News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:47PM (#8460803)
That's hardly ever true. In my experience, Hacker News is full of people from the software field; folks whose professions are often unconstrained by physics,[1] and who have a generally optimistic "this can happen" mentality. That's why everyone here believes we'll have fully self-driving cars in 5-6 years.

In the rest of the engineering world, the answer to any question is: it'll be harder than you think it'll be (physics will beat you over the head at every step). You can cross your arms and say "that won't work" and you'll be correct 97% of the time. Fusion is something that some of the smartest people in the world, with enormous amounts of money behind them, have been beating their heads against for the last half century or more. Somebody will figure it out, eventually, but statistically, any given project is very likely not to be the one that does, and it will almost certainly take much longer than the optimists assume it will take.

Did you know that coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production, are only about twice as efficient today than they were a century ago?

[1] Although math can be a kick in the ass too if you're working in domains where you can prove there are no polynomial-time algorithms for whatever problem you're working on. E.g. there is a reason people have been banging their heads on the garbage collection problem since the 1950's and it's still an active area of research.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by cpwright on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:54PM (#8460854)
> Did you know that coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production, are only about twice as efficient today than they were a century ago?

There are certainly two ways of looking at that. The way I read your sentence it sounds very pessimistic. On the other hand, I look at that and say that over 100 year's we've managed to extract twice as much usable energy out of a pound of coal, through a variety of incremental improvements to what is fundamentally the same technology; and the world is a better place for it.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by jfoutz on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:00PM (#8460891)
> Did you know that coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production, are only about twice as efficient today than they were a century ago?

Wasn't most of the effort put into making them MUCH MUCH cleaner? I mean, the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuyahoga_River doesn't catch on fire anymore, and the amount of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acid_rain seems pretty tolerable compared to the early 80's

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by revelation on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:52PM (#8461635)
If you can make a coal plant twice as efficient, you can generate X amount of electricity for half the cost. Adding filters meanwhile just adds cost.

I think both of these things happened, but only one of them is in the interest of a market actor.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by trhway on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @05:20PM (#8461837)
>but only one of them is in the interest of a market actor.

it is only until that market actor is allowed to externalize the costs of his pollution

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Cthulhu_ on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:04AM (#8464035)
Given how there's a huge trade going on in CO2 emission rights (at least in Europe), that's already a thing. Less CO2 emissions (catching them, filtering, etc) means they can sell off their CO2 emission rights to other companies. (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_emission_trading )
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:13PM (#8461003)
> Did you know that coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production, are only about twice as efficient today than they were a century ago?

Did you know that wind and solar are already at grid parity in over half the world? And that in many large first-world countries (Germany, Australia) the price of energy goes negative during daylight hours because of the amount of energy produced by renewables?

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by petercoolz on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @07:32PM (#8462452)
To be clear, the price of energy goes negative because of government subsidies. For example, a wind plant with a $30/MWH subsidy can afford to run at a price of -$30.

Similarly, if you're in California and you ever wondered why your electricity bill is 2x that of any other state, it is because you are the ones footing the bill for those subsidies. Without subsidies, wind and solar are far more inefficient at a $/MWH basis.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @07:45PM (#8462498)
Oil, coal, and gas is subsidized to the tune of ~$400 billion a year (2010 numbers), while renewables are around ~$60 billion a year. Renewables have a capital cost, but no fuel cost.

http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-10-21/when-it-come...

"Meanwhile, a recent report from the U.N. Industrial Development Organization notes that photovoltaic module prices have been falling at a rate of 15 percent to 24 percent a year for some time. In 2011, factory gate prices for crystalline-silicon photovoltaic modules fell below the $1-per-watt mark, often regarded as the point of “grid parity” for solar power. Earlier this year, they reached 85¢.

The “levelized cost of electricity” for solar, a measure of the average price of power over the lifetime of a power project, has fallen from 32¢ per kilowatt hour in 2009 to 17¢ in early 2012. These declining costs are a major factor behind an explosion in use. A report by the Natural Resources Defense Council calculates that from 2006 to 2011, wind, solar, geothermal, tidal, and wave electricity production increased from 1 percent to 2.7 percent of total US production, from 0.1 percent to 1.5 percent in China, and from 5.3 percent to 10.7 percent in Germany. One sunny Saturday in May 2012 saw Germany produce nearly half of its electricity from solar. Given the long life of power plants—often measured in decades—this rate of change is phenomenal. Again, five years ago, total global photovoltaic capacity was just 16 gigawatts. In 2011, the world added nearly twice that—29 gigawatts—of new capacity."

Note this article is from October 2012, two years ago. Renewable installations have skyrocketed, with subsidies far below what oil, gas, and other fossil fuels are provided with.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by brc on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @08:18PM (#8462605)
Those oil, has and coal subsidy numbers are completely bogus if they are generated from the iea numbers. Iea is just a solar/wind lobbying front - and the bulk of the numbers are made from countries like Saudi Arabia and Iran directly subsidising the cost of petrol for their citizens.

It is laughable for anyone to suggest that oil, coal or gas energy is subsidised when these numbers are calculated on wooly figures like access to land, or tax deductibility of research - the same rules that apply to all companies, software companies included.

The simple fact is that oil, gas and coal energy generates a magnitude more tax revenue than it ever gets in irritating or indirect subsidies, while the 'renewables' sector only ever takes subsidies and doesn't return net tax. This is plainly obvious based on the per mw/h cost of these technologies - there is no magic formula involved in selling something below average cost of production an making a profit, no matter how much volume you do.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @08:47PM (#8462691)
A Harvard study a few years ago found the externalized cost of coal to be about $350 billion per year in the U.S. alone: http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/16/usa-coal-study-idU....

You can't have your cake and eat it too. If you want to bring government subsidies for renewable into the discussion, you also have to consider the externalized cost of legalized pollution. The only defensible calculation is to look at cost per kilowatt hour excluding government subsidies and including externalized costs. That's the true economic cost of the energy source.

And coal is miserable on that front. I wouldn't be surprised if coal use is a net loss to the economy (i.e. the value of the energy generated by coal is less than the environmental cost of coal use).

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by refurb on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @09:35PM (#8462833)
I wouldn't be surprised if coal use is a net loss to the economy (i.e. the value of the energy generated by coal is less than the environmental cost of coal use)

That doesn't make any sense. Net loss to the economy? If you were to say a net loss overall, including environmental costs, I might agree.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @09:59PM (#8462896)
Environmental costs are part of the economy. The cost of solar includes paying highly-skilled workers to build the panels. The cost of coal includes paying doctors to treat the resulting increase in lung disease, etc.

The problem is that we don't measure economic activity accurately, because we ignore draw-down of capital (human, natural, or otherwise). Fukushima actually increased Japan's GDP for a quarter, because the damage-response activity gets counted in GDP while the loss of physical capital does not. Fossil fuel use suffers from this problem in two ways: 1) the value of the capital removed from the ground isn't counted (i.e. nobody counts selling off their family furniture as net positive income, but resource-rich countries count selling off oil or minerals as such); 2) the loss of human and environmental capital is ignored (strip mining mountains causes rain to wash away river banks, and that's money directly out of someone's pocket).

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by brc on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:21PM (#8468702)
Even then, it's not a net loss to the environment.

Coal is an energy dense naturally occurring product. The environmental damage from coal relates to mining, shipping and burning it. The environmental benefits of coal are that extraction, transport and burning doesn't happen to other things - ie, biomass, otherwise known as timber.

England has more forest now than it has for centuries, because a more energy dense substitute for energy was extracted (coal). In many developing countries, access to coal would be a net benefit, because it would reduce clearing and burning of vegetation, and because the ensuing affordable energy allows for more intensive food production, and the keeping of food inventories, further lessening the pressure on the environment.

Of course, everything that applies to coal also applies to natural gas even more so, and obviously to fusion even more than that. But this meme of 'coal is evil and must be stopped' ignores the reality of the situation and completely ignores the benefits of efficient energy production, especially in the case where real, persistent and preventable environmental damage is taking place because there is a lack of efficient energy productin.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by JanezStupar on Thursday October 16, 2014 @01:08PM (#8466020)
So are you implying that we would be better off long term if we just shut down coal plants immediately?
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @07:41PM (#8462477)
Being able to externalize pollution is a subsidy. Accounting for externalized costs, coal is about parity with wind in terms of cost, though gas is ahead of both.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @08:14PM (#8462593)
Agreed, but with the price of oil headed below $80/barrel, shale and other fracking operations that are expensive to operate are now going to operate at a loss (causing some producers to go bankrupt). You're going to see the cost of natgas dip down, and if enough producers go out of business, jump back up to new highs as production will have dropped quite a bit.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by kbart on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:22AM (#8470549)
Yes, there was an article about that few days ago: http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/oct/13/wind-powe...
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by thret on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @06:16PM (#8462134)
You make that sound like it is a daily phenomenon. It has happened infrequently (in Australia).

http://cleantechnica.com/2014/07/05/queensland-solar-negativ...

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:10PM (#8463154)
"Hacker News is full of people from the software field; folks whose professions are often unconstrained by physics"

Lockheed Skunk Works, on the other hand, is not.

They've been pushing the frontiers of engineering in areas that are very much constrained by physics since 1943, and succeeding. Many times.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Confusion on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:12AM (#8463895)
What have they successfully designed that was not an airplane?
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Cthulhu_ on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:07AM (#8464046)
An experimental stealth ship, apparently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Shadow_(IX-529)
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by crazypyro on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:25AM (#8465005)
You realize an airplane is just an insanely complex collection of highly specialized and engineered systems? Just because they specialize in airplanes doesn't mean that the problems they have faced, solved and are still facing today are not relevant to thousands of other engineering problems.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Confusion on Thursday October 16, 2014 @11:18AM (#8465358)
Sure. The question remains how many of those systems and solutions are relevant to designing a fusion reactor. I think it's easy to overestimate the relevance from a helicopter point of view.

For instance, the same argument applies to a wafer stepper or 'dreadnought class' surface mining equipment. Yet it seems unlikely they are able to commercially compete on both of those extremely different specialized kinds of machines. And I wonder if a fusion reactor would be any different.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by waterlesscloud on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:05PM (#8460941)
Did you know computer chips are infinitely more efficient than they were a century ago?

They too are a product of applying new discoveries and then engineering around the constraints of physics.

Things change. Progress is made.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:21PM (#8461065)
Sure, but in any given field, the low-hanging fruit gets eaten quickly.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by logfromblammo on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:09PM (#8461381)
Physicists recognize the constraints on development imposed by the laws of physics.

Software professionals recognize the constraints on development imposed by entropy, information theory, and other esoteric branches of mathematics.

Rather than scoff at this article because Lockheed is making extraordinary claims without the backing of extraordinary evidence, I prefer to scoff because nuclear physics modeling and simulation software is still software. If I cross my arms and say "that has a critical undiscovered bug in it that invalidates the results," I'd be correct 97% of the time. It also has a SQL injection vulnerability, links to at least one library written 30 years ago, and was originally written by a physicist that knew a little programming rather than a programmer that knew a little physics.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by tjradcliffe on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:03AM (#8463306)
Simulations are way easier to write than almost anything else (I'm a nuclear physicist who did this professionally for many years.) The reason why: physics. Or more specifically: conservation laws.

Conservation laws are the book-keeping of physics, and they act as global checks on correctness. If your code conserves energy, mass, particle number, charge, momentum, etc it is probably correct in the ways that matter, because it's incredibly hard to get bugs that get the physics wrong in materially interesting ways while still obeying conservation laws.

I once wrote a rarefied gas dynamics simulator (modelling a few thousand interacting particles--I was curious about some non-equilibrium thermodynamics questions) that conserved energy to +/-1 bit in double-precision (and which exercised the weird feature of some x86 processors that had something like 80-bit internal registers but did 64 bit double precision computations, and which allowed the garbage in the extra bits to contaminate the LSB, resulting in very slightly different behaviour in debug and release mode, which gave me fits for weeks.) It is just incredibly hard to get that level of conservation and still get the physics wrong.

And then there's semi-analytic solutions: to check that gas dynamics code I wrote a super-simple analog of the system in Perl based on approximate equations of motion, and got the same results. Because the underlying physics admits of different computational representations that are guaranteed to be the same if they are both correct and extremely unlikely to suffer from the same bugs you can have a very high degree of confidence in their correctness.

So no: the results of simulation are not wrong 97% of the time. I've worked on one experiment where the modelling was wrong, and which took three different computational approaches to sort out, but it's a rarity.

My feeling, based on experience, is these guys are onto something very interesting.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by logfromblammo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:53AM (#8465198)
You are simply skeptical for different reasons than I have.

As a software professional, I have been explicitly instructed to alter a program solely for the purpose of making the output more palatable for customers and investors, at the expense of real-world accuracy. And I did it, because as much as I dislike dishonesty, I also hate searching for new jobs and thoroughly enjoy sleeping under a roof and not starving.

Did the simulation that you wrote have a check for conservation of professional ethics?

You have a great advantage in that subatomic particles are unable to lie to you. Software developers have a capacity for deception exceeding even that of accountants, and we are sometimes asked to use it in unethical ways. One might think that there are reasonable limits, but we still have electronic voting machines that are mysteriously unauditable, and software trading agents programmed to automatically front-run institutional investors.

While the 97% figure was simply made up to mirror the ancestor post, it is possible that all those programs that are not accidentally wrong are intentionally wrong. In your case, you can rule out ill intent for the software you wrote yourself, but as there are potentially hundreds of millions of dollars in funding at stake for this fusion "discovery", I would not discount it for any simulation that suggests this device will work.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by ntoronto on Thursday October 16, 2014 @07:34AM (#8464376)
...and which exercised the weird feature of some x86 processors that had something like 80-bit internal registers but did 64 bit double precision computations, and which allowed the garbage in the extra bits to contaminate the LSB, resulting in very slightly different behaviour in debug and release mode, which gave me fits for weeks...

FWIW, this is a compiler error. Most x86 processors have 80-bit extended floats, which allow 64-bit "pow" to be computed in software with low error (among other benefits). Some compilers "helpfully" compile for 80-bit mode with some combinations of compile options. They should never do this unless it's specifically asked for using a single command-line option, partly for the reason you discovered: it totally messes with replicability. It also messes with implementations of "log1p", Kahan summation, and other high-precision algorithms like double-double arithmetic.

If you ever come across this again, submit a bug report.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by mng2 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @02:23AM (#8463640)
The question is, what did they simulate and how? A full-on dynamical plasma simulation of the entire machine is intractable, and every approximation technique has its blind spots.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by robotresearcher on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @05:06PM (#8461748)
And yet engineers, including nuclear engineers, very often build stuff that works despite imperfect software.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by seanflyon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @05:34PM (#8461930)
> coal plants, which still make up the majority of U.S. energy production

This is no longer the case.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_power_in_the_United_States

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @10:50PM (#8463079)
electricity generation is only a small part of energy consumption.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by seanflyon on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:23AM (#8463784)
Are other sectors of energy consumption coal intensive?
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by brohee on Thursday October 16, 2014 @08:25AM (#8464508)
Steel mills and cement factories for a start.
Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by kamaal on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:24AM (#8463347)
>>"this can happen"

Among people who have a common mindset, yes. But in general people don't like to take risks or expend insane efforts to make something happen. When they see others doing it, they like to stop them. Generally its because they don't want the regret 'They tried and got it, If I had ...' Or they are plainly jealous and can't stand some one else do progress.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:45PM (#8461224)
> That's hardly ever true.

Even pg discussed the phenomenon, as you undoubtedly know. There's a good idea, or a news article hailing progress, or some other kind of optimism, then the first comment is a mid-brow dismissal. They are the lowest-effort comments to make; "that won't work because X isn't well-respected and Y often happens to similar teams" requires almost no research and cannot really be refuted.

The only way to refute it is by calling a spade a spade, and look what I get for doing so: having my comment twisted to be fuzzy feel-good smarm crap, when really I'm just saying "shut up and get out of the way if you don't think it'll work."

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by rayiner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:08PM (#8461376)
I don't think of such comments as being "mid-brow" dismissals. Indeed, the people most knowledgable about the field are the ones who are most likely to tell you it won't work. And 97% of the time they'll be right.

As for "shut up and get out of the way"--whose way exactly? Unless you're a nuclear physicist, comments expressing hopeful optimism aren't very useful.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by CamperBob2 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:14PM (#8461429)
The only solution is one that can't be applied here: LockMart shouldn't make extraordinary claims ("Check out this cool fusion reactor!") until they have extraordinary proof to go with them.

Right now, this entire story is just a waste of space on a hard drive somewhere in Palo Alto, and no comments pro or con are going to change that.

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by Anjin on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @06:47PM (#8462279)
I don't know about that. What you are suggesting doesn't really fit the MO of Skunkworks where they work on advanced projects for years before revealing them. It's not like they announced stealth aircraft in the 90s just to drive up their stock price, they'd been working on it for nearly 4o years by that point and the planes were flying missions for decades.

Also someone on reddit made an interesting observation about job openings at Lockheed: http://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/2jbgcf/lockheed_...

Re:Skunk Works Reveals Compact Fusion Reactor Details by CamperBob2 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @02:13PM (#8466369)
With a fusion reactor, the only proof that's adequate would be a press conference at a facility where there's a large object under a tarp and a big red button to push. By itself, a press release on the subject just doesn't convey any actionable information, no matter what it says or who it comes from.