Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by bane on Saturday November 01, 2014 @03:54PM
(#8544367)
I'm a travel photographer in my spare time. I don't really need a photo organizing app, what I need is a photo metadata app. I already have a great way to organize my photos via the file system, but I don't have a good system to put metadata on each photo (where it was shot, what it is, etc.), personal rating (so I can grab the top shots and public them), etc.
The old flickr was perfect for me, I could group things by continent/country/city give a title, drop it on a map to geolocate it, etc. But now they've flattened out the structure a bit and it's not as good for my purposes.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by privong on Saturday November 01, 2014 @05:38PM
(#8544715)
> I don't really need a photo organizing app, what I need is a photo metadata app.
I completely agree. I also liked flickr's system, but I left a year or two ago, after deciding I would rather not put my photos on someone else's server. I would love a good desktop metadata system that felt like it would be long-lived and widely useable. gthumb and darktable both have tagging capabilities, for example, but I have not gotten the sense that either of their systems are worth going back and tagging the past 10+ years of photos I have taken. A great metadata system would have me doing that.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Veratyr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @09:13PM
(#8545222)
Lightroom + Picturelife works pretty good for me. Lightroom plays with the EXIF and XMP sidecars and Picturelife picks them up and allows me to search them online.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Osmium on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:04PM
(#8544797)
> don't have a good system to put metadata on each photo (where it was shot, what it is, etc.)
On the "where it was shot" front, I'd love an app that could interpolate positions from iPhone photo EXIF data and use those positions to tag photos from my proper camera based on timestamp in a way that's easy to use and dead-simple. I've found methods of doing it, but none that are worth the effort...
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by sib on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:26PM
(#8545511)
If you'd like to learn more than you thought possible about EXIF, IPTC, and other metadata for photos, check out Phil Harvey's excellent ExifTool program and libraries. It lets you read, write, and edit metadata from image files created by hundreds of different devices.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by stevekemp on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:11PM
(#8544966)
To be honest I've found interoperability to be a pain though.
So what I do is store a ".meta" file in the directory of each set of photos. That contains "location=" and "tags=foo,bar". Then I have a wee shell script to search.
If I need to I can have ".meta.IMG_FOO.CR3" to store per-picture data. But generally I order by date + location anyway, so having one file in a directory works out well.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by clarkm on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:13PM
(#8544829)
I totally forgot about that. Though I thought EXIF just had technical info like resolution, camera mode, date, and location. Is it really as flexible as ID3?
I know next to nothing about photography, so maybe there tons of tools out there to manage your photo library EXIF tags that I have never noticed.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Brian-Puccio on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:43PM
(#8544893)
Beyond EXIF, there's also IPTC, which the afore-mentioned Lightroom is pretty good at managing. Couple that with built in geo-tagging of photos thanks to cameras with built in GPS (or do it after the fact with a GPS logger) and you can have a pretty decent system. Both the geographic feature and the keyword feature allow for hierarchies, not just strictly free tagging.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by veidr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:47PM
(#8545040)
I've tried them all too, including the ones that cost $100+ (Lightroom, Aperture), the free ones (iPhoto and friends), and the doomed web apps (Everpix, Picturelife, etc.), and I fully agree that there is not one workable solution in this space -- which is crazy since there are more than a billion people who need this.
This problem cannot be reasonably solved with a web app. Or even a native app running off a mechanical hard disk. With 20MB photos common these days, you need the data coming off a blazing fast local SSD. Otherwise, you can't flip through your photos in a reasonable way. It takes too long to move from one to the next, and every web app does that thing where they load this horrid blurry version first while waiting for the full-resolution version to load. Unacceptable (to anybody who's ever experienced instantly flipping through a hundred pics off a fast SSD, anyway).
So a web app can't do it, but you do need a web app component, and cloud storage strategy, to solve this problem. People's local SSDs are typically too small to store all their photos. Plus, you want your photos everywhere, on all your devices.
So not only do you do need to architect a web/cloud component, but you either need to create a native app for all devices, or at least create an integration with the local photo management facilities on each platform, so that the subset of photos people want are in fast local storage.
It's a hard problem. Meanwhile, my own 500GB of photos (I used to have only maybe 20GB, but then my kids were born) are just sitting in a big folder, with no organization at all, waiting for somebody so solve it.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by GreatCrane on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:58PM
(#8545582)
Mylio might be the solution to your problem. I don't just want to deliver the sales pitch, but I'm reading about your problems and I know that Mylio was designed to help address them.
To address the speed issue, Mylio converts 20+ MB raw images into 1 MB, 2048 px previews that are faster to load and can be automatically loaded on mobile devices or laptops with smaller hdds. Caveat, we use a proprietary compression technology to convert raw images into previews, so not all cameras are supported, but we are increasing camera support all the time.
A lot of the users of Mylio have terrabytes of photos, and Mylio will automatically provide you with different views of your photos (time, location, people, and customized albums) as well as metadata and rating based searches across your entire library of photos, on desktops or mobile devices.
Bonus features, Mylio will help you sync you automatically sync photos between your phone/table/desktop and external hard drives/nas all without going through the cloud.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Veratyr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @09:31PM
(#8545257)
Picturelife + Lightroom works pretty well for me.
Lightroom lets me do all the adjustments and metadata correction locally (something that only has to be done once anyway) and Picturelife gives me the cloud storage and browsing/sharing capabilities I need. It's not one application but it is a workable solution.
As for webapps being 'doomed', there's a pretty large spectrum between 'horrid blurry version' and 'full-resolution version'. Considering that my photos are generally ~4K in resolution and I don't own a monitor that can display them in full resolution, a 1080p scaled version is fine and loads entirely fast enough, even on my terrible ~8Mbps ADSL connection.
Sure it's not as great as flipping through an SSD locally but I think it's definitely acceptable and 'a reasonable way'. I think you're just setting your standards too high. Most of the world doesn't even own an SSD, let alone demand that speed in every application they use. Most users are entirely happy just flipping through albums on Facebook.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by veidr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @09:56PM
(#8545317)
You are right to some extent, but I think the reason I have these expectations is not that I'm some kind of computing perfectionist, it's simply that all my machines have had SSDs and high-res monitors for a while now.
Once you get used to that (which doesn't take long at all) the old, painfully slow ways no longer seem 'reasonable'.
Right now, my equipment may be fairly high-end, but we are fast approaching the day when virtually all computers have fast storage and 4K+ displays.
In 1992, I thought it was reasonable to dial a modem, log onto the Interzone BBS, and have conversations like this one at 9600 baud in Zterm on a 512x342 pixel screen. Few people would accept that today, though.
Having said that, I do agree that Dropbox + Lightroom + Picturelife is about as good as managing photos gets today. (I canceled my own Picturelife subscription, though, because using it was too slow.)
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by win_ini on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:22PM
(#8544990)
I don't work there - but that's what I thought when I read that article too. Picturelife has made it onto my homescreen and has supplanted several of the other apps I used to use. Good work!
I like how picturelife:
- has location based searching
- shows "very rough" thumbnails if you browse quickly
- Can handle my 9000+ pics on my iphone easily
- doesn't REQUIRE me to backup to the cloud (but has that option)
Like others, i'm still looking for a good desktop solution to keep track of my RAW photos from my SLR that is in multiple LR catalogs - it all ends up on my NAS bu t unbrowsable really. Mosaic has been a great fit to help see my LR photos in iOS - better than LR mobile. http://www.mosaicarchive.com/
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by taftster on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:00PM
(#8544787)
Thanks for the mention. I didn't know about Picturelife, but now I do. This is pretty close to what I want. Namely, a "cloud" product that let's me get all my photos into the same account, download them back when I want them, and organize online.
I don't want ever want to "sync" to local storage, nor rely in anyway on local storage. Local storage is temporary. I want durable "cloud" storage.
But note, I want to be able to safely backup my entire digital collection wherever I choose. Perhaps backing up the Amazon Glacier, or something like that. I don't trust that a new dotcom is going to necessarily survive.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by citruspi on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:05PM
(#8544946)
> But note, I want to be able to safely backup my entire digital collection wherever I choose. Perhaps backing up the Amazon Glacier, or something like that. I don't trust that a new dotcom is going to necessarily survive.
I completely agree. One of the features that I love about Picturelife is the ability to setup your own storage. Instead of paying for the service, you can connect it to an Amazon S3 bucket. All the photos you upload are stored in a bucket that you own and you only pay the S3 bills.
Then, because you have complete control and access to the bucket itself, you could setup a backup to Glacier every week or something.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by hsshah on Sunday November 02, 2014 @02:51AM
(#8545994)
This is great. Had I known about this couple of weeks back, I would have opted for this instead of singing up for Dropbox and going to the initial painful step of uploading ALL my local photos (hundreds of GB) to it.
Do you know if PictureLife works with Dropbox?!
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by qohloinc on Saturday November 01, 2014 @03:49PM
(#8544343)
I am the author :) It's a valuable feedback. Thanks. Moments are to group photos by event (taken in short span of time) and timeline view to group photos by month. Do you suggest me to switch the functionality, like timeline to show photos by event and moments by month? I'll revise the app to use other UI pattern instead of radio buttons. Also, bulk selection is very important. My mistake, I thought about it, must have implemented it, at least :(
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by qohloinc on Tuesday November 04, 2014 @08:26AM
(#8556356)
We fixed UX based on your feedback. And implemented bulk selection of photos. Please get new update (1.1.13). Moments is meant to group photos in small clusters (photos taken in a short span of time) in a day. We're happy to receive your thoughts! Please write to us for free promo-code ([email protected]), as a token of gratitude for the feedback
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by miahi on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:11PM
(#8544823)
Trying it now. Opinions/bugs (not very well organized, sorry):
- please allow multiple folder selection for volume source folder
- the analysis phase is really slow and it looks CPU-bound on the ImageScaler.resize() method; try to find a faster resize library or at least allow user setting for scaling (smooth is quite slow) and multithread the resize - right now I have 7 idle CPU cores and you have a really slow application. This is bordering on unusable. I have ~2TB of jpg and raw photos, it would take at least half a month to resize them - and I didn't even ask for a thumbnail.
- A snapshot cannot be stopped (there is no "stop" button/menu entry).
- the persistent mode is called "Persistent" in one place and "Archival" in another
- Not sure I understand the "persistent/archival" setting; I would expect that I can access the old/deleted files as long as they are in the repository files even if the source is deleted/unavailable. I now have a 2GB repository "backup" but I cannot access anything from it because I removed the volumes (the repository did not shrink). At least make it the default with a big warning if you disable it.
- 64MB file chunk for the repository is quite small for something containing photos that cannot ever be deleted (a raw file can easily have 10 or 20MB); file access in folders with a lot of files is slow
- please read EXIF data - it's way more important than Hex views; the metadata-extractor library[1] is stable and fast (I'm using it for my photo organizing application)
- please rotate the thumbnails by EXIF data
- corrupting/deleting a backup file doesn't give any warning (just that the backups don't work anymore and I cannot see the photos)
- not providing a name for the volume in step 1 gives a warning when you want to leave step 2 (and not when you leave step 1)
- raw image decoding is painfully slow; processing an 8MP Canon RAW takes 40 seconds; it estimates 6 hours for 480 photos.
- try to buffer the DBInput/Output as RAF can be quite slow; check MappedByteBuffer
So it looks like a good idea but it's really slow and it can fill up disk space with files that cannot be recovered.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by java-man on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:20PM
(#8544986)
Excellent feedback, many thanks! The tool is still in the development stage, so a lot of things are sub-optimal or missing. But your comments are all valid.
Persistent mode idea is for situations where the user wants to accumulate a large repository piecemeal - for example, a photographer can dump a day worth of files in a folder, upload to the repository and then delete the files on the local machine. This way the next sync will not delete the files dring the next snapshot.
Can you email me an example of an image file that needs to be rotated (all mine have been rotated using windows preview)?
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by rokhayakebe on Saturday November 01, 2014 @03:45PM
(#8544325)
Xoopit. It does not exist anymore, but this was by far the best plugin I ever used. In fact it was one of the best software products I ever used, period. It would go through your email, and organize every photo, pdf, document you ever received and let you search through them.
Xoopit search was better than gmail search. Significantly.
Xoopit created a "personal media," [1] not social media, out of my inbox. This felt better than Facebook to me; when I had FB that is.
[1] I heard the term personal media from Tyler Crowley, which helped to change how I thought about this space.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by jscheel on Saturday November 01, 2014 @04:46PM
(#8544555)
i consider myself a fairly smart and technical human being, but a good photo storage solution is something I still haven't figured out. I want all my photos on an external drive that is also backed up to backblaze. But I also want that external drive backed up to dropbox so that I can access my photos from my phone. Between dropbox wanting to auto-sync my phone pics, itunes backing up my phone, lightroom's photo library management, my external drive issue, etc, I'm at a loss how to organize everything.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by rakoo on Saturday November 01, 2014 @05:18PM
(#8544647)
Camlistore (http://camlistore.org/) is kind of an answer to that: just stuff all your data into it, and get back to it by searching. You shouldn't have to care about where to put what: what you have is Photos, Music, PDFs, and all are accessible through a search box. The content can also be synced between your computers, and there's some work started to sync with the phone (as far as I know, there's a photo uploader for Android at the moment).
The project is still in its infancy (as in "not widespread yet") but it's advancing at a good pace. For the moment the focus is put on how to run it in the cloud, so that people can install a simple instance somewhere for them, for their family or even for business (so you can run a public instance). But if you want to see it for yourself, you'll see that a good amount of work has been put on images (the golang's stdlib for image was improved from camlistore work) as you can see in the videos.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by monksy on Saturday November 01, 2014 @05:42PM
(#8544723)
What I'm looking for is a way to have multiple contributers to a photo album. I've got photos from a lot of difference sources, so I need the ability to merge those into one album.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by surreal on Saturday November 01, 2014 @05:59PM
(#8544780)
We're doing exactly that at FOMO - we were fed up of missing out on great memories just because someone else happened to press the shutter. www.fomo.fm
Get in touch if you need anything and/or have feedback :) [email protected]
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Spearchucker on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:19PM
(#8544026)
It's interesting to me that the author has photos on multiple devices. I sync mine to my PC, where they get placed in folders named yyyy.mm.dd - [location/event]. Since my kid was born I started adding folders named yyyy.mm, which contain the day-to-day photos for a month.
Given that I've been doing this ever since I started amassing digital photos, and that the author doesn't, and that her NY Times post is on HN, I have to wonder what others do with their photos.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by bane on Saturday November 01, 2014 @04:11PM
(#8544426)
I mostly shoot photos when traveling. So I do
year\year-month location
Then under that yyyymmdd, then sorted by camera (I have multiple) and then location or subject and under that pictures of people I'm with (I like taking pictures of things more than people so my pictures of friends/family go in their own folder, while my wife likes pictures of people more) sorted by person or group of people.
So for example
2010\2010-11 Paris\2010-11-27\Nikon\Louvre
Is where all the pictures of the Louvre I took on that day are. If I need to find pictures of the Louvre, I just use Everything on the top level folder and search for "Louvre".
It works well enough, and I just sort everything back at the hotel while I'm copying off of my camera onto my laptop. I'm not super strict about the specific locations, sometimes under "Nikon" will just be a pile of pictures. Depends on how motivated I am to sort. I'm usually really good about filtering out pictures of people from stuff though, and I post pictures of people to my G+ account so my friends and wife and can enjoy them, and I use my flickr for stuff. The best quality stuff I then publish through Getty. Maybe less than 1% gets professionally published, but I have almost 120,000 photos organized this way. I spend lots of time editing metadata in flickr and even more for the Getty material since they have very high quality control.
I don't really make much money at it, but it's a hobby and I get to call myself a "professional photographer" in some settings.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by bane on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:35PM
(#8545010)
I don't. I just dump them all in the same pot and look at them. If I need to select some out for some purpose (making an album or something), I just make another folder inside there and copy out the ones I need for that purpose.
The ones I publish, I go through, pick the best shots from the group and when I go through and edit the levels and crops and such I usually do a little pruning of that set along the way and the edited versions go in yet another folder deeper (so I have a non-destructive copy). It's useful for me to publish several variations (like different zoom levels or crops) so they buyers can buy one that fits their need the best.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by PavlovsCat on Saturday November 01, 2014 @09:00PM
(#8545201)
I'm sure other applications can do that too, but Bibble (since bought by Corel and named Aftershot or something) allows for several sets of settings to exist as "versions" of a RAW file, so it doesn't actually create "physical files" (the cropped/edited etc. JPEG/PNG version, that is) until it's time for the batch to output them how and where you want them, which means you can always delete and recreate the output files at will.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by PavlovsCat on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:35PM
(#8544078)
I don't really "amass" photos that much, but for what it's worth, I auto-rename all photos to yy-mm-dd_hh-mm-ss first thing I do after deleting the ones I don't want to keep. From then on out it's pretty much just a tree of folders, with the ones that have a lot of photos in them having additional subfolders per year. So far I never even had use for using tags, and my main tool is still the delete key followed by enter :)
(with "location" being usually a city or country name; it's not so much about where the photo was taken but rather about "where do I know this person from")
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by PavlovsCat on Saturday November 01, 2014 @08:54PM
(#8545190)
They'll be somewhere in that Bob folder ^^ If there are a lot, and the distinction seems important, they get their own folder, and when the permutations get too much, I would go for tags, but that didn't come up for me yet. And really I meant it when I said my main tool is the delete key: I don't need 50 photos of a person laughing a certain way at a party, I just need one, if even that, and I don't need one for every party either, I keep the good ones. Generally speaking, the more photos of a particular subject I have, the higher the selection pressure; the absolute number still grows, but not in linear relation to the number of photos I take.
I understand that my answer to the problem is a crappy one, namely "enjoy curating your photos and occasionally culling those who have become redundant or obsolete". But for what it's worth, it's how I do it :)
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by Spearchucker on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:48PM
(#8544133)
That's a great question and one I haven't solved for my scenario other than knowing who was with me when I did x at y. The idea is to tag photos in a database (photo location and name, plus tags). One of many things on my todo list.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by java-man on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:51PM
(#8544145)
Does anyone know of an open source (BSD/Apache) face detection/recognition algorithm? It would be relatively easy to plug it in into my Secure Digital Archive tool.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by dunham on Saturday November 01, 2014 @03:54PM
(#8544369)
OpenCV does detection. I haven't found anything to do recognition, I suspect it's a much harder problem.
It's not open source, but in the past I've used picassa to do recognition. You let it run, interact with it to resolve ambiguities, and then pull the face assignments/rectangles out of the .picasa.ini files that it drops next to your photos. (There was also a contacts.xml file somewhere that provided the mapping from a guid to name/email.)
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by rokhayakebe on Saturday November 01, 2014 @03:58PM
(#8544389)
Jason Calacanis interviewed this company (http://www.kairos.com/pricing) last week. While not OS, you can implement their product and get 5000 free api calls per month which should take care of your personal library.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by rbritton on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:34PM
(#8544073)
I'm a bit different in that a significant part of my income is from professional photography. Here's how I'm organized:
Each year has a folder: YYYY. Inside that folder is an Aperture library per category (e.g., Weddings, Portraits, Personal, etc.) Inside each Aperture library there are projects for each grouping of photos (e.g., Valley of Fire). Every file has a unique name that includes the date photographed and the frame number.
I do allow Aperture to keep the image files internally because it simplifies backups. Aperture does not support XMP sidecar files like Lightroom and others do, so the only benefit I feel I'm losing out on by not storing them separately is having a file structure that matches the library structure. The libraries themselves are OS X packages, so it is possible to extract the files relatively easily if I'm no longer able to open Aperture in the future.
I also do not care to have most photos on multiple devices. I have the ability to remote into the computer with the photos from anywhere I have an internet connection, so I'm able to grab a file if needed. With multiple terabytes of photos it's impractical to make them universally available to all of my devices anyway.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by espinchi on Saturday November 01, 2014 @07:15PM
(#8544978)
We tried at Photofeed, but decided to close it earlier this year.
It's not easy to make ends meet in this market: the percentage of users that are willing to pay a monthly/yearly subscription fee is too low to make up for the cost of storing the photos.
The big players provide online photo storage for free, so the user's position is understandable. But it doesn't make it any easier for a small business that wants to, well, make business.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by icefox on Sunday November 02, 2014 @11:04AM
(#8546920)
Where you able to find anything users were willing to pay for related to photos? Maybe more on the physical side with prints, photo books, posters, postcards, etc?
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by espinchi on Sunday November 02, 2014 @11:21AM
(#8546959)
That's a good idea. We did some research on that and, still, the net revenue we would generate out of those wouldn't make up for the costs either.
We started pushing some cool features like auto-magic clustering of photos into moments. Now Google and a few others do it too, so I know it doesn't sound all that impressive now.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by icefox on Sunday November 02, 2014 @01:53PM
(#8547580)
Reading over all of the comments it sounds like trying to have a company that is simply providing a place to store photos is a losing proposition. The revenue would have to come somewhere else.
* By default the photos can be re-sold and the user gets part of the profit.
* Services such as photo restoration
* Selling physical goods such as mugs, tshirts, postcards,
posters, puzzles, Christmas cards, photo books, etc
* Ads on top of a chat system based around photos ;)
* A social network that uses the photos to get your friends to join the network
* Now that you are backing up your photos for $ we could back up all your data
* Daily advertising games such as 1 random users that uploads a photo today featuring Taco Bell gets $1000 (aka advertisers pay for everything).
In fact any company that derives revenue secondary from having photos, but not from the users storing the photos is incentivized to let the users store the photos for as cheap as possible if not free (when possible). This is probably the number one problem with any company that is trying to sell storage for photos and will no doubt force them to pivot or close down eventually.
Alternatively the other option is to only cater to users that are willing to pay and have no free option at all. You would want to interview those users and make sure the problem they have is being solved.
Re:The Best Photo Organizing App? I’m Still Looking
by uvee on Saturday November 01, 2014 @05:10PM
(#8544629)
If you store your images on a bunch of online storage locations, you could use http://mazira.me to see them all at one place (even from inside your email).
The old flickr was perfect for me, I could group things by continent/country/city give a title, drop it on a map to geolocate it, etc. But now they've flattened out the structure a bit and it's not as good for my purposes.
I completely agree. I also liked flickr's system, but I left a year or two ago, after deciding I would rather not put my photos on someone else's server. I would love a good desktop metadata system that felt like it would be long-lived and widely useable. gthumb and darktable both have tagging capabilities, for example, but I have not gotten the sense that either of their systems are worth going back and tagging the past 10+ years of photos I have taken. A great metadata system would have me doing that.
On the "where it was shot" front, I'd love an app that could interpolate positions from iPhone photo EXIF data and use those positions to tag photos from my proper camera based on timestamp in a way that's easy to use and dead-simple. I've found methods of doing it, but none that are worth the effort...
http://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/
So what I do is store a ".meta" file in the directory of each set of photos. That contains "location=" and "tags=foo,bar". Then I have a wee shell script to search.
If I need to I can have ".meta.IMG_FOO.CR3" to store per-picture data. But generally I order by date + location anyway, so having one file in a directory works out well.
I know next to nothing about photography, so maybe there tons of tools out there to manage your photo library EXIF tags that I have never noticed.
This problem cannot be reasonably solved with a web app. Or even a native app running off a mechanical hard disk. With 20MB photos common these days, you need the data coming off a blazing fast local SSD. Otherwise, you can't flip through your photos in a reasonable way. It takes too long to move from one to the next, and every web app does that thing where they load this horrid blurry version first while waiting for the full-resolution version to load. Unacceptable (to anybody who's ever experienced instantly flipping through a hundred pics off a fast SSD, anyway).
So a web app can't do it, but you do need a web app component, and cloud storage strategy, to solve this problem. People's local SSDs are typically too small to store all their photos. Plus, you want your photos everywhere, on all your devices.
So not only do you do need to architect a web/cloud component, but you either need to create a native app for all devices, or at least create an integration with the local photo management facilities on each platform, so that the subset of photos people want are in fast local storage.
It's a hard problem. Meanwhile, my own 500GB of photos (I used to have only maybe 20GB, but then my kids were born) are just sitting in a big folder, with no organization at all, waiting for somebody so solve it.
To address the speed issue, Mylio converts 20+ MB raw images into 1 MB, 2048 px previews that are faster to load and can be automatically loaded on mobile devices or laptops with smaller hdds. Caveat, we use a proprietary compression technology to convert raw images into previews, so not all cameras are supported, but we are increasing camera support all the time.
A lot of the users of Mylio have terrabytes of photos, and Mylio will automatically provide you with different views of your photos (time, location, people, and customized albums) as well as metadata and rating based searches across your entire library of photos, on desktops or mobile devices.
Bonus features, Mylio will help you sync you automatically sync photos between your phone/table/desktop and external hard drives/nas all without going through the cloud.
Lightroom lets me do all the adjustments and metadata correction locally (something that only has to be done once anyway) and Picturelife gives me the cloud storage and browsing/sharing capabilities I need. It's not one application but it is a workable solution.
As for webapps being 'doomed', there's a pretty large spectrum between 'horrid blurry version' and 'full-resolution version'. Considering that my photos are generally ~4K in resolution and I don't own a monitor that can display them in full resolution, a 1080p scaled version is fine and loads entirely fast enough, even on my terrible ~8Mbps ADSL connection.
Sure it's not as great as flipping through an SSD locally but I think it's definitely acceptable and 'a reasonable way'. I think you're just setting your standards too high. Most of the world doesn't even own an SSD, let alone demand that speed in every application they use. Most users are entirely happy just flipping through albums on Facebook.
Once you get used to that (which doesn't take long at all) the old, painfully slow ways no longer seem 'reasonable'.
Right now, my equipment may be fairly high-end, but we are fast approaching the day when virtually all computers have fast storage and 4K+ displays.
In 1992, I thought it was reasonable to dial a modem, log onto the Interzone BBS, and have conversations like this one at 9600 baud in Zterm on a 512x342 pixel screen. Few people would accept that today, though.
Having said that, I do agree that Dropbox + Lightroom + Picturelife is about as good as managing photos gets today. (I canceled my own Picturelife subscription, though, because using it was too slow.)
(Disclaimer: I work there, but my position is supported by many other reviews.)
I like how picturelife: - has location based searching - shows "very rough" thumbnails if you browse quickly - Can handle my 9000+ pics on my iphone easily - doesn't REQUIRE me to backup to the cloud (but has that option)
Like others, i'm still looking for a good desktop solution to keep track of my RAW photos from my SLR that is in multiple LR catalogs - it all ends up on my NAS bu t unbrowsable really. Mosaic has been a great fit to help see my LR photos in iOS - better than LR mobile. http://www.mosaicarchive.com/
I don't want ever want to "sync" to local storage, nor rely in anyway on local storage. Local storage is temporary. I want durable "cloud" storage.
But note, I want to be able to safely backup my entire digital collection wherever I choose. Perhaps backing up the Amazon Glacier, or something like that. I don't trust that a new dotcom is going to necessarily survive.
Thanks for the pointer, going to check it out.
I completely agree. One of the features that I love about Picturelife is the ability to setup your own storage. Instead of paying for the service, you can connect it to an Amazon S3 bucket. All the photos you upload are stored in a bucket that you own and you only pay the S3 bills.
Then, because you have complete control and access to the bucket itself, you could setup a backup to Glacier every week or something.
1. First of its kind to group photos by moments.
2. Easy to organize your pics into awesome albums.
3. SafeView, brilliantly hide your personal photos, and only show relevant photos to your friends
Get from Google Play: http://goo.gl/L1myRJ
- Moments just seems to be organized by day instead of by month as in Timeline view.
- No easy way to bulk-select photos to add to an album.
- Curious overuse of radio buttons. Did not like.
While not strictly a photo organizer app, it does have a photo gallery, timeline, and raw file format support.
- please allow multiple folder selection for volume source folder
- the analysis phase is really slow and it looks CPU-bound on the ImageScaler.resize() method; try to find a faster resize library or at least allow user setting for scaling (smooth is quite slow) and multithread the resize - right now I have 7 idle CPU cores and you have a really slow application. This is bordering on unusable. I have ~2TB of jpg and raw photos, it would take at least half a month to resize them - and I didn't even ask for a thumbnail.
- A snapshot cannot be stopped (there is no "stop" button/menu entry).
- the persistent mode is called "Persistent" in one place and "Archival" in another
- Not sure I understand the "persistent/archival" setting; I would expect that I can access the old/deleted files as long as they are in the repository files even if the source is deleted/unavailable. I now have a 2GB repository "backup" but I cannot access anything from it because I removed the volumes (the repository did not shrink). At least make it the default with a big warning if you disable it.
- 64MB file chunk for the repository is quite small for something containing photos that cannot ever be deleted (a raw file can easily have 10 or 20MB); file access in folders with a lot of files is slow
- please read EXIF data - it's way more important than Hex views; the metadata-extractor library[1] is stable and fast (I'm using it for my photo organizing application)
- please rotate the thumbnails by EXIF data
- corrupting/deleting a backup file doesn't give any warning (just that the backups don't work anymore and I cannot see the photos)
- not providing a name for the volume in step 1 gives a warning when you want to leave step 2 (and not when you leave step 1)
- raw image decoding is painfully slow; processing an 8MP Canon RAW takes 40 seconds; it estimates 6 hours for 480 photos.
- try to buffer the DBInput/Output as RAF can be quite slow; check MappedByteBuffer
So it looks like a good idea but it's really slow and it can fill up disk space with files that cannot be recovered.
[1] https://code.google.com/p/metadata-extractor/
Persistent mode idea is for situations where the user wants to accumulate a large repository piecemeal - for example, a photographer can dump a day worth of files in a folder, upload to the repository and then delete the files on the local machine. This way the next sync will not delete the files dring the next snapshot.
Can you email me an example of an image file that needs to be rotated (all mine have been rotated using windows preview)?
Again, thanks for your comments! Very helpful.
Xoopit search was better than gmail search. Significantly.
Xoopit created a "personal media," [1] not social media, out of my inbox. This felt better than Facebook to me; when I had FB that is.
[1] I heard the term personal media from Tyler Crowley, which helped to change how I thought about this space.
The project is still in its infancy (as in "not widespread yet") but it's advancing at a good pace. For the moment the focus is put on how to run it in the cloud, so that people can install a simple instance somewhere for them, for their family or even for business (so you can run a public instance). But if you want to see it for yourself, you'll see that a good amount of work has been put on images (the golang's stdlib for image was improved from camlistore work) as you can see in the videos.
Get in touch if you need anything and/or have feedback :) [email protected]
Given that I've been doing this ever since I started amassing digital photos, and that the author doesn't, and that her NY Times post is on HN, I have to wonder what others do with their photos.
So for example 2010\2010-11 Paris\2010-11-27\Nikon\Louvre
Is where all the pictures of the Louvre I took on that day are. If I need to find pictures of the Louvre, I just use Everything on the top level folder and search for "Louvre".
It works well enough, and I just sort everything back at the hotel while I'm copying off of my camera onto my laptop. I'm not super strict about the specific locations, sometimes under "Nikon" will just be a pile of pictures. Depends on how motivated I am to sort. I'm usually really good about filtering out pictures of people from stuff though, and I post pictures of people to my G+ account so my friends and wife and can enjoy them, and I use my flickr for stuff. The best quality stuff I then publish through Getty. Maybe less than 1% gets professionally published, but I have almost 120,000 photos organized this way. I spend lots of time editing metadata in flickr and even more for the Getty material since they have very high quality control.
I don't really make much money at it, but it's a hobby and I get to call myself a "professional photographer" in some settings.
The ones I publish, I go through, pick the best shots from the group and when I go through and edit the levels and crops and such I usually do a little pruning of that set along the way and the edited versions go in yet another folder deeper (so I have a non-destructive copy). It's useful for me to publish several variations (like different zoom levels or crops) so they buyers can buy one that fits their need the best.
I understand that my answer to the problem is a crappy one, namely "enjoy curating your photos and occasionally culling those who have become redundant or obsolete". But for what it's worth, it's how I do it :)
It's not open source, but in the past I've used picassa to do recognition. You let it run, interact with it to resolve ambiguities, and then pull the face assignments/rectangles out of the .picasa.ini files that it drops next to your photos. (There was also a contacts.xml file somewhere that provided the mapping from a guid to name/email.)
Each year has a folder: YYYY. Inside that folder is an Aperture library per category (e.g., Weddings, Portraits, Personal, etc.) Inside each Aperture library there are projects for each grouping of photos (e.g., Valley of Fire). Every file has a unique name that includes the date photographed and the frame number.
I do allow Aperture to keep the image files internally because it simplifies backups. Aperture does not support XMP sidecar files like Lightroom and others do, so the only benefit I feel I'm losing out on by not storing them separately is having a file structure that matches the library structure. The libraries themselves are OS X packages, so it is possible to extract the files relatively easily if I'm no longer able to open Aperture in the future.
I also do not care to have most photos on multiple devices. I have the ability to remote into the computer with the photos from anywhere I have an internet connection, so I'm able to grab a file if needed. With multiple terabytes of photos it's impractical to make them universally available to all of my devices anyway.
It's not easy to make ends meet in this market: the percentage of users that are willing to pay a monthly/yearly subscription fee is too low to make up for the cost of storing the photos.
The big players provide online photo storage for free, so the user's position is understandable. But it doesn't make it any easier for a small business that wants to, well, make business.
We started pushing some cool features like auto-magic clustering of photos into moments. Now Google and a few others do it too, so I know it doesn't sound all that impressive now.
* By default the photos can be re-sold and the user gets part of the profit.
* Services such as photo restoration
* Selling physical goods such as mugs, tshirts, postcards, posters, puzzles, Christmas cards, photo books, etc
* Ads on top of a chat system based around photos ;)
* A social network that uses the photos to get your friends to join the network
* Now that you are backing up your photos for $ we could back up all your data
* Daily advertising games such as 1 random users that uploads a photo today featuring Taco Bell gets $1000 (aka advertisers pay for everything).
In fact any company that derives revenue secondary from having photos, but not from the users storing the photos is incentivized to let the users store the photos for as cheap as possible if not free (when possible). This is probably the number one problem with any company that is trying to sell storage for photos and will no doubt force them to pivot or close down eventually.
Alternatively the other option is to only cater to users that are willing to pay and have no free option at all. You would want to interview those users and make sure the problem they have is being solved.
It has automated cataloguing, organization, and offline backup of large number of photos all synchronized across multiple devices.
Disclaimer - I work for the company, but I really feel that the product can help people manage their photos.
From online services I like (and fear) Google+ which let you search your photos via context without any prior tagging (e.g “show my photos of cats”).