If we get rid of teachers after 6 years, what would that teacher do? How would this work exactly?
As for "what will teachers do" after 6 years, they can either continue to perform well or find a new job (just like a trader or salesman). The purpose of school is education, not jobs for liberal arts grads.
"they can either continue to perform well or find a new job" How to measure?
http://notebook.lausd.net/pls/ptl/docs/PAGE/CA_LAUSD/FLDR_OR...
So I suppose that a more careful cost-benefit analysis needs to be made.
So. You are proposing to throw teachers out after six years of teaching. Then, assuming every teacher stays the full six years, 1/3 of all teachers will be in that low-experience category that teaches so much less effectively. At present, according to the study you cited, the figure is more like 1/5. It seems that your proposal will result in 65% more pupils being taught by teachers who do not do a good job.
This is not the only reason why your suggestion seems to me unlikely to be a good one, but it seems a pretty compelling reason.
Though I must admit, I don't really buy your thesis that incentives only work short term. If they did, you'd expect entrepreneurs to be unmotivated beyond the short term, for example.