Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by spolu on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:25PM
(#8604837)
Quick note on comparison with node-webkit / atom-shell:
node-webkit and atom-shell embeds NodeJS along the chromium content module forcing its user to use not only NodeJS but a particular build of it.
On the contrary, Thrust embeds the Chromium content module and exposes an API on the standard IO, which makes it bindable in any language and works perfectly well as a dependency with vanilla nodeJS / Go / Python
Makes the distribution of cross-platform GUI apps through the pip/npm possible.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:40PM
(#8604896)
Correct, there have also been other similar implementations along the same vain, but they all attempt to inject one technology into another. Thrust takes a different approach, it is itself the chromium content library, with some added libraries, and an rpc interface. This allows it to be used without forcing another library implementor to `inject` their code into it.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by morganrallen on Thursday November 13, 2014 @07:14PM
(#8605055)
As a proof of concept I knocked up JankyBrowser in about 3 hours. Nagivation? Check. Tabs? Check (how long did other browser take to get those!). All in a little over 6K of JS.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by christiangenco on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:49PM
(#8605856)
...wow! This is a really compelling
I know it's really fashionable to hate on javascript, but there's really something to be said for being able to code a web browser with tools you can learn on Khan Academy.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Friday November 14, 2014 @09:12AM
(#8607164)
al2o3cr, actually no. There are a load of difficult implementations needed to achieve even the most basic webbrowser, even when building on top of the already great chromium content lib. For instance, Thrust's predecessor ExoBrowser failed where Thrust is succeeding, thankfully we have progressed to a state of composability where we can take the work of others before and compose it into something useable for the world. The 500 something commits to Thrust were no simple feat, and their are many more to come.
Honestly, I'm super prepared for the world where HTML/CSS is used for all the GUIs (while HTML/CSS are not perfect, I think they've done a pretty good job being flexible enough style to millions of user-facing GUI applications, also known as web sites, for so long). I don't think many people agree, but the day I don't have to try and choose between TK, GTK, QT, and some other smaller framework is gonna be a good day.
Not quite the same (since this runs on chromium, and I'm not sure that TideSDK does also -- at least it's been around too long that it feels like they couldn't possibly have).
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by jmnicolas on Friday November 14, 2014 @04:11AM
(#8606373)
This is not a popular view, but I think as developers we should focus on one platform and serve it well, instead of making nearly tolerable apps for every platforms.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by hardwaresofton on Friday November 14, 2014 @10:37AM
(#8607580)
Some days I agree with you -- optimization/platform-specific code definitely has it's place (we would be nowhere without it, all the web stuff stands on shoulders of giants on other giants), and targeted building.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mcdermed on Thursday November 13, 2014 @09:13PM
(#8605482)
As a web developer this is a very cool project. It's a very simple sandbox to develop a custom application or even customize my browsing experience. Being built on the current stable release of Chrome makes it even better.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by xtacy on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:07PM
(#8605630)
I get this error when building it. Any thoughts?
$ go get -u github.com/miketheprogrammer/go-thrust
package github.com/miketheprogrammer/go-thrust
imports github.com/miketheprogrammer/go-thrust
imports github.com/miketheprogrammer/go-thrust: no buildable Go source files in /Users/user/.gocode/src/github.com/miketheprogrammer/go-thrust
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Friday November 14, 2014 @07:14AM
(#8606751)
Apologies to all, we are restructuring the application to work better with go get.
You can try with the -d flag to avoid building files. this should download the application to the proper gopath.
then you can use the instructions from the go-thrust repo homepage.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by liuyanghejerry on Friday November 14, 2014 @12:11PM
(#8608209)
Seems nice, especially with variant bindings instead of only one.
One more question, how to update the whole application after distributed, including HTML/CSS/JS files and the framework binaries? Do I still have to make one updater(which is not really an easy task if you want a fancy UI), or is Chromium's update framework included already?
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by morganrallen on Friday November 14, 2014 @01:23PM
(#8608606)
Unlike PhantomJS, this is not a headless browser (though can be!), its a browser that can be designed in HTML/CSS/JS. This is to say, the navigation buttons are controlled by you, your own download manager, etc. Time and imagination are your limits.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by JasonFruit on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:56PM
(#8605745)
I think this is the first time I've seen the phrase, "requires Python 3." It's certainly the first time I've seen it on something that I want badly enough to mess with it.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by jpgvm on Friday November 14, 2014 @12:16AM
(#8605911)
To be fair the Python bindings are pretty simple, you could easily implement it in Python 2. You do need evented I/O however so you could write either gevent or twisted bindings.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by c0brac0bra on Friday November 14, 2014 @12:14PM
(#8608234)
Not sure if it's the same issue, but I ran into problems with node-webkit and jagged font-icon animations due to them not being able to package direct3d dlls with the project. Simply popping them in on my own solved it.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @09:52PM
(#8605597)
Node-Webkit is hacky at best. Atom-Shell is a major improvement on Node-Webkit, however not quite there. Native modules need to be compiled for a completely different target.
Thrust takes it a step further, improving on the past. Thrust uses the same backing library as Atom-Shell (brightray) to expose the Chromium Content Library.
Thrust is cross-platform cross-language. Use a similar familiar api from any language you want, or roll your own.
No need to use javascript on the backend if you dont want to.
For example, Go-Thrust can compile, this is a particular advantage for distributing applications.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:01PM
(#8605614)
Now to add some more context, Thrust's predecessor (ExoBrowser) still used embedded NodeJS, this made it incredibly difficult to package native modules with applications. The Thrust team learned from the mistakes of the past and decided to try to simplify the stack as much as possible to allow true composability.
Re:Thrust: Chromium-based cross-platform, cross-language app...
by mhernandez1988 on Friday November 14, 2014 @09:08AM
(#8607149)
One could use c++ instead of Python/JS/Go, I would however recommend still using the JSONRpc bridge to communicate. I would not recommend using c/c++ at all, as Atom.io has proven more modern garbage collected languages have become so incredibly fast that c/c++ are primarily distractions unless you are a master of the incredibly huge ecosystem and can sling code together fast without having leaks, pointer issues, and a host of other security issues.
At a minimum, I would recommend using Go or NodeJS with a C binding for any extremely low level operations you would like to achieve, that would make everything much more suitable, you would also benefit of the ecosystem of modules.
node-webkit and atom-shell embeds NodeJS along the chromium content module forcing its user to use not only NodeJS but a particular build of it.
On the contrary, Thrust embeds the Chromium content module and exposes an API on the standard IO, which makes it bindable in any language and works perfectly well as a dependency with vanilla nodeJS / Go / Python
Makes the distribution of cross-platform GUI apps through the pip/npm possible.
https://gist.github.com/morganrallen/f07f59802884bcdcad4a
I know it's really fashionable to hate on javascript, but there's really something to be said for being able to code a web browser with tools you can learn on Khan Academy.
Turns out, it's pretty easy to code a web browser in ANYTHING if one of the primitives you can instantiate is A WEB BROWSER...
Or are they completely ignored?
The same thing in Java Swing took me 3 weeks 4 years ago.
Honestly, I'm super prepared for the world where HTML/CSS is used for all the GUIs (while HTML/CSS are not perfect, I think they've done a pretty good job being flexible enough style to millions of user-facing GUI applications, also known as web sites, for so long). I don't think many people agree, but the day I don't have to try and choose between TK, GTK, QT, and some other smaller framework is gonna be a good day.
Not quite the same (since this runs on chromium, and I'm not sure that TideSDK does also -- at least it's been around too long that it feels like they couldn't possibly have).
We thought "Hey, it runs on everything!" would be nice for our future roadmap...but didn't we say the same about Java?
But other days I'm struggling to use objective-c.
Thrust takes it a step further, improving on the past. Thrust uses the same backing library as Atom-Shell (brightray) to expose the Chromium Content Library.
Thrust is cross-platform cross-language. Use a similar familiar api from any language you want, or roll your own. No need to use javascript on the backend if you dont want to.
For example, Go-Thrust can compile, this is a particular advantage for distributing applications.
At a minimum, I would recommend using Go or NodeJS with a C binding for any extremely low level operations you would like to achieve, that would make everything much more suitable, you would also benefit of the ecosystem of modules.
Make sense?