News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by rspeer on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:50PM (#8585812)
> To prevent abuse, moderators review flagged stories and comments and revoke flagging privileges from users who flag inappropriately.

This seems like one of the cases where HN's moderation is both draconian and completely opaque. I can't flag comments, and I have no idea why. I certainly don't think of myself as an abusive user.

Maybe I accidentally clicked the "flag" link once. If that gets flagging privileges removed, HN should at least consider creating a way to undo an action!

Re:An Update on Hacker News by dang on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:07PM (#8585939)
As other users have pointed out, to flag a comment you have to click on 'link' to go to the comment's item page [1]. I don't know why PG designed it this way but have always assumed it was a speed bump to reduce impulsive flagging, since flags are more powerful than downvotes.

We never remove flagging privileges because of just one flag. The concept of a mistake is all too familiar over here.

1. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=author%3Adang+flag+link#!/comment/...

Re:An Update on Hacker News by robert_tweed on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:31PM (#8586610)
It's not great UI and it's made worse if, like me, you mostly read HN on a tablet so hitting the wrong link is easy to do. A better speed bump would be to have the flag link always available, but have it take you to a page that says "you are flagging the following item: <comment/link> by <author>. You should continue if <list of reasons> and not <list of bad reasons>. [OK, flag it!]"

This (a) draws attention to the exact thing you are flagging (the individual comment/link, not the thread) and (b) puts the confirm link somewhere else on the screen so you can't double-tap the same hotspot by accident. The advisory text is optional, but as others have pointed out, it's not really clear where the line between flagging and downvoting should be drawn.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by DanBC on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:43PM (#8586244)
Is there any way for me to tell if my flags are useful or stupid?

I tend to pre-emptively flag stories which I know will draw out the worst bits of HN. That's probably a bad thing, and I wouldn't be surprised if it caused my flags to be ignored.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by gaius on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:09PM (#8586449)
Same here. I generally flag gender stories, not because I disagree, but because the comments quickly deteriorate.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by phkahler on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:29PM (#8586602)
Perhaps flagging those comments would be better, since they are what you claim to be the problem.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by gaius on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:33PM (#8586628)
I have only just become aware of flagging comments. Some of the threads tho' you would need to flag 100 and a lot of bad feeling is generated. Best nip it in the bud early I reckon.m
Re:An Update on Hacker News by aaren on Monday November 10, 2014 @06:04PM (#8587214)
The threads that you are flagging are the ones that need to happen.

I can see why you would flag a whole thread, but I don't think that will ultimately get us anywhere. If you care about the accessibility of this site, then I implore you to upvote those threads^ and flag the bad comments within.

^presuming that they have some techy slant

Re:An Update on Hacker News by dang on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:25AM (#8588720)
> Is there any way for me to tell if my flags are useful

Anyone worried about this is welcome to email [email protected] and ask, and we'll be happy to take a look for you. But I feel like the kind of people who would worry about this probably tend to be the kind whose flags are useful.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by FooBarWidget on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:20PM (#8586965)
There was one time when I accidentally clicked on 'flag'. I meant to click on the 'comments' link, but I was on my phone and the link was too small so I ended up clicking on 'flag'. I couldn't find a way to undo it. It seems unfair if my flagging rights get revoked because of that.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by danielweber on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:26PM (#8587004)
You can unflag. Go to the link for the comment, click "flag", and when the page reloads you can unflag.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by hayksaakian on Monday November 10, 2014 @07:28PM (#8587556)
he's referring to flagging stories, not comments.

the flag link is right next to the comments link.

it's very easy to accidentally flag something from the home page of hacker news, when you actually intended to read the comments.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by danielweber on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @09:12AM (#8589830)
I agree that navigating HN on a phone is terrible.

You can also unflag stories.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by chimeracoder on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:16PM (#8586015)
> We never remove flagging privileges because of just one flag. The concept of a mistake is intimately familiar to us, I assure you.

Is it possible to either allow people to upvote a comment they have previously downvoted (or vice versa), or at least to undo an accidental upvote/downvote?

Especially on mobile devices, the margin of error here is very low, and I know I have accidentally downvoted a comment that I meant to upvote.

(In addition, I know some people may upvote/downvote a long comment before they have finished reading the entire text. This probably isn't behavior that should be encouraged or catered to, which is why allowing people to change their mind on votes[0] may be overkill. But at least allowing people to revoke an incorrect upvote/downvote might mitigate this effect.)

[0] ie, the way Reddit does

Re:An Update on Hacker News by nightpool on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:39PM (#8586207)
Also, FWIW, all flag actions can already be undone.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by jval on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:58PM (#8586360)
I feel like the UI should be consistent dang, because I've been flagging entire threads where there's an inappropriate comment (not knowing that there was a comment flag there).

I think at the moment it's too easy to hit that flag button on the front page (as others have said, especially on mobile), so maybe it should be moved back too?

Re:An Update on Hacker News by zanny on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:05PM (#8586421)
The consistency would be to remove the flag button from the front page, but clicking on a story and flagging it in the thread itself is equivalent to clicking on a comment to flag it in its page.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by rspeer on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:52PM (#8588035)
And now I know. It's not draconian in this case, it's just twice as opaque as I expected.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by cs702 on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:03PM (#8585905)
More than once, I've unintentionally downvoted comments I meant to upvote, upvoted comments I meant to downvote, and/or clicked on a button I didn't mean to click (that includes clicking on 'reply' after writing something that doesn't really add any value and almost instantly regretting it).

So I agree, it would be great to have more/better undo options!

Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:38PM (#8586199)
Agreed. I wish the up/down vote links were on opposite sides (I would prefer they were bigger too, but at least spacing them would be preferable).

Something more like this..

   ▲ cs702 31 minutes ago ▼ | link
note: they are supposed to be the same size.. oddly unicode down triangle is rending larger for me.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by gojomo on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:00PM (#8586376)
Also it's sufficiently typical to have the timestamp be the permalink to the post/comment, that the "| link" could be eliminated.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8586914)
great idea!
Re:An Update on Hacker News by dang on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:49AM (#8588773)
Seconded. I've added that to our list.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by etcet on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:56PM (#8586785)
I actually don't agree with this from a UX perspective. The downvote arrow is currently in a predictable position. If you move it after the timestamp, it will be in a variable position. Although, I can imagine how you could argue that the downvote arrow should not be easy to hit.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by stock_toaster on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8586909)
I guess in addition to raw usability perspective, how you view downvoting in general has an impact on the layout. If you want to place downvoting on equal footing with upvoting, placing them together does make some sense. If, however, you feel downvoting should be a more rare occurrence, it makes some sense to relegate downvoting to a worse position, especially in light of the seemingly frequent issues with accidental clicking.

I also find the single leading upvote to be a bit more consistent, as you are not able to downvote replies to your comments, only upvote. So in that regard, the UI would be a bit more uniform regardless of whether the comment was a reply or not.

Another straightforward possibility could be replacing the arrows with words, and making the time a link to the comment (removing "link" from trailing actions as gojomo suggested). This may result in better support for screen readers, in addition to mobile users, as well.

  etcet 5 minutes ago | upvote | downvote | flag | parent
Re:An Update on Hacker News by couchand on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:12PM (#8585985)
I've done this, too. If you e-mail the mods they'll reverse it pretty quickly. On the same hand, if you e-mail the mods all the time they might have more of an incentive to implement a self-undo.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by cs702 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:16PM (#8586501)
Thanks for the tip. I'll consider doing that next time, even though I'm somewhat reluctant to try it, because I have a sense the mods already dedicate a lot of time to HN -- the last thing they want or need is a barrage of emails asking for essentially unimportant reversals.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by spicyj on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:56PM (#8585858)
> I can't flag comments, and I have no idea why.

Make sure you're clicking "link" through to the comment's page -- the flag links don't appear when comments are shown in a thread.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by BoppreH on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:58PM (#8585876)
Are you sure you are looking at the right place? To flag a comment you must click on "link", and only then the "flag" option appears. TFA mentions the threshold for flagging is only 30 karma.

This has been the source of much confusion and I'm not 100% sure on the reason why it was implemented.

Re:An Update on Hacker News by weaksauce on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:03PM (#8585904)
There is a karma threshold (iirc, I know there is one for downvotes) to be able to flag and a link threshold that if you don't know where to find it, you won't use it. only the experienced HN people will 1. care enough to use it and 2. have the karma for(old members) it so it's a low pass filter of sorts against poor commenting.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by yoha on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:52PM (#8585829)
I am in a similar situation. I do remember having mis-clicked on a "flag" link once.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by Donzo on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:11PM (#8585976)
I did this too. I unflagged them in the past, but it's happened repeatedly. It's because the UI on mobile is terrible.
Re:An Update on Hacker News by drinchev on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:57PM (#8585871)
+1. I event didn't know that I can flag comments until now. I don't have flag link since I don't know when.