Of a year the majority would fail, but would would do great - he would then tout all the 'good' traders out as being new super star traders, and use them to get new business. As long as he had a large enough pool he'd be sure to have a few that became multi-year profitable, and now command large fees.
Basically they are able to make it seem like they know what they are doing, when really they are just hiding failure.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9R5OWh7luL4
More info for anyone who hasn't had the pleasure of knowing who Derren Brown is:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derren_Brown
Derren Brown is a British illusionist, mentalist, trickster, hypnotist, painter, writer, and sceptic. He is known for his appearances in television specials, stage productions, and British television series such as Trick of the Mind and Trick or Treat. Since the first broadcast of his show Derren Brown: Mind Control in 2000, Brown has become increasingly well known for his mind-reading act. He has written books for magicians as well as the general public.
Though his performances of mind-reading and other feats of mentalism may appear to be the result of psychic or paranormal practices, he claims no such abilities and frequently denounces those who do. Brown states at the beginning of his Trick of the Mind programmes that he achieves his results using a combination of "magic, suggestion, psychology, misdirection and showmanship".
The System, a Channel 4 special in which Brown shared his "100 percent guaranteed" method for winning on the horses, was first shown on 1 February 2008.
The show was based around the idea that a system could be developed to "guarantee a winner" of horse races. Cameras followed a member of the public, Khadisha, as Brown anonymously sent her correct predictions of five races in a row, before encouraging her to place as much money as she could on the sixth race. To demonstrate the system to the viewer, Brown tossed a coin showing ten heads in a row to prove it was not impossible, just highly improbable.
After Brown had placed a bet of £4,000 of Khadisha's money on a horse in the final race, he explained that "The System" did not really exist. He had started by contacting 7,776 people and split them into six groups, giving each group a different horse. As each race had taken place 5⁄6 of the people had lost and were dropped from the system. Brown had a different person backing each horse in each race, and one individual, Khadisha, won five times in a row. This was similar to the coin flipping earlier: rather than having a predictive technique, Brown had tossed a coin repeatedly until ten heads had come up in a row, taking over nine hours to produce the required film. Brown expressed the opinion that the principle behind "The System" (essentially confirmation bias or survivorship bias) is what is behind belief in spiritualism or homoeopathic and alternative medicine.
After the selected horse in the final race lost, and Khadisha was convinced that she had lost all her borrowed money, Brown told Khadisha to look again at the betting slip in her hand. The ticket showed the winning horse's name, meaning Khadisha kept her stake and received winnings of £13,000. Brown claimed that he had decided to bet on a different horse when he got to the booth.
At the end of the show, a title card explained that "at each stage of the process, participants who did not make it to the next round were offered a complete refund of any bets they had placed."
It's all quite easy, actually. For pretty much all you need to know in condensed form read Allan Roth's "How a Second Grader Beats Wallstreet" or Bill Bernstein's "If You Can."
[0]http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/05/18/how-to-make-money-...
Too many fund managers aim for consistent shorter term performance, which is getting into dice rolling territory.
Have a look at the fund managers that big pension schemes use. Some of them do genuinely perform well over the long run by not being distracted by short term issues.
That is pretty much the opposite advice you should take from those findings.
In general, investors now have the widest array of low cost, diversified instruments available at any point in history. Most advisors who know what they are talking about, will tell you to take one of these options (a non-managed index fund, a highly diversified etf) and invest in that. Rebalance once a year and don't worry about beating the market.
Thanks, do you have any references for this, or more details on such options?
Also "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" is a central book in this genre.
I will say, you can't generally control how your pension is run (and they run the gamut from wonderful to nearly criminal). It's one of the reasons I highly discount pension funds as a benefit.
I would be amazed if a retail consumer could put together a balanced, diversified portfolio with the same cost as an actively managed fund. To try and compete with an etf or non-managed index fund is crazy.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/23/magazine/dont-blink-the-ha...
"Mutual funds are run by highly experienced and hard-working professionals who buy and sell stocks to achieve the best possible results for their clients. Nevertheless, the evidence from more than 50 years of research is conclusive: for a large majority of fund managers, the selection of stocks is more like rolling dice than like playing poker. At least two out of every three mutual funds underperform the overall market in any given year.
More important, the year-to-year correlation among the outcomes of mutual funds is very small, barely different from zero. The funds that were successful in any given year were mostly lucky; they had a good roll of the dice. There is general agreement among researchers that this is true for nearly all stock pickers, whether they know it or not — and most do not. The subjective experience of traders is that they are making sensible, educated guesses in a situation of great uncertainty. In highly efficient markets, however, educated guesses are not more accurate than blind guesses. "