News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Problem with Feminism by dang on Monday October 13, 2014 @01:11AM (#8447574)
This post was killed by user flags.
Re:My Problem with Feminism by jolux on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:47AM (#8447524)
I'm going to sound like a dick here, but my karma is already low, so fuck it.

You're falling into the common trap of the technologically skilled, rational, intelligent, male. You see yourself as a meritocratic person and you believe that people should be judged based on their merits.

Fair enough. It would be nice if the world worked that way. Unbiased meritocratic decision is impossible when the subject in question is to known to their interviewer by anything but their merits. As far as we know, it's simply not possible to make meritocratic decisions when you know anything other than the subject's merits. It doesn't matter if you're racist or sexist, everyone inevitably makes assumptions about other races and other genders. Not being racist and sexist is about realizing those assumptions are incorrect and suppressing them.

Take the case of professional orchestras for example. Before the 1970s and 80s, most professional orchestras were 5% women. In the 70s and 80s when blind auditions became the standard, that number rose to 25%. You don't need to tell me that correlation doesn't imply causation but if the data doesn't say that to you I'm not sure what can.

People are awesome solely based on their merits, but acting like you have the capability to thusly judge them in such a perfect manner is silly. It's simply not possible.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by alukima on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:55AM (#8447539)
This was poorly written. I'm still not sure why the author dislikes feminism. He jumped from one topic to another, without supporting facts anywhere.

The biggest thing I have an issue with is this paragraph-

>I happen to believe that many well meaning people of many causes damage their cause by basically forcing people to deal with their "diversity" first, instead of of being able to deal with people as people on their own merit.

If you feel like you're being 'forced' to deal with others diversity you should rethink being in the tech industry. Being in the tech industry means being able to deal with change and new ideas. Part of everyones merit is their different backgrounds, value sets and experiences. Equality/fairness is not treating everyone the exact same. It's absurd to be how undervalued diversity is in the tech world, it makes it's hard to believe that sexism/racism isn't at the heart of it.

Diverse teams make better decisions: http://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/better_decis...

Diversity increases creative: http://www.eidi-results.org/pdfs/EIDARTICLE1-17-12.pdf

Diverse teams produce better results: http://www.inc.com/welcome.html?destination=http://www.inc.c...

Diversity makes for greater success in venture: http://www.mercurynews.com/opinion/ci_26086229/tech-workforc...

Re:My Problem with Feminism by goldfeld on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:57PM (#8447429)
When something has been far too bent over in one direction, you often need to push it over the other way to eventually correct it. Holding it in the middle and thinking it will stay put over generations is wishful at best.

That's why campaigning often takes on an aggressive bent, and why affirmative action is called for. Current generations steeped in sexism (I mean, much as I'm a feminist, I see many of my ingrained sexist biases) need to prop up this scaffold to make sure the changes are institutionalized and carry over and next generations are raised with less biases by means of institutions, as opposed to "just keep in mind everybody is equal, yay!"

I'm a man, and I could even agree with you that "feminism" is not a great term, but I disagree about most of the rest of your opinion. It's a serious matter, very serious, and some people do need to feel inconvenienced sometimes. For me being a feminist is nothing more than a modern open mind's rational stance. Unless you don't really care about fellow human beings.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by ahomescu1 on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:35AM (#8447496)
> That's why campaigning often takes on an aggressive bent, and why affirmative action is called for. Current generations steeped in sexism (I mean, much as I'm a feminist, I see many of my ingrained sexist biases) need to prop up this scaffold to make sure the changes are institutionalized and carry over and next generations are raised with less biases by means of institutions, as opposed to "just keep in mind everybody is equal, yay!"

If you fight one injustice with an even bigger one, the war just continues forever. Counteracting sexism against women this generation using affirmative action (giving women more rights than men) just means that next generation men will see themselves as abused and exploited and ask for affirmative action in their favor. This will simply keep escalating more and more. The only solution is to treat everyone the same.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by gizmo686 on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:25AM (#8447471)
>When something has been far too bent over in one direction, you often need to push it over the other way to eventually correct it. Holding it in the middle and thinking it will stay put over generations is wishful at best.

I disagree, once it is held at the middle for a generation, it will stay there (barring some unrelated event pushing it back), because people will have grown up with it there, and all of the inertia has shifted to holding it in the middle.

In fact, even without any holding, I would expect it to tend towards the middle (albeit very slowly). In my mind, all that movements such as feminism are doing is (greatly) accelerating the rate we get there (which I am in favor of).

Re:My Problem with Feminism by soeinfachistdas on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:59AM (#8447550)
When it comes to those in poverty, minorities have an upper hand over europeans. They get food and housing more easily their entire lives, and its because of the laws that give them social assistance that europeans (especially single european males and females) don't get.

Bending racism or sexism one way too far to correct some perceived historical slight, is sexist, racist, and wrong, and you are wrong.

Answering sexism and racism with other forms of sexism and racism, is a slight against all who were not initially involved in the racism and sexism, and encourages families who have no history of being sexist or racist to become so, to correct the sexist and racist laws you've implemented on them.

Have a good day.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by dalke on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:33PM (#8447384)
The idea of relabeling "feminism" is not new. A quick search finds a summary of replacement ideas at http://jezebel.com/5828798/the-catchy-new-word-for-feminism , with 'equalitarian' (a 200 year old word) taking the lead.

Unfortunately, that word already has a meaning in economic analysis. Eg, https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/subject/hist-mat... : "The traces of common ownership which are also found in the early stages of the new religion can be ascribed to solidarity among the proscribed rather than to real equalitarian ideas."

Still, many other words have been proposed (and discarded).

But I'm really writing to comment about:

> I'm not sure what "term" should replace feminism -- in the workplace I'd suggest "professionalism". After all everyone wants to be treated professionally, not just women.

The problem here is that "professionalism" is not well-defined. Is it professional to drink alcohol while at work? What about at a conference? At a conference reception? Is it professional to leave your desk cluttered at the end of the day? Is it professional to wear shorts at work? What about to not wear lipstick? Is it professional to take 6 months off to be with one's newborn? Is it professional to participate in a protest march (during off hours) against the company? What about if it's to protest discriminatory hiring practices in upper management? Is it professional to insist on 9-5 working hours, or is it professional to work as long as you think it takes, or is it professional to work as long as your boss thinks it takes?

"Feminism" means that people should have the same political, economic, and social rights no matter if they are male, female, or don't identify as either sex.

What's the equivalent for "professionism"? As best as I can tell, it's broadly defined by whatever the people in power (ie, your boss, or anyone else who can fire you, or your customers) say that it means. There's no underlying philosophy which guides changes in the meaning of "professionalism". One upon a time it was unprofessional to have women working in the office, or studying at universities. That didn't change simply by being "professional."

Re:My Problem with Feminism by tagrun on Monday October 13, 2014 @01:06AM (#8447568)
In academia the situation is arguably worse.

There are gender-based quotas forcing us to favor less capable women over more capable men (capability is objectively measured by education and publication history).

Now, I don't care what the gender of a grad student is at all. What I care is I want to get projects done. And I need capable people for that, and such regulations pushed by "successful" feminist agendas are actually hurting the academia as a whole.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by Frozenlock on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:58AM (#8447549)
For the interested, feminism (and other social justice battles) is a big part of the #gamergate and #notyourshield movement that's been raging for 2 months in the gaming industry.
Re:My Problem with Feminism by jolux on Monday October 13, 2014 @01:00AM (#8447554)
How is this relevant? This just seems like trying to bring gamergate into HN which lord knows nobody here wants.
Re:My Problem with Feminism by Frozenlock on Monday October 13, 2014 @01:02AM (#8447559)
How is this relevant?

I'll refer you to the parent comment, where you can see that its sole purpose was to describe the relevance.

Re:My Problem with Feminism by tzs on Monday October 13, 2014 @01:51AM (#8447649)
HN trivia: you can still comment on a dead discussion if you have a window opened on it from before it was killed.