News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by wil421 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:15PM (#8603026)
>The subject’s last memory before passing out was the realization that the water on his tongue was boiling, according to NASA.

That is not something I would ever want to experience.

I wonder how similar this environment is the the SR71 that disintegrated [1]. Luckily the SR71 pilots wore space suits with this happened. Otherwise I dont think he would have survived.

[1]http://www.916-starfighter.de/SR-71_Waever.htm

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:56PM (#8603673)
In addition to the boiling spit thing, he was rammed at Mach 1 into -57C air at 15km altitude, without wearing some fancy astronaut suit, coming out of a space vehicle disintegrating around him. Then he regained consciousness en route down to Earth and unbuckled the seat. How was the whole ordeal survivable - I can't even begin to imagine.

This is the real man of steel.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by pwnna on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:52PM (#8604009)
Just did some rough calculations on a different thread about the conditions he would have experienced here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8603968

But yeah, he's gotta be the luckiest person alive right now, being the only one surviving a space launch related accident while airborne.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by lmm on Friday November 14, 2014 @05:22AM (#8606512)
Yeager famously survived an accident with a modified F-104 that was in some ways quite similar to the SpaceX craft (i.e. a plane with a rocket that can fly an arc up out of the atmosphere). Quite a few of these rocket-plane flights were considered spaceflight at the time, though they don't meet the modern (100km) definition.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by yincrash on Friday November 14, 2014 @08:17AM (#8606945)
To clarify, it was a Virgin Galactic craft, not SpaceX.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jsmthrowaway on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:47PM (#8603972)
Bloomberg flubbed that bit. The NASA subject felt the boiling, not the pilot. The next section's heading was a paragraph early and confused me, too.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jcampbell1 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:19PM (#8603788)
Interestingly, low altitude supersonic ejection is worse than high altitude.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HecyxhXDepU

Water boiling on the tongue sounds less bad than having your arms and legs blown out of socket.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:57PM (#8604048)
Fluids are not so fluid - if encountered suddenly at high enough speed.

As anyone who did a belly flop from a high place can testify.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by davyjones on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:33AM (#8606303)
Actually, the water boiling is a sign that probably Nitrogen is boiling off your blood too. Don't want that to happen.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by 3327 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:28PM (#8603840)
He is not a man of steel. Just his nut sack. And probably depleted uranium is more likely.

Years of experience and training. Thats why he was in that seat in the first place.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by thekingofspain on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:39PM (#8603199)
That doesn't mean the water was super hot, though.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by wil421 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:41PM (#8603216)
The next sentence in the article is:

>Water boils at lower temperatures as pressure decreases.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by viewer5 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:54PM (#8603658)
So it wouldn't feel boiling-hot, just weird and bubbly?
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Sharlin on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:59PM (#8603686)
Yes. Probably something like a carbonated beverage but without the acidity.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by lutorm on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:29PM (#8604850)
Anyone who's put liquid nitrogen in their mouth (and if you haven't, you've missed out) knows the feeling.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by scoot on Thursday November 13, 2014 @07:37PM (#8605145)
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by lutorm on Thursday November 13, 2014 @08:01PM (#8605234)
Yeah, you should obviously not actually ingest it.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by DigitalJack on Thursday November 13, 2014 @08:37PM (#8605360)
The risk of shattered teeth stopped me from trying that one.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by syncsynchalt on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:55PM (#8604038)
Like Pop Rocks, yes.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by chrisbennet on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:51PM (#8604002)
In high school chemistry class, we watched as water under a vacuum boiled and then turned to ice.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by robotcookies on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:33PM (#8603541)
Yeah, any liquid water will boil in a vacuum, even if it's at body temperature or even colder (as long as it's not frozen of course).
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by sp332 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:55PM (#8603315)
The air was either way too thin to breathe, or quite hot (or both). Pretty uncomfortable no matter what.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by ajcarpy2005 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:42PM (#8604320)
Wouldn't the air have been cold?
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by sp332 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:01PM (#8604427)
Maybe not if a spaceship was exploding nearby?
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by ProAm on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:49PM (#8603272)
Still terrifying.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Zikes on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:43PM (#8603600)
Hard to imagine it would feel much different from a mouthful of Pop Rocks, really.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by DanBC on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:02PM (#8603698)
But pop rocks at 15km when you've just been blown out of a malfunctioning space vehicle still strapped to your chair while you're tryi to unbuckle it so you can pull the shute.

Just like pop rocks.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Zikes on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:07PM (#8604100)
The context is an account of an incident in a NASA vacuum testing chamber where a tester's suit lost pressure, not of the crash.

I'm quite certain both experiences on the whole would be terrifying, but as the detail of the saliva boiling on the tongue was singled out to be terrifying on its own, that is what I based my comment on.

In my imagining of what it would feel like to have your saliva boil yet not be under a great amount of heat, I can only imagine it would feel like a mouth full of pop rocks. I don't find that terrifying.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by chdir on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:52PM (#8602879)
Crash investigation (Source - NTSB : http://www.ntsb.gov/news/2014/141112.html)

According to the pilot, he was unaware that the feather system had been unlocked early by the copilot. His description of the vehicle motion was consistent with other data sources in the investigation. He stated that he was extracted from the vehicle as a result of the break-up sequence and unbuckled from his seat at some point before the parachute deployed automatically. Recorded information from telemetry, non-volatile memory, and videos are being processed and validated to assist the investigative groups.

... The investigation is ongoing. Any future updates will be issued as events warrant.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by smackfu on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:29PM (#8603107)
Yes, that's actually the only source of new info.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by TrevorJ on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:02PM (#8604074)
I was also interested in the fast that they weren't in pressure suits. Apparently the ingress/egress hatch is so small as to preclude them wearing basic safety equipment. I'm becoming less and less sympathetic to Virgin Galactic the more I hear.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jostmey on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:05PM (#8604093)
Cut the company some slack. Space flight is hard. There are physical constraints imposed by the laws of Nature that have to be carefully weighed. It is easy to forget this fact when all you ever do is software design or whatever.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by bunderbunder on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:24PM (#8604207)
Not too much slack. It's true that space flight is hard. But it's also true that Virgin Galactic is a company based entirely around sub-orbital space tourism. The level of risk we should consider acceptable for what's essentially an ultra-high-priced amusement park ride is rather lower than the level of risk we should consider acceptable for space exploration.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by 4ad on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:27PM (#8604568)
People who pay to go can make their own decision if the risk is acceptable to them or not. It's not anyone else's business to decide what the acceptable level of risk is.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by trhway on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:21PM (#8604820)
>People who pay to go can make their own decision if the risk is acceptable to them or not. It's not anyone else's business to decide what the acceptable level of risk is.

until they are a MIT trained airspace engineers, i doubt they are able to estimate the risk and thus to make a fully informed decision on their own. This is why it is official government agencies' business to at least establish minimum acceptable risk baselines.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by c1sc0 on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:54AM (#8606347)
And that's how you end up in a society where all risk-taking is banned to the fringes. No thanks, I'd much rather sign the "waiver from hell". High-risk activities CAN be self-regulated by industry, i.e. skydiving.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by bunderbunder on Friday November 14, 2014 @10:22AM (#8607510)
I'm no expert on this subject, but a small amount of Googling suggests that rumors of skydiving's lack of regulation in the US have been greatly exaggerated. For example, you can't just pack your own chute - there's a special FAA certification you have to get before you're allowed to do that.

The rules I'm seeing seem more like the ones that govern recreational sailing, which is a topic I'm more familiar with: If you're just doing it on your own, sailing is fairly lightly regulated. Your boat needs to meet some minimum requirements for safety equipment and the like, but for the most part all the rules for recreational sailing are voluntary and self-imposed by the community.

But all that goes out the window once you start doing it commercially. If you want to take tourists out on a day sail, you need to be a licensed captain and there's a whole host of federally-imposed rules about how you operate your boat that come into play.

Virgin Galactic isn't analogous to some guy day-sailing in his own boat. SpaceShipOne would have been, but SpaceShipTwo is much more analogous to commercial sailing, which is comprehensively regulated for the sake of consumer protection.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by alexhawdon on Friday November 14, 2014 @05:46AM (#8606560)
I wouldn't say this parallels with skydiving as it's something new. If I choose to go skydiving I can easily get a grasp on how dangerous it is by looking up statistics and choosing a reputable company with a good track record. If I choose to take a Virgin Galactic trip then unless I possess very specialist knowledge I just have to take their word that it's "safe".
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by trhway on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:25PM (#8604838)
>Space flight is hard.

this is why lessons of previous attempts in the industry should be rolled into the next ones. Pressure suits on launch is standard long established practice in space flight industry since the dawn of times, and so far there is no evidence that it should be changed.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by vertis on Friday November 14, 2014 @08:55AM (#8607082)
Out of curiosity how many people have pressure suits saved?
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by TrevorJ on Friday November 14, 2014 @08:45PM (#8610549)
There's slack, and then there's there's unnecessary risk. If you can't fit a basic piece of safety equipment on your test pilot then you need to rethink your strategy.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by clueless123 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:14PM (#8603023)
To survive this is absolutely incredible, the only pitty is that the article lacks so many interesting details!

Was he wearing the chute on his back? (So,he had to get out of his seat to be able to open)

What kind of AAD was he wearing ? (was it an off the shelf AAD like a Cypress?)

What where it's settings? pass through such altitude at such vertical speed to open..

Any one knows? any links?

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by smu3l on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:44PM (#8603235)
I couldn't find any information on who manufactured the automatic activation device, but it was almost certainly not an off the shelf model. Airtec created a specialized Cypres[1] for the Redbull Stratos project, and Cypres has had other applications in space, so I wouldn't be surprised if that's what was used.

[1] http://www.cypres.cc/index.php?option=com_content&view=artic...

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by smackfu on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:30PM (#8603115)
Good thing: NTSB will release a full report at some point with all these answers.

Bad thing: Until then, they tend to not say much.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by JshWright on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:39PM (#8603911)
Some might consider that to be two good things...
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by sebcat on Friday November 14, 2014 @12:27AM (#8605930)
AADs have barometric sensors. That works for skydivers because they zero it on the ground, they're in an unpressurized vessel and they always experience the same force vectors (with variations, belly vs. freefly &c).

How would you build a CYPRES-style (barometric, integrated, cutter based) AAD for an event like this? And why would you not have it built into the seat?

Speculation: they wore standard bail outs sans AAD, like regular pilots. This guy either don't remember pulling or had the forces excerted on him and/or his gear pull for him.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by InclinedPlane on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:34AM (#8606309)
CYPRES AADs work based on calculating rate of decent, not from some triggered barometric pressure. With modern micro-controllers it's practically trivial to tell the difference between a barometric altimeter sensor history of pressure changes in a cabin and pressure changes due to free falling through the open atmosphere. From there it's just a matter of triggering based on rate of decent, altitude ranges, etc.

Some "selling points" of the CYPRES-2: http://www.cypres-2.com/

Note how they call out that you can keep it activated on the ground, in vehicles, in pressurized cabins, etc. without fear of accidental automatic activation.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by sebcat on Friday November 14, 2014 @07:22AM (#8606782)
Rate of descent is calculated from barometric pressure in a CYPRES.

When a CYPRES is turned on, it calibrates itself and uses the current barometric pressure to determine the reference ground. When you enter an unpressurized aircraft and begi your ascent, the CYPRES will arm itself above a certain altitude (1000 ft normally). When you exit the aircraft, the CYPRES knows your altitude because of the difference in barometric pressure between the reference ground and the urrent pressure. It will also calculate your rate of descent from change in barometric pressure over time. It will activate if you're too low and too fast.

Notice how the environment is fairly static. You're jumping right above your reference. You're in an unpressurized vessel so the CYPRES can tell when to arm itself. You're starting a descent by exiting a level-flying aircraft. Any departure from normal operating limits and the CYPRES will not arm itself or activate at the proper speed and altitude.

You want a system like fighter pilots have and not something skydivers use. The environments are different, the operational requirements are different.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jobu on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:35PM (#8602769)
After all the speculation about engine failure, it sounds like the culprit is a combination of poor design and pilot error.

The "Feather System" was unlocked by a pilot too early in the flight, then air currents caused it to activate in atmosphere instead of near vacuum - likely tearing the ship apart.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by osivertsson on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:33PM (#8603872)
10-11 years ago I followed the Ansari X Prize a lot. I have a fuzzy recollection that Peter Siebold, the surviving pilot, actually designed and, at least in part, programmed almost everything related to pilot controls (and lots lots more!) on the SpaceShipOne.

If pilot controls are similar on SpaceShipTwo and poor design of them is blamed in the final NTSB report, then I hope Peter doesn't put too much blame on himself.

Peter Siebold has given and achieved so much on this project, definitely a hero of mine together with Burt Rutan.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by joezydeco on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:47PM (#8602838)
But part of the flight procedure is to actually unlock the feathers slightly later in the flight - at Mach 1.4.

The article states this is to make sure the feathers are operational before heading upward, but that seems like a really narrow margin of time to execute this test.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by malandrew on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:54PM (#8602892)
While speed is a factor, it isn't the only factor. The altitude at which they are unlocked matters as well. Moving at Mach 1.0 at a lower altitude could subject the plane to far greater forces than at Mach 1.4 at a much higher altitude, where the air is thinner.

Furthermore, where the force is coming from probably also plays a role. The angle of the force applied to the feathers may change when the force is not coming from a fall, but is instead the result of the engines provide force from behind the fuselage.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by hga on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:55PM (#8604704)
Not poor design, the Feather System has to be unlocked at some point. And testing it early, at Mach 1.4 might be a really good idea before you (I assume) commit to needing it.

And there's a good possibility removing its contribution to the center of pressure too early is what caused the destruction.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by thrill on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:47PM (#8604919)
Hard to say if poor design is a contributing factor or not - if the release mechanism is easily confused because it's a tiny little switch that looks just like all the other tiny little switches, then yeah, it may be poor design. In new endeavors, especially the often unforgiving aviation arena, frequent and focused training often makes up for poor design, or less-than-wonderful human factors engineering, or other recognized-after-the-event shortcomings - until it doesn't.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by dfox on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:29PM (#8605680)
I would assume that in typical aircraft cockpit, most of the prominently placed tiny little switches are actually important and unimportant tiny little switches are the exception.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by 001sky on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:43PM (#8602812)
This was by design, not magic.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by vuldin on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:49PM (#8602858)
:D I know, the title is just a little misleading. And the article doesn't seem to make any mention of the automated parachute system.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jessaustin on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:14PM (#8603405)
Did the copilot's chute also deploy?
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by teleclimber on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:36PM (#8603553)
Apparently yes. He was found in the wreckage, strapped in his seat, with the chute partially deployed. It probably deployed automatically during the fall and shot out between the pilot and the seat.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jessaustin on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:51PM (#8603639)
Perhaps NTSB will have some thoughts about how to coordinate seat separation and chute deployment.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by teleclimber on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:13PM (#8603757)
If you don't have an ejection seat, getting kicked out of your seat inside a cockpit doesn't sound terribly helpful. Inflight breakup situations where the pilot breaks free in their seat are so rare that this would probably would cause more accidents than it would save lives.

Ejection seats do kick you out of the seat automatically sometime after ejection so that the automatic parachute deployment can work.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by jessaustin on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:38PM (#8604293)
Inflight breakup situations where the pilot breaks free in their seat are so rare...

Do intuitions developed about airframe integrity in an aviation context necessarily apply to spaceflight? Normally I wouldn't think automatic chute deployment would have much value without a full ejection seat, although in this case it saved a life. Did the designers of this craft actually have a meeting in which they decided that the likelihood of this exact sort of incident is so much higher than an intact-vehicle incident that an automatic chute is warranted while an ejection seat is not?

For some reason I suspect that a couple of years from now we'll be reading a tell-all about the culture of risk-taking at "The Spaceship Company". (Whether such a book is warranted or not.)

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Implicated on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:32PM (#8603528)
If I remember correctly he was still strapped into his seat when found.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by neurotech1 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:50PM (#8604684)
According to reports, the co-pilot was still in the cockpit section (seated and strapped in) on impact with the ground.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by popeshoe on Friday November 14, 2014 @06:44AM (#8606673)
Does anybody know if it's common that an aircraft can be structurally compromised like that due to user error?

I can easily imagine the stress on the airframe doing manoeuvres like this, if I were a pilot I'd be absolutely terrified that it were possible for me to flip a switch and just have the vehicle I'm in disintegrate around me.

edit: whoops, commented on a day old thread, what a dingus

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by kazinator on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:21PM (#8603795)
> “I can’t imagine the forces he must have experienced being thrown out of the aircraft,” Sventek, who spent 31 years in the U.S. Air Force, said in an interview.

Some initial impulse from the ejecting motion of the craft breakup, and then immediately after losing contact, the only net force should be the one from air drag due to the velocity. There is gravity, of course, but in free-fall, that force is balanced by your acceleration so you don't feel it. As you reach terminal velocity, it rises toward 1g.

That air drag would be a big force, though, when you're thrown into the air at the craft's velocity.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by pwnna on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:47PM (#8603968)
Did a little bit of a back of the envelop calculation on the subject, so this maybe completely bogus, be aware.

It would seem like the temperature that the pilot experienced upon ejection at Mach 1 at 15000m (when they broke apart) would be about -13C, which is reasonably survivable[1]. The pressure experienced is probably around 22kPa absolute, which in theory will generate anywhere between 6 - 20g[2]. Not pleasant, but survivable.

Given these, it takes a lot of luck to survive those conditions (1/5th atmosphere, extreme acceleration, low temperature when he falls), but it might be more survivable than we think (this is much better than exploding and ejecting at lower altitudes)

[1]: Calculation via the stagnation temperature at that speed for the standard condition at that altitude (Temperature ~= 217K, P ~= 12kPa)

[2]: Stagnation pressure on him in the front of the body (23kPa), ambient at the back. Average male body surface area is about 2m^2, depending on the geometry you might be able to get down to a quarter of that. Throw in the mass of the pilot (70kg? 90kg?), you should get accelerations in those ranges.

Edit: some more interpretations

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:01PM (#8604072)
> this maybe completely bogus, be aware

Well, much over 20g is not very survivable, so I'd say you're in the ballpark at least.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by pwnna on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:05PM (#8604452)
I doubt he got anywhere near 15g. As the pilot had a seat strapped to him when he was ejected, adding to his mass. On top of that I assume that he had much less surface area due to sitting down, although that one is much more speculative.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by durandal1 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:33PM (#8604263)
Your temperature is just plain wrong, the standard atmosphere model states -6.5°C per 1000m. This is means that the temperature was -97.5C below surface temp. So -70C is more likely.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Standard_Atmosphe...

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by pwnna on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:11PM (#8604479)
Which temperature?

For ambient (T), I'm using http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=temperature+at+15000m as the data. Also see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_temperature#mediavi...

The temperature experienced by the pilot as he was ejected was is calculated as the stagnation temperature (temperature on the surface of his clothing, or where the speed of the air = 0), which at Mach 1 would be around -12C. However this temperature will decrease as he slow down. Luckily it should take only about.. 45 seconds for him to get around 5000m, which becomes much more survivable.

Edit: from that page you linked, it says:

> Between 11 km and 20 km the temperature remains constant.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by mariuolo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:32PM (#8604594)
Could the low temperature have helped with regard to thin air?

I'm no expert, but I seem to recall that cold limits the damage from hypoxia.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by teraflop on Thursday November 13, 2014 @07:14PM (#8605051)
Hypothermia does provide some protection against hypoxia-induced brain damage. However, exposure to air at -13C for only a few minutes is very unlikely affect your core body temperature enough to cause hypothermia. And anyway, the time taken to fall from 15km to a more tolerable altitude would probably not be long enough to cause that type of damage in the first place.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by lutorm on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:33PM (#8604869)
That lapse rate is only valid in the troposphere, afaik.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by neurotech1 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:31PM (#8604585)
The forces on Peter Siebold would have been worse than using an ejection seat as he was unstable and tumbling through the air.

ACES ejection seats have a drogue chute that stabilizes prior to man-seat separation during a high altitude ejection. http://www.ejectionsite.com/acesiitech.htm

During ejection, most major injuries occur during the first seconds due to g-forces during ejection, or windblast.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by 3327 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:27PM (#8603829)
>> True, however air density at 70K feet is about 1/20th of sea level. source: http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/standard-atmosphere-d_604....
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by spb on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:44PM (#8604332)
Warning: link plays loud video shortly after opening.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by callesgg on Thursday November 13, 2014 @05:20PM (#8604527)
Are they seriously going to blame the dead pilot for the crash.

Even if he might have caused it, playing the blame game does not feel very professional. I would be very careful before making such a statement.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by ars on Thursday November 13, 2014 @07:49PM (#8605191)
How do you manage to say both of those things at once?

He caused it, but he's not to blame?

I mean if you want to talk about other systemic factors then fine. But otherwise your request is nonsensical.

Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by callesgg on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:54PM (#8605871)
It could be cause they did not train him properly, or other factors out of his control. Who knows....
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by c1sc0 on Friday November 14, 2014 @04:09AM (#8606371)
While I agree it's useful to look at the bigger picture to avoid future mistakes. He pulled the switch, the buck stops with him. Could be fatigue, could be bad training, but ultimately for the purpose of the investigation it's human error.
[deleted]
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by thrill on Thursday November 13, 2014 @06:49PM (#8604934)
If the pilot was at fault then the only unprofessional act would be to not state so. But likewise with any other deficiencies, from material sourcing to engineering process to flight operation.
Re:Pilot Who Survived Space Crash Says Parachute Opened Itself by 205guy on Friday November 14, 2014 @07:58AM (#8606890)
This. At first, I wondered why the NTSB was getting all the design data from the company, much of which must be proprietary and, as a one-off custom design craft, not useful to the NTSB. I mean, wouldn't the company want to do its own research and find out what happened so it can fix it and resume flights? But then I realized that it's better for everyone if an outside party learns all it can and essentially debugs their design, like Feynman did with the space shuttle. One might even wonder if they aren't getting some highly expert aerospace consulting done for free.