News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by kazinator on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:40PM (#8364299)
How about reliable electricity and water for your people, then Mars.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_Resources_in_India

"Water supply and sanitation in India continue to be inadequate ..."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_India

"Over 300 million (300 million) people in India have no access to electricity. Of those who do, almost all find electricity supply intermittent and unreliable."

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by tn13 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:51PM (#8364611)
Remind me again how much surplus money did US have to fight wars in Iraq ? Please tell me that US is overflowing with so much money that they have an army stationed in Germany for absolutely no rational reason.

Why exactly is US spending so much of higher education when most of the public elementary education is good enough to mass produce kids whose only skill is flipping burgers ?

Large nations need to allocate money to all problems proportional to the seriousness of the problem. We have learned how to live with less. My classrooms did not have even a bulb. Did not prevent me from getting good education. My village did not have any water pipeline and we figured out how to survive.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by chc on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @08:37PM (#8364934)
The fact that the US wastes huge wads of money doesn't exactly convince me that wasting money is a good idea. The US does lots of things that are questionable at best.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by tn13 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @10:12PM (#8365201)
That was not really my point. What people need to understand is that each nation gives certain priority of all the problems and accordingly invests money into those problems. Saying that spending money on X is a waste when you have problem Y unsolved is stupid.

India has 1/6th of world population and has very good reason to invest in space research. India is going to needs its own satellite guided missiles, ASAT, GPS and other systems down the line if those 1.2B people have to see a good future. Or these people will be held hostage to USA's Military Industrial Complex.

India was already one of the largest Shipbuilding nation and had more Aircraft maintenance centers than most other countries in 1950s. India did not invest well into these industries, today our defense imports are obscene. We cant even manufacture a reliable pistol leave alone mortar. Had we invested in those tech also we could have saved a lot more money today which could have helped the poor.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by thisGuysAccount on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @10:19PM (#8365226)
"Why exactly is US spending so much of higher education when most of the public elementary education is good enough to mass produce kids whose only skill is flipping burgers ?"

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make about 13 year olds, but I assure you I don't care what you have to say.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by tn13 on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:59AM (#8365701)
Just empty rhetoric.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by thirsteh on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:53PM (#8364373)
You might as well ask the same question about anything the U.S. does, given that the U.S. undisputedly has "more important" and unresolved domestic problems.

In the words of Carl Sagan: "Just now, there a great many matters that are pressing in on us that compete for the money it takes to send people to other worlds. Should we solve those problems first, or are they a reason for going? "

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by baddox on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:02PM (#8364422)
People do ask the same question about many things the U.S. does.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by spindritf on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:38PM (#8364566)
The US does have more important and unresolved domestic problems but there are vanishingly few that could be solved with just more money.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by cmdrfred on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:53PM (#8364619)
Correct, but the majority of them can be solved with a more equitable distribution of said money.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by tn13 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:58PM (#8364635)
US debt is one problem that can be solved purely by money and nothing else not especially Obama's rhetoric.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by dkokelley on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @07:09PM (#8364673)
I have a feeling this thread is leading down a very nonproductive path, but I'd like to salvage something of value from it and discuss the consequences of the national debt.

http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/10/21/141510617/what-if-...

I'd like to challenge the notion that the national debt is undisputedly a bad thing. The majority of the U.S.'s debt is in the form of treasury bonds - widely considered the most secure form of financial instrument. If the treasury bond can't be paid by the U.S., there are much bigger problems (such as the government of the largest national economy in the world collapsing). The treasury bond is utilized worldwide for its stability. It is used to moderate economic growth, and to stimulate it when it slows.

I'm not convinced government debt is entirely good, but I'm also not convinced that things would be better by paying it off.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by Retric on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @07:34PM (#8364745)
There was actually a lot of economics saying the possibility of the US paying off the national debt in the Clinton years would be a bad thing. Unfortunately, 2 wars, massive tax breaks for the wealthy, and a 2 recessions have taken care of that problem.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by pushtheenvelope on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:46PM (#8364335)
better response than I can write. This is why: http://balajiviswanathan.quora.com/Indian-Space-Mission-Pove...
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by primelens on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:56PM (#8364390)
Thank you! After reading this same statement about toilets vs space missions dozens of times I could hardly muster anything more articulate than "aaargh!" Apparently the West had solved all of humanity's problems and ensured a reign of perfect equality and peace before embarking on trivial things like research!
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by chc on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:18PM (#8364496)
This is pure ad hominem. "The West is dumb and mean" doesn't make anybody else's actions smart. You may as well criticize their odor for all the relevance it has to whether or not this is a sensible use of India's money.

For the record, I actually think it's probably a good use of money. I just think this breed of response — "Shut up, because the West sucks!" — is singularly toxic.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by primelens on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:55PM (#8364625)
You misunderstand my argument if you read it as "the West is dumb and mean". What I meant to emphasize was that the West made the (IMHO right) decision, to spend on research etc while it was working on other social problems. It is never one or the other. But I would add the same model should be extended to other countries as well.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by manish_gill on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:32PM (#8364543)
The article in question specifically criticizes the journalists. The author (in subsequent comments) even discourages others from blatantly generalizing countries' reaction in the same manner as some of the components of the media.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by chc on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:46PM (#8364593)
The OP doesn't really do that. The article linked by pushtheenvelope does, but that is what I was criticizing. It doesn't actually support India's program; it mostly just makes sarcastic and hostile comments about other countries. Regardless of your opinion of the West or of India, personally attacking critics (based on their ethnicity, no less) is not the same thing as supporting an idea.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by vaishaksuresh on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @07:19PM (#8364701)
"INR5 billion (US$82 million) provided for ultra modern solar power plants in Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Ladakh in Jammu and Kashmir."

"INR2 billion (US$33 million) provided for power reforms, INR5 billion (US$82 million) for water reforms in Delhi"

"10-year tax holiday to be extended to companies that start power generation by March 31, 2017"

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Union_budget_of_India

And yet, you complain about the mere $67 million spent on this mission.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by anigbrowl on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:20PM (#8364502)
Don't be so short-sighted. Putting an orbiter around Mars on a relative shoestring is likely to generate a lot of inward investment in India, which will help to pay for very expensive things like content-scale infrastructure.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by paramendra on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @08:13PM (#8364867)
The best comment to date. This 75 million will come back in droves as India now high gears its space exports.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by roywiggins on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:57PM (#8364393)
If you could provide reliable electricity and water for 300 million people for $74m ($0.25 per head) then you might have a point, but it's not really a lot of money for a country as large as India.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by paramendra on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @08:15PM (#8364874)
So true. $75 million is not a lot of money for India. The Prime Minister's Office just spent $50 million on latest equipment for his bodyguards (secret service detail). ONE Indian company just signed a deal with the Nepal government to spend $1 billion for ONE hydro project in Nepal. And it is nowhere in news in India.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by baddox on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:02PM (#8364418)
How many people could you provide reliable utilities to for $74m?
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by pm90 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:15PM (#8364481)
Not very many. And for how long? If you look at it from another perspective: providing jobs for the scientists and all the industrial manufacturers with that money probably did a lot better in that regard.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by bsder on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:39PM (#8364572)
Because the technology to send a spacecraft to another planet is the same technology to solve terrestrial problems.

The Internet, nominally the single biggest technology solution for the developing world ever, runs on compression and error correction algorithms that were first implemented for Voyager.

A manned mission to Mars must solve a the problem of a closed ecosystem. Think that might be important to developing countries who are polluting terribly (just like everybody did) in an effort to modernize?

You can't solve everything. There will always be some problems.

And, get enough good scientists together and those same scientists will start demanding that you make progress on domestic fronts as well.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by ericd on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:20PM (#8364500)
They're spending $75M to inspire a generation. It's dirt cheap.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by grownseed on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:36PM (#8364553)
This is what I show people with this perspective: http://me.brandabrand.com/t/letter-by-ernst-stuhlinger/6288. It's clever, touching and to the point.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by rsynnott on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @08:39PM (#8364945)
On this reasoning, really, all space programmes are unacceptable, and always have been. People are without healthcare in the US; scrap NASA! People are unemployed in Europe; cut funding to the ESA! Zero-sum!

There seems to be a strange idea that spending on space is inherently wasteful. In fact, India spent ~$75m on this, mostly locally, thus providing economic stimulus, and no doubt assisting education.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by wehadfun on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:15PM (#8364479)
We are quick to call comments like this racist but I don't know. If Singapor or Qutar did the same thing I doubt anyone would say their priorities are jacked up.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by frandroid on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:50PM (#8364360)
I'm not sure I agree with Amos' argument, but the fact is that he does address this in the article.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by chernevik on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @09:20PM (#8365040)
Maybe folks in India will start asking, hey, we can orbit Mars, how come we can't get clean water around here? Raising the standards of competence, intelligence and honesty for that government probably does far more than piping another $74mm into the same decrepit apparatus.
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by known on Saturday September 27, 2014 @04:54AM (#8376504)
People in India HATE their neighbourhood. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2013/05/15...
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by mullingitover on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:17PM (#8364492)
Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by palakchokshi on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:01PM (#8364413)
Ummmm you like posting links without thinking? Here are a couple of them for you. You see the fallacy in your argument?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#Re...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_Stat...

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by dang on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:18PM (#8364497)
> you like posting links without thinking?

No personal attacks on Hacker News, please, regardless of how annoying another's comment may be.

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by kazinator on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @09:06PM (#8365009)
Yes, I see a fallacy and it is in your own argument.

The fallacy you are invoking, in fact, has a fancy Latin name; it may be this one:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque

Re:Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling by seanflyon on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @07:09PM (#8364670)
While I completely disagree with kazinator, you have not pointed out a fallacy and your links do not contradict anything kazinator wrote.