News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by tptacek on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:06PM (#8455454)
I am confused by what appears to be an assertion that Jimmy John's has a legitimate concern that their minimum-wage-earning food service employees might leave to start a competing national sandwich chain.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by frankc on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:51PM (#8455731)
Of course the vast majority of them are no threat, but you should not assume every fast food employee is in it for the pay. If you are committed to opening a hamburger shop, you go and get a job at a hamburger shop for a few months to get some experience, see how they operate, maybe even pick up some ideas in terms of recipes, though usually its more learning the operations rather than stealing recipes. I know for a fact that this is a real thing because I know people who have done it in the taco truck business. If you are opening a hamburger shop without significant hamburger shop experience and you don't do this, you are a moron.

Doesn't mean blanket non-compete is fair, but to completely dismiss the OPs point it at best naive.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by tptacek on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:01PM (#8455785)
Once again: this isn't an argument. Taco truck owners could also rationally want to demand that their employees work for Taco Bux instead of dollars. But they can't, because neither the law nor human decency recognizes the validity of that exchange. And so too it is with noncompetes. The relationship a Jimmy Johns retail employee has with their company will inevitably fail to satisfy the requirements for an enforceable noncompete. In particular: minimum- and near-minimum- wage employees by definition haven't been given consideration in exchange for agreeing not to compete, and have neither privileged access to a rolodex of customers nor access to trade secrets.

My opinion is that Jimmy Johns is in fact not concerned that their employes will start competing firms. Rather, they'd like to minimize employee turnover, which, unlike local sandwich business starts, is a metric they actually probably do track. And one vehicle they've found for minimizing turnover is in tricking their employees into believing they have fewer alternative jobs available than they actually do.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by frankc on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:27PM (#8455929)
There are different issues being mixed up here: the fairness of the policy, the enforcibility of the policy and the motivation of the policy. I am only speaking to the motivation of the policy. Obviously we are just trying to read minds here since neither of us has any evidence of what went into their decision-making process. I am simply telling you from my first-hand knowledge in this industry, that 1) infiltration by potential competitors is common 2) it is a real concern 3) a non-compete provides some mitigation in terms discouraging the practice and providing a possible avenue of enforcement (though it might not actually be enforceable)

The blanket way OP has been dismissed really has to do with the rustled jimmies about the fairness of the policy and does not reflect well on the quality of the replies.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by tptacek on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:25PM (#8456163)
That's evasive. We have good reason to discount the idea that Jimmy Johns is seriously motivated by concerns about competing with sandwich chains started by their employees, and among them is the fact that they don't satisfy the requirements for enforcing those noncompetes, which their numerous attorneys have doubtlessly told them.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by frankc on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @11:07PM (#8457003)
They have then doubtlessly been told that they are unenforceable again Joe Employee who wants to work at Subway, but you seem to think that they still do it to trick people from leaving to work at subway. Why don't you think it's useful to discourage people potential competitors from infiltrating their company? I'd bet you it's way more likely to be enforceable in the latter case, against someone looking to copy your operations, if it's enforceable at all.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by aptwebapps on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @09:59AM (#8458424)
Because the bogus non-compete will fool Joe Employee but not Joe Next-Captain-of-Industry.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by bsbechtel on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @09:02AM (#8458190)
You should familiarize yourself with the story of Homejoy. The founders did pretty much exactly what we are describing as a potential threat here in order to gain experience in the cleaning world.

The argument that asking employees to sign a non-compete is somehow unethical, yet getting a low-wage job to learn how to run a competing business is not unethical is moot and completely subjective.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by benjohnson on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:17PM (#8455525)
Devil's Advocate:

It's certain that Jimmy John's line-worker can't start a 2,000 store chain, but they could run off with some of the catering business.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by bsbechtel on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:28PM (#8455591)
Jimmy John's competes with every local restaurant in every local market where it operates. Someone can easily start a local business that cuts into the market share of one of its local stores, although yes, it's very unlikely that restaurant is going to overtake Jimmy John's nationally. And yes, many local businesses, especially restaurant businesses, are started by former employees who enter a field to get training, but one day want to open their own business. It's obvious many of the comments (and my downvotes) here are from individuals who have never ran, nor worked in, a business that operates and competes on a local scale.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by tptacek on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:41PM (#8455666)
I work in a fiercely competitive space in which the modal vector for company formation is employees of competing companies leaving to start them.

The idea that Jimmy Johns could expect the right to bind minimum-wage-earning food service workers with a noncompete is verkakte. Even in circumstances where employees are given access to trade secrets and client rolodexes, noncompete agreements are difficult to enforce and almost invariably slashed to bits by courts when they survive at all.

Obviously, Jimmy Johns will not prevail in enforcing a noncompete on a minimum-wage employee. What they're doing is simply intimidating their own workers, probably based on some simple calculation about the impact their bogus noncompete will have on employee turnover, which is a metric every at-scale retail business optimizes for.

It is easy to devise logically-consistent reasons Jimmy Johns would want to bind their employees with anti-competitive contracts. Such arguments more or less beg the question.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by johnward on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:37PM (#8455643)
I didn't up or downvote you but from my perspective I don't feel that employers deserve more protections. If I want to run off with the secret recipe it's already protected by IP laws. I think it should be illegal for an employer to limit your future employment in any way. I'm not saying the restaurant industry isn't competitive, it's probably one of the most competitive I can think of, but limiting employees rights is not the right way to handle that.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by bsbechtel on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @05:38PM (#8455985)
At JJ, it was more about operational secrets that can't be protected by law. However, I mentioned in my original post that I don't necessarily think it's right or wrong, it's just why JJ does it.

I generally agree with you that limiting future employment is generally not a good thing, although I'm not convinced getting rid of non-competes in minimum wage jobs would materially affect wages. At most, it might prevent someone from taking a manager position at Subway, but I don't think it is going to raise the overall wages of restaurant workers.

Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by tptacek on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @06:23PM (#8456154)
Jimmy Johns is a franchise operation with tens of thousands of employees. Their retail workers do not have access to meaningful "operational secrets". It wouldn't matter if they did, either: trade secrets can be protected directly without noncompetes.
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by jackmaney on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:32PM (#8455610)
If Jimmy John's can't compete with a fly-by-night catering business started by a former worker, then why shouldn't Jimmy John's fail?
Re:When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause by lotsofmangos on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:18PM (#8455533)
I can clear up your confusion, but I warn you, it isn't pretty. Quick, put on these sunglasses and look at bsbechtel again. Just don't stare too long.