News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by tucaz on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @09:07PM (#8359375)
I've been watching it for 8 minutes as of now and despite the fact that the content looks good it really bores me to death that he is reading the whole thing like a robot. It does not sound like a natural converstation or presentation. Does anyone else share this feeling?
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by _pius on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:40AM (#8359931)
it really bores me to death that he is reading the whole thing like a robot

Give the guy a break. It's Lecture 1, I'd imagine he was nervous.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:39PM (#8359811)
Agreed completely, it definitely felt rushed and not particularly well prepared - thus reading off of the paper.

That said, the content is strong and for the desired audience it is all probably novel, besides the fact that this was day 1 of a new course.

When I thought about it more though, it seems like the idea of the class is more of a lecture series style than traditional instruction anyway.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by sloanesturz on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @10:12PM (#8359546)
I was there in person, and I felt the same way. Very surprising.
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by bequanna on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:06PM (#8359698)
I disagree.

The content is great and communicated well.

Some people prefer making presentations having only some general idea of what they are going to say before hand. Other people spend a good deal of time thinking about exactly what they want to say and how they want to say it. Both presentation styles are perfectly valid.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by peter_mcrae on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:05AM (#8359871)
Agreed that both presentation styles work. That said, regardless of the "strategy", the delivery needs to be clean to be seen as authoritative (unless a tremendous amount of respect as been pre-built). Imagine your CEO delivering an all-hands with 47 ums and reading from a script -- how much confidence would that instill?
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by pyre on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:48AM (#8359952)
> Both presentation styles are perfectly valid.

Where did the parent claim that this was an 'invalid' presentation style?

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by corford on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @04:19AM (#8360384)
I really enjoyed sama's delivery. It was easy to digest; not too fast, not too slow; important ideas/concepts were repeated but not overly so; the choice and sequence of topics covered was very good. Length was just about right too.

I hate it when speakers "over engage" and keep throwing in jokes, personal anecdotes, rhetorical questions, funny slides etc. in a perceived need to keep people's attention. If a presentation's worth listening to, the content (delivered in a friendly and relaxed way) should be all that's needed to keep an audience engaged. If some people haven't got the attention span for that, it's usually their problem not the speaker's.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by giarc on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @03:46PM (#8363675)
I think it was a bit choppy, but not distracting by any means. I think having the text is great because it makes the delivery more efficient. All too often presenters, including myself, tend to circle back on a point, even repeating statements as they "find their way" or determine their next point. It can be confusing as a listener and therefore having a script helps to reduce this. The value of this (free!) course and the speakers FAR outweigh any issues with delivery/presentation style etc.
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by peter_mcrae on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:34PM (#8359794)
Totally agree. The content is great, but the delivery is uncomfortable (both speakers). I stopped watching and just listened. Ultimately, the content is the most important thing and I appreciate the opportunity to access awesome content. If anything, I think the first lecture helped humanize the whole "start-up scene". From the outside, it seems like everyone has figured it all out, but clearly we all have areas to improve.

Lastly, given that this will be so broadly distributed, I totally get the need to be on message so it may make sense to read in this scenario.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by jonalmeida on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @11:45AM (#8362097)
FWIW, this was the same content he gave us at Hack The North when he was visiting less than 24 hours ago. It makes sense to copy it down and repeat it rather than try to memorize all of it.
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by tucaz on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @01:01PM (#8362602)
I'm not sure this is about memorization. Teachers give the same content over and over again and do not memorize (in the sense of repeating it until it's memorized). Great presenters do not memorize their speeches. They practice it until it's natural.

I agree that content is king, but the one reason why we attend to classes, events and speeches is to see a great delivery of the content being presented. If not, better handle the written version by email and be done with it.

I'm pretty sure Steve Jobs wouldn't be remembered by his presentation skills if he read the whole thing. That's also not the reason why I remember my physics teacher from 10 years ago.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by jonalmeida on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:18PM (#8367947)
True, they I'd have to agree it was something else then that made him choose to read from notes. We still shouldn't judge after just one lecture though.

Let's see how today's goes..

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by rtpg on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @03:20AM (#8360274)
I have the feeling when watching, but by just listening I'm actually fine with it.

I think the visual indication plays a huge part in the perception.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by wyclif on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @03:33AM (#8360295)
People are getting way too hung up on the fact the he read from a text. But so what? The content was interesting and compelling. I'd rather listen to somebody using a prepared text and conveying the information quickly (like Altman does here) than painfully reading slides.

I thought he did a good job. Usually I hate watching a video presentation if there's copy of the text to read. It's way more efficient to read the content than to watch most videos and then set the speed to 4x.

Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by andrewchambers on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @09:43PM (#8359487)
Not at all.
Re:Lecture 1 – How to Start a Startup [video] by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:11AM (#8359883)
100% agree.