News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by cs702 on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:03PM (#8585905)
More than once, I've unintentionally downvoted comments I meant to upvote, upvoted comments I meant to downvote, and/or clicked on a button I didn't mean to click (that includes clicking on 'reply' after writing something that doesn't really add any value and almost instantly regretting it).

So I agree, it would be great to have more/better undo options!

Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:38PM (#8586199)
Agreed. I wish the up/down vote links were on opposite sides (I would prefer they were bigger too, but at least spacing them would be preferable).

Something more like this..

   ▲ cs702 31 minutes ago ▼ | link
note: they are supposed to be the same size.. oddly unicode down triangle is rending larger for me.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by gojomo on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:00PM (#8586376)
Also it's sufficiently typical to have the timestamp be the permalink to the post/comment, that the "| link" could be eliminated.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8586914)
great idea!
Re:An Update on Hacker News by dang on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:49AM (#8588773)
Seconded. I've added that to our list.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by etcet on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:56PM (#8586785)
I actually don't agree with this from a UX perspective. The downvote arrow is currently in a predictable position. If you move it after the timestamp, it will be in a variable position. Although, I can imagine how you could argue that the downvote arrow should not be easy to hit.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8586909)
I guess in addition to raw usability perspective, how you view downvoting in general has an impact on the layout. If you want to place downvoting on equal footing with upvoting, placing them together does make some sense. If, however, you feel downvoting should be a more rare occurrence, it makes some sense to relegate downvoting to a worse position, especially in light of the seemingly frequent issues with accidental clicking.

I also find the single leading upvote to be a bit more consistent, as you are not able to downvote replies to your comments, only upvote. So in that regard, the UI would be a bit more uniform regardless of whether the comment was a reply or not.

Another straightforward possibility could be replacing the arrows with words, and making the time a link to the comment (removing "link" from trailing actions as gojomo suggested). This may result in better support for screen readers, in addition to mobile users, as well.

  etcet 5 minutes ago | upvote | downvote | flag | parent
Re:An Update on Hacker News by couchand on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:12PM (#8585985)
I've done this, too. If you e-mail the mods they'll reverse it pretty quickly. On the same hand, if you e-mail the mods all the time they might have more of an incentive to implement a self-undo.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by cs702 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:16PM (#8586501)
Thanks for the tip. I'll consider doing that next time, even though I'm somewhat reluctant to try it, because I have a sense the mods already dedicate a lot of time to HN -- the last thing they want or need is a barrage of emails asking for essentially unimportant reversals.