanish law.

This approach would be a nasty way to do as you said: limit the ability of smaller, alternative news sources, to attract readers. Unless they left Spain, they would not be allowed to volunteer their content to any free aggregator anywhere, and if they DID leave Spain, they would lose the ability to report on local Spanish issues.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by mcv on Thursday December 11, 2014 @05:36AM (#8734083)
That is exactly the market opportunity I'm seeing here: news sites for Spanish news that are based outside Spain. Reporting on issues abroad is still possible, and they may even be able to hire freelancers based in Spain.

Or to put it another way: with no way to find Spanish news sites online, Spaniards would become entirely dependent on foreign news sites, which creates an incentive for foreign sites to focus more on Spanish news in Spanish.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by jcfrei on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:58AM (#8734689)
Indeed, a very interesting development and I already see the government back paddling in a few years time. Imagine a large part of the Spanish receiving the bulk of their news from Mexican news outlets - the Spanish nationalists will go furious. It'll be a very ironic watershed moment.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by pvaldes on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:54PM (#8738621)
Lets take in mind that some big newspapers in Spain are buyed from the banks. Same big companies can have a newspaper in Spain and another in Mexico, Colombia and Argentina. Is not so inusual.

And yes, as spaniard this is another shit from our beloved government that basically is butchering the whole entire country and giving all, blood flesh and bones, to carefully nurture his friends and family. A small and really happy minory. Everyday is his/her birthday.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by muyuu on Thursday December 11, 2014 @06:54AM (#8734263)
The main media in Spain will start hosting sites abroad to bypass this law. This law is basically a way to hinder smaller media more than collecting money from Google, and in this respect I guess it will work.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by marcosdumay on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:40AM (#8734916)
I dunno. How hard is it to host a site abroad?

I know very little about Spain situation, but even then I'd guess that it's easier than hosting it in Spain. Smaller media can certainly do that.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by _up on Thursday December 11, 2014 @02:50PM (#8736704)
I am pretty sure it is not about where you host, but where your company sits. And courts won't only look at where you are incorporated, but will look where they think the executive descisions are done.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by jasonisalive on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:07AM (#8734498)
It's always the small fish who suffer the most from socialist policies. Only large organisations can justify the resources to out-maneuever punitive legislation.

It's a shame that this irony isn't more widely understood.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by radio4fan on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:00AM (#8734696)
While I have no opinion either way on your post, I felt that I should point out that Spain's government is not socialist.

The party in power (Partido Popular) is on the right of Spanish politics, and sits with the right wing EPP group in the European Parliament.

For what it's worth, while the US tends to think of Europe as being socialist, I can't think of any EU countries with socialist governments except Austria and Denmark.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by vsl on Friday December 12, 2014 @03:07AM (#8738996)
That Partido Popular brands itself as right doesn’t necessarily make it so. This policy does show the typically socialist “let’s regulate everything and remove choice” approach.

> I can't think of any EU countries with socialist governments except Austria and Denmark.

Off the top of my head, France, Czech Republic or Slovakia. And the _previous_ Czech government was a prime example of a left-leaning gov. in anything but name.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by kaoD on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:37AM (#8735303)
> socialist policies

That's the funny thing about this. PP is a right-wing conservative ultra-catholic neolibertarian mixture. Not a trace of socialism...

This is simply crony capitalism.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by pm90 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:20AM (#8734555)
I think it is understood pretty well by those large organizations, and also the politicians that they are in cahoots with.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by aikah on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:49AM (#8734972)
The current spanish government is hardly socialist
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by ep103 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:55AM (#8735008)
This has nothing to do with socialism.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by RRiccio on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:45AM (#8735353)
Creating products for your own country while basing your company abroad seems likely to become a big trend among startups, as tech collides with archaic government regulators. It's already happening in many areas.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by RyanMcGreal on Thursday December 11, 2014 @07:08AM (#8734298)
Who knew the internet would herald a new era of pirate radio?
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by einrealist on Thursday December 11, 2014 @05:07AM (#8734020)
I guess, the law may also be in conflict with EU law/rulings/contracts. Aggregator companies outside Spain have an advantage over those within the spanish jurisdiction. So those spanish companies can call the European Court to fight the spanish law.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by Atropos on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:53AM (#8734996)
Unfortunately the law does not work in this direction: It is perfectly fine under EU law if Spain treats its own companies worse than Non-Spain EU companies. Lacking a cross-border element, the EU freedoms (Freedom of services/establishment) don't apply, and I think it would be hard to classify the Spanish law as an export ban.

However the Spanish rules might constitute a restriction of competition under EU law, but since the political climate is a bit anti-Google right now, maybe it won't be investigated too closely.

Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by carlesfe on Thursday December 11, 2014 @05:30AM (#8734073)
Exactly. And you can even move to a contry where they don't have legal agreements with the EU so that you can't get sued for doing something which is legal in your (new) country
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by fizgig on Thursday December 11, 2014 @07:48AM (#8734423)
Sounds like compulsory licencing. Is a pricing schedule spelled out, demanding a minimum charge? Cannot these small shops simply charge Google a token, blanket licence for all their content for, say, $1 and side-step these legislative shenanigans?
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by mobiplayer on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:08AM (#8734506)
Please someone print this and staple it on the forehead of every single person behind this non-sense.
Re:Google News to shut down in Spain by Shivetya on Thursday December 11, 2014 @04:19PM (#8737114)
and how soon before EU wide legislation like this makes it was through the halls in Brussels?