News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by AndrewHampton on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:09AM (#8583867)
Here's the thing that bothers me the most about a lot of the talk about net neutrality by government officials:

> If a consumer requests access to a website or service, and the content is legal, your ISP should not be permitted to block it.

Specifically "and the content is legal" is what raises a flag for me. I've seen similar phrases in nearly everything I've read coming from any government official regarding net neutrality.

If this phrasing makes it into eventual laws regarding net neutrality, it seems to me that it could easily require inspection of all traffic by ISPs to ensure the legality of traffic.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by warfangle on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:11AM (#8584332)
On the other hand, he's also calling for it to be classified under Title II. Unless Title II is modified, that would prohibit ISPs from deep packet inspection.

It would also prohibit ISPs from modifying responses in situ - like inserting tracking beacons gifs into HTML responses or returning a custom search page (with associated ad revenue) when a DNS lookup fails.

Edit: So, with the 'if the content is legal' clause, Obama was probably referring to refusal to carry / illegal purpose court decisions. This can be applied only in very, very limited circumstances. A couple court decisions that are relevant:

* Nadel v NY Tel., 170 NYS2d 95 (1957); carrier suspected caller of using the telephone for illegal gambling transactions and terminated their service. Court ruled that service should be reinstated: the telephone company "is not at all qualified, in the absence of evidence of illegal use, to withhold from the petitioner, at will an essential and public utility."

* Shillitani v. Valentine, 53 NYS 2d 127 (1945); "a telephone company may not refuse to furnish service and facilities because of a mere suspicion or mere belief that they may be or are being used for an illegitimate end; more is required."

* People v. Brophy, 49 Cal.App.2d 15, at 33, 120 P2d 946, at 965; "public utilities and common carriers are not the censors of public or private morals, nor are they authorized or required to investigate or regulate the public or private conduct of those who seek service at their hands."

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by AndrewHampton on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:49PM (#8584998)
I hope you're correct and deep packet inspection is prohibited. The language being used still concerns me though.

> If a consumer requests access to a website or service, and the content is legal, your ISP should not be permitted to block it.

This implies that ISPs would be permitted to block illegal content. How can they know traffic is legal without some form of traffic monitoring/inspection?

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by warfangle on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:23PM (#8585230)
Going from the court decisions, they would know that traffic is illegal if a court tells them it's illegal. Again, refer to People v. Brophy: the common carrier is not "authorized or required" to investigate. Probably meaning they can aid in investigation (e.g., supply information to police) but not perform an investigation (analyze said information themselves).

In addition, Title II would probably put internet traffic on the same level as wiretaps in terms of (non-DHS) data snooping. If anything, it would give internet users more protection for this sort of thing than they are granted now.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by cortesoft on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:55PM (#8587834)
If a court decides it is illegal, they would need to tell an ISP to block... what? An IP address? Or the content?

If the former, we have issues because IP addresses are transient. If the latter, we have issues because that would require deep packet inspection.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by joshAg on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:55PM (#8588044)
It would probably be a specific url. Or an entire domain for something like a site dedicated to illegal gambling. Though why they wouldn't just go after the website to take it down like they do currently eludes me.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by warfangle on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:04AM (#8588671)
Pretty much. If it's hosted in the US, they'll take it down. If it's not, they'll do pretty much whatever they can ... which boils down to seizing the domain. Usually with the kinds of sites people are typically worried about USGOV taking down, they leave up ... and watch the traffic. It's like in The Wire - they don't want the criminal's site (cell phone) to go down when they're watching the connections it's making.

Title II combined with the 2nd amendment actually prevents things like The Great Firewall :)

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by warfangle on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:06AM (#8588678)
And deep packet inspection is pretty easy to get around with some rudimentary encryption technologies.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by feld on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:25PM (#8585247)
Usenet is a common carrier service. However, they do make content inaccessible if there's a takedown request for copyright. But they don't filter anything that gets uploaded or block your downloads.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:54PM (#8585453)
i don't think usenet is a common carrier service. if it were, it would be illegal to block or prohibit access to it... and currently a lot of ISP's explicitly block access to usenet.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by feld on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:35PM (#8587978)
I've never seen an ISP block usenet. I've seen ISPs stop hosting their own free Usenet servers, but that's not blocking Usenet.

I'm searching for an adequate source for this information but I'm failing to find anything to stand on its own. It's definitely been treated like common carrier for many years, but as for an official classification... I'm struggling to find one.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by cortesoft on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:59PM (#8587846)
Do they actually block it? I thought the issue was that ISPs stopped hosting usenet servers for their users. You can still access usenet hosted somewhere else.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by vegedor on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:08PM (#8585947)
>public utilities and common carriers are not the censors of public or private morals

Well of course they are, to a limited degree. They are not the sole carrier - I sometimes find it hard to express or notice the plural distinction - of moral, but neither is the justice system, although it likes to paint itself that way. As can be shown:

  lt. moralis: proper behavior of a person in society
They have to decide a proper course of action for themselves. It would just be nice if it was in accordance with the censorship of the law. OTOH, i find the result proper.

>nor are they authorized or required to investigate or regulate the public or private conduct of those who seek service at their hands

Clearly not authorized, but morally, they might be required to regulate, therefore to investigate, if possible without violating privacy rights, which with automation can be ensured to a degree. Even if warranted by a judge, or done by the police, it meant massive overhead for the providers, too. So it would be nice if we can go on without all that hassle. Maybe it would require relaxing some laws, that require those investigations; Or moving on as society, as calling on moral draws in a bag of huge implications.

What if crack junkies buying crack on silkroad steal copper cables from the grid? The Telcos are indirectly affected by that, when the users get unsatisfied and directly they have to pay for replacement.

The users are directly affected and responsible, so in first degree it's their responsibility. (not as implied, the court's or w/e).

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dragonwriter on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:27AM (#8584006)
I think the concern is somewhat misplaced, because we've already seen the FCC take multiple stabs at regulations on net neutrality, that have been based on the principle of no or limited interference with lawful content, and they haven't required inspection of traffic.

Its not a requirement that ISPs block unlawful content, its a prohibition on blocking lawful content. A strong enough prohibition on blocking lawful content (e.g., one which provides consequences whenever lawful content is blocked, even if the intent was to block unlawful content and the lawful content just got caught up in the net) actually reduces the incentive for ISPs to attempt to identify and block unlawful content, since attempting to do so but making a misidentification in the process can result in penalties.

In fact, I'd argue that a no-blocking-lawful-content rule combined with a safe harbor provisions preventing ISPs from being liable for transmission of unlawful content by customers so long as the ISP wasn't actively involved in soliciting or promoting the specific illegal content is probably a good protection against ISP-initiated snooping, since it eliminates any liability-based incentive for it.

OTOH, it doesn't stop ISP-snooping-at-behest-of-government, but if you get a mechanism to do that, its going to be outside the context of net neutrality.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by AndrewHampton on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:41AM (#8584109)
I agree that my concern may be misplaced and everything could work out fine. I'd categorize myself as "cautiously optimistic" about these laws still, but wanted to bring this up since I don't see much discussion about it.

Additionally, I almost brought this up in my original post, but decided against it, but "lawful content" is another phrase I commonly see in the same discussions. IANAL, but my understanding is that unlawful != illegal. "Lawful" means the subject is specifically addressed and permitted by law, and "unlawful" is anything else. So traffic can be legal, but not lawful.

My biggest fear is that we in the tech community will rally behind a net neutrality law which sounds good in theory, but ends up a nightmare in practice. Phrases like "ISPs will not be able to filter lawful content" are nowhere close to "ISPs will not be able to filter traffic". I'd much prefer the latter in a net neutrality law.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dragonwriter on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:27AM (#8584452)
> IANAL, but my understanding is that unlawful != illegal. "Lawful" means the subject is specifically addressed and permitted by law, and "unlawful" is anything else. So traffic can be legal, but not lawful.

Inasmuch as there is a distinction between "lawful" and "legal", but its pretty much the other way around. Both address conformity to the law, but "legal" focusses more on procedural, technical conformity. Something can be lawful (e.g., a contract for a non-prohibited purpose wherein non-prohibited performances are exchanged) but illegal (because, say, its a contract for a purposes for which the law requires certain procedures for registration, etc., of the contract, and these were not correctly completed.)

In the case of content in the US, an example might be commercial adult content where all the content standing on its own conformed to the law (so that it was lawful), but where the producers had not followed all the technical record-keeping requirements relating to such content (such that it was illegal.)

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by vegedor on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:51PM (#8586300)
does not compute hides for cover
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by noobermin on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:18AM (#8584381)
While your concerns are valid and should be discussed, I don't think they warrant backing down from supporting what Obama calls for here and what we've generally been calling for, reclassifying ISPs under title II. I'm not aware that being under title II gives them a requirement (explicitly or implicitly) or an incentive[1] to filter "unlawful" content.

I agree with GP that the issue of snooping is important but is an issue unrelated to net neutrality (other than that they both concern the internet).

[1] That is, an incentive greater than the pressure they've received in the past from law enforcement/the NSA/the CIA already.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by psykovsky on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:37AM (#8584074)
The laws will change a couple times before you see the problem for what it really is.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by hristov on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:30PM (#8585660)
You are reading too much into this. Obama is merely adding this phrase to protect himself from those that will intentionally try to twist his words. When you hear anything Obama says, you must remember that there are literally thousands of hacks and an entire media empire out there carefully examining his words and thinking how they can twist them or misrepresent them to make him look bad.

If he did not put that phrase in there, there would be a story on fox news saying "Obama supports child pornography".

Regarding having ISPs police users, I do not know why the government would do something like that. The government already tracks internet traffic all over the US thanks to the patriot law and you know how the government hates giving up its functions to private parties.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dragonwriter on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:27PM (#8587946)
> You are reading too much into this. Obama is merely adding this phrase to protect himself from those that will intentionally try to twist his words.

Actually, much the same language has been in both the 2010 FCC Open Internet order and the draft for a new order earlier this year, its not something that was original in Obama's statement.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by efuquen on Monday November 10, 2014 @06:40PM (#8587383)
You were close, "Obamacare for the internet".

Edit: Which in retrospect is more likely to outrage the Republican base.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by alvaromuir on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:06PM (#8585930)
well said.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by venomsnake on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:24AM (#8584431)
I think that it is preventative of headlines "Obama wants pedophiles to be able to download kiddie porn fast" that the other party pundits are sure to make.

Edit: I am not defending any party, just assume that in current poisonous climate ANY action of ANY high position party official of ANY party will be stretched and twisted by the other side.

Inspection of traffic with the coming certificate pinning and https implementations will be very hard. And you always have VPN. At worst there will be overnet in which bittorrent will flow.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dasmithii on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @03:16PM (#8591892)
Good point. It could be doubly motivated as well, by (1) anticipated twisting of words, and (2) potential censoring of content.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by couchand on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:20AM (#8583954)
It's a pretty massive stretch to go from "ISPs are permitted to block illegal traffic" to "ISPs are required to perform deep-packet inspection to ensure the legality of all traffic they carry".
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by emcrazyone on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:23PM (#8585223)
Agree. ISP owner here. Not all web sites or IP addresses contain 100% illegal material. Virtual hosting (hosting more than one web site from same IP address) poses problems as does content among sub-domains. I don't have the resources to monitor and track such things and if I were forced into it, I would either go out of business or try to become a search engine.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by arthurcolle on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:57PM (#8586798)
I've actually wondered how do you go about providing access to internet? I write a lot of code and spent a good amount of time on the internet and it's always made me wonder how exactly one goes about providing internet to customers. Really curious for any resources to read about this if you have any resources to read or just your personal experience!
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by corobo on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @02:41PM (#8591723)
Basically it's a reselling system no matter which way you go. You buy access into a bigger ISP's network and then provide services on top of it.

If you've got a huge wallet you could run your own physical infrastructure but it would be hugely expensive for anything more than a small userbase [1]. If you went that way you'd make peering agreements with your closest internet backbone providers to hook into the rest of the internet (backbone providers being even bigger ISPs than those mentioned earlier, the ISP's ISP if you like)

[1] It has been done in the past: http://www.techradar.com/news/internet/how-to-start-your-own...

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by macns on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @03:04AM (#8588813)
I don't think internet is what he provides, as an ISP (Internet services provider). He mentioned virtual hosting, so he's probably offering webhosting services.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by aragot on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:53PM (#8585449)
I don't see why the good old model of "Someone deposits a complaint against a website at a police station, then the server/website is investigated upon, then the fine is raised against the renter/owner of the server" isn't enough.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dguaraglia on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:48PM (#8584993)
On the other hand, just think about it: now you have the wedge in, there'll be a massive lobby (Hollywood, recording companies, 'big media' if you will) trying to use that wedge to push stronger legislation in. In fact, the government itself (NSA, FBI) will think 'hey, now that we have this, we might as well use it to Protect Our Children (tm)'.

On the other hand, besides the ACLU and maybe a few people organizing over the internet, there will be no money spent in lobbying to tighten up definitions and improve privacy.

So there, it's a 'pretty massive stretch' but by no means it's an unexpected thing.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by randomfool on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:52PM (#8585027)
SSL everything.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:58PM (#8585481)
Unless, of course, direct encrypted communication is prohibited. Because, you know, Internet is a public utility now, and if you are using public thing, you should abide by public's rules. Like connecting to SSL sites only using approved ISP SSL proxies that allow lawful intercept. After all, you accept that to drive on public roads you need a license. So, to browse on public internet, you need to follow the rules too. And the rules say law enforcement should be able to see what you are transmitting - given properly signed court order, of course - so that means you can not use non-interceptable encryption. See how this logic works?
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dguaraglia on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:20PM (#8586963)
Oh, this is totally coming. If they really manage to pull off the "you can't encrypt your own device because TERRORISM" (what Comey has been asking for) then what guarantee you have that they won't force corporations to stop using encrypted transfer between servers? It's so much easier to force corporations with an NSL than trying to pass legislation violating the rights of individual people.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by venomsnake on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:41PM (#8586225)
I think that this creates both first and fourth amendment issues.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:45PM (#8586707)
I don't see 1st amendment issues if this is content-neutral (I don't think the Supreme Court would consider the choice of encryption scheme being speech by itself and thus protected expression) towards underlying data. As for 4th amendment, right now I think the prevailing position is that ability to collect data is not search until the data is actually collected, so providing capability for lawful intercept would not be considered 4th amendment problem. I don't like it too much, but that seems to be the state of affairs now.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by Alupis on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:55PM (#8585462)
You mean: "TLS Everything" ;-P
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by bushido on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:34AM (#8584060)
Those two statements from a legal (writing) perspective are mutually exclusive, sort of. One is a Right and the other is a law. But both need to exist is some form to make the other possible.

Also, they both require the same technology to be automated and possible. The main constraint for the latter is computational power.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by richardwhiuk on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:40AM (#8584543)
No they aren't. There is a difference between being required to do something by law, and being allowed to do something by law.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by bushido on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:43PM (#8584964)
I agree they are different and stated that as such.

Yet that regulation cannot exist without this Right.

And the regulation is required to limit the abuse this Right can bestow on users.

This is a tricky one, because the right and the law are both mutually exclusive and mutually inclusive.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by AndrewHampton on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:24AM (#8583977)
It is. It's just a concern I have since similar language seems to be everywhere, which makes me think including it is intentional.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by jstalin on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:32AM (#8584048)
You're right to be concerned. If they keep using the same language in these sorts of statements, you better believe it's for a reason. Look for any legislation or regulation to implement such language.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by leeber on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:25PM (#8585634)
I wouldn't read into it too much.

If he didn't put that in there, tons of idiots would go around saying how net neutrality will support all the crooks of the dark web, illegal filesharing websites, etc. Obviously that's ridiculous and not the case, but it would have really given net neutrality a bad image to the average person who probably has no idea what net neutrality is at all.

We've already got idiots let Ted Cruz tweeting that net neutrality is the "Obamacare of the internet."

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by benmathes on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:51AM (#8584178)
At least constitutionally, the 4th amendment (unlawful search) and "innocent until proven guilty" would mean blocking if _known_ illegal traffic.

Yes, granted, those rights are often infringed upon, especially in tech.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by lazyant on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:55AM (#8584210)
And police seizures. And airport/border guard.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by primitivesuave on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:12AM (#8584340)
And the NSA, FISA courts, Patriot Act... the list of 4th amendment infringements goes on and on.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by droopybuns on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:25AM (#8584434)
I agree so heartily. The tired trope endures: do we really want the innovations of the DMV applied to the Internet?

Is there a country that is regulating Internet in existence that is doing anything that we'd consider positive?

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by ArtDev on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:36AM (#8584505)
If electricity, gas and water were not regulated, we would be outraged about that too.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by robomartin on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @01:31AM (#8588590)
No. The part that should bother you has nothing whatsoever to do with this directly. It is found in hundreds and thousands of speeches, press conferences, government meetings and laws. They are called "lies". And, because we keep tolerating them the governing class, itself mostly immune and isolated from the very decisions they make and laws they pass, is emboldened.

Every election is full of lies. Party divisions do not matter. They lie to get elected and then do as they please. They lie to pass laws, and then do as they please. Of course, Obamacare is a favorite punching back, and rightly so. The whole business of "an average savings of $2,500 per family", "if you like your plan you can keep it" and "if you like your doctor you can keep'em. Period" should be grounds for millions of people revolting. My family is going to have to pay $14,000 per year next year for health insurance. If we go to the cheapest crap plan we can find that number goes down to $12,000 per year. We were paying $5,000 per year before Obamacare and had fantastic health insurance with great providers. Un-fucking-believable.

Someone just sent me this today:

http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Frare.us%2Fstory...

So, in a nutshell: Worry about what lies you are being told.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by lotharbot on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:51PM (#8585017)
He's basically saying that this ruling wouldn't override other court orders. That's a perfectly sensible thing to say.

(I rarely side with Obama.)

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by wahsd on Monday November 10, 2014 @11:55AM (#8584631)
The problem is that society has been sitting on its laurels and even though the default should have been that the inherent spirit of the Constitution be extended into the digital world, instead, we have allowed and been complicit in allowing government to not only become authoritarian on the internet, but even to subvert and pervert the very fundamental concepts that set parameters on our whole existence.

People, the world is cruel, savage, sadistic, perverse, and brutish without social agreement on fundamental principles. If the underlying concepts that the Constitution is based on are eroded further and further the way they have been for years now, we will, with guarantee, find ourselves in the same predicament as all other people who wake up one day and are dominated by a totalitarian regime.

Some may see that as hyperbole, but too often humans take privilege, safety, and security for granted and squander away what their ancestors had to pay with their lives and livelihoods for to achieve.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by guelo on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:22PM (#8584819)
The government created the internet. For a while in the early 90s corporations tried to create it, and what they came up with were walled gardens, the open internet blew them away, look up Compuserve, AOL and Prodigy.

The internet works because of the underlying open, bidirectional, equally privileged connections. If the corps are starting to change that it must be stopped. The internet is one of humanities greatest achievements and we can't let greedy monopoly beuraucrats kill it.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:12PM (#8585562)
The government didn't create the internet. At the most, the government gave money to some projects that developed some technologies that were subsequently used to create the internet. Yes, there were a lot of failed attempts at how to handle the informational world - like AOL (which btw is alive and well as a company with multibillion revenues), Compuserve, etc. - but some of these attempts worked. And that what we call the internet now. Of course, it's not only companies, but NGOs, universities, etc.

>>> The internet works because of the underlying open, bidirectional, equally privileged connections.

This is very simplistic view which does not match what really happens on the net. There are a lot of barriers, firewalls, routing preferences, private bandwidth exchanges, etc. It still works reasonably well so far.

>>> The internet is one of humanities greatest achievements and we can't let greedy monopoly beuraucrats kill it.

You realize that "monopoly bureaucrats" is the very definition of the government? If you were ever scared of huge bureaucratic power that would take away the control from you and use it for its own purposes, the US federal government would fit this role ideally.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by guelo on Monday November 10, 2014 @03:47PM (#8586270)
At least theoretically, the government bureaucrat can be influenced for the general good. The corporate monopoly bureaucrat will fuck everybody over if it serves his interest.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:41PM (#8586688)
True, but corporation can be influenced for the general good too - by its customers. In fact, you can argue customers have more control than the voters - if the politician has 50%+1 votes in his pocket and appoints the bureaucrat, the opinion of the rest of 50%-1 voters have absolutely no weight to him (unless he is of a special rare breed of saint which is so rare in real politics). However, for the corporation losing 50% of their customers would be a huge blow, which given healthy competitive market would probably kill it, so the control of the customers is greater. Of course, with monopoly it would be different, but if the monopoly is not externally enforced, large reluctance of the customers to deal with it will eventually lead to the competition emerging and thus the monopoly would be lost. If the monopoly is persisted by law or regulation then this may not happen, but then the problem again is in that regulation that essentially now forces almost 50% of people to use service they do not want to use.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by guelo on Monday November 10, 2014 @05:23PM (#8586981)
I always considered the libertarian theory that corporate monopolies are caused by the government as very suspect and entirely unproven.

Natural monopolies are obvious when you think about it a little bit. When your entire ideology depends on them not existing them maybe it's time for a rethink.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Monday November 10, 2014 @07:20PM (#8587528)
When you think a little bit, sure. When you think more than a little bit, it's not really that obvious. Remember how Microsoft was a monopoly and EU spent so much time and money on struggling with MSIE to no noticeable effect? Remember what happens now when the most wished for feature of MSIE is "please die already"? So what happened - is that EU that brought that most natural of monopolies down or was there something else? Maybe thinking more than just little a bit is warranted here.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by guelo on Monday November 10, 2014 @08:58PM (#8587840)
Not only EU, the US DOJ also sued Microsoft over their monopoly. Microsoft could have blocked Firefox, they could have banned dual booting Windows on Macs. There's a lot of things they could have done to lock down their monopoly permanently, but they didn't do them because they were afraid of government regulators breaking them up. It was a huge win for government regulation promoting innovation.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by saraid216 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:59AM (#8590447)
> if the politician has 50%+1 votes in his pocket and appoints the bureaucrat, the opinion of the rest of 50%-1 voters have absolutely no weight to him (unless he is of a special rare breed of saint which is so rare in real politics).

This sounds plausible, but it isn't correct. Remember, first of all, that no politician has real access to who did and did not vote for him. He has access to polling data, which generally scrubs well enough to reduce people to demographics. Conveniently, we generally engage with our politics through the lens of demographics anyways. But demographics are effectively never 100% accurate: samples are only samples.

Second, votes matter to politicians only if they want to be re-elected. They also matter on ballot measures and propositions and so on, but those are generally not what people mean when they talk about politician-voter relationships. Obama, since 2012, has no real reason to care about who voted for him in 2012 because he's not going to get any votes in 2016. There are other reasons in play, yes, but electoral votes are irrelevant when a politician has no interest in retaining his seat at the next cycle.

Third, politicians care about public opinion. They balance this against other competing interests, to be sure, but public opinion is the reason most of them ran for office in the first place. Those competing interests run the gamut from commercial interests to legal interests to moral interests to realpolitik, and ultimately, their job is to reconcile every interest with every other interest. That's what a politician is. People are afraid of politicians because they do not understand or recognize the interests they have outside of public opinion.

Public opinion is not votes, because public opinion is not tied to the electoral cycle. It suffers from the same problem of votes--that it is polled and often reduced to demographics--but from a far smaller degree because public opinion is also expressed by individuals who are willing to identify themselves.

The problem with public opinion, though, is that it's extremely rare to get anything solid resembling 50%. Nowhere close to 50% of a population is generally willing to identify themselves, meaning such a thing will always come down to polling data.

The advantage that corporations have in influenceability isn't that 50% could walk away (which will basically never happen on solely moral grounds); it's that it can track their interests with far, far more precision. It can know if you stop spending money, and it can calculate exactly what effect that will have on its bottom line. A politician, on the other hand, cannot track your personal opinion, and even if he could, he cannot determine how that would play out against the myriad other priorities he must keep in mind, not least of which is the rest of his constituency's opinions.

A politician makes a marketer look like an engineer in comparison. And yeah. Improving this would basically be a privacy risk. So we're fucked.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by smsm42 on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @08:27PM (#8593474)
>>> Obama, since 2012, has no real reason to care about who voted for him in 2012 because he's not going to get any votes in 2016

That's not entirely true. Obama is not alone, there's a party around him, and what he does influences how this party is viewed and how others in the same party do on elections. However, if their base support is wide enough for being elected, there's no reason to feel any obligation to cater to people who are not part of that base.

>>> their job is to reconcile every interest with every other interest.

If it is so, most politicians do their job extremely poorly, as they are nowhere near every. In fact, it is very common to dismiss interests of opposing or unaffiliated groups completely, or even present them as evil for voicing such interests, let alone trying to get them recognized and respected.

>>> It can know if you stop spending money, and it can calculate exactly what effect that will have on its bottom line.

In theory, it could be possible if some corporation owned/had access to all the data, in practice, I don't think any big corporation does it on personal level. But on statistical level, it works the same way - the difference it, the market share is more fine-grained. So for the corporation offending each person is a direct loss, for a politician usually offending 20-30% of the population is no problem, provided all the others are OK with it.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by cypher0x99 on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:46PM (#8585788)
There are those of us that swore and reswore an oath to defend those principals, some of us continue to uphold that oath personally, even though we have taken off the uniform, that doesn't mean we have taken off the oath. For me, It seemed obvious, I had to become a cypherpunk, or at least support and defend them. I agree with your assessment, and have concluded that I am not willing to let others give my and mine posterity's rights.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by jeangenie on Monday November 10, 2014 @01:15PM (#8585167)
I agree that the presence of that single qualifier casts an irrevocably ominous shadow over the entire sentiment.

In a purely-hypothetical dystopia it could be the basis of more invasive monitoring and control capabilities over network infrastructure.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dragonwriter on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:16PM (#8585582)
Not really. Blocking of illegal content is possible -- and can be (and, at times, has been) encouraged and even mandated by government -- even without protection of legal content. So, while the qualifier might suggest that such practices would not be curtailed by the neutrality, they don't provide the basis for more invasive monitoring and control than the absence of neutrality does, because the basis of that more invasive monitory and control already exists in the illegality of certain content, whether or not there is neutrality for legal content.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by jeangenie on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:19PM (#8586523)
Why would the statement need to provide any basis? It's merely a carefully worded expression of a decision that's already been made. You will find even recent history rife with examples.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by brandonmenc on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:32PM (#8584883)
I'm betting "illegal content" will eventually come to include things like "bullying." Expect a much broader array of takedown notices once the FCC is granted content-level authority over the internet.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by rinon on Monday November 10, 2014 @02:20PM (#8585612)
If such "bullying" is found illegal in court, then I don't see the problem here. Nobody is saying the FCC should be in charge of deciding these things, just that companies are still required to comply with court orders.

Speaking of "bullying," assault, "an intentional act by one person that creates an apprehension in another of an imminent harmful or offensive contact," [1] is already illegal. Sounds an awful lot like credible bullying. Why should this be legal online?

[1] http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Verbal+assault

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by Bud on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:18PM (#8586519)
Great. Bullying should be illegal already, and internet bullies should be aggressively prosecuted.

This is currently a law enforcement blind spot, but that needs to change.

BTW, putting quotes around the world "bullying" isn't actually effective in mocking it as something actionable; it just communicates to us that you are perfectly ok with bullying.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by thizzbuzz on Monday November 10, 2014 @09:25PM (#8587938)
The worry is that "bullying" can be redefined to mean almost anything. A scathing critique of a bad business or politician could be construed as bullying.

We should also be careful about criminalizing bullies, since a large portion of them are young (and quite possibly bullied or abused themselves). It's a problem, and it needs more attention, but rushing to criminalize it seems hasty to me.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by dasmithii on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @03:29PM (#8591953)
Agreed. Criminalizing antagonism would provide dirt on just about everyone. Hell, half of YouTube [commenters] would be prosecutable.

Not all wrongful doings ought be illegal.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by brandonmenc on Monday November 10, 2014 @04:56PM (#8586787)
The FCC regulates content that it deems "indecent" or "obscene" - legally nebulous terms. "Bullying" could cover incidents like Dan Savage redefining Santorum.

The FCC has been trying to get their hands on the internet for decades, and I see enforced net neutrality as their Trojan horse. It's possible I'm overly paranoid.

fwiw, we probably agree on the actual definition of bullying, and also that it should be illegal. I put it in quotes to indicate I'm using it imprecisely, not because I'm OK with what I believe to be legitimate bullying.

Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by antocv on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:19AM (#8583941)
Which is the whole point of net-neutrality, that ISPs must not accountable for what flows through the network, or to block "illegal" messages.
Re:President Obama Calls for a Free and Open Internet by ctdonath on Monday November 10, 2014 @10:46AM (#8584145)
Not quite the "whole" point. It's not so much about accountability as not demanding customers pay more based on content; not being accountable for content is a consequence of not analyzing that content for whatever reason. It's about customers getting the bandwidth they pay for by not throttling the content they're requesting.