News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by melling on Friday October 24, 2014 @09:50PM (#8506895)
I find it hard to believe that you can do squats more than one day a week. It takes a while for large muscles to recover, especially when you're doing heavy weight.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by tptacek on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:41PM (#8507013)
5x5, 3x per week, bumping up 5# each session (we got a squat rack for the basement). It was rough getting started, but after a week or so, no big deal.

I've had much more trouble consistently increasing weight on bench presses.

In fairness, I probably have a mechanical advantage for squats.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by Alex_MJ on Friday October 24, 2014 @11:04PM (#8507064)
Seconded.

I'm a relatively experienced lifter - heavy squats 3x per week is brutal for the first week or so and then your body adapts to it.

I've found that I'll actually stick with a ~hourlong workout, 3-5x a week that I believe in and have goals for over anything quick with no discernible aim. And it's amazing how time magically appears to actually show up at the gym when you prioritize it.

A "scientific" 7 minute workout with no discernible goals is an admirable thing but honestly it's a cheap novelty at best - I've never heard of anybody actually sticking to one, "doing the bare minimum" is just not motivating at all. Scientific according to whom? To what end? Why am I doing this?

Exercise science is inherently a little bit voodoo. Motivation and consistency are much more important than the time requirement.

If somebody's had any success with vague goalless 7-minute workouts, or has even stuck with them consistently, I'd love to hear differing opinions.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by TylerJay on Saturday October 25, 2014 @11:38AM (#8508476)
I agree with most of what you said, except for the part about doing the bare minimum not being motivating. I'm also a pretty experienced lifter (Been lifting for 9 years, can DL 3x my bodyweight, Squat 2.5x bodyweight, BP 1.6x) but I'm always looking for the bare minimum to improve. If that happened to be a 7 minute workout, that's what I would do. I think it's incredibly motivating to use your time really effectively. I spend probably about 1/4 to 1/2 the time in the gym as anyone else there with comparable fitness levels because I've done a lot of research on training methods and have tried tons of different programs and permutations to find the ones that are most effective for me.

I think you're right that the biggest problem with this is that there are "no discernible goals" associated with this "scientific" workout. For noticeable strength and physique improvements, the lowest I've found to be effective are 40 minute workouts 3 times per cycle with a cycle length of 7-10 days depending on the types of workouts done.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by fasteo on Saturday October 25, 2014 @04:30AM (#8507595)
In my experience, this is doable as long as you stick to these rules:

1. Leave one rep in the tank for every set you do. 5 reps means 5 picture-perfect repetitions. As soon as form starts to break down, you are doing it wrong.

2. Start light.

3. Eat like a horse. At least 10% above you maintenance levels in training days.

4. Deload every 4 weeks.

Note that I am 40+ years old. I have been squatting twice per week more than 3 years now.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by brandonmenc on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:12PM (#8506942)
Just about every powerlifting or strength/mass program, from novice to expert, has multiple squat days a week.

The theory is that because the large areas (ex: leg, back) are actually composed of many muscles, you can hit them more frequently with slight variations (working different parts/ranges/etc.) and still recover.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by jamesaguilar on Friday October 24, 2014 @11:03PM (#8507057)
I have never heard of that. To my understanding, the important elements are:

    - Recovery doesn't take seven days.
    - Squats target the biggest muscles.
    - The biggest muscles produce the most testosterone, enabling you to make gains in other muscle groups more easily.
Given those and the constraints of safety and putting up the most weight you can for a decent amount of volume, you want to squat as often as possible. Not just for your legs, but because it enables you to do more elsewhere.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by kyberias on Saturday October 25, 2014 @03:26AM (#8507509)
Molecular biology student here. I've never heard muscles producing (synthesizing) testosterone. It's synthesized in male testicles and adrenal gland. Care to elaborate what do you mean?
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by jamesaguilar on Saturday October 25, 2014 @05:41AM (#8507698)
Maybe its just bro science, but most natty lifters talk about the importance of squats in terms of the additional testosterone released by growing the largest muscle group.

Ex. http://breakingmuscle.com/strength-conditioning/new-study-pi.... The muscle may not produce the testosterone, but it is produced by working the muscle.

That's all I know.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by raverbashing on Saturday October 25, 2014 @04:08AM (#8507568)
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by brandonmenc on Friday October 24, 2014 @11:18PM (#8507089)
I agree, you are more correct than I was in my post.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by cynicalkane on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:49PM (#8507024)
That's not any theory I've heard of. Programs generally have you doing the same exercises repeatedly. Variations are not usually intra-program substitutes, and "slight variations" as substitutes are an anti-pattern. "Many muscles" also has nothing to do with it either--most leg exercises put the largest component of stress on the glutes, which are one big muscle body. On the other hand, the back is a whole lot of different muscles but I don't think very many people do 3 back days a week.

In particular, the GP was talking about Stronglifts, which has you doing the same old back squats 3 times a week, variations strongly discouraged.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by brandonmenc on Friday October 24, 2014 @11:16PM (#8507083)
There are a lot of tried-and-true programs that include multiple squats a week.

Stronglifts is one, but there are programs from Glenn Pendlay, Bill Starr, Mark Rippetoe, etc. and they're all good for beginner to intermediate lifters - and they all feature two or three days a week of the same-old squats.

A beginning lifter should make gains in the squat even while doing it three times a week, sometimes for many months. After you hit the wall, programs will drop the number of squat days, replace a day of back squats with the front squat, or replace all-heavy days with a light-heavy-medium rotation.

It's true - you'll eventually plateau. But a 3x week squat program works for a lot of people, especially when starting out.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by danieltillett on Saturday October 25, 2014 @04:04AM (#8507562)
When I was younger and had the time for serious weight lifting I found that I could do heavy lifts every day without issue provided that I slept afterwards. I used to get up at 4 am and lift massive weights for an hour and a half and then go home and sleep for a couple of hours (I was a student at the time who never went to a class before 11 am, but that is another story). Provided I slept my body could handle the load of doing this every day and I got massive increases in strength in a relative short period of time.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by MichaelDickens on Saturday October 25, 2014 @02:35PM (#8508953)
Novices should be able to do this. When I first started working out, I increased my squat 5lb per session, 3 times a week, for about 2 months straight. Novices' large muscles can usually fully recover within 48-72 hours. Large muscles actually recover quicker than small muscles.

You're right though that more experienced trainees who have built up a base level of strength take more like a week to recover. Intermediate powerlifting/Olympic weightlifting programs (see Texas Method, Bill Starr 5x5) usually still recommend squatting three days a week, but only one of these days is a heavy day.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by dredmorbius on Saturday October 25, 2014 @11:56AM (#8508523)
For Stronglifts / Starting Strength, you're starting out very light.

SL5x5 starts out with the unloaded bar, SS with a _lightly_ weighted bar. The whole idea is that you're initially _well_ below your actual potential.

You're increasing the weight fairly aggressively (10# per week for squats), but it'll take you a few months before you're up to significantly challenging weights.

You'll also re-set a few times, and eventually switch to a different progression.

If you're not going balls-to-the-wall, you can squat twice a week. If you're going heavy, 1x is more viable.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by speedyapoc on Friday October 24, 2014 @09:55PM (#8506906)
The first few workouts are tough. As a beginner I could squat heavy 3x a week for the first 6ish months, increasing weight per workout. Now it's 2 days heavy and 1 day light.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by wdewind on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:39PM (#8507009)
There are many advanced programs that squat heavy as possible every workout. Look at some of the Average Broz programming.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by jamesaguilar on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:50PM (#8507027)
Believe it. I'm not strong though. Maybe when I'm repping 300 it'll be hard to do it three times a week. At 245 it is not a big problem.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by zhte415 on Saturday October 25, 2014 @05:38AM (#8507690)
I agree recovery is key. I do one day per week legs, one day pulling based (upper body, legs of course somewhat involved), and one day pushing based (legs not really involved) weights. Each time large muscle groups first, working to smaller ones that aren't tired yet. A small amount of various whatever-I-feel-like cardio each day, from a fast hike to a swim. That and eating well.

Sometimes less is more.

Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by KobaQ on Saturday October 25, 2014 @12:08AM (#8507173)
Then you've done it too hard. Ideally one should work-out at an intensity and volume (reps) that allows to be recovered after round about 48 hours. If the training is too hard compared to the fitness level you miss the point of supercompensation for the next training session. So, you have to build the ability to train hard up.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by will_lam on Saturday October 25, 2014 @12:30PM (#8508614)
You'd be surprised at what you're body is capable of as long as you're lifting with proper form, getting enough rest and doing mobility on a regular basis.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by jacques_chester on Saturday October 25, 2014 @08:32AM (#8508014)
I've squatted up to 5 days per week. Recovery is a multi-week integral, and good programming accounts for that.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout by wdewind on Friday October 24, 2014 @10:38PM (#8507003)
I squat heavy 3x a week. It's mostly about the diet.