I ran into administration on multiple occasions, and within the broader laws of corporal punishment they can exact any reasonable, or unreasonable, punishments. I've heard of schools now taxing parents if students are tardy, moving the responsibility up. You don't have the same rights as an adult when you're in school, you don't get to do what you want, conversely when you do screw up you don't get as heavy handed a punishment an adult might.
Imagine the same scenario, but instead of school, this is the place you work, and instead of a school administration its the IT department bringing you in. You'll lose your job pretty darn quick right? Even if you're innocently exploring, cross the wrong person and you'll get cut.
Additionally, instead of complaining about the school we should be congratulating the kid. He or she has bucked the system, questioned authority, pushed their boundaries, found limits, and circumvented them. Don't come to their defense, it will do them no good to continue growing, instead help them back up, pat them on the back and say 'good job'. He or she is a welcome addition to society! Congrats on questioning authority and sticking to what you believe, I can't wait to see what you do.
This is exactly the opposite of what a school is supposed to do. Spreading awareness that the system is so badly broken ("complaining") is anything but silly.
Even if you thought the policy is a good fit at a high school, they should be trying to use this as a chance to tune the student's interests into a classroom assignment or something rather than just tell him he's in trouble.
I help run the web proxy for a large bank. /That/ network has plenty of reasons to be completely locked down, and we even provide wifi for employees to use their devices for personal web access. My point being that I recognize the legitimate use of a proxy to secure a network from malicious software and completely inappropriate sites (for a public net) like porn, violence, etc. But this is a place that should censor as little as possible.
E.g., there's an audit and someone starts looking into the router logs, and then word leaks to the local newspaper. ("Think of the children!") So the district in effect must put in a filter. Now we're just arguing about the threshold on the filter, and it's not a matter of absolute principle, just the setting of a knob.
The same reasoning applies to a school-supplied laptop or iPad.
The situation is similar to a job-supplied network and computer. There are limits on what you should be doing on it, because it's not yours.
If you want to do whatever you want, you'd better own the resources.
The district could actually not put in a filter. That is a thing they could just do. Then, when the newspapers complain, they can yes that's what they did. I promise you the world won't end.
Do you know where underage school children can go to access "controversial websites"? The public library. They can walk right in, sit down at a computer, and view the internet in all it's uncensored glory. For free. In public. As children. Shocking I know.
Also they can just use their smart phone because it seems like every kid over the age of 10 has a smart phone with internet. As best I can tell the world has still not ended.
For the teacher and the school administrator, it could. We don't live in the world you're writing about.
The smart phone comparison is not the same, because the kid's parents control whether there is a phone and its settings.
The public library comparison is interesting. Not the same (because their missions are different), but interesting.
Even in the face of public anger the school district could choose not to fire the targets of public ire. That would of course require having a backbone and principles, but it's totally a thing that could happen.
Kids look at porn at smart phones. I'm not even sorry if this bothers you. It's a thing. You can't stop it. Stop trying.
I think I see. My aims have been unclear.
I'm pointing out a political reality that I feel is controlling outcomes here. I'm not staking out a personal position, because in the context of a school administration embedded in a city government with oversight by the voters, my personal position means little.
To be honest, and this is where we diverge, I'm not interested in staking an opinion on this one. The school can do whatever it wants. Let it be open, or restrict it -- whichever works.
The library case is different; there are obvious free expression interests at play there -- including patrons who rely on the library for all internet access. (Would it further irritate you to mention I've been an ACLU member since the early 1990s?)
As I mentioned, the smart phone comparison is not apropos, because parents would supply the smart phone, and what their kids do on the phone is up to their family to decide.
Then teachers shouldn't assign homework activities that require use of those same websites (Twitter being one example from the article).
"Your homework assignment is to go use Twitter to find 5 spanish language articles and translate them, then tweet in spanish. Oh, and Twitter is deemed 'controversial' enough to not be allowed on school property. And you'll get a 0 on this assignment if you don't complete it".
Sweet...
But homework is, sort of by definition, meant to be done at home. When I was in school, I would certainly take advantage of down time to get homework done early, but (until I started getting free blocks in high school) I never felt like homework was meant to be done during school hours on school grounds.
Why are teachers assigning work to be done on websites that the school network blocks? Because at home, it's the parent's job to ensure their child doesn't access material that parents object to; at school, it's the administrator's job to ensure that EVERY child doesn't access material that ANY parent can object to. That's a much more challenging proposition, and (for better or for worse), schools tend to paint with a broad brush when it comes to enforcing limits.
Make it a book. The school system has deemed that "Huckleberry Finn" is too controversial to be allowed in our library. Your homework assignment is to do a book report on "Huckleberry Finn".
We have a direct interest in this.
How about, "our children, our rules"? I would personally like to see school rules that do not single out and punish harmless behavior from students who merely don't act "normal."
Welcome to 21st century education.
Intentionally doing things they do not want you to do is a terrible idea. I agree that the rules are stupid but the author is very lucky they haven't run into someone vindictive and stupid who called the police, or just expelled them. These things happen.