News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by DigitalSea on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:48PM (#8688508)
The experience for getting a working visa in the US is absolutely atrocious, and let me preface this with the fact I am Australian and Australia offers an E3 visa which allows you to work in the US indefinitely for the sponsoring company. It doesn't have the same issues as a H1-B visa (lottery, restrictions on when you can apply), but offers just as much flexibility and power.

I am currently a remote worker for a US company. The company have expressed they would like for me to come over and work full-time and permanently with their company as an actual employee. The kicker is: I have no degree and I don't quite have the 12 years needed experience to qualify for the visa either. This puts me in a difficult position.

I have about 8 years experience in web development, my title is actually "front-end developer" and there is no degree in front-end development or even web development herein lies an issue with how eligibility for visas are determined, the H1-B included. You basically are expected to have a degree in something even if it doesn't relate to your job exactly. If I had a degree in arts or something, I would be able to get an E3 visa just like that because all they see is the paper and go: here you are.

In the instance of this particular company, it is not that they are looking for "cheap labour" they are offering quite a decent relocation bonus, monthly expenditure for housing and other benefits, the issue is competition for them.

The company is based in Seattle and they are facing increasing competition from Microsoft and Amazon mostly who are sucking up all of the talent in the area, whilst other smaller startups and companies struggle to hire people because the bigger companies are offering more money. Apparently Facebook also are in that list, but you really only hear of Microsoft and Amazon mostly taking the talent.

The particular skill-set they are looking for is another thing. They needed someone with Java experience, AngularJS, React.js and the basics of web down-pat. There are other people out there with similar skills, but if you know Java especially, Amazon who are big users of the language, will scoop you up before the for sale sign has even been put up.

It is at the point where it works out cheaper for the company to offer a decent salary, relocation costs, monthly housing costs and pay for my flights from Australia than it is for them to match the salaries being offered by the other heavyweights in the area. That is how crazy things have become. Not to mention the salary being offered is twice that of what I would get from any employer here in Australia for my skill-set and experience.

I am sure that a few companies are taking advantage of working visas, but it isn't fair to lump all companies into the same bucket. Some companies legitimately need to hire outside country hires to compete.

I think there definitely needs to be reform. Companies who want to hire candidates like me face challenges because of strict and archaic requirements for obtaining a visa. Even visas that make it easier like the E3 still have the same eligibility criteria which for people like me who are self-taught puts us into a tricky spot.

Then you have Canada. They make it so incredibly easy to come over and work as an Australian. Provided you have enough funds and a clean criminal history you can get a working holiday visa for up-to 24 months. No degree required, no archaic process, an actual visa that lets you work and gives you rights. While this isn't permanent, it goes to show, how fundamentally different the US and other countries are when it comes to visas.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by 300bps on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:21PM (#8688770)
First you said:

it is not that they are looking for "cheap labour"

Then you said:

The company is based in Seattle and they are facing increasing competition from Microsoft and Amazon mostly who are sucking up all of the talent in the area, whilst other smaller startups and companies struggle to hire people because the bigger companies are offering more money.

Your second statement contradicts your first statement. What you're saying is that there are people to hire but your company isn't willing to pay them the market rate, so they are turning to foreign workers.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by DigitalSea on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @04:31PM (#8690053)
At face value, I can see why you think that. Supply and demand, as supply dwindles and demand increases, the price increases as well, right? Simple economics. I understand it and I get it, but I don't think the instance of developers that it is fair that bigger companies with larger profits and reach should be able to take all of the talent in the area by offering above average salaries to get them to sign. Smaller companies with half the profits and budgets shouldn't have to compete or die, it just is not fair.

While I agree that companies should not see it as an excuse to hire cheap talent elsewhere, when there is nobody to pick from in the pool (nobody decent) then where do you go? When the likes of Google are actually offering students jobs before they've even graduated and entered the job market, how does little ACME Corp or Joe Startup compete when workers are being plucked before they even enter the workforce?

Forget the money for a moment, when there is nobody to pick from or you are constantly entering into a bidding war with Application A who has received an offer from Google for $250k per year and all you can offer is $125k and perhaps some other perks, is that fair? Google aren't paying $250k because they think the applicant is worth it or that is the going market rate, they are paying this much because they know the application nine times out of ten will say yes to a ridiculous sum of money, because they need a developer and the cost is irrelevant to them and because they can.

Proper average market salary and inflated market salary are two different things, wouldn't you agree? And people ask if we are in a tech bubble? When graduate developers fresh out of college are being offered the kind of salaries close to what the prime minister of Australia earns (about $500k AUD for reference) you have to ask yourself, is it fair for smaller companies to compete or die because some big companies have set the bar way above average market rate?

But like I said, I know there are companies that take advantage of overseas workers. I have heard stories of people being forced to work ridiculous hours because they are on a H1-B and know that if they fire the employee, everything they have just packed up and moved thousands of miles will have to be packed up and transported again back home. But not all companies are like that, just like not everyone is a racist. It's always a handful of people that ruin it for everyone else.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by cableshaft on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:20PM (#8690382)
Going off of what another poster said: I'd agree to that $125k salary if I could work remotely. I'm in the Chicago area, and it's significantly more difficult to find jobs that are willing to pay that much out here (most jobs that advertise their ranges are more in the $80-100k area), whereas it's trivial to get a job offer as low as $125k if I were to move to the west coast (I was interviewing for jobs advertising $140k+).

But I've been trying to stay in the Chicago area because that's where my social network and family are, and I actually want to consider buying a house someday, instead of it being a silly pipe dream out there.

I'm sure I'm not the only person like this. Hiring managers don't immediately have to go "hey there's no one local, let's go overseas!". If you're willing to open yourself up to having employees that work remotely (and programming jobs require people to be left alone by themselves 90% of the time anyway), then you may find it easier to find candidates.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by robwilliams on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:00PM (#8690246)
>Forget the money for a moment, when there is nobody to pick from or you are constantly entering into a bidding war with Application A who has received an offer from Google for $250k per year and all you can offer is $125k and perhaps some other perks, is that fair? Google aren't paying $250k because they think the applicant is worth it or that is the going market rate, they are paying this much because they know the application nine times out of ten will say yes to a ridiculous sum of money, because they need a developer and the cost is irrelevant to them and because they can.

How is this not fair? If Google can offer more money to hire a skilled developer, they will. To get top talent you have to pay for it.

>Smaller companies with half the profits and budgets shouldn't have to compete or die, it just is not fair.

Yes it is. Compete or die is the entire basis of the US economy, isn't it?

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @01:44AM (#8692213)
>Proper average market salary and inflated market salary are two different things

I don't think you can have "inflated market salary." Instead what you have is the true market salary (for an experienced engineer that's good, that's a minimum of $200k at this point), and then you have the amount that most companies are willing to pay (which typically caps at $125-150k).

In the US, until the 1970s, average income (in constant dollars) rose at a pretty compelling rate. After the 1970s, a number of factors have combined such that we've not seen the same rise in real income -- despite the fact that productivity, as in, the amount of value we're adding to companies' bottom lines, has been rising.

This is why the gap between the rich and the rest has been growing so quickly. The added productivity is enriching the few at the expense of the many, except for a very few exceptions; one of those is exceptional software developers, who can take advantage (at the moment) of their rarity to actually negotiate salaries commensurate with their productivity.

I'm one of those who was able to secure a $250k+ offer from a big company, which is awesome, and I'm really lucky to be in this position. But the reality is that I know a lot of developers who are really good and who should be making over $200k/year, at a minimum, but who make $125k or less.

Importing H1-B workers in large quantities keeps those salaries lower than they should be. Instead companies need to raise compensation to keep up with demand. Maybe it means they can only afford half as many developers, but they're likely better off with fewer good developers anyway. :)

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by aidenn0 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:04PM (#8690277)
If Google regularly pays people more than the value they create, they will eventually run out of money.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by Squarel on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:36PM (#8689304)
Only if you define the market rate as "That paid by those with the deepest pockets", in which case, you may find the price of a gallon of milk to be somewhat different than what you expect.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by jtbigwoo on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @03:25PM (#8689611)
>> Only if you define the market rate as "That paid by those with the deepest pockets",

This is exactly what market rate means. That's why apartments are so expensive in SF or NY.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by cm2012 on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @03:22PM (#8689595)
The price of milk is that paid by those with the deepest pockets. It's just that the supply of milk is plentiful.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by ianlevesque on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:17PM (#8688747)
Really it just sounds like they should extend your remote position to full-time employee status. The modern workforce extends beyond a single office with warm bodies in seats.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by manticore_alpha on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:53PM (#8688538)
I hate to say this, but in your position I'd suggest you collude with your employer to fake a degree.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by msie on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:12PM (#8688706)
And you just said: "There's standard, normalized ways immigrants have come to the US for a long time now."

But for this guy's sake you'll make an exception? Is that because he won't form an ethnic ghetto?

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by DigitalSea on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @04:20PM (#8689986)
If you faked a degree, you would definitely be caught. If you are caught defrauding the Government in such a way, you might escape jail time (if it is your first offense) but also face the possibility of a ban from the US itself (permanently or for a very long time). This means you would not possibly even be able to travel to the US as a tourist because you tried to deceptively defraud.

Not really an avenue I am looking to explore, thanks. I am going to speak with an immigration lawyer and see what my options are, perhaps for other visas, equivalency for education experience to substitute and an exception on an application. I will probably write up a little blog post detailing how I go, for anyone else who finds themselves in a similar situation.

Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by SamReidHughes on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:56PM (#8688569)
That is an incredibly stupid idea.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by axotty on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @12:56PM (#8688570)
This is fraud. Do not do this.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by bsusensjackson on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:05PM (#8688639)
Right, because it is so difficult to verify credentials. Under no circumstances should you do this.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by curiousDog on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @11:32PM (#8691917)
So what you're saying is you only want white people coming in? Australia is also pretty diverse you know.
Re:Immigration is about talent, not costs by zerr on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @01:26PM (#8688815)
Or he can get his real degree in some Patrick Korseka private university, Some street, Building 56, 5th floor, room #34. Ask Paul :)