It gets better: you can't even depend on the large players generally getting it right. If a large organization makes a bad decision with their first infosec hire, it's not a self-correcting problem - the next hires will be cut from the same cloth, and unless something blows up, almost nobody will know.
As far as I can tell the best information provided by a certificate is that you should avoid applicants who brag about them (and for applicants, avoid employers who list them as job qualifications).
The whole point of those audits is to show that, while every company of any importance will eventually have some sort of breach/break-in/hack, the company takes all reasonable steps to prevent it and mitigate the possible effects of such an event.
Infosec isn't a fool-proof thing. There's no way to prevent everything, and all you can do is keep on top of things and take steps to ensure you're doing everything you can to protect your systems.
You WILL get hacked eventually.
However, genuine question - how does the laymen (like myself) rate infosec specialists? Imagine for a second I'm a senior exec at Target and IBN (IBM's fake arch-competitor) comes to me and says "no worries about security, we use 256-bit encryption, bank grade security, etc etc". Do I believe him?
I feel like infosec is a "I don't know what I don't know" industry and the consequences could be potentially dire.