News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by abandonliberty on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:40PM (#8358465)
Yes, it's unclear.

The CRTC is arguing that Netflix is now a legitimate broadcaster subject to the same laws that govern traditional broadcasters.

Open internet doesn't mean unregulated and lawless.

In fact, we need quite a bit of laws and regulations to ensure an open internet.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:23AM (#8359911)
> The CRTC is arguing that Netflix is now a legitimate broadcaster subject to the same laws that govern traditional broadcasters.

Netflix isn't a broadcaster at all. Netflix is unicast. And yes, that matters in practice, because broadcast spectrum is finite and broadcasters have to choose content on behalf of everyone. With Netflix the users choose what content is transmitted and can choose from arbitrarily many alternatives.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by abandonliberty on Thursday September 25, 2014 @11:09PM (#8371141)
Laws can change and will likely have to to cope with the new reality. This is how it starts.

The specifics of the implementation aren't really relevant to anyone but lawyers at this time. The How is less important than the Why.

How questions: Does Netflix have licenses for all possible content? Do they pay it out at per-view level?

Netflix and other online streaming options are replacing traditional broadcasters who were legislated to ensure the continued survival of Canadian content.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by nickonline on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:29PM (#8359778)
I'm not sure what Canadian content rules the CRTC is trying to enforce, but if it's anything like 5% of content shown must be Canadian I'm not sure how they can enforce that as a content provider where the consumer picks what they want to watch.

Additionally if noone is watching the Canadian shows how does the CRTC determine what % content they require netflix to provide.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by abandonliberty on Thursday September 25, 2014 @10:59PM (#8371108)
I'm sure part of the process will examine this. We have to update our laws to deal with the new world. Privacy laws are decades behind.

There could be several reasonable approaches. E.g. 5% of their content expenditures must be Canadian, whether or not it is watched.

I'll leave the discussion of whether this is desirable alone.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by Mikeb85 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @03:30AM (#8360288)
But with Netflix the consumer doesn't pick the content. They choose a 'channel' they want, just as they would on a normal TV. They don't pay per show, they pay for a curated service and then 'tune in', albeit on demand.

The consumer doesn't choose what's on Netflix, they only choose what they watch. They don't choose what they pay for, they pay for what Netflix chooses. This is the same model as every content provider in Canada, which is why Netflix needs to abide by the same laws.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by lucisferre on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:33PM (#8362409)
I can see how you're not understanding why people don't agree with you, but it's because you are twisting the meaning of words to suit your case. There are no "channels" on Netflex.

A more accurate description would be: There is a limited library of content that Netflix licences and you can pick and choose what you watch from that library. This is, for the most part, nothing like existing broadcasters who have finite channels which have finite scheduling space. Thus when CanCon rules state X% of that space must be Canadian it has a clear meaning.

With Netflix, I suppose they could require that X% of the library be Canadian shows, but that seems pretty arbitrary.

In the end this is another example of how much the CRTC panders to the existing broadcast industry in Canada. Much as they did when people tried to subscribe to US satellite television providers. It is protectionism at best, corporate pandering at worst.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by ay on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @05:08AM (#8360484)
Is the parent comment a sarcasm ?

If not - then it's completely incorrect description of how Netflix works. They have one month for free - so you can check for yourself how exactly it functions, before commenting.

(disclaimer: I'm a happy streaming-only Netflix user for several years, and I do not own a TV, my cable subscription is internet-only).

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by Mikeb85 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @10:02AM (#8361452)
I've used Netflix... You've given no example or explanation whatsoever of how I'm wrong.
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by delinka on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @11:18AM (#8361930)
What are these "channels" of which you speak? I choose specific episodes of specific shows that I want to watch. There are no "channels," no curated collections that just serially stream various episodes of varied shows.

Please explain how a user of Netflix chooses a "channel" and receives the streaming content of said channel without the need to continue to select content to watch.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by Mikeb85 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:30PM (#8362390)
Each show is essentially the same as a channel. BTW, the current incumbents also have Netflix-like services. Which are subject to CRTC rules...
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by delinka on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @07:05PM (#8364663)
The current incumbents are indeed broadcasters - they broadcast on radio frequency spectrum their selection of episodes from a variety of shows. And yes, they have features similar to Netflix. No amount of logic dictates that such features offered by others automatically drags Netflix into the "broadcaster" categorization. Taking such logic further would bring bloggers into the "broadcaster" category should the incumbent broadcasters begin blogging themselves.

Each show is not "essentially the same" as a channel. A channel is a curation of related content (by the curator's definition of 'related.') Obtaining a collection of all episodes of a series and making them available for customers to play on demand is pretty much the opposite of curation, in my opinion.

So I'm still not seeing how Netflix is a broadcaster by any existing definition of the term.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by ay on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @02:14PM (#8363103)
Hit "search", search for "Rain man", watch the movie.

How is this a "channel" ?

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by ende on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @04:01AM (#8360346)
Wrong.
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by Mikeb85 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @04:22AM (#8360391)
Why? Because internet, right...
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by wyager on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @07:37PM (#8359019)
>In fact, we need quite a bit of laws and regulations to ensure an open internet.

Patently false in theory and extremely debatable in practic.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by abandonliberty on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @09:03PM (#8359355)
Maybe we have different definitions of open. For me that includes freedom of speech and net neutrality.

These things don't exist unless you make laws to protect them.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by wyager on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @02:23AM (#8360155)
> For me that includes freedom of speech and net neutrality. > These things don't exist unless you make laws to protect them.

Net neutrality? Maybe. You could argue that network provision is a natural monopoly and therefore needs regulation to keep it "fair".

Free speech? Absolutely not. There is no sensible way a law can make the internet freer (as in speech) than it is in the absence of law. Right now, any lack of free speech on the internet is directly due to laws. Please explain your reasoning.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by abandonliberty on Thursday September 25, 2014 @10:52PM (#8371095)
You are correct, pure anarchy can provide the freest speech - until it causes retribution. Pure anarchy isn't great for society, so we have a of laws that trade speech for social benefit. Patent, copyright, criminal, civil. Granted, many of these are broken. I would propose that anarchy is a very undesirable state, so we need laws to protect free speech.

Honestly, my heart goes very quickly to democratic free speech. And it's not the same thing. We only had it for a short period of time - the wealthy now have more speech again. Can you really have a democracy when speech isn't democratic?

Net neutrality: It's more complex than a monopolistic problem. I would suggest you look more into it.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by wyager on Friday September 26, 2014 @02:06AM (#8371552)
>my heart goes very quickly to democratic free speech.

Democratic "free speech" isn't free. Democracy implies the majority can vote to silence the minority.

The only speech that is truly free is anarchic, where no one can preclude anyone else from speech. That is why the internet, with its lack of hierarchy, is a particularly good vehicle for free speech.

I don't care much for IP, so we may disagree there. I think any system that relies on violent coercion to (try to) incentivize production is undesirable.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by NolF on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:16PM (#8359726)
No, that is incorrect, you do not need laws to protect "freedom of speech". In fact it is very easy to go from a law that "protects" freedom of speech to one which limits it. E.g. You can say whatever you want as long as...

The net neutrality issue is largely due to government granted monopolies and subsidies during the internet revolution era of the dotcom days. Now you have to content with monoliths and a very high barrier to entry by competition.

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by sha90 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @03:11AM (#8360255)
Oh the irony of this comment given that the very first amendment to the US constitution is a law protecting "freedom of speech". You know, the one that everyone talks about being so important and necessary for the American way of life.
Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by wyager on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @12:05PM (#8362204)
>the very first amendment to the US constitution is a law protecting "freedom of speech"

The same constitution that is regularly ignored and shit on as part of standard practice?

The constitution doesn't mean anything if the government doesn't follow it.

We also don't need a government to tell us we have free speech on the internet; we have that by default. The only thing governments have the power to do on the internet is damage free speech (which they have done with great consistency).

Re:Netflix refuses CRTC demand to hand over subscriber data by DavidAdams on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @08:39PM (#8359264)
Keep in mind that laws may also exist to inhibit the powers of regulatory agencies. I believe that's what wyager is suggesting.