News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by mturmon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:39AM (#8458978)
Her video series, which you can see on YouTube, is actually quite good and well-researched. You might disagree with her conclusions (I agree with them) but even if you disagree, you have to admit she's done a lot of legwork.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Argorak on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:42AM (#8458996)
Even if they were poor or badly researched, death threats are just way out of scope. Like: NEVER, EVER, IN ANY INTERACTION ARE THEY OKAY, NO POINT TO ARGUE. They are also no joke.

(sorry for using all caps for once) (I take explanations for downvotes)

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Houshalter on Thursday October 16, 2014 @01:16AM (#8463489)
Saying that death threats are bad is not something anyone disagrees with, as far as I know. It's just an applause light (http://lesswrong.com/lw/jb/applause_lights/) at best.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Argorak on Friday October 17, 2014 @10:57AM (#8471259)
This very page has people arguing that death threats are par for the course on the internet and should be ignored as well as others trying to contextualize them.

There is a reason why I wrote this sentence on this very page.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Houshalter on Friday October 17, 2014 @05:09PM (#8473390)
You said that making death threats was bad, which everyone agrees on. Some people disagree that they are as significant as made out to be. Almost all controversial figures get death threats. Obama gets 30 a day, about 40,000 in total. Yet assassinations and mass shootings are extremely rare.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Argorak on Saturday October 18, 2014 @02:58AM (#8474821)
No. I said that they are never okay and no joke, which people disagree with (including you, just now, you argue that they are ignorable). Don't rephrase or interpret.

Yes, Obama gets 30 per day. What a sad world we live in, in which people are okay with that. Also, Obama can pay for bodyguards.

The goal of a death threat is not necessarily the killing, but insecurity and psychological effect.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by caligulatte on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:50AM (#8459055)
The 'Women as Background Part 2' video was very well-made, and utterly disturbing. I've seen terrible videos and images - it is the Internet afterall- but it was painful to watch. There's a number of games on there that I no longer care to revisit, or even play for the first time.

(Also, what were the makers of God of War 3 thinking? Staggers the mind.)

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by sebular on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:46PM (#8460275)
Your comment provoked me to go and watch that video, and watching it clarified this whole issue for me. As someone who's done a reasonable amount of undergraduate-level film and literature analysis, I felt that the video fell quite nicely in line with that style of presentation, and it's clear that Ms. Sarkeesian has a strong background in that area. If this were for an assignment, she would've gotten a perfect score.

However, watching the video as a gamer, not as a student, there is one thing about her video which stands out to me as the reason why she inspires rage in a subset of gamers.

Ms. Sarkeesian doesn't highlight anything positive about gender roles in the games that she critiques. While she is under no obligation to do so, the indignant gamer might accuse her of cherry-picking her facts, forgetting that her video series is about "Tropes vs Women", not "when games do justice and injustice to women".

Her series really is like a homework assignment for a college class, where the professor has asked for a list of tropes. If she'd included a "full assessment" of each game, her paper would've been ten times as long, and the professor would've given her a lower grade for including a bunch of irrelevant information.

In other words, her series is so single-minded in its purpose (to identify tropes) that it bothers gamers who feel that it's unfair that she only talks about "Tropes vs Women in Video Games". They misinterpret this as a video series on "games that fail women and are therefore terrible", when she's just doing a series on "games that have these tropes."

They're enraged not by what she says, but rather by what she omits.

And as far as games journalism goes, the fully-fledged "feminist game ratings" YouTube series/website is a void still waiting to be filled.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by vec on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:38PM (#8460728)
> They misinterpret this as a video series on "games that fail women and are therefore terrible", when she's just doing a series on "games that have these tropes."

Except that I don't think she's even doing that. She seems to take pains to avoid implicating any single game, and including so many references actually serves to blunt the criticism of each individual example. Instead, the message seems to be that the conventions of storytelling in interactive media have some deep, fundamental flaws. The entire medium, therefore, must change dramatically for these flaws to be addressed.

I can understand a reaction of "I like my games just like they are, thankyouverymuch" (though such a response obviously does not justify the behavior Ms. Sarkeesian has been subjected to). Speaking for myself, though, I enjoy games in spite of, not because of, these tropes, and I can't imagine that removing them would do anything other than make future games more enjoyable.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by DanBC on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:56PM (#8460378)
You make calm, reasonable, critiques of that video.

You claim other "gamers" will not like her video for the reason you give.

Can you explain how someone moves from "I disagree strongly with some aspects of the video you made" to [insert death threat here]?

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by dfxm12 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:58PM (#8461676)
Because it is easier. It's easier to be heard by making grandiose threats. It's easier to scare your target with such threats. FWIW, I've been getting death (and other) threats in my PSN inbox for as long as I've had my PS3 (just for winning games of Street Fighter). Threats are kind of a social norm for "gamers". I know that doesn't make it OK though, and I'm glad this behavior is finally getting exposed & chastised.

It's how immature people act. They feel threatened & don't really know why, so they threaten back. I wish it was just children engaging in that type of behavior, but I know that's not the case.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by archagon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @11:53AM (#8459078)
Yeah... and the worst part is, you kind of grow to ignore these tropes as you play these games. (And of course, this makes developers try to amp up the grit more and more.) Seeing them all at once is quite shocking. This is one of the reasons why I think these videos are very valuable.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by mturmon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:33PM (#8460147)
I agree, it is painful to watch. I wonder about my gender sometimes -- it's not like misogyny is isolated to video games. Boys' clubs seem to allow it to blossom.
[dead]
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by psuter on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:07PM (#8459874)
Cherry-picking is made considerably easier by the abundance of loaded cherry trees: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5i_RPr9DwMA

    GAMES REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE:
    Assassin’s Creed 2 (2009)
    Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood (2010)
    Bioshock (2007)
    Bioshock 2 (2010)
    Dead Island (2011)
    Dishonored (2012)
    Dragon Age: Origins (2009)
    Fable 2 (2008)
    Far Cry 3 (2012)
    God of War 3 (2008)
    Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)
    Grand Theft Auto V (2013)
    Hitman: Absolution (2012)
    Hitman: Blood Money (2006)
    Kane & Lynch (2007)
    L.A. Noire (2011)
    Mafia II: Joe’s Adventures (2010)
    Metro: Last Light (2013)
    No More Heroes (2008)
    Papo & Yo (2012)
    Prototype (2009)
    Red Dead Redemption (2010)
    Saints Row (2006)
    Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)
    The Darkness II (2012)
    The Witcher (2007)
    The Witcher 2 (2011)
    Thief (2014)
    Watch Dogs (2014)
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by bentcorner on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:05PM (#8459854)
You're not wrong - her message could be delivered with better impact if she omitted these examples (most of the "you get rewarded for killing women" examples are specific instances of "you get rewarded for killing npcs").

Still, she does have a point. Objectification of women in video games still runs rampant and does everyone a disservice. Just because there are some bad examples here doesn't invalidate the rest of her message.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by comrh on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:23PM (#8459346)
> maybe there would have never such a shitstorm.

Nice. All this is totally her fault then.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by hnha on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:48PM (#8459625)
Nice cherry you picked there. If you would leave a meaningful comment, I would be happy to talk.

I stand by my words. Her videos are full of lies. They are on a Columbine or Jack Thomson level of "objectivity". Someone please prove me wrong about Hitman otherwise.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by EvilTrout on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:08PM (#8459896)
I watched her video that featured Hitman Absolution as well and I don't recall her saying "this is integral" to the game. It was one of many examples.

Also, to me that sounds like cherry picking -- out of literally dozens of games you are focusing on one example.

And that specific example is from a game that caused outrage before it was even released for their "sexy latex nun" trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9NC-PCHp_I

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by xtrumanx on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:30PM (#8460674)
I don't know much about her videos but her description of Hitman left with a bad impression of her work.

It's objectively wrong. Wouldn't it be great if she just corrected it so as to not give her detractors more things to work with?

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by comrh on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:58PM (#8459762)
> If her videos were well researched and fair, maybe there would have never such a shitstorm.

This isn't about her videos. It is about the shitstorm (death threats!) you say is somehow partially her fault. Coming from the same person who said she was "bathing in the outrage". This is beyond criticism of her work, this is an attack.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by hashberry on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:02PM (#8459146)
It better be. She raised $158K on Kickstarter to make these YouTube videos. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/566429325/tropes-vs-wom...
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by vlunkr on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:31PM (#8459444)
I keep seeing her getting criticized for this and I don't get it. She didn't ask for that much, it just happened.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by FireBeyond on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:04PM (#8468079)
I don't think it's so much criticized for this, as people appealing to authority - witness upstream, where someone says 'you have to admit, there's a lot of leg work done, the videos look impressive' - which says nothing about the content or message - to which someone says "well, yes, but this isn't about 'how professional a video series can you produce given $160,000+?'.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by smackfu on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:29PM (#8459426)
You say that like it's a bad thing.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by bvanslyke on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:21PM (#8459319)
In case you (the reader of this comment) are interested in what kind of person it is that races to articles to post this tidbit, try taking a dive through his comment history.

> hashberry 235 days ago | link | parent | on: My children’s book on technology raised 100k withi...

> The presentation and video was amazing. I immediately fell in love with her. She smiles non-stop. She jumps around with giddy excitement in a cute little dress. She's the perfect manic pixie dream girl trope. I want her to have all my babies.

I know hashberry's too far gone to change his mind, but to anyone else reading, if you're hearing about Anita for the first time and are on the fence about what's going on, realize that there is an army of sexists who swarm to all women-in-tech articles to push the same talking points over and over.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by hashberry on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:28PM (#8459409)
Shaming male hetrosexuality is Feminism 101. Yes, I am attracted to young, maternal, intelligent women who like to smile.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:20PM (#8460590)
There's nothing wrong with what you're attracted to.

What's wrong is that you seem to think that commenting on your attraction to the female in the video is a worthwhile comment on the video. The video might have actual content, you know? It might be less sexist of you to actually pay some attention to the content, rather than to your attraction to the presenter?

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Rubix117 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:46PM (#8459596)
I disagree. Her videos have been shown to cherry pick. She is also a liar and has no interest in video gaming. This has been shown in older videos of herself. Its a money making scam.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by DanBC on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:35PM (#8460173)
You repeatedly call her a liar.

Your inability to point to any occasion where she has lied is telling.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:02PM (#8459809)
How is it a scam? People gave her money to post videos about video games, she is posting videos about video games. Are you saying she's not enthusiastic enough about the video games she's calling out to deserve the money people decided to pay her?
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by vec on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:41PM (#8460766)
He's obviously using the colloquial definition of the word "scam", namely "a completely legal and ethical enterprise with a business model that I, personally, disapprove of".
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:54PM (#8460852)
Nah, the meme that she scammed their supporters by taking the kickstarter money and disappearing has been part of the harassment campaign against her since the beginning, before she published the first videos. People in the gamergate miasma just don't like giving up their talking points even if blatantly contradicted by reality, I suppose. :V