Without that, how would they validate who is a student vs not? I know nothing of Go but want to learn. Am I not a 'student'?
I understand what you are saying, but without being an actual verifiable student they would be giving this away to the world
Further, with all of the thousands of dollars saved by not being a traditional student, surely there is some money for these services out of pocket (not all of which are 100% required to learn)
What? Why would they need to?
Those "perks" are only appealing to somebody who's learning or a hobbyist. They are absolutely worthless to a professional. I will burn through them in a week.
Github is just trying to market this to kids. It has nothing to do with learning or providing a better value proposition. It's all about hooking them into your brand early. Nothing wrong with that, but that's what it is.
Yup. That's how Amazon Prime got me. Free Prime for students? Well, four years later I'm hooked and pay full price.
Ingenious marketing strategy.
Adobe, do it as well I think, though they're close to a monopoly with Photoshop.
Have people become so accustomed to using your software that it's easier for them to pay for it than to transition to another company's products or indeed to go with FOSS alternatives.
It's the drug dealer model: first hit is free.
Isn't it worth mentioning that a package meant to give people access to expensive learning resources isn't available to those who need it most?
It's not a charity. The open source hosting tools (which github offers) are more charitable.
Couldn't agree more!!
In the US, I guess you do.
Here in Finland, all uni/polytechnic/what-have-you students get a school-issued email address and student identification card, and tuition is free.
So I guess your criticism is for the US culture? :)
I once made a rough comparison, in the 60k–100k yearly salary range, for tax rates between Finland and California. As far as I remember, they were quite similar.
Just, in Finland you get (almost) free education, (almost) free health care, better public transportation and worse national defense.
I'd be happy to do this again, if you (or someone) provide the California numbers, I'll do Finland.
You've blown my mind. I need to think this through carefully, but your reasoning may very well apply to health-care too.
Thanks for setting us straight. I'll be sure to vote for privitization next opportunity!
EDIT: Sarcasm!
I haven't seen the numbers on education, but certainly no OECD country has healthcare more expensive than that in the US. Heck, many pay less in public funds than the US, even though the private healthcare costs in the US are a little bit higher than the public costs -- and this was true before the Affordable Care Act, just to forestall anyone who might blame "ObamaCare".
Additionally, several also have lower public + private costs than the US's public costs (which in turn are lower than US private costs).
It can stand to improve, but I see nothing wrong with the idea. You still have to pay taxes anyway, why not spend them on the common good?
"Most" do not want anything close to it, or the rich do not want anything close to it?
I'm absolutely certain that most people in the US would vote for free healthcare and education. The problem of course is that politicians and special interest groups make sure things never get to that stage.
[1] "Free" in this context means that it is subsidized by the government, and it is probably funded by some taxation. Do you have a better word for it, that isn't impractically wordy and awkward? Then convince us to use that.
This points out sort of the paradox we have here...it's argued that you should just "learn to code," but then they're requiring here that in order to do this you need to be part of some larger engine of learning that my or may not have anything to do with what you're trying to learn in the first place. So which is it?
If anyone wants the DO portion of this and are not enrolled in traditional education but learning code full time and thinks they should get it regardless: email me: [email protected]
What? You mean to say that students, who spend all their time studying (and pay tuition in some countries), are in a better financial position than people who has either free time and don't pay tuition, or has a full-time job?
They give it to students because that the reality is that students often don't have any spare money for tools, but they do indeed need/use them for their education etc.
Besides you need some easy way to check if someone is a student or not and the most easy way to delegate this job is to require an email from an institution.
"If you're a student aged 13+ and enrolled in degree or diploma granting course of study, the GitHub Student Developer Pack is for you. All you need is a school-issued email address, valid student identification card, or other official proof of enrollment"
So I need to pay money to a big institution to be considered a student? Many 'students' would probably be in a better financial situation than a non-'student' who is trying to learn. Somehow 'education' has turned into a tool for passing on privilege.
I do agree this pack is not meant for everyone. And I also agree that these guys would find it hard to differentiate between a real learner and one who is not. But I'm amazed they didn't think about linking it with a coursera course or something. Anyways, I've spent 10 minutes thinking about this and they've probably spent 10 weeks. They've done more research, I might be missing something.