People who haven't read e.g. Adam Smith on linen shirts like to take the image of a poor person with a wedding ring or a television and hold it up as an example of excess, but when you see widespread behavior that appears irrational, the right response is not to criticize it on those grounds, but to try to understand why it's happening. It's always happening for a reason.
1: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/05... 2: http://thepsychreport.com/research-application/featured-rese...
I understand this sentiment, but it's risk mitigation. As the article points out, there are no options for these people outside of this. It's serving a market and it's doing so in a way that reduces the risk - in some ways for both parties.
Is it a smart move on the part of customers? I think it's hard to argue that it is, but I don't know that it's necessarily the fault of these businesses. If anything, it's a better move than going to an Amscot or getting a subprime credit card, because you're not wrecked financially nor is your credit ruined necessarily.
It really goes to show the culture of poverty, and how hard it is to break from it. These people simply do not have the means or even the faintest idea to better their situation. It is very, very sad. They have no chance of breaking away from this vicious cycle. It is a major societal problem.
This business model is exploitative and downright evil. But they are not the problem. They are merely the symptoms. Getting rid of those rent-to-own shops won't fix the broken system.
> They are charging people with ridiculous prices because the risk of them failing to pay is ridiculous certain.
> This business model is exploitative and downright evil. But they are not the problem.
Indeed, the problem is that these business are kept open by people who do not budget properly. Closing these businesses doesn't mean these people will have more money to spend on things that matter. We can say they aren't helping, but we can't say the consumers would better allocate their money.
Going without a 60" TV or iPad isn't an option?
Then again, it could also just be a way to spend more time and money on video games and movies...
Is two months of having to use the internet from the library really worth spending $1000 on when you can't even afford a $230 ipad? Sorry, but there are other options.
I believe there is a place for businesses like these. They're making an offer for important things, while possibly not quite absolute necessities definitely very useful "luxuries", to a group of people that would otherwise not be able to have them. No one else is willing to touch the prospective borrower in this situation because they are massively high risk. If you're in that position, you have to accept that people are going to want to be compensated for their exposure.
If the only way to get a couch was to buy it over again each year for four years, would you do it? Remember, it's your only reasonable option to actually get a couch that you don't pull directly out of the landfill. Some people may go without a couch and be fine, but I don't think it's unreasonable to RTO a couch or a bed if it's your only option to get a decent furnishing.
Except that isn't even remotely true.
Compare to buying a couch like a normal person at a normal furniture retailer. If you have the income to sustain the payments and know that you'll be paying more in the long run, it's a tradeoff some people are willing to make. Most of the time, you can pay off rentals early.
The same kind of shenanigans go on with any financial instrument when one is considered "high risk". Credit cards charge ~30% APR until you have a well-established credit history. Car loans cost 15-20%. In any of these cases, you're a fool if you let the full term run out at those rates. You could say that someone doesn't need a car to get by, but it sure helps a lot, and so does a decent bed if someone is trying to get a good night's rest and be functional for work the next day.
RTO does serve a legitimate purpose. It's just expensive, but sometimes that tradeoff can be reasonable.
Yes, it's true that it's probably possible to get a couch without going through a RTO contract if you have the money to make RTO payments. That doesn't mean it's reasonable, plausible, or even just worth all the extra effort. If you need a couch now and can pay it off a few payments down the road, it's not so bad to be willing to pay a substantial expense for that convenience. As long as the consumer is informed, there's no reason this voluntary trade of security/convenience for money shouldn't be allowed or performed.
Of course it'd be cheaper if the consumer had access to cheaper credit, but they don't, so these places have sprung up to help/serve those people. Again, I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with that. It's just expensive (for both parties).
I know because I was doing exactly what some people in this thread would suggest. We moved to a new house Wednesday and needed a gas dryer instead of electric. Though we could afford the $2k for a nice new set, I looked around and found a great deal on a barely used pair that an elderly couple had to put in storage when they downsized. I rented a Home Depot truck while movers were still loading up at the old house, met the folks at their storage unit with their son to help me load it, got the W/D loaded up, and brought it over to the new house while the movers were still there so that they could unload and hook it up. I ended up saving about a thousand dollars and helped out some nice folks who were happy to not need to pay for the storage unit anymore.
You're right about the insurance and valid license being a requirement for a rental, of course. Around here, that's a pretty low bar because almost everyone drives (and I'd bet the people in the article drive too). I could see that being an issue in places where public transit was half decent and people didn't drive. On the other hand, a fair number of people in blue collar work (like at least the one guy in that article) have easier access to work trucks than most of us.
I'm well aware of and thankful for how privileged I am to be able to maneuver without as much financial pressure as the people in the article. On the other hand, if my time was only exchangeable for minimum wage, saving four figures would be well worth the time and effort of arranging something like a Craigslist purchase.
Like I said, it might be an absolutely terrible idea, but this business presenting the opportunity in this fashion actually reduces the overall risk for this demographic.
There's clearly some blame to go around. Better public education on financial decision making would help. The companies providing this type of financing could alter their business model or screening processes.
Also, it seems that many lower income individuals strive to own new items because it portrays financial success even if it results in the opposite.
They only look at the monthly cost. There's no consideration given to the lifetime cost. Sometimes it's an inability to make the calculation, sometimes it just never occurs to them, and sometimes it's deliberate avoidance.
Further, when examining the monthly cost, it's often done with an eye towards the most optimistic scenario. "I make X in a good month, I spend Y if I eat mostly ramen, therefore I can afford to pay X - Y per month on my new toy." There's often no consideration of normal fluctuations, let alone emergency expenses.
The above probably comes across as blaming the poor, but I really think a lot of it comes down to education and culture. People just aren't taught what these deals really cost, or how to budget, or how to spend less than you earn. And then it's hard to have crap furniture and a junky car when your neighbor, who you know makes no more money than you do, has a nice new couch and a sporty car.
I've seen this in action. I've lived it a little, but fortunately not much. I'm trying real hard not to be disparaging even though I may not have completely succeeded.
Indeed, and bad in the sense that it generally doesn't teach this sort of thing. Or prepare individuals sufficiently deal with a lot of life situations.
But at least they know trigonometry! (If they even graduated higschool)
Well. In this case, he may just don't want to care too much about financial math because he does not have any financial issue pressing him to consider that part.
Paul Erdős might not care about his own financial status as well, but that does not mean he will pay all he has to buy an iPad.
I did basic math on my cell phone plan this morning, and realized I can get a better deal by buying the device outright, and just getting a BYOD plan - so that's what I'm planning to do. Yet the VAST majority of Americans are doing the subsidized phone thing.
These are the MVNOs:
Sprint: Go with Ting, Freedom pop, virgin mobile ATT: Cricket (all thought they're pretty bad) TMobile: TMobile Prepaid multi carrier: Walmart StraightTalk, TracFone Verizon: PagePlus
It's sad that we've created a paycheck to paycheck culture, but thats what we have.
And yeah, it's a way better bet than an iPad in every sense except maybe screen size.
They could've gotten several decent looking couches for $300 or less on Craigslist: http://huntsville.craigslist.org/search/fuo?query=couch+cull...
If that seems callous, then it's because I've been poor and had to make those choices. Always pay cash, unless it's something that can help you make money (car to get to work, training, college education).
http://www.walmart.com/cp/4038?povid=cat1070145-env172199-mo...
From my own experience, we were selling a house that we'd moved out of, and having a hard time finding a buyer. Realtor suggested 'staging' the home, filling it with furniture, as a full home looks more lived in, and gives buyers an easier time imagining their own furniture in place of yours.
Went to rent-a-center, rented a living room and dining room set and a bed for the master, and the home sold rather quickly thereafter. Though I couldn't say whether or not the furniture had anything to do with it, the renting of furniture is, by no means, predatory on its face.
That people are renting furniture to own is the problem. There are numerous other options, including Craigslist, buying used furniture, or even layaway are all superior to rental.
However, if you are a businessperson offering to rent furniture, and if you believe that there are non-predatory reasons to rent out such furniture, then shouldn't you be targeting such rental purposes? If renting to own is the problem, then perhaps you shouldn't offer rent-to-own. Or, if a credit check is enough to rule out customers who are unlikely to pay, perhaps there should be a credit check. I am sure, in your case, you would have been able to pass such a check. I simply do not believe that a renter can benefit from usurious rentals and be absolved of moral burden because the renter 'should have known better'.
There are also plenty of benefits for renting to own. I know a couple of startups on the east coast who rent furniture to own, specifically the lobby stuff (moreso than the actual office equipment) because
1) They were able to negotiate better than the listed prices and
2) it's potentially cheaper than hiring an account and/or figuring out the excise and use taxes on the assets.
Just because there are predatory use cases doesn't make the practice predatory ut totum. Also, nobody's compelling people to buy furniture they can't afford.
People who only have ninth-grade educations aren't the greatest at basic math or delayed gratification.
Maybe they should see that video.
Just look at that Nitwit Long Island Medium she's preying on vulnerable and gullible people and I doubt she does it free of charge!
However, the sensible side is frustrated that these people aren't doing basic math. These people are choosing to buy something that they can't afford. Do they need these items? Does anyone need a couch? Does anyone NEED a TV/wedding ring? No. You can live without it.
End the end: All I got from this article was: "Look at these people who don't realize where they stand financially and refuse to accept that it's not where they'd like to be."