News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by dingaling on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:03AM (#8444652)
Thereby entrenching the FAT patent fee scheme.

This is a very odd decision that originated in the difficulty of renaming external volumes ( why was this considerd important? ) and then became conflated with 'security'.

I believe the kernel modules are still there, though, so you can mount extx from the command line in dev mode. But not much use for everyday users.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by higherpurpose on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:31AM (#8444854)
I'm puzzled that more OEMs aren't using Samsung's open source implementation of exFAT at least, which is already version 1.2.4.

http://opensource.samsung.com/reception/receptionSub.do?meth...

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by techrat on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:44AM (#8444867)
exFAT is currently under Patent. Implement it all you want but Samsung pays Microsoft for the right to use it.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by overcertified on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:21PM (#8451643)
First, reverse engineering in some cases may violate the DMCA regardless of what you do with the code.

If a patent is valid, then reverse engineering doesn't get you anywhere. Patent is not copyright. You can sit down and write your own implementation of the code, not copying anything, and still violate the patent.

Most of the people who complain about having to pay for exfat are the open source people who are used to getting what they thought was free software. However with the Heartbleed and shell shock issues this year the crditbity and false notions that open source are free are going down the drain. Meanwhile, Microsoft successful defense of the vfat (long for name in fat32) and mapping parents against Tom Tom has minimized cases where someone goes against those patents and almost all major distributions of Linux will not (and probably can't) add exfat to the distribution. That leaves most using FUSE and there are many complaints over the various forums about issues, bugs, and corruption ISO g the FUSE drivers.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by higherpurpose on Monday October 13, 2014 @07:48AM (#8448313)
Last I checked reverse engineering without paying licenses was legal. And that's what this open source implementation of exFAT is.

As a monopoly on PC's, why is Microsoft allowed to collect royalties on the filesystem anyway? Is there another way to connect external media to a Windows PC without having to pay Microsoft royalties?

If there is not, that should be an anti-trust issue.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by higherpurpose on Monday October 13, 2014 @07:45AM (#8448305)
Last I checked reverse engineering without paying licenses was legal. And that's what this open source implementation of exFAT is.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by fuzzix on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:10AM (#8444983)
Wasn't the patent mess the reason Android stopped supporting usb-storage and now uses (the horror!) MTP?

I think UDF is well supported by everything now and has several advantages over FAT (including large file and basic rwx permissions support).

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by cnvogel on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:32AM (#8445007)
The rationale behind using MTP is that "in the old days", the android device had to unmount its "/sdcard" partition and hand over the block-device to the PC, that mounted it just like any single-partition usb-stick. Downside is, that a) the PC mounting the android device could arbitrarily corrupt the filesystem structure and b) all programs accessing the filesystem on the android side needed to shutdown, and c) you only could use a filesytem well supported by all major computer operating systems: hence FAT.

MTP doesn't work on the level of a block-device, but rather works like, e.g. "rsync/scp/sftp over USB". So the Android handset can leave the partition mounted, all program can stay running, any filesystem can be used on the handset side, and potential for data corruption is minimized.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by fuzzix on Sunday October 12, 2014 @08:32AM (#8445105)
But it doesn't work like "rsync/scp/sftp over USB". No seek or partial transfer support makes it a dog. Very poor cross-platform support makes it a terrible choice.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by gambiting on Sunday October 12, 2014 @09:04AM (#8445168)
It is still a million times better choice than mounting the device directly as a block device.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by fuzzix on Sunday October 12, 2014 @09:58AM (#8445289)
A read only block device would have been better and would actually work on non-Windows OSes.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by yincrash on Sunday October 12, 2014 @10:17AM (#8445337)
You only read from your external storage and never write to it, from the computer?
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by fuzzix on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @07:42AM (#8457955)
Sure, with an option to enable write with the usual "omg ur apps!" warning.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by danmaz74 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:26AM (#8444847)
BTW, when will those patents expire? Shouldn't be long I guess..
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by radicalbyte on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:53AM (#8444878)
AFAIK US patents expire 20 years after filing, which means that a number of them will soon be expired.

http://www.google.com/patents/US5579517 expires next year. http://www.google.com/patents/US5758352 expires in 2016. http://www.google.com/patents/US6286013 expires in 2017.

There is one more, which looked to have already expired:

http://www.google.com/patents/US5745902

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by pwg on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:50AM (#8445593)
5579517 is pre-gatt, so it is 17 years from date of grant, which for it is Nov 26, 1996 + 17 years => Nov 26, 2013 - so already expired.

5758352 is post-gatt, so it is 20 years from earliest priority date, the earliest priority date is Apr. 1, 1993 + 20 years = Apr. 1, 2013 - so also already expired (unless it has any term extension).

6286013 is also post-gatt, also with a priority date of Apr. 1, 1993 + 20 years = Apr. 1, 2013 - so also already expired (unless it has any term extension).

5745902 is pre-gatt, it patented Apr. 28, 1998 and gets 17 years from that date, so Apr. 28, 1998 + 17 years => Apr. 28, 2015 - it expires in about six months.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by techrat on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:43AM (#8444866)
The issue is exFAT and Fat32 long filenames. exFAT was introduced with Windows Vista and is what 32GB+ flash media tends to be formatted in. It'll be a long time before this one expires.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by overcertified on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:06PM (#8451597)
There are at least 4 patents involved, extensible file system, name hash lookup, transactional fat, contiguous file allocation. If you look at overcertified'a recent slideshare presentations on exFAT, including the recent HTCIA 2014 exFAT presentation, the patent numbers are listed on the ending reference slides.
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by caf on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:56AM (#8444882)
Does anyone know exactly what innovation(s) in exFAT is/are newly patented? Which patents read on it?
Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by techrat on Sunday October 12, 2014 @06:17AM (#8444908)
From wiki:

>exFAT is a proprietary file system. However exFAT is protected under US patent law, and its initial application was issued on 10 July 2009 under the application number US2008168029.[7] On 12 November 2013, the patent was granted by the US patent office under US8583708.

Patent length is 20 years, so we're looking at least until 2033 before exFat is expired and (safely) freely usable.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by cowsandmilk on Sunday October 12, 2014 @10:11AM (#8445317)
> Patent length is 20 years, so we're looking at least until 2033 before exFat is expired and (safely) freely usable.

Nope. For the dates this was filed, length goes from filing date. Depending on how dangerous you want to be, you could argue it expires anywhere from 2024-2028.

Re:ChromeOS will no longer support ext2/3/4 on external driv... by danmaz74 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @06:20AM (#8444913)
Thanks for the info - even if this really sucks!