News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by eklavya on Thursday November 06, 2014 @12:28PM (#8568257)
Am I the only one surprised by the fact that "the people" have to secure right to start a business for the common good in a democracy? I may be misinformed but in India I can not ever imagine having to need to do this.

p.s. I am not trying to show anyone in a bad light, just wondering if things like this are possible in a democracy.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 06, 2014 @01:39PM (#8568807)
What's funny is that a lot of people are worried about the "government" limiting their liberty, whereas in cases like this it's the big corporations that need to be defeated to win back your freedom.

Maybe freedom-above-all folks need to rethink what freedom is all about in this new reality.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by coryrc on Thursday November 06, 2014 @01:56PM (#8568925)
Huh? It's the state government that has the law mostly preventing municipal broadband. If the government wasn't so powerful, the corporations couldn't use it as a tool against us.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by DrJosiah on Thursday November 06, 2014 @02:15PM (#8569065)
That is some fucked up doublespeak right there.

If corporations weren't so powerful, they wouldn't be able to manipulate the government into passing laws that restrict choice among citizens.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by sanderjd on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:00PM (#8569397)
You are talking around each other because there isn't one "the government", but rather a bunch of different levels constantly pushing and pulling against one another. It's very reasonable to be a small government ideologue while simultaneously wanting a more powerful city government. Many people who want "small government" simply want a less powerful federal government. A few states are playing with this balance (Colorado certainly among them) at all levels. Should the federal government control the state's drug policy? Should the state control the county's or municipality's infrastructure or natural resources? What about schools, who should control those?

These sorts of questions are where you see major differences between lots of different people who would all identify themselves as "conservatives" and agreement with many people would would identify themselves as "liberals". It isn't a simple system!

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:16PM (#8569834)
I could not agree more with the liberty-above-all folks - in terms of sentiment. I could not disagree more with them that the greatest threat to individual liberty is the "government" - that was true back in the day of Paul Revere maybe. But times have changed.

Nowadays the greatest threat, and a much more intelligent and subtle threat, too, is from Big Money. There's a war out there for people's minds, and we-the-people are currently losing.

Chaining up the bodies is so medieval and inefficient, so why bother, when you can chain up the minds and then the slaves will passionately defend their own chains. It's easy, too, just set up some "think tanks", or promote some newfangled ideologies that seem to promise "liberty" while in fact weaken the very defenses that support it. Problem solved.

I lived the first 2 decades of my life under communist dictatorship, so I think I know from first hand experience what freedom, or lack thereof, truly mean.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by TelmoMenezes on Friday November 07, 2014 @02:38AM (#8571542)
> I lived the first 2 decades of my life under communist dictatorship, so I think I know from first hand experience what freedom, or lack thereof, truly mean.

So you experienced a regime where government became too powerful and oppressive in the name of protecting the interests of the people, and you conclude that the biggest threat to freedom is not enough government to protect the interests of the people?

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by refurb on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:22AM (#8571418)
I could not disagree more with them that the greatest threat to individual liberty is the "government" - that was true back in the day of Paul Revere maybe. But times have changed.

You've got to be kidding. Most of the violations of human rights that occur in the world come from governments. What other entity is powerful enough to take everything you have and thrown you in prison?

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by namlem on Sunday November 09, 2014 @08:02AM (#8579810)
There's no such thing as a world without governments. A large scale stateless society is impossible. If you weaken the power of democratic governments, non-democratic entities will take their place as the de facto government.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by refurb on Sunday November 09, 2014 @04:12PM (#8580913)
That didn't answer the question. If the world can't exist without governments, that doesn't imply that governments won't take away your freedoms.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by baddox on Thursday November 06, 2014 @06:26PM (#8570433)
Your statement sounds like the doublespeak to me. At the end of the day, it's government that physically enforces things with relative impunity. The "power" of corporations in this context is just the power of government being used for corporate interests; it doesn't work the other way around.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by DrJosiah on Monday November 17, 2014 @03:07PM (#8620186)
Nominally, governments act at the behest of the good of the people, powerful or not. Regulation is part of its purpose. If they are not operating for the good of the people, then who are they operating for?

This is a clear case where a government founded for the good of the people has been side-tracked to operate at the good of a corporation, at the expense of the people. So I will stick with my earlier statement: governments have power due to the will of the people, and blaming the existence of governmental power for the fact that corporations bought the legislation is doublespeak.

The problem is not the existence of government (unless you are anarchist), nor is the fact that the government has the power to regulate. The problem is that a corporation bought legislation to restrict consumer choice, and that neither the politicians nor the corporations are being held accountable for the implicit (or even explicit) bribery that went on to make it happen.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:06PM (#8569771)
Yes, if the gun wasn't so powerful, the criminal could not kill people. Let's blame the gun.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by baddox on Thursday November 06, 2014 @06:29PM (#8570441)
No, you blame the actual person with the gun, i.e. the group of people who physically enforce rules. That's government, not corporations.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by dvanduzer on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:10PM (#8569451)
"We the people" have the right to amend the United States Constitution. Are we out of ideas for ways to protect the liberty of individuals? :)
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by logn on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:22PM (#8569512)
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by dvanduzer on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:26PM (#8569529)
As a resident of Colorado, I'm slightly wary of amendments with language involving the definition of personhood.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:25PM (#8569889)
The time when you should have been worried about personhood and legislation has passed. It was when they messed with Citizens United, and gave humongous power over the political process to semi-anonymous legal fictions.

Now is the time to fix that.

> I also don't think that "get money out of politics" is a pragmatic approach to amending the constitution.

But that's the current root of all evil. Unless you pull that out of the ground, bad stuff will keep sprouting up.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by anonbanker on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:29PM (#8573920)
Some of us benefit greatly from our semi-anonymous legal fictions. Keeping one's assets and liabilities at arm's length (or two) is a handy way to keep my 1099 and 1040's nice and simple. And I really enjoy getting quarterly tax refunds. That my legal fictions now have political power is just another added bonus for me.

So, don't fret about where the river is going. Jump on in and take a ride. The water's nice and warm.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by mac01021 on Thursday November 06, 2014 @07:01PM (#8570552)
Anyone know of a study or methodical analysis anywhere (on the web or in a publication) assessing the character and extent of the influence of this "money in politics"?

I would love to see it.

It seems to me that massive campaign donations from corporations are only effective when a large fraction of the voters is voting in an ill-informed, rather mindless fashion. And as long as voters behave thus, it's not clear (to me) that it would take much money at all to undermine the effectiveness of a democracy.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by logn on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:40PM (#8569606)
That language is only proposed and carries no legal weight or significance. The call for a constitutional convention has to have a singular focus it's just based around money in politics. E.g., http://www.leg.state.vt.us/docs/2014/Resolutions/JRS027/ACTR...

The wording of the amendment would be decided and voted upon at the convention (75% of states required).

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by dvanduzer on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:14PM (#8569822)
I was half joking, but I also don't think that "get money out of politics" is a pragmatic approach to amending the constitution.

Maybe something like "get governance back into politics" could take the form of a constitutional amendment requiring that every citizen vote (along with mandated funding to make that convenient for every citizen).

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by gretful on Thursday November 06, 2014 @02:20PM (#8569093)
ahh, but who provides the framework that denies the local governments the right to implement this? That's right, the Judicial branch (local, state or federal). So, while corporations initiate and shepherd the process through the court systems, it is the court systems that allow this process.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:07PM (#8569776)
Yes, let's accuse the sock puppet. The hand in it, however, is blameless.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by adventured on Thursday November 06, 2014 @05:25PM (#8570190)
Yes, let's definitely accuse the government officials taking the legal bribes to sell citizens down the river. They deserve a lot of blame as well.
Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by cookrn on Thursday November 06, 2014 @12:55PM (#8568497)
The state of Colorado passed bill in 2005 [0] disallowing municipalities to offer their own advanced communications (read: broadband/fiber/wireless) services without a local vote. These local votes are what the OP was referring to.

[0] http://www.leg.state.co.us/clics2005a/csl.nsf/billcontainers...

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by rhino369 on Thursday November 06, 2014 @03:40PM (#8569611)
Municipalities aren't "the people." The State has total police power in US federal system. Local governments only exist by the charter of the State government. Colorado eliminate all local governments if it wanted to.

If a group of citizens wanted to start a cooperative, they could do that.

It's more complicated than this, but it's the gist.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by mudetroit on Thursday November 06, 2014 @01:00PM (#8568528)
It is a difficult problem. Governments have a number of built in advantages over private companies trying to deliver the same services. I say this while being, in general, a supporter of the ability for municipalities to provide broadband if they choose to do so.

There are a number of complex opposing factors in allowing them to do so though. For example, Boulder has required companies leasing space on the public right of way to install, at the company's expense, fiber to be owned by the city. (http://www.branfiber.net/Conduit%20Lease%20Agreement%20betwe...) Basically, Boulder can force competitors for it's own broadband service to subsidize their own competitor. These are non-trivial problems to overcome.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by Zigurd on Thursday November 06, 2014 @04:20PM (#8569856)
> * Boulder can force competitors for it's own broadband service to subsidize their own competitor. These are non-trivial problems to overcome.*

If it is the will of the people, it isn't a problem. Nobody has a right to operate a for-profit SP any more than they have a right to operate a for-profit water utility.

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by mikeyouse on Thursday November 06, 2014 @05:29PM (#8570215)
Then again, these rules exist largely to prevent scenes like this:

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Wdm_lyaf5XQ/UBiioQwzsCI/AAAAAAAAC2...

Re:Colorado communities secure the right to build their own ... by bhhaskin on Thursday November 06, 2014 @01:34PM (#8568771)
It wouldn't be starting a business so much as the local government offering a service.