News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by sentiental on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:31PM (#8682741)
I have been concerned that Docker's scope was expanding too far for a while now, so I'm glad to see an alternative that might work appear on the horizon. That said, I am somewhat concerned that CoreOS has a suspiciously similar business model to where Docker would probably like to be.

It's in a business's best interest, and exceedingly common practice, to "land and expand" with something clear and compelling, and following that add features to compete with alternative solutions. I don't think there's anything inherently altruistic about CoreOS that would keep Rocket lean in the long-run, especially as they begin migrating their various tools away from Docker containers.

Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by rafikk on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:38PM (#8682795)
I had the same initial reaction, but I think there's good reason to trust the CoreOS folks to remain faithful to the project's goals. Containerization (although foundational) is one part of CoreOS's platform. It's easy to see where the boundaries fall, e.g. I expect systemd and fleetd to keep their respective functionality and not overlap with Rocket.

It become pretty clear once dotCloud became Docker Inc. that they intended to capitalize on the "Docker" brand to sell an integrated orchestration platform. CoreOS already has enterprise customers for their operating system and related components. They seem like the perfect team to take this challenge on.

Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by Alupis on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:49PM (#8682860)
I think it's also crucial users have more than one viable container option.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by jmendeth on Monday December 01, 2014 @02:33PM (#8683138)
The difference here would be, IMO, that they have clearly made openness one of Rocket's goals: the formats should be well-specified and maintained separately so that other implementations can run them.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by altcognito on Monday December 01, 2014 @02:26PM (#8683085)
> I have been concerned that Docker's scope was expanding too far for a while now

What features were recently introduced that it increased Docker's scope?

Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by lclarkmichalek on Monday December 01, 2014 @03:57PM (#8683731)
Talk of Docker cluster, which might include a network overlay layer a la weave
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by shykes on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:03PM (#8683771)
All of which will be fully pluggable with a "batteries included but removable" design, just like we did with sandboxing and storage.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by lclarkmichalek on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:10PM (#8683815)
You may need to make that clearer to some of the people that are due to be building your plugins: reading http://weaveblog.com/2014/11/13/life-and-docker-networking/, I get the feeling that they're not thrilled about it.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by shykes on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:42PM (#8684037)
maybe they're busy designing the interface and implementing a proof-of-concept with us as we speak, instead of blogging and twittering.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by lclarkmichalek on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:47PM (#8684066)
Welp, I'm putting "been snarked by founder of Docker" on my CV.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by shykes on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:54PM (#8684119)
I guess so - sorry ;)

I hope you can understand that it's frustrating when, after hard work pitching an API to dozens of ecosystem players, spending weeks trying to wrangle a working implementation which makes as many of them as happy as possible, without compromising integrity of design - after all that, in the end, all it takes is one unhappy camper to write a blog post and that immediately tramples everything else.

It's even more discouraging in this particular case, because after this blog post, Alexis and I have discussed this topic extensively, and as a result he has since joined the effort. In fact I will be hacking with him in person on integrating Weave as a native networking plugin in 2 days in Amsterdam.

So, sorry for the insta-snark. But it can be frustrating to see so much good will and hard work be crushed in a second.

Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by lclarkmichalek on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:58PM (#8684155)
Hey, regardless of the technical sides of anything, I'm sure this is not a fun day for you. I think you're handling the situation terribly, but still, not a fun day. Anyway, docker is awesome, and thanks for building it. I know it's made my devops life a lot more enjoyable of late.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by shykes on Monday December 01, 2014 @05:05PM (#8684207)
I guess I am. PR has never been my thing. I'll get back to hacking, after all it's the reason we do all this: building cool things.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by jsprogrammer on Monday December 01, 2014 @06:55PM (#8684892)
Don't do PR, just build the better thing.

No malice, just a friendly tip :)

Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by jbaptiste on Monday December 01, 2014 @06:49PM (#8684871)
Concerning Weave that's quite a good news, the weave point of view for docker networking is good and can be easily setup in many (not all of them of course) infrastructure.
Re:CoreOS is building a container runtime, Rocket by wmf on Monday December 01, 2014 @02:53PM (#8683294)
They'll probably keep Rocket lean and introduce new features as "separate projects" that will all be bundled into CoreOS.