Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by barisser on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:23PM
(#8590973)
The team is in a great superposition to collapse into a winning eigenstate. Its interference pattern is constructive. The phase they're in is totally coherent. Their offense has got this great duality going, that you simply can't measure without screwing up. They've got this non-classical strategy that I don't understand. However I'm not going to comment on their position at this time; I don't want to alter the team's momentum going into the game.
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by Mithaldu on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:32PM
(#8591025)
Maybe it's because i'm not american, but that article is completely and utterly nonsensical to me. Is there some kind of injoke going on i don't understand?
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by KMag on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:20PM
(#8591274)
Does it help to imagine it's being read by John Oliver? There's a heavy dose of self-deprecating humor about Americans prizing university athletic performance over academics. "Yes, yes, 80 Nobel Prizes, blah blah, but congratulations to MIT on doing something that's finally important: winning at American football."
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by TillE on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:15PM
(#8591252)
It's not nonsensical, but it is a random collection of facts with no explanation. The article doesn't even attempt to answer the obvious question: what changed? Why are they successful now?
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by KMag on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:49PM
(#8591463)
Unless something changed with regard to the crew (rowing) program (which historically had more mindshare amongst MIT students), it's likely largely random. In Division III sports, you tend to have high variance in performance, since athletics are seldom the top priority of any of the students. It's probably a combination of solid coaching with luck off the field (which athletes the team was able to recruit) and luck on the field.
Next year, the football team will have a recruiting advantage over the crew (rowing) team, and you may see a long-term shift in football performance relative to crew performance. On the other hand, most US high schools have football teams but no crew teams. Incoming MIT students who didn't play on their HS football teams (most of them) perceive they're at less of a disadvantage competing in crew vs. competing in football. At least, these were my perceptions as an MIT freshman almost 2 decades ago.
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by mikeryan on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:42PM
(#8591413)
Just a note for those who don't know;
The NACDA Learfield Sports Directors' Cup is an award given annually by the National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics to the colleges and universities in the United States with the most success in collegiate athletics.
So Stanford has been the successful collegiate sports program across all sports. Its also held that title for 20 years.
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by shitehawk on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:33PM
(#8591030)
That comment should not have been downvoted like it was, there is a real problem with concussions and the science is clear. If I had a son I don't think I would let him play football.
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by ghshephard on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:16PM
(#8591255)
A great comment on this from Jets linebacker Bart Scott back in 2012, "“I don’t want my son to play football,...I play football so he won’t have to. With what is going on, I don’t know if it’s really worth it. . . . I don’t want to have to deal with him getting a concussion and what it would be like later in life.”
Re:The Genius of MIT's Football Team
by jessaustin on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @12:38PM
(#8591056)
In general, commentators are too quick to delete downvoted comments. Often, a comment that is initially downvoted will return to positive within a day or so, if only it is left alive.
Although my brothers and I played football (one of them professionally), I share your concern about concussions. If football doesn't solve this problem in the next decade it will deserve its eventual obscurity.
Next year, the football team will have a recruiting advantage over the crew (rowing) team, and you may see a long-term shift in football performance relative to crew performance. On the other hand, most US high schools have football teams but no crew teams. Incoming MIT students who didn't play on their HS football teams (most of them) perceive they're at less of a disadvantage competing in crew vs. competing in football. At least, these were my perceptions as an MIT freshman almost 2 decades ago.
We do take it as a point of pride. We also had the first Heisman winner ever.
The NACDA Learfield Sports Directors' Cup is an award given annually by the National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics to the colleges and universities in the United States with the most success in collegiate athletics.
So Stanford has been the successful collegiate sports program across all sports. Its also held that title for 20 years.
Edit: the comment I was responding to said something like "it makes me sad there are people at MIT smashing their heads against each other"
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/05/26/bart-scott-i...
Although my brothers and I played football (one of them professionally), I share your concern about concussions. If football doesn't solve this problem in the next decade it will deserve its eventual obscurity.