News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by api on Thursday September 18, 2014 @04:55PM (#8337575)
Everything you cite is in or closely related to the IT sector, which is the exception. Every other sector has gone cold or even backwards since ~1970.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by nostrademons on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:51PM (#8337849)
That's only because you're unaware of innovations that have happened in other sectors and their consequences.

In oil, there've been huge breakthroughs in fracking, horizontal drilling, and oil shale and tar sands mining. As a result, U.S. oil imports have fallen by a third since 2008 [1], and domestic crude oil production is up nearly 50%. We've pulled out of Iraq and Afghanistan because the Middle East is no longer strategically important to us, saving thousands of lives in those wars. Oil is expensive now, but the price is relatively stable, meaning that we can plan ahead for the future (like buying a fuel-efficient car instead of an SUV) instead of being at the whims of global politics.

In finance, it's now possible to get funding for an idea without being a grizzled 30-year veteran of an industry. If you have a creative project or even something plain-old crazy, you can go on Kickstarter and crowd-fund it with pre-orders. Microfinance is commonplace enough that it's driving down returns, and it's lifted millions of people out of poverty in the developing world. You can accept credit card payments with just an iPad.

In education, you can take courses online with world-leading professors at elite universities, all without leaving your living room or paying tuition.

In travel, you can take virtual tours of places you might want to visit on your computer, map out on itinerary, read reviews, and book flights, hotel rooms, and activities within minutes, again all without leaving your living room. I'm just old enough to remember travel agents. Remember when you had to drive to meet one, have only a vague idea of what country you wanted to see, take the options they give you because you don't know what else is available, and pay through the nose for all of it? The first Google-assisted trip I took, back in 2004, was a revelation, and that was before Maps or StreetView or smartphones or Kayak or Yelp or the universal ability to book things online.

Most of the time when I hear folks say "Things have gotten worse than they used to be", they don't mean "things have gotten worse", they mean "Argh, things have changed and I don't know how anything works anymore and what's my place in the world and how will I support myself and everybody else seems to be doing better than me!" Much of which is an illusion, because everybody else is equally insecure about their prospects and place in the world. But the opportunities are out there, and objectively speaking, we are so much, much better off than we were when I was a kid in the 80s.

[1] http://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/pet_move_impcus_a2_nus_ep00_im0_...

[2] http://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/pet_crd_crpdn_adc_mbbl_a.htm

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by frandroid on Thursday September 18, 2014 @06:15PM (#8337965)
> We've pulled out of Iraq and Afghanistan because the Middle East is no longer strategically important to us

I think the U.S. pulled out of these two wars because they were stupid in the first place and became fiscally unstrategic at a straggering scale... Like we could have paid for Kyoto worldwide with that kind of money. Just washed down the drain, and we're not done dealing with the geopolitical costs, not to mention the human costs.

Also, Afghanistan is in Central Asia.

I agree with the rest of your point on oil innovation, even if it's just driving us faster towards the next anoxic event...

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by foobarqux on Thursday September 18, 2014 @06:40PM (#8338073)
The US pulled out once they thought they had installed stable vassal governments.

Moreover, the US will try to gain control over energy resources in the Middle East long after US energy independence: They remain valuable as a means of influence against countries that rely on externally sourced energy.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by rpedela on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:16PM (#8337675)
There has been plenty of innovation.

When mature, electric vehicles mean the cost of fuel is essentially zero. Whenever there has a been a massive drop in energy costs, there has also been an economic boom. Electric vehicles also mean no more air pollution from vehicles which means a healthier population and fewer medical bills. Then you have the whole AI thing which promises to drastically reduce, if not eliminate, accidents as well as reduce traffic congestion.

SpaceX is getting pretty damn close to a reusable rocket which will drastically reduce the cost of entering orbit. If that happens, then it is likely that space will become a viable market for private enterprise: tourism, mining, etc.

There is a lot of work going on in energy including some designs for fusion that should be commercially viable. I don't know what is going to happen with energy, but there are way too many people working on it for nothing significant to happen in the near future.

In healthcare, it seems like every few days I am reading about a person being cured of blindness with stem cells, growing or 3D printing an organ in a lab, or some new insight into how the body ages.

I could keep going, but I am tired of typing letters. The point is that "Every other sector has gone cold or even backwards since ~1970" is a false statement.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by jacinda on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:37PM (#8337777)
I find it interesting that the three areas you highlight are all areas that Elon Musk has companies in.

Electric Vehicles = Tesla Motors

SpaceX you mentioned by name

Energy = SolarCity

It would be interesting to contrast Peter Thiel's views on modern innovation with Elon Musk's.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by dragonwriter on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:20PM (#8337700)
> When mature, electric vehicles mean the cost of fuel is essentially zero. Whenever there has a been a massive drop in energy costs, there has also been an economic boom.

But the first sentence is wrong -- it only means the cost of energy for a vehicle is equal to the cost of the same energy on the electric grid, plus the cost of wear on the onboard storage system (battery, etc.)

Unless your definition of "mature" for electric vehicles includes existing in a world where energy costs on the electric grid are essentially zero (which is a whole lot bigger of an advance than electric vehicles, and applies a lot more broadly!), mature electric vehicle technology doesn't mean that the energy cost for vehicles in essentially zero, either.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by rpedela on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:30PM (#8337744)
> plus the cost of wear on the onboard storage system (battery, etc.)

That falls under vehicle maintenance and does not play into the cost of fuel.

> it only means the cost of energy for a vehicle is equal to the cost of the same energy on the electric grid

Yes, I was exaggerating but it is already pretty cheap. If memory serves, it is about $0.08/kWh in the US or $6.80 to charge Tesla's largest battery pack which is way cheaper than $40-60 per gasoline tank. And if you extrapolate a little, that cost is going to go down by the time electric vehicles are mature because the literal energy cost should be less and electric vehicles should be more efficient. But maybe I am wrong about that, only time will tell.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by dragonwriter on Thursday September 18, 2014 @06:23PM (#8337994)
> > > plus the cost of wear on the onboard storage system (battery, etc.)

> That falls under vehicle maintenance and does not play into the cost of fuel.

Whenever you talk about "fuel" with an electric vehicle, you are doing so by loose analogy; the battery electrolytes are the closest thing to "fuel" in an electric vehicle. I suppose one could quibble over the degree to which the battery is analogous to the "fuel tank" vs. part of the "fuel", the main point, in any case, is that even the electricity isn't even approximately zero cost.

> Yes, I was exaggerating but it is already pretty cheap. If memory serves, it is about $0.08/kWh

Which is equivalent (by GGE [1]) to $2.67/gallon of gasoline, which, while lower than current gasoline prices, is so by less than factor of 2, so its an incremental improvement improvement, not the kind of orders-of-magnitude implied by "essentially zero", even allowing for a bit of artistic exaggeration.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_gallon_equivalent

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by asdf11111 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @07:45PM (#8338306)
Unless I'm mistaken you're glossing over the fact that electric motors are significantly more efficient than combustion engines. An electric motor doesn't turn more than half of all the energy in the batteries into heat.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by seanflyon on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:30PM (#8337742)
"essentially zero" is an exaggeration, but electric cars are dramatically cheaper to fuel. They use much less energy and the energy they use is in a much cheaper form (electricity vs gasoline).
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by barney54 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:07PM (#8338823)
But electrics are much more expensive and are less flexible than gasoline powered cars. That's why sales of electrics have stalled at less than 4% of the market.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by seanflyon on Friday September 19, 2014 @01:23PM (#8341420)
Sales of electric cars have not stalled, they are growing rapidly. They are also a very small segment of the market but as price drops and range increases that will cease to be the case.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by joeclark77 on Friday September 19, 2014 @01:16AM (#8339092)
Well, that, and the fact that they spontaneously burst into flame from time to time.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by dllthomas on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:24PM (#8337712)
I agree with your point, but I think an interesting aspect is that a shift toward pushing our transportation energy through the grid might (maybe) lead to some additional economies of scale that could bring down energy costs more broadly. That said, there might instead be diseconomies of scale that dominate - so certainly not a sure thing.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by dragonwriter on Thursday September 18, 2014 @06:26PM (#8338008)
> I think an interesting aspect is that a shift toward pushing our transportation energy through the grid might (maybe) lead to some additional economies of scale that could bring down energy costs more broadly.

I do think that both the economies of scale that this involves and the fact that it makes the shift to alternative (whether "cheaper" or "cleaner" or both) fuels one that involves changing grid inputs without requiring changes to vehicles, fueling infrastructure (once you have the electric charging infrastructure in place), etc., are big gains.

When I was dismissing the idea that electric vehicles had a near-zero energy cost, I wasn't intending to dismiss the idea that electric vehicles offer some real opportunities for improvement.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by notahacker on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:40PM (#8337788)
>Everything you cite is in or closely related to the IT sector, which is the exception. Every other sector has gone cold or even backwards since ~1970

Sure, the IT sector has enabled pretty much everything since the 1970s, including most of the world having a telephone in their pocket, and developments like with massive transformative potential like encoding human genomes.

But that's like writing off the Industrial Revolution as being a time entirely unremarkable but for developments "in or closely related to the mechanical engineering sector"

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by k__ on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:08PM (#8337637)
But I got the feeling that the other sectors need IT for advancement.

IT just has to get on a level that it's full power can be used by everyone.

Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by pillowpants2 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:13PM (#8337659)
Self-Driving would classify under transportation.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by baddox on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:34PM (#8337760)
Do you consider self-driving cars to be in or closely related to the IT sector?
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by scottlocklin on Thursday September 18, 2014 @05:45PM (#8337812)
I consider "self driving cars" as not existing the corporeal world.
Re:Why Is Peter Thiel Pessimistic About Technological Innova... by baddox on Friday September 19, 2014 @03:17AM (#8339302)
But that's the only thing cited in dicroce's comment, and api said "Everything you cite is in or closely related to the IT sector, which is the exception."

Also, self driving cars certainly exist in the corporeal world.