A major omission when attacking someone's legal qualifications.
> When he's not writing antitrust papers, he's busy writing scare papers about click fraud, or online ad deals
Yes, and they're scary because they are true. The insidious thing about click fraud is that consumers are the mules who do the work but generally are only indirectly harmed. Advertisers and merchants really get screwed. Ben has been exposing those situations for a decade.
> You only have to look at his testimony list to see where his views lie, and have since 2006.
Actually I worked with him in 2005 and his views were consistent then as well. If he works on behalf of people who share his views, that's not a bad thing is it? It's fully disclosed, which is more than I can say for many of his attackers.
See, e.g., http://mumbrella.com.au/google-adwords-benjamin-edelman-3700...
Google literally does not pay me for my views on this.
Ben is literally paid for his anti-google views on this stuff.
You are of course, welcome to discount whatever you like. You should always read and judge everything critically :)
My conclusions from this thread are in fact that you mostly just happen to work for Google, that you have a long personal (and vaguely professional) interest in observing this dispute, and that Ben is a paid shill that abuses his credentials and the brand of his employer to make easy money. But it gave me pause that you weren't up-front about your own employer.
Also, once again: you can't accuse someone of being biased by their employer, and then say you've "taken pause" about it, without insulting that person's integrity. To do so casually says much more about you than the person you're talking about.
People like Daniel take a lot of flak on HN simply because they sign their names to their comments. As we saw downthread: not only do the anonymous assholes taking potshot not do that, but those anonymous people are actually paid shills.
It is fine to have questions about people, but you should have been much more careful asking them. You share a community with these people, but just now, you didn't act that way. Like they say on Wikipedia: WP:AGF.
(This is a hobby-horse issue with me on this site, because I've been here awhile and had a lot of dipshits question my integrity over utterly fictitious biases, like "you work in security so all that government contracting money you get selling vulnerabilities to the CIA is why your crypto advice is obviously corrupted by NSA".)
(Also: 'DannyBee is one of several compiler-wonk/lawyers we have on HN, and how cool is it that we have any of those? It pisses me off to see people try to chase them off with torches and pitchforks, even if those chasers are so dumb they're using nerf pitchforks.)
Claiming that they don't pay you for your views may be true in the sense that this is not an official assignment for you, but to pretend that you are not heavily incentivized to act in what you perceive to be Google's interests is dishonest.
Disclaimer: I work for TAGA (The Arrogant Google Assholes)
https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=recoiledsnake
https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=cooldeal
... and many dozens of others.
This person (or persons) is an accomplished if not professional pro-Microsoft astroturfer whose "contributions" to Hacker News consist of shilling for Microsoft, slagging Microsoft competitors, and covering their tracks. At one point they even created fake female identities to make it look like when we banned them, we were banning women (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7079380).
We ban any account that evidence suggests is part of this campaign or anything similar. It is a bad-faith abuse of this site that has cost us many hours of work that would otherwise have been poured into improving HN, so they steal from this community in addition to violating it.
It's especially galling to see them personally attack sincere users who don't hide their affiliations and don't snake around replying to themselves.
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.
In the history of this site nobody has ever made themselves look smarter or been more persuasive by accusing another HN commenter of being a shill.
Everyone on HN works for someone. I am not my company. Google has plenty of views i don't agree with, and I have plenty of views they don't agree with.
If you believe comments on HN (or almost anywhere else) should have conflict of interest disclosures, you may as well shut it all down.
Everything here is opinions of people, presented as opinions of people.
Ben publishes pieces in newspapers, journals, and testimony, and pretends they are objective while being paid by companies to write them.
If you think this is the same as me or anyone else commenting on HN about their personal opinions, i'm not sure what to tell you.
When I start submitting congressional testimony on behalf of google, and we start talking about it on HN, i'll happily note that i wrote it.
(In the same way when we talked about Google code.google.com, i happily noted i worked on it)
Are you pretending to be unaffected by the incentives you have to defend Google?
A Googler defending Google on HN has the backing of one of the most powerful corporations in the industry, and no risk to his future career.
Calling out this bias or even being critical of the Google carries potentially huge career risk.
Anonymity is a necessity if unpopular opinions are to be heard.
And by all means assume I work for a competitor (which I do not) - that doesn't change the fact that DannyBee is incentivized to support Google and yet tries to distinct himself from this truth.
But that's what I'd expect to see from a secret shill for Yahoo.
You, on the other hand, are now name calling, denying the power imbalance I mentioned, and accusing me of lying.
Why do you feel the need to put so much emotional energy into defending DannyBee, who seems quite capable of defending himself?
You seem to have clearly deviated from what you call 'civic discourse' - why have you chosen to do that? Does it seem justified by my comment?
If you think so, then ask yourself why it is acceptable for you to break from 'civic discourse', and yet it is not justified for me to do so, as you claim I have. Do you think your opinion is more right, or more likely to receive support?
Ironically, voice of the hackers, the independents, the non-affiliated is weak here. The voice of the tech establishment, the VCs, the startups, the megacorps is heard loud and clear.
Do you not see how HN is crucial for YC continued success as the VC company? YC doesn't have to censor anything, the increased presence of YC alumni defines the narrative.
I do not believe that it is healthy for most important tech community on the open internet to be so strongly influenced by one VC company.
Disclosures would help a little bit.
edit I don't mind the downvotes :)
Also, ofc, with you being one of the top HN members would not support that. I don't have any personal benefit from any outcome, but you do. Who is all class now?
edit: I am curious, in what way, shape or form "external entity or random event" part of my comment is related to either presence or lack of my class? Care to elaborate?
(a) "A conflict of interest is a set of circumstances that creates a risk that professional judgement or actions regarding a primary interest will be unduly influenced by a secondary interest." "The conflict in a conflict of interest exists whether or not a particular individual is actually influenced by the secondary interest. It exists if the circumstances are reasonably believed (on the basis of past experience and objective evidence) to create a risk that decisions may be unduly influenced by secondary interests."
It is reasonable to believe that a person discussing his employer on public forum creates a RISK that his posting decisions MAY be unduly influenced.
Stating that a conflict of interest exists doesn't question the integrity of the person per se. I am not sure why would you choose a COI definition that is easily disproven by Wikipedia.
(b) Simple. That is not what I said. "suggesting that coercive force to be used to shut down" != "[to] be not against some external entity or random event shutting down".
And finally, (c). You were the one going full ad hominem without addressing anything in my original argument.
I don't get your motivation, though. It is obvious that HN is skewed in UX/UI and in the discussion contents in the favor of YC and YC alumni. That's the point. What is your reason to be aggressive about that?
I posted something the other day about the myo and i got a error page everytime I submitted it. tried submitting something else and bang it goes straight through.
I dont care that they censor stuff but that they are underhand and sneaky about it gives me pause for thought when I see content on here from YC startups, was it pushed to the front page artificially? Probably. Best to err on the side of caution and assume that it is just YC trying to sell me on their latest startup.
No, we don't do that. We actually take care to penalize stories less when they are negative about YC or YC-funded startups, and none of the HN software takes YC-related material into account. I mention the latter because what you're describing sounds like it was done by the software.
There must have been some other problem with your post. If you provide a link we'll be happy to look into it for you.
This was the link that I tried to post, I submitted it 9 days ago when I subsequently posted another Myo link to the offical website which was allowed to stay up. I tried to post 3 times each time it just disappeared and threw me back to the submission page. I then tried to make another submission, one about a drone being used by an estate agent, which went through fine, then I submitted a direct link to the Myo site which also went through fine. So I tried my original link again and got the same 'error'.
Interestingly enough if you look at the original article I tried to submit there is a line that says:
"Quick aside, but if you want to see how nearly every form of media is crooked, try submitting this to Hacker News and look at the Thalmic investors. Edit: don’t bother, we’re blacklisted or something."
So evidently others had a similar experience to me whislt trying to submit the story.
Re the quote from that article, it's common for article writers to spice their posts with claims of being blacklisted. In HN's case, at least, you should take such claims with a lot of salt—they're usually groundless, and the ones that aren't are typically distorted. I tried to point that out in this case at the time (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8625890).
Whether this is by fanboys or by YC it doesn't really matter, it is still a form of censorship.
Ben has literally no legal training in antitrust law that i'm aware of, so his opining on it is somewhat interesting.
(I edited this comment because Ben does have a JD from Harvard law that I forgot about, so he does have legal training, just not anything related to antitrust law)
When he's not writing antitrust papers, he's busy writing scare papers about click fraud, or online ad deals.
There are plenty of people who have views i disagree with, and respect. But folks like Ben, whose views seem to change entirely with who is paying him (i've watched him argue the same thing both ways depending on whether MS was doing it or Google was doing it), are not even worth arguing with.
You only have to look at his testimony list to see where his views lie, and have since 2006.