Honestly, those folks that stand back with their arms crossed watching you fail, and reminding you the whole way that you might fail, are the biggest pains in my ass in this profession. By a mile.
Maybe you can contribute your wisdom by going to Lockheed, instead of Internet commentary in which you bet against them?
In the rest of the engineering world, the answer to any question is: it'll be harder than you think it'll be (physics will beat you over the head at every step). You can cross your arms and say "that won't work" and you'll be correct 97% of the time. Fusion is something that some of the smartest people in the world, with enormous amounts of money behind them, have been beating their heads against for the last half century or more. Somebody will figure it out, eventually, but statistically, any given project is very likely not to be the one that does, and it will almost certainly take much longer than the optimists assume it will take.
Did you know that coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production, are only about twice as efficient today than they were a century ago?
[1] Although math can be a kick in the ass too if you're working in domains where you can prove there are no polynomial-time algorithms for whatever problem you're working on. E.g. there is a reason people have been banging their heads on the garbage collection problem since the 1950's and it's still an active area of research.
There are certainly two ways of looking at that. The way I read your sentence it sounds very pessimistic. On the other hand, I look at that and say that over 100 year's we've managed to extract twice as much usable energy out of a pound of coal, through a variety of incremental improvements to what is fundamentally the same technology; and the world is a better place for it.
Wasn't most of the effort put into making them MUCH MUCH cleaner? I mean, the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuyahoga_River doesn't catch on fire anymore, and the amount of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acid_rain seems pretty tolerable compared to the early 80's
I think both of these things happened, but only one of them is in the interest of a market actor.
it is only until that market actor is allowed to externalize the costs of his pollution
Did you know that wind and solar are already at grid parity in over half the world? And that in many large first-world countries (Germany, Australia) the price of energy goes negative during daylight hours because of the amount of energy produced by renewables?
Similarly, if you're in California and you ever wondered why your electricity bill is 2x that of any other state, it is because you are the ones footing the bill for those subsidies. Without subsidies, wind and solar are far more inefficient at a $/MWH basis.
http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-10-21/when-it-come...
"Meanwhile, a recent report from the U.N. Industrial Development Organization notes that photovoltaic module prices have been falling at a rate of 15 percent to 24 percent a year for some time. In 2011, factory gate prices for crystalline-silicon photovoltaic modules fell below the $1-per-watt mark, often regarded as the point of “grid parity” for solar power. Earlier this year, they reached 85¢.
The “levelized cost of electricity” for solar, a measure of the average price of power over the lifetime of a power project, has fallen from 32¢ per kilowatt hour in 2009 to 17¢ in early 2012. These declining costs are a major factor behind an explosion in use. A report by the Natural Resources Defense Council calculates that from 2006 to 2011, wind, solar, geothermal, tidal, and wave electricity production increased from 1 percent to 2.7 percent of total US production, from 0.1 percent to 1.5 percent in China, and from 5.3 percent to 10.7 percent in Germany. One sunny Saturday in May 2012 saw Germany produce nearly half of its electricity from solar. Given the long life of power plants—often measured in decades—this rate of change is phenomenal. Again, five years ago, total global photovoltaic capacity was just 16 gigawatts. In 2011, the world added nearly twice that—29 gigawatts—of new capacity."
Note this article is from October 2012, two years ago. Renewable installations have skyrocketed, with subsidies far below what oil, gas, and other fossil fuels are provided with.
It is laughable for anyone to suggest that oil, coal or gas energy is subsidised when these numbers are calculated on wooly figures like access to land, or tax deductibility of research - the same rules that apply to all companies, software companies included.
The simple fact is that oil, gas and coal energy generates a magnitude more tax revenue than it ever gets in irritating or indirect subsidies, while the 'renewables' sector only ever takes subsidies and doesn't return net tax. This is plainly obvious based on the per mw/h cost of these technologies - there is no magic formula involved in selling something below average cost of production an making a profit, no matter how much volume you do.
You can't have your cake and eat it too. If you want to bring government subsidies for renewable into the discussion, you also have to consider the externalized cost of legalized pollution. The only defensible calculation is to look at cost per kilowatt hour excluding government subsidies and including externalized costs. That's the true economic cost of the energy source.
And coal is miserable on that front. I wouldn't be surprised if coal use is a net loss to the economy (i.e. the value of the energy generated by coal is less than the environmental cost of coal use).
That doesn't make any sense. Net loss to the economy? If you were to say a net loss overall, including environmental costs, I might agree.
The problem is that we don't measure economic activity accurately, because we ignore draw-down of capital (human, natural, or otherwise). Fukushima actually increased Japan's GDP for a quarter, because the damage-response activity gets counted in GDP while the loss of physical capital does not. Fossil fuel use suffers from this problem in two ways: 1) the value of the capital removed from the ground isn't counted (i.e. nobody counts selling off their family furniture as net positive income, but resource-rich countries count selling off oil or minerals as such); 2) the loss of human and environmental capital is ignored (strip mining mountains causes rain to wash away river banks, and that's money directly out of someone's pocket).
Coal is an energy dense naturally occurring product. The environmental damage from coal relates to mining, shipping and burning it. The environmental benefits of coal are that extraction, transport and burning doesn't happen to other things - ie, biomass, otherwise known as timber.
England has more forest now than it has for centuries, because a more energy dense substitute for energy was extracted (coal). In many developing countries, access to coal would be a net benefit, because it would reduce clearing and burning of vegetation, and because the ensuing affordable energy allows for more intensive food production, and the keeping of food inventories, further lessening the pressure on the environment.
Of course, everything that applies to coal also applies to natural gas even more so, and obviously to fusion even more than that. But this meme of 'coal is evil and must be stopped' ignores the reality of the situation and completely ignores the benefits of efficient energy production, especially in the case where real, persistent and preventable environmental damage is taking place because there is a lack of efficient energy productin.
http://cleantechnica.com/2014/07/05/queensland-solar-negativ...
Lockheed Skunk Works, on the other hand, is not.
They've been pushing the frontiers of engineering in areas that are very much constrained by physics since 1943, and succeeding. Many times.
For instance, the same argument applies to a wafer stepper or 'dreadnought class' surface mining equipment. Yet it seems unlikely they are able to commercially compete on both of those extremely different specialized kinds of machines. And I wonder if a fusion reactor would be any different.
They too are a product of applying new discoveries and then engineering around the constraints of physics.
Things change. Progress is made.
Software professionals recognize the constraints on development imposed by entropy, information theory, and other esoteric branches of mathematics.
Rather than scoff at this article because Lockheed is making extraordinary claims without the backing of extraordinary evidence, I prefer to scoff because nuclear physics modeling and simulation software is still software. If I cross my arms and say "that has a critical undiscovered bug in it that invalidates the results," I'd be correct 97% of the time. It also has a SQL injection vulnerability, links to at least one library written 30 years ago, and was originally written by a physicist that knew a little programming rather than a programmer that knew a little physics.
Conservation laws are the book-keeping of physics, and they act as global checks on correctness. If your code conserves energy, mass, particle number, charge, momentum, etc it is probably correct in the ways that matter, because it's incredibly hard to get bugs that get the physics wrong in materially interesting ways while still obeying conservation laws.
I once wrote a rarefied gas dynamics simulator (modelling a few thousand interacting particles--I was curious about some non-equilibrium thermodynamics questions) that conserved energy to +/-1 bit in double-precision (and which exercised the weird feature of some x86 processors that had something like 80-bit internal registers but did 64 bit double precision computations, and which allowed the garbage in the extra bits to contaminate the LSB, resulting in very slightly different behaviour in debug and release mode, which gave me fits for weeks.) It is just incredibly hard to get that level of conservation and still get the physics wrong.
And then there's semi-analytic solutions: to check that gas dynamics code I wrote a super-simple analog of the system in Perl based on approximate equations of motion, and got the same results. Because the underlying physics admits of different computational representations that are guaranteed to be the same if they are both correct and extremely unlikely to suffer from the same bugs you can have a very high degree of confidence in their correctness.
So no: the results of simulation are not wrong 97% of the time. I've worked on one experiment where the modelling was wrong, and which took three different computational approaches to sort out, but it's a rarity.
My feeling, based on experience, is these guys are onto something very interesting.
As a software professional, I have been explicitly instructed to alter a program solely for the purpose of making the output more palatable for customers and investors, at the expense of real-world accuracy. And I did it, because as much as I dislike dishonesty, I also hate searching for new jobs and thoroughly enjoy sleeping under a roof and not starving.
Did the simulation that you wrote have a check for conservation of professional ethics?
You have a great advantage in that subatomic particles are unable to lie to you. Software developers have a capacity for deception exceeding even that of accountants, and we are sometimes asked to use it in unethical ways. One might think that there are reasonable limits, but we still have electronic voting machines that are mysteriously unauditable, and software trading agents programmed to automatically front-run institutional investors.
While the 97% figure was simply made up to mirror the ancestor post, it is possible that all those programs that are not accidentally wrong are intentionally wrong. In your case, you can rule out ill intent for the software you wrote yourself, but as there are potentially hundreds of millions of dollars in funding at stake for this fusion "discovery", I would not discount it for any simulation that suggests this device will work.
FWIW, this is a compiler error. Most x86 processors have 80-bit extended floats, which allow 64-bit "pow" to be computed in software with low error (among other benefits). Some compilers "helpfully" compile for 80-bit mode with some combinations of compile options. They should never do this unless it's specifically asked for using a single command-line option, partly for the reason you discovered: it totally messes with replicability. It also messes with implementations of "log1p", Kahan summation, and other high-precision algorithms like double-double arithmetic.
If you ever come across this again, submit a bug report.
This is no longer the case.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_power_in_the_United_States
Among people who have a common mindset, yes. But in general people don't like to take risks or expend insane efforts to make something happen. When they see others doing it, they like to stop them. Generally its because they don't want the regret 'They tried and got it, If I had ...' Or they are plainly jealous and can't stand some one else do progress.
Even pg discussed the phenomenon, as you undoubtedly know. There's a good idea, or a news article hailing progress, or some other kind of optimism, then the first comment is a mid-brow dismissal. They are the lowest-effort comments to make; "that won't work because X isn't well-respected and Y often happens to similar teams" requires almost no research and cannot really be refuted.
The only way to refute it is by calling a spade a spade, and look what I get for doing so: having my comment twisted to be fuzzy feel-good smarm crap, when really I'm just saying "shut up and get out of the way if you don't think it'll work."
As for "shut up and get out of the way"--whose way exactly? Unless you're a nuclear physicist, comments expressing hopeful optimism aren't very useful.
Right now, this entire story is just a waste of space on a hard drive somewhere in Palo Alto, and no comments pro or con are going to change that.
Also someone on reddit made an interesting observation about job openings at Lockheed: http://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/2jbgcf/lockheed_...
What I said, reworded, was the people who sit on the sidelines of anything and tell you, while you are trying something, that it won't work are among the worst people in the profession. I didn't say believe harder. I don't give a damn what you believe and don't need you reminding me, constantly, that my project has a chance of failure. Keep it to yourself or get on board. That's my point.
I am not a kind person, so that you'd ascribe feel-good nonsense to me is downright hilarious. I can handle it but a lot of people can't, and it's really, really tiring to keep a team from becoming demoralized when there's a naysayer popcorn gallery in every thread and watercooler discussion.
You know what demoralizes a team like nothing else? And endless litany of projects that failed because nobody wanted to listen to the people pointing out problems.
When people on the team think they are pointing out problems, but are doing so without support, by simply saying "That won't work" instead of "That won't work because of ...".
This does nothing to further a project and leaves the burden of proof for a working solution on the person who proposed the solution in the first place, and the way for them to prove their solution is to continue working on it, with no actionable feedback to revise their project on.
It's turtles all the way down. Guess we should just give up on Internet commenting. /s
That's a good way to lose your comment-voting privileges - I just noticed my ability to vote on comments disappeared at some point.
Dropbox is a prime example of this effect: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
I hope they have some novel ideas about neutron containment, though, otherwise you're right and this is project is not likely to yield the first economical fusion reactor.
obviously. The proposed reactor looks exactly like a great PhD thesis with honors - a novel field configuration proposed which allows to reach beta of one. The rest of the whole system is given only cursory treatment. In particular how about a "neutron absorbing blanket" in a business-jet size envelope?
Shielding was mentioned, though not enough, but it's fairly trivial: if you add enough matter with a high neutron cross section (paraffin for example), and build the mechanical components out of things with a low cross section (iron, I think) it's not a problem. Plasma is the problem.
It's interesting, but "10 years off" is not much better than the standard "20 years off" promises of fusion research. As others have pointed out, controlled fusion has been 20 years in the future since 1950 or so. "1 year off" would be a lot more noteworthy. As it stands, this is just Lockheed informing us they have a controlled fusion program. Anyway, "nice press release, dudes."
So are refrigerators.
Plausible, since he had the experience.
The challenges of fusion power are largely fundamental nitty gritty engineering issues. We know fairly well how to design most of a fusion reactor; in a lot of ways they are conceptually easier than fission reactors.
The two main hurdles are the materials problems and how to keep the reaction critical with radiative heat loss. These are big problems that so many times have been ignored by people claiming to have solved fusion power. You just can't get away from them, but solving them would be truly revolutionary.
I'm not saying they don't have something novel here as they really are some fine researchers at Skunkworks. Just temper your expectations.
I'm not saying they've done it and extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof but this is the place that made a Mach 3.5 jet with wings that leaked out of titanium in the 60's.
Nitty-gritty engineering is something they are fairly good at.
Time sell any oil company stocks, mutual fund holding?
Two points made reply to you are correct: neutrons are radiation, but not electromagnetic radiation; and neutrons can make other things radioactive.
Some thing other people are saying are less correct: any individual neutron will deposit most of its energy in one place, but averaging over many neutrons their energy deposition will be spread out. Furthermore, neutrons will come out in all directions. The problem of neutron damage is not small, but no one seriously believes it's a show-stopper.
Neutrons are the exploding billiard-balls of nuclear physics. Fusion produces "fast" neutrons, with moderate energies. This is a deuterium-deuterium device, so most of the neutrons will come out with 2.4 MeV, which happens to be the same as fission neutrons. The DD reaction produces tritium as a byproduct about half the time, though, and DT fusion will lead to 14 MeV neutrons. There will be fewer of these in most designs, and some designs incorporate ideas to get rid of the tritium quickly to suppress these higher energy neutrons.
At high energies neutrons don't tend to interact very much with light nuclei, and for a variety of reasons fusion reactor design is dominated by light nuclei. What they do do is bounce off, which is where the billiard-ball analogy comes in. Each time a neutron bounces off another nucleus it loses energy (because the nucleus it bounces off of recoils, carrying some energy with it.) This is just pure Newtonian mechanics.
Neutrons typically travel a few metres in the process of slowing down, depending on the material. Light materials slow them down faster: a light ball bouncing off a heavy ball doesn't loss much energy, but bouncing off another light ball it does (hydrogen is the best material for slowing neutrons down because of this, and hydrogen-rich materials like water are good too.)
The neutron never completely stops because the nuclei it is bouncing off of are in thermal motion. At room temperature a neutron in thermal equilibrium moves at about 2200 m/s. But not for very long, because this is where the exploding comes in.
You can think of it in these terms: once thermalized, a neutron is passing by other nuclei rather slowly (2200 m/s is slow when you're a neutron). This gives it lots of time to react with nuclei, rather than just bouncing off, and eventually it does. When a nucleus absorbs a neutron it becomes a different isotope of the same element, and in many cases adding a neutron to a stable isotope makes it radioactive. Carbon-12 is a stable isotope that, with the addition of a neutron becomes carbon-13, and if it happens to get another neutron added later on, radioactive carbon-14.
Neutrons are a pain, even to fission engineers, and fission depends absolutely on them to happen. They get everywhere, are hard to shield, make stuff radioactive and damage materials. But we know pretty much how to deal with them, and it's unlikely they will make the difference between working and not working in a device like this.
Putting a mice next to this system can make it a "carbon-14" mice? Can it glow in the dark? :-)
Fusion neutron (14 MeV) from fusion reactor is exactly as energetic as fusion neutron emitted by a neutron bomb and causes equal damage (just distributed over longer time). They have 10x as much energy as fission neutrons and travel at speed of 52,000 km/s (17.3% of the speed of light). Neutron capture before they hit and damage magnets, electronics or wear out materials is important part of the fusion reactor design.
Neutrons are interesting in that they dump all their energy into a very small region. Instead of losing energy continually and gradually, they travel a ways and then dump all their energy into one spot. This makes them potentially very useful for things like cancer treatment (you can select neutrons to ensure they deliver most of their energy into the cancer, rather than evenly along their travel path). I suspect this effect means that, for reactors, the wear and tear is more localized, but of a larger amplitude.
Not exactly. The initial collisions do indeed cause localised damage cascades, but the overall effect of a large neutron flux is embrittlement of the material. This is a problem already in fission reactor vessels, but the neutron fluxes are a whole order of magnitude larger in fusion reactors, and it's a very difficult problem to solve. To my knowledge, current materials can only just about deal with with the neutron fluxes in standard fission reactors, with no current materials being capable of withstanding neutron fluxes in a fusion reactor over any long (i.e. commercial) timescale at present. It would be a big achievement and a big jump in materials science to discover such a material, completely separate of any fusion project.
(Disclaimer: this is not remotely my field, but I have looked at some of this stuff in the past, and been to talks about ITER.)
Frankly, the best neutron shielding in the world, on a per-cost basis, is water with borax. I don't know why people don't use this more. We used to use stacked bags of borax as neutron shielding when I built a fusion reactor (non-self sustaining, of course), and we had more than enough shielding to handle 2.45 MeV neutrons for under $1000.
A cool thing about the shield being liquid is that you could theoretically replace it while it's running. It could make the neuron shield double as the heat transfer medium too.
Of course I'm a total layman so this is just highlevel blabbering.
Neutrons slow down via interaction with nuclei (all of which except hydrogen are heavier) so they lose energy slowly and scatter all over the place. They have no definite range (search for "fermi age theory" to get a rough idea of the distribution) and can't be meaningfully beamed (unless they are ultra-cold, which is not relevant to fusion power.)
I've made a longer comment above that goes into neutron physics in a little more detail.
Neutrons are radiation. Also It's the worst kind of radiation because unlike X-rays or Gamma, neutrons make other things radioactive.
Source for this claim: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_activation
Neutrons are radiation, but not electromagnetic radiation. I'm guessing that nitpicking this is why you were downvoted? Dunno.
Actually even if you believed there's a chance this Lockheed concept can work, the time to buy airline stocks would be on the back end of this dead bull market that's about to fall off a cliff. And then there's the 20 year wait before it's finally deployed to a commercial airplane.
True?
I wanted my Ph.D. in mathematical physics, but all the physics courses I could find did the math in very sloppy ways, and my hope for any research progress in physics wanted to do the math with full care. I did get much of that math, but by then I was occupied with my money making work and didn't get back to physics. I'd like to, maybe, someday! Then maybe I'll be able to give you a solid answer.
For now, some of the discussions claim that a lot of neutrons will make a metal brittle but don't go the next step and explain just why. Before I'd say anything about what neutrons do, if only as a check on the level of understanding, I'd want to know why.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner_effect
Whatever production process partially relies on arranging the crystal structure of the metal to arrive at desirable properties, the neutrons disrupt it.
(if it doesn't follow why that would matter, look into the heat treatment of steel)
"As Tom McGuire, who is leading the Lockheed team, notes, however, the circular magnetic fields which coil around a tokamak’s doughnut become unstable if the plasma’s pressure is too high."
The new system: Find a war torn area (perhaps one decimated by oil wars), dismantle their army and replace it with a wildly incompetent one. Make an earnest but fruitless attempt to train them (how humanitarian!). Give them American weapons (cha-ching) without actually solving any of the issues that were destabilizing the region. Local strive escalates to war, the incompetent army is crushed and their American weapons are seized. Use American owned and operated weapons (cha-ching) to bomb the seized American weapons back into the stone age (how humanitarian!). Rinse and repeat.
War machine get's their money, and the politicians get to pretend that they are only trying to help others.
Exactly! Just repeat keep repeating that process!
McGuire is a top physicist - he is currently working on a compact fusion reactor at Skunk Works, which came out with the SR-71 Blackbird among other innovations.
Oh, did you mean, ones who had already succeeded in their top projects? Well, how do you think they got to succeed - by not doing it?
Problem with fusion research like this is that the closer you get self sustainment or energy generation, the harder it gets and problems pile up. This project looks like many other similar projects that have gone bust. They start by solving the easiest problems first, get some funding and hit the wall.
The main problem with any reactor design is how to handle the 14 MeV neutrons produced by the fusion reaction (no mention in the article). They tend to damage the reactor and make it economically unfeasible. At this point being able to create fusion reaction is not the main challenge. It's the sustainment and economics of limiting the damage. If they really have solved all the problems and demonstrate economically sound fusion in 5-10 years, they will be handed Nobel price in physics for sure.