Re:In Wayzata, Minnesota, a school spies on its students
by tomjen3 on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @03:18PM
(#8696098)
I cannot believe I am reading this on hacker news. Your comment is so far from the spirit of hacking that I, frankly, have no idea what the heel you are doing here. Just know that if the Apple founders had taken you advice there wouldn't have been an Apple today.
Re:In Wayzata, Minnesota, a school spies on its students
by sosuke on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @03:26PM
(#8696133)
Perhaps I didn't get my point across adequately enough then, hacking is awesome, it should be encouraged and supported. However complaining that a school does what it does best, stifling the creative and curious mind, is silly. We can discuss improving schools, but I'd rather just tell this young person that they are doing well, right, and to stay curious and keep questioning things. I'd love to be more clear, but you didn't specify, what, if anything, was against the spirit of hacking or hacker news.
Re:In Wayzata, Minnesota, a school spies on its students
by tomjen3 on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:12PM
(#8706273)
I was arguing against the notion that they should go the traditionalist way and become an educator to change the system, I was arguing against the school being right about their actions, I was arguing for disrupting rules that only exist to protect the status que.
Re:In Wayzata, Minnesota, a school spies on its students
by iak8god on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @04:41PM
(#8696482)
> complaining that a school does what it does best, stifling the creative and curious mind, is silly.
This is exactly the opposite of what a school is supposed to do. Spreading awareness that the system is so badly broken ("complaining") is anything but silly.
I ran into administration on multiple occasions, and within the broader laws of corporal punishment they can exact any reasonable, or unreasonable, punishments. I've heard of schools now taxing parents if students are tardy, moving the responsibility up. You don't have the same rights as an adult when you're in school, you don't get to do what you want, conversely when you do screw up you don't get as heavy handed a punishment an adult might.
Imagine the same scenario, but instead of school, this is the place you work, and instead of a school administration its the IT department bringing you in. You'll lose your job pretty darn quick right? Even if you're innocently exploring, cross the wrong person and you'll get cut.
Additionally, instead of complaining about the school we should be congratulating the kid. He or she has bucked the system, questioned authority, pushed their boundaries, found limits, and circumvented them. Don't come to their defense, it will do them no good to continue growing, instead help them back up, pat them on the back and say 'good job'. He or she is a welcome addition to society! Congrats on questioning authority and sticking to what you believe, I can't wait to see what you do.