News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:12AM (#8464943)
"Surprisingly we do it all the time, on animals, and we call it breeding. It is very successful"

Breeding is successful in some sense, but certainly not without its issues. For example, by breeding pedigree dogs we've left them with a number of genetic defects that are hard to remove due to the reduced gene pool, e.g. Dalmatian deafness, Bulldog respiration, King Charles Spaniel syringomyelia, etc...

Addressing the article, I find the idea of quantifiable intelligence to be one of the dumbest ideas we ever came up with. What does an IQ point mean, really? From my understanding, testing it basically boils down to using a specific subset of symbolic puzzles. Intelligence can be quantified numerically in the same way love can be quantified numerically, i.e. not at all, without losing the essence of what you're looking for.

Also, intelligence by itself is not a goal in its own right, it's the purpose to which it's applied that matters. If super intelligent people exist, what would we have them do? The same things we do but faster? No thanks.

Instead of wasting our time trying to group ourselves into categories, we should be looking to bring out the best of the talents we find in the people around us. That seems like a better goal than chasing a 1000 IQ person.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by threatofrain on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:19AM (#8465366)
I think that to many people, the phenomena behind IQ is a suspected general mental ability. It may also be fitting to describe this as a general or arbitrary analogical or mapping ability. I think this definition also captures what people think of when they say "artificial", or non-organic intelligence.

When you say that IQ is just "a specific subset of symbolic puzzles", I believe you are criticizing IQ as ungeneralizable, or as having external validity issues.

I think the reason why IQ has remained as a widespread construct is because it is actually so useful in predicting performance across an array of situations, such as general job performance, of which IQ or g is often a top-tier or unmatched predictor, better than years of relevant work experience. And whenever someone accuses IQ of being inadequate, and they come out with their More Complete test, it turns out that their measurements and predictions are insufficiently distinctive from IQ, which even further supports the idea of a "general" mental ability.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:57AM (#8465585)
"And whenever someone accuses IQ of being inadequate, and they come out with their More Complete test, it turns out that their measurements and predictions are insufficiently distinctive from IQ, which even further supports the idea of a "general" mental ability."

Here's the thing... I'm criticising IQ tests, but I'm not suggesting we create a more complete test, I'm suggesting the whole idea of measuring intelligence numerically is fundamentally flawed.

There are a few reasons I believe measuring intelligence numerically is flawed, but probably the central one is that I don't believe it exists as a fixed entity, I believe it's adaptive depending on the circumstances we find ourselves in.

As with any debate on human traits the tendency is to go back to the nature vs. nurture question. I believe you can have a natural aptitude for something, but the environment you live in is what helps your intelligence develop, and this is the largest differentiator in what we perceive as intelligence. Put simply, change the environment and you change the intelligence. Therefore scores like IQ do not measure someone's true potential, they only hint at what they've already been exposed to. That's why to me such tests are a waste of time.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by eitland on Thursday October 16, 2014 @02:03PM (#8466307)
> Therefore scores like IQ do not measure someone's true potential, they only hint at what they've already been exposed to. That's why to me such tests are a waste of time.

Hmmm. As far as I know you are allowed to retake IQ-tests if you want, still the differences are there. Some people will never pass 120 no matter how many times they take the test.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:43PM (#8467963)
eitland, I'm sorry I was rude towards you, you didn't deserve it.

I'll try and make this constructive. Would you agree that human intelligence centres around pattern recognition? If so, which patterns would you class as hard to teach?

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:15PM (#8466911)
It appears reading comprehension isn't a prerequisite for a good IQ score, what I'm saying is those scores are irrelevant, do try and keep up. Oh and its very easy to train someone to get beyond your benchmark as long as they have a reasonable grasp on language, you just show them past exam questions and show the steps to take to get the answer, it's what passes for education in many subjects.

Just to go further into this, decided to remind myself what an IQ test question looked like. This is the first one that came up...

"1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11 - Which one doesn't belong in this series?"

Now the "correct" answer is 8, but that's only because we second guess what the examiner wants. Truthfully 11 is equally correct, as its the only 2 digit number, and the number series could be single digit numbers. But there's nowhere to explain your reasoning, so you better choose the "correct" answer anyway...

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:44PM (#8467158)
>reading comprehension...try and keep up

Don't be an ass.

>What I'm saying is those scores are irrelevant

But you claimed the scores are based on what you're exposed to rather than your potential. If they don't change over time then that's a strong counter to your argument.

And not being potential was critical to your 'central' flaw with the approach. Perhaps you can name other flaws, but you haven't made them clear, and you haven't actually disagreed with threatofrain's assertion that IQ is the best correlation with general performance that we have.

>math

It's a series, not a set. 11 is not 'equally' correct.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:07PM (#8467319)
"But you claimed the scores are based on what you're exposed to rather than your potential. If they don't change over time then that's a strong counter to your argument."

As I mentioned in another comment, I was rude because I was tired of explaining why it was pointless, but I did address that it's possible to teach better IQ scores by focusing on how to pass the tests.

"It's a series, not a set. 11 is not 'equally' correct"

http://i.word.com/idictionary/series

"a number of things or events of the same class coming one after another in spatial or temporal succession"

Depending on your definition, there's no requirement on a series to contain the complete list of elements, so long as they are in the correct order.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:23PM (#8467430)
Yep that's a definition. I'm not sure why you quoted it?

You can make all kinds of arguments to remove any number, but which one leaves a sequence with minimal kolmogorov complexity? Which one leaves a sequence where you can predict the next number?

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:31PM (#8467475)
"Which one leaves a sequence where you can predict the next number?"

Who said you had to predict the next number? If the question asked "Fill in the next number in this sequence" then I'd agree with you, but instead it asked which number didn't belong.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:40PM (#8467545)
It's a heuristic. If you can't explain the series then you lose a lot of points in arguing that you interpreted it correctly.

Remember, the question isn't asking you to sort a bag of numbers into piles, it's giving them in a specific order and asking which list of n-1 numbers in that order is most coherent.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:47PM (#8467984)
"is most coherent" Of course it's clear which is most coherent, but what I'm trying to illustrate is how less obvious approaches may still demonstrate intelligence, I'll look up some more IQ test questions and find a different example to do this...

EDIT: Found one that should be better. What is your answer to this question... http://imgbox.com/a7vshE9u

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @07:49PM (#8468588)
Well there's one interpretation with three answers that doesn't use the info presented, and there's another interpretation with one answer that does use the info presented... 8

So I see your point about figuring out what the examiner wants and I think it makes the question better since you can't blindly run with a first interpretation and ignore half the question.

(Is that a real IQ test? I'm not trying to say it isn't, just that "internet IQ test" is not a trustworthy phrase.)

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:02PM (#8468857)
I'm glad we found something we can agree on (the 'figuring out what the examiner wants' point).

The question was from an Internet IQ Test, no idea if it's ever been used elsewhere, I understand it's not necessarily the most reliable source.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by reitanqild on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:48PM (#8467192)
To be honest it now seems you are arrogant on top of your ignorance.

Two people try to explain to you and you go on talking without reading.

Regarding reading comprehension: what part of eitlands explanation that you are often free to take iq tests multiple times didn't you understand? And so on.

And, regarding your example: if you are going to be arrogant, make sure you are right.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:00PM (#8467264)
"Regarding reading comprehension: what part of eitlands explanation that you are often free to take iq tests multiple times didn't you understand? And so on."

I was tired of having to explain why assigning a number to intelligence made little sense, so yes I was a little rude. Besides, I addressed eitlands' assertion that certain numbers are beyond reach, just like any formal test you can train people to become good at taking the test.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by reitanqild on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:11PM (#8467356)
> I was tired of having to explain why assigning a number to intelligence made little sense

So stop explaing it. Assigning a number to intelligence makes a lot of sense.

As have been pointed out 1.) it seems those measurements can be reproduced with statistical significance so they measure something and 2.) whatever it measures it seems to be one of the best indicators we have of future job performance.

What they don't tell us is what a person is worth, if he is a good person etc.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:26PM (#8467442)
"So stop explaing it."

Okay, I'll let someone else do it then...

"those measurements can be reproduced with statistical significance"

http://m.psychologytoday.com/blog/beautiful-minds/200910/int...

"How much can these scores change over a person's lifetime, and how limiting are a person's scores for obtaining what they want out of life?

For groups of individuals, IQs are fairly stable between childhood and adulthood, but for specific individuals within a group, IQs can--and do--vary greatly over a lifetime. The IQs will vary as a result of specific interventions (such as preschool enrichment programs), quality education (or the lack of it), injuries that affect brain functioning, and other aspects of the environment that either enhance or diminish one's cognitive ability. In addition, errors of measurement are much larger than people tend to think, and, therefore, an individual's IQs will vary from time to time--sometimes substantially--simply due to the chance fluctuations that accompany any repeated measurement. And, there is more to life success than the ability to score high on IQ tests. People can be successful based on their creativity, street smarts, and personality variables."

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by readerrrr on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:27AM (#8465022)
Breeding is successful in some sense, but certainly not without its issues. For example, by breeding pedigree dogs we've left them with a number of genetic defects that are hard to remove due to the reduced gene pool, e.g. Dalmatian deafness, Bulldog respiration, King Charles Spaniel syringomyelia, etc...

I agree the research would have to be gradual and aware of those issues. I doubt dog breeders really care for those.

Addressing the article, I find the idea of quantifiable intelligence to be one of the dumbest ideas we ever came up with. What does an IQ point mean, really? From my understanding, testing it basically boils down to using a specific subset of symbolic puzzles. Intelligence can be quantified numerically in the same way love can be quantified numerically, i.e. not at all, without losing the essence of what you're looking for.

IQ can be measured, there are many tests that do so. More time you spend checking more accurate you can get. Not infinitely accurately but good enough.

Also, intelligence by itself is not a goal in its own right, it's the purpose to which it's applied that matters. If super intelligent people exist, what would we have them do? The same things we do but faster? No thanks.

That makes little sense. Speed is not a requirement for new research and discovery. Original though is. That is what we should strive for.

Instead of wasting our time trying to group ourselves into categories, we should be looking to bring out the best of the talents we find in the people around us. That seems like a better goal than chasing a 1000 IQ person.

Eugenics could do exactly that.

Re:Super-Intelligent Humans Are Coming by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:30PM (#8465789)
"I agree the research would have to be gradual and aware of those issues. I doubt dog breeders really care for those."

Are you suggesting dog breeders don't care about dogs? From what I've seen they tend to be quite fond of them. The issue is we breed dogs for different traits, with the issues I mentioned before the dogs might've been bred for their looks, but other dogs that were at some point bred for work still have issues... Golden Retrievers are high risk for developing cancer, German Shepherds are high risk for hip dysplasia, Dachshunds are high risk for back problems, etc... It's not that dog breeders want to give dogs issues, it's a byproduct of selective breeding, as defects that do creep in are harder to remove.

"That makes little sense. Speed is not a requirement for new research and discovery. Original though is. That is what we should strive for."

The tests we are talking about do not measure creativity in any meaningful sense.

"Eugenics could do exactly that."

How could eugenics do exactly that? I'm talking about bringing out the talents of people around you, i.e. they already exist.