I suspect that, once they're using Linux, a bit of friction isn't going to stop them. Rather, the friction stops them from successfully starting to use it in the first place.
You have organised this conference. You have an audience of millions of Windows users. It's likely once-in-a-lifetime for the majority of them. You are going to give them a hands-on presentation detailing the value of free software and Linux, you will have their undivided attention for a week.
One problem: the organiser fell through with the chairs. There are unassembled ones ready to go, but the company who made those parts require that their guys assemble the chairs. You have some real smart fellas around that figured out how to assemble the chairs, only it's not perfect and there's a bit sticking into your butt.
So you start off the event with everyone standing their respective venues, no chairs in sight. You start off like this:
"We had a problem with the chairs. If you don't want to sit on the dirty floor you'll need to use one of these chairs one of our guys put together." (Not telling them about the bit sticking into their butt, which you don't)
"We can get the manufacturer to build the chairs for you, however, because we don't know how they did it we don't know if the chairs will break. If it breaks you could snap your spine, turning you into a paraplegic."
"Or you could remain standing, or sit on the floor."
How many people will walk out right there and then? Would you?
Some people, who no have reason to trust you over the manufacturer (keep that in mind), might use the ones your guys made. After a day sitting with a pokey bit in your butt, what would you do?
If you had a fully functional chair how long would you stick around for? Who provided that chair?
What have you just done to your potential audience?
The message is important, maybe one day people will understand but never if this hardline approach is maintained.
An honest appraisal of each option is needed for users, up-front during the installation process. They must not go in search of it:
- Open source drivers: poor performance, very stable, likely to not crash.
- Proprietary drivers: high performance, we don't know if you should trust them, if something goes wrong there is nothing we can do.
> Change always comes bearing gifts. ~Price Pritchett
The better solution is there should never be a need to search for it. AMD already knows their Mesa driver is all around a better user experience than Catalyst, and are making steps to depreciate work done on the Catalyst side by using a free kernel driver. Hopefully soon they will depreciate it entirely and dedicate all their Linux developers to making Gallium great.
Because Gallium is not just about playing games anymore. It is the basis for every other free software graphics driver besides Intels. It has the potential to revolutionize not just the Linux ecosystem but all operating systems by providing a well architected way to support dozens of GPUs with one system API and one driver model. It has a state tracker model that lets you run OpenGL, DirectX, OpenMAX, EGL, GLES, etc all on top of one driver implementation.
And Nvidia should get in on that, but those who hold the reins over there (business suits) are incompetent twat assholes who don't want to play ball with free software and damn all of us for it, and cripple the industry and any momentum they have because nonsense like "SteamOS only works on Nvidia cards".
OpenGL 4.2 will land soon™. A lot of stuff up through 4.5 after that is already done. Once they catch up on OpenGL, hopefully they can fix the performance.
> Open source drivers: poor performance, very stable, likely to not crash.
Actually, in my experience the open-source drivers for all my NVIDIA GPUs has been abysmally unstable. I couldn't even boot or install Ubuntu with the graphical interface, because nouveau kept freezing.
You could blame my uncommon but perfectly valid SLI GTX 580 setup for confusing the open source drivers, but the end result remains: the open-source drivers are inferior in every way except perhaps for the "open source" part (which is kind of meaningless if they don't work).
Another big problem is packaging for third-party software. Personally I would love to see a system where software isn't distributed as final binaries, but pre-built object files, together with a few very light shim source-files that then get built and linked on my machine, and rebuilt and relinked when the libs they depend on get updated.
This is how we learn. It's how I learned anyway. A bit of friction is good, IMHO.
Obviously if you just want to install and play, it's less than ideal.
Yeah, this is where I am coming from. Not many are as persistent as we are.
That's precisely why the Steam Machines are supposed to exist. To provide hardware which is supported and properly configured by default.
Note that on Windows it's pretty bad as well, performance wise, if you do not install your GPU drivers from a scratch Windows install. Having to do extra steps is nowhere the exception of Linux.
Really not true. For a start if you get an out of the box PC it will come with graphics drivers pre-installed (maybe not the best, but good enough to run a 2-year-old game smoothly)
If you build it yourself windows update will almost certainly have graphics drivers for your card
Even if you do have to manually install drivers, it's about a million times easier than on linux
For nvidia cards you do not need to install anything on your own on most distributions, and it comes with the latest drivers, so I can't see how it can be "million times easier than on Linux". AMD is another story, granted, but that does not mean it's the rule.
In addition, the release of a few Linux games such as Civ5 & Borderlands, have provided sales figures to those companies on whether the investment was worthwhile.
Many companies considered Linux primarily because SteamBox was an interesting market. While some companies were taking a wait-and-see audience, the slow play of SteamBox only makes more people take a wait-and-see attitude.
The OpenGL mess of "4.4 is good enough", while both AMD & Intel failed to deliver good drivers, is further muddled by OpenGL Next. Basically, accepting the OpenGL API needs a re-write and will become more Mantle/Metal/DX12 like. So will Intel & AMD deliver good-enough 4.4 drivers, or do we all wait for OpenGL-Next. Don't forget that AMD just did a 7% layoff, limited resources.
Remember SteamOS was born before Win8 was announced and Valve was scared where MS was going. Steam on Windows seems pretty safe, the pressure is off.
It may be off, but Microsoft may become more of a games distributor in the future through their own app store, so it may eat up some of Valve's revenue because MS app store is included by default while Steam is not.
In the real world my son pulls out his school issued ipad and starts playing games. Sometimes his friend comes over and he complains he can't connect to "my" wifi until I whitelist his MAC, whatever, and then they play minecraft on their ipads. Quite often they play games on the xbox connected to the living room TV because its a big enough screen to be shared. He has access to a desktop and hasn't really used it since gaining access to an ipad.
As for myself I go thru phases of dwarf fortress and heavily modded minecraft on my desktop and I just kicked a severe "pixel dungeon" habit on my phone.
My SiL still plays that farming game on facebook, or some modern clone or whatever.
The only thing worse than letting the "gamers" take over linux would be letting the "desktop" people take over linux, whoops looks like we did. Well, there's always freebsd for me.
I wonder what our hardware differences are? I have an Radeon R9 270X, if you have a different brand (Nvidia or Intel) are the open source ATI drivers really that much better?
> driver situation
Completely anecdotal:
I remember a few years back, when I was much younger trying to get drivers working for XOrg and compiz. I couldn't even manage a smooth GLGears. I botched my installation multiple times with no indication of how to fix it.
Fast forward a few years and we have open source drivers that actually work. Install Ubuntu, compiz works. Lovely, now maybe I see what the game situation is like. I dig through the app store and find that game with the Tux luge. 2FPS. So I dig around in settings and find the option to install the "non-free" drivers. Install them and I get my buttery-smooth 60FPS, I will continue to get harassed about that fact that I'm scum who installs closed-source software for the foreseeable future, by the OS. I can live with that.
So how would a 14 year old wanting to play games on Linux see this? Firstly, he'd install a game such as Borderlands and try it out. He hits a wall with dreadful framerate. One of two things, he goes back to a pirated copy of Windows (most likely) or somehow finds out he needs the vendor kernel module:
He pulls down the compiler tools, which could take up to an hour in 3rd world countries (first-hand experience). He then goes through the process of changing the init level to 2, compiling the driver shim and installing it. He then reboots his PC and XOrg crashes. Back to Windows or...
He discovers the Ubuntu automatic installer. Excellent! Just a few clicks and... "non-free?" Does this mean I have to pay for it? Will I need my parents' credit card? Why is there a warning sign? Am I doing something wrong? Could this damage my hardware?
Let's say he figures it all out and wants to play some MP3s while he games...
It's friction the whole way. This is a very severe case of getting your message mixed up with extremism. The situation of people using Linux is always better than the situation of them using something like Windows, even if they do have to use some non-free components to do so.
You can't change the world overnight, baby steps.
/rant