News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by gliese1337 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:02PM (#8327351)
You can probably guess it from context, but I had to look this up to be sure, so for the benefit of others: assortative mating is when you have kids with other people similar to you, rather than selecting mates randomly. In other words, in this case, people with high intelligence tend to marry other people with high intelligence, and people with low intelligence marry other people with low intelligence. This causes the variance in the distribution of intelligence to steadily increase, rather than everybody evening out over a few generations.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by eastbayjake on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:26PM (#8327470)
Assortative mating -- among other things -- was one of the "problems" identified by Charles Murray in his book Coming Apart as a cause of greater inequality in American society[1]. As people "stick to their own kind", there are fewer opportunities for both economic and cognitive mobility: in the past, when marriage was determined by other factors, it was more likely that a highly intelligent person might have children with a much less intelligent person. That's increasingly no longer the case.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/12/books/review/charles-murra...

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by matoffk on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:30PM (#8327484)
Interesting, but assortative mating is not a new phenomenon in the history of mankind. If anything, its impact has probably decreased significantly over the past centuries and decades. This makes it more difficult to take such explanations for growing income inequality at face value.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by eastbayjake on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:53PM (#8327565)
Let's put it this way: a "meritocratic" society has made intelligence inextricable from wealth and power in a way that was not true 100 years ago or earlier. If you were very smart in 1900, whether you worked in a factory or ran the factory was determined by your family's wealth and influence, and that also determined your pool of available mates. So instead of having a society where people practice assortative mating based on non-hereditary factors (wealth and power) people are mating based on intelligence and passing it onto their children. (I suppose familiar wealth and power is "hereditary" to a degree, but not with the durability of intelligence.)
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by eastbayjake on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:18PM (#8327651)
> Are the U.S. economy and society more meritocratic than they were 100 years ago?

I think this question is more fuzzy at the 100-year time scale than the 200, 500, or 1000-year scale. It seems fairly uncontroversial that "merit" (whether by pure intelligence or some other metric for skill) had little to do with your station in life in 1514.

> The value of specific cognitive skills varies over time.

True. We should be careful not to anachronistically apply meritocratic assumptions about intelligence to other eras where raw intelligence and mental flexibility was less important than domain knowledge and practiced skill. But can we safely say that the Information Age has put a premium on the skills of those with high intelligence, and the benefits accruing to those workers over the last 50-60 years has skewed the mating priorities of many?

> There is far more to capability than intelligence. For example, there are very smart people who, due to lack of emotional or interpersonal skills, don't produce much.

Also true. Murray is careful to note that when we speak about meritocracy or the hereditary impact of intelligence, we can really only generalize about groups -- it can be wildly inaccurate for individuals. Can we safely say that the Harvard Class of 2014 as a group will have greater economic value over the course of their lives than the Anytown Junior College Class of 2014?

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by hackuser on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:03PM (#8327594)
> a "meritocratic" society has made intelligence inextricable from wealth and power in a way that was not true 100 years ago or earlier

An interesting hypothesis.

1) Are the U.S. economy and society more meritocratic than they were 100 years ago? I've seen research saying social mobility has decreased recently (it didn't say about over 100 years) and is lower than in Europe, for example. Also, at least some research says that access to higher education depends significantly on the wealth of your parents; elite universities (and others) have problems attracting and graduating poor, smart students.

2) The value of specific cognitive skills varies over time. If 100 years ago, you had great ability to translate problems into efficient data structures and logic, I'm not sure how much economic value you would have. 50 years from now, I'm not sure how many humans will be writing code.

3) There is far more to capability than intelligence. For example, there are very smart people who, due to lack of emotional or interpersonal skills, don't produce much.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:54PM (#8327915)
Suppose US society was meritocratic, intelligence is highly hereditary, and assortative mating happens. Then you'd expect low social mobility - people will have the same intelligence, and hence the same income, as their parents.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by phkahler on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:18PM (#8327426)
And if a society values intelligence, they should encourage smarter people to reproduce and offer as much birth control as possible to less smart people. Following this line of reasoning and policy is sure to ignite all kinds of flame wars ;-)
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jiggy2011 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:40PM (#8327521)
The problem is that smart people tend to earn more, thus the children tend to cost them more both in terms of opportunity cost (hours away from work) and actual cost (more likely to consider things like private school as essential). To incentive them you would need to start giving already wealthy people quite significant tax breaks etc.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by rcoder on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:11PM (#8327811)
This is the silliest argument for why intelligence would be negatively correlated with number of children. FWIW, the original article very much did not assert that assertion; reproductive success (meaning having any children at all survive the parents) in fact may be positively correlated because the social status of richer/more intelligent parents translates to higher survival rates for their offspring.

Regardless, while the absolute cost of raising children may be higher for high-income families, the share of their total income that represents is much lower. Someone earning minimum wage will struggle to support even one child's basic food, clothing, and shelter; their counterpart making $1M a year could easily afford private school, childcare, and the best possible opportunities for a family of 3-4 children.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jiggy2011 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:25PM (#8327841)
My comment doesn't argue that intelligence is negatively correlated with having children, it argues that it is difficult to incentivise intelligent people to have children. Although looking at figures for 2010 it does seem that there is a negative correlation between income and number of births (at least in the US).

http://www.statista.com/statistics/241530/birth-rate-by-fami...

Survival rate is unlikely to be highly correlated with income in a first world country because even the poor have relatively good healthcare. The group most likely to have children are those earning $10,000 per year or less, probably because at that income level the state will pay most of the costs associated with child rearing. In fact in some cases having children might make a person better off financially due to higher priority for welfare or public housing etc.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by tjradcliffe on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:30PM (#8327682)
There is an interesting and much-neglected corollary to the heritability of intelligence, which is that we are part of the least intelligent generation of humanity that has ever lived.

This follows from the two conditions:

1) intelligence is at least somewhat heritable (empirically true, according to the article)

and

2) intelligence is positively correlated with reproductive success (plausible give humans seem to have been selected for it)

The conclusion follows from the way world population has exploded in the past 250 years, increasing roughly ten-fold in twenty or twenty-five generations. That increase equates to "zero selective pressure": basically anybody could breed successfully, and they did (including my ancestors, some of whom occupied the more stagnant and brackish depths of the gene pool...)

So up until 1750 or so intelligence was being selected for, generation after generation. After that time, there was no pressure and the many small effects that this article documents as underlying the heritability of intelligence (with no single gene showing as much as a 1% effect on the overall outcome) would happily carry us all on a random walk across the landscape, creating engineers in some parts and political partisans in others.

This realization makes particularly funny the various organizations that have at times promoted Nobelists etc as pinnacles of intelligence (William Shockly, inventor of the transistor, was heavily involved in this kind of thing). Nobelists are certainly bright, but it seems more likely you'd find the most intelligent people amongst still-extant stone age tribes, whose pre-industrial life-style would still subject them to selective pressures long released in the more-developed world.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:42PM (#8327710)
> Nobelists are certainly bright, but it seems more likely you'd find the most intelligent people amongst still-extant stone age tribes, whose pre-industrial life-style would still subject them to selective pressures long released in the more-developed world.

This conclusion is only justifiable if (1) the population of "stone age tribes" and the part of the world where those selective pressures have been released (because people are indivisible units beyond a certain point), and (2) if intelligence was fully determined by genetics rather than merely having some heritable component.

If there are important environmental factors in intelligence to which modern technology can positively contributed, and there are a lot more people living with modern technology, then its quite possible that the mean, median, and max realized intelligence would be higher in the modern part of the world than in "stone age tribes", even if the latter have more genetic benefit from pro-intelligence selective pressure and thus a higher mean/median genetic intelligence capacity.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:50PM (#8327743)
Stone age tribes select for more than just intelligence, as a smart guy you might be an advisor to the tribe leader but the tribe leader was most probably a medium smart very bulky fellow.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jostmey on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:06PM (#8327793)
Reminds me of the recent study where Chimps beat humans in a simple strategy game.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by vikiomega9 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:40PM (#8328045)
Do you remember the name?
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:38PM (#8327513)
It's called eugenics and it's very bad. At the very least it suffers from this self-referential craziness that nearly guarantees bad results.

People are economically unproductive because the economy slowly gets more and more hostile to more and more people. Tyler Cowan and others call this problem "Zero Marginal Product Workers".

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by fizixer on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:24PM (#8327460)
And it sure did ignite flame wars and the topic is not openly pursued anymore in scientific circles, regardless of how objective it might be.

Luckily we don't have to go there. Technology is going to be the great equalizer, and might end up offering you off-the-shelf intelligence upgrade (I'm talking about a time-frame of next 30-80 years).

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:41PM (#8327523)
So long as people have to compete in the workplace, then the resulting equilibrium from everybody having an artificially extended intelligence will probably be ( according to Arnold Kling ) like the Vickies and Thetes in Neal Stephenson's "The Diamond Age".
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by nesyt on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:32PM (#8327685)
I've never read that, what is the resulting equilibrium?
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by JetSpiegel on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:57PM (#8327763)
Let's just say endings are not Stephenson's strong point.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:04PM (#8327788)
I have yet to read it myself :)

Dr. Kling is using the book as a template/metaphor more than as a specific proscriptive. But I've seen this myself in the wind as various crises have held forth since 1973 ( when I was first old enough to ask questions about what was going on ).

http://www.arnoldkling.com/blog/vickies-and-thetes/

http://www.arnoldkling.com/blog/experts-surveyed-on-the-futu...

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by defen on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:38PM (#8327701)
> the topic is not openly pursued anymore in scientific circles

http://edge.org/response-detail/23838

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by Ygg2 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:06PM (#8327794)
I'm not sure IQ is really that great in the grand scheme of things. Don't get me wrong it's good, but IQ wouldn't help us much if managed to screw the environment beyond our ability to repair it.

Also that article reeks of alarmism.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by sfbsfbsfb on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:52PM (#8327559)
I first saw this concept in the context of intelligence in "The Bell Curve" by Richard J. Herrnstein and Charles Murray (1996). They suggested the process is accelerating dramatically with development of situations that make it easier for intelligent people to find each other: the movement of the population from the farm to cities, higher education, improved communications and less restricted travel. I would not be surprised if online dating sites are also playing a role. Once you start thinking about this in the context of genetics, matings and the potential for a survival advantage and increased quality of life leading to further segregation you wonder if this does not have the potential to eventually result in the development of a new species?! I would be interesting to know if the IQ "density" is significantly altered in certain communities in northern California, Boston, NY, etc. associated with industries selecting for high IQ workers. [Edit]Just amused myself thinking of the Silicon Valley crew as participants in a breeding experiment.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:47PM (#8327727)
Species are not 'developed'. They come into being because of isolation and sufficient time passing.

Even all the breeding done with dogs has not resulted in speciation.

The time scales are vast and the degree of separation that a barrier such as 'intelligence' (for whatever definition you wish to employ) will provide will be insufficient to cause this to happen.

No Elois and Morlocks in our future through that avenue.

Think about it: if geographic separation and very long spans of time have not been enough then why would a mere trait be enough, we have plenty of examples of the former.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by perrylaj on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:17PM (#8327822)
It's certainly possible if you factor in the social and geographic trends and take them to extreme conclusions. It's merely reproductive separation that is required. Whether this be due to geography, climate, mating calls or unattractive IQ isn't really of import. I'll agree that right now the barrier isn't sufficient enough, but I don't think that is what OP was saying (could be wrong).

That said, your point about the time scales is definitely on mark. It would take a long time and likely far more significant isolation than present (don't have numbers). Genetic engineering could speed that up substantially.

Of course social factors would likely prohibit any talk about separate species. From a pure biologist perspective there are many different animal species fully capable of reproducing but are speciated because their natural breeding behavior (or location) doesn't support interbreeding. Using the same measure/definition, one could objectively argue that uncontacted tribes and isolated peoples are a different 'species'.

I personally think scientists need to agree on some fundamental genetic/epigenetic (maybe even microbiomic) markers of speciation and move away from more subjective definitions. Reproductive potential makes sense when looking at speciation likelihood, but I am not sure it makes sense as a definition of different species.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:25PM (#8327843)
Being able to interbreed is the very definition of a species.

So if two specimen are capable of breeding and the resulting offspring is not sterile they are considered to be of the same species.

Being from an un-contacted tribe has nothing whatsoever to do with speciation.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by perrylaj on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @11:47PM (#8328481)
That's actually not the definition used in biology. Simple example: The entire genus Amphiprion (aka anemonefish) are speciated due to appearance and regional locality. They can and do interbreed when introduced into each others populations, and have fertile offspring that are mixed species. They are declared species due to their appearance, and their natural range's prevention of interbreeding. That said, there are areas where some ranges overlap and it's not uncommon that one species mates with another and has hybrid offspring.

Being genetically capable of interbreeding makes sense as a definition of speciation, but that is not how species are currently identified. Natural range, aesthetics, and more than that, whether or not they DO interbreed in the wild (vs physically/genetically capable) play a more significant role in determining species.

There are many 'hybrid' species in nature, which is what I feel warrants some revision, perhaps using genetic data to restructure many classifications as subspecies rather than independent species.

edit: Sorry, I think I may have misinterpreted what you said to some extent and think we generally agree. I will maintain that according to the classification methods described, people such as the Sentinelese, may well be considered a separate species to an unbiased observer using the same guidelines we apply to other animals due to slightly different physical characteristics and social/geographical reproductive isolation prevents the possibility of breeding with anyone outside of their group.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:04PM (#8327945)
Being able to interbreed is the very definition of a species.

It isn't, and cannot be. The relation A interbreeds with B is not transitive.

Larus Gulls originated in Finland and spread west, evolving as they moved. Eventually some of them reached England. The Finnish ones breed with the Russian ones, Russian with Canadian, Canadian with English, but the English don't breed with the Finnish.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:09PM (#8327964)
Sure. And that's just the spatial variety. There is also the temporal variety of that same phenomenon.

If a 3 million year old ancestor would suddenly pop out of nowhere into our midst chances are that we're far enough removed for interbreeding to be impossible and yet, we were able to breed at every intermediary stage just fine.

But for all normal everyday intents and purposes that definition holds up just fine. It's when you start to zoom in on what a species really is that it becomes more nebulous until you realize that all there is is individuals and their breeding capabilities.

Species are a phenomenon that is observed rather than one that actually exists.

Fascinating stuff.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by sfbsfbsfb on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:02PM (#8327785)
It does not seem hard for me to contemplate the possibility that modern humans are primarily defined by our intelligence and that our closest relatives had less of it. Of course, as you point out, these developments occur over the course of perhaps hundreds of thousands of generations.It also seems pretty clear that catastrophes that dramatically reduce population sizes may also play a significant role in the process. Survivors of a catastrophe are likely to be geographically localized. The catastrophe eliminates gene pools and, by chance, selects for small subsets of the previously existing pool. Wash, rinse, repeat. And in a cosmic heartbeat....you have something different than what you started with.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:13PM (#8327817)
Such catastrophes would have to do a better job of isolating people than they've been doing so far. Humanity is remarkably similar from a genetic perspective when taken as a species. I don't think your theory stands much chance unless you're willing to go interplanetary or inter-stellar. On planet earth we are remarkably mobile, to the point where if we lose all shipping ability and even knowledge of other civilizations that we'll likely re-discover all this from first principles within at most a few thousand years.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by sfbsfbsfb on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:28PM (#8327850)
I was thinking "catastrophe" as in a wipe out the dinosaurs asteroid hit or a global pandemic that takes out 95% of the population (think Ebola)or an EMP event that results civilization collapse, etc. So if Silicon Valley residents are the only survivors (god help us :-)and there is a higher IQ density there than other locations and if IQ is really significantly genetic, then the average IQ of humans has increased and can be maintained in the population. Other pockets of survivors would have an IQ density similar to that present in the general population existing before the catastrophe and based on our hypothetical case, lower than that in Silicon Valley. It is the geographic isolation and geographic concentration of a particular genetic trait that makes this type of selection possible.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by jacquesm on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:40PM (#8327882)
What makes you feel that the average IQ of Silicon Valley might be higher than say Beijing, Tokyo, Adelaide or Moscow?
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by sfbsfbsfb on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:41PM (#8328050)
Nothing. I was just using an example of which I had some familiarity. In the context of this hypothetical thread, it is interesting to note that there is apparently some scientific data suggesting that Asians have a slightly higher IQ than other races. Not being an expert I can't readily provide the references. The other reason for using Silicon Valley as an example is that the theoretical we are discussing requires a survivor population that has a higher IQ density than the average population. The larger the sampling the closer the IQ density approaches average. Although I guess the argument would still hold for a city or country. I was just thinking that the difference in IQ density between Silicon Vally and California as a whole might be 20 points while the difference between China and the US might be 2 points.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by ap22213 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:04PM (#8327948)
Unfortunately for us, it seems that the more 'evolved' we get, the smaller our brains get:

http://www.npr.org/2011/01/02/132591244/our-brains-are-shrin...

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by gliese1337 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:08PM (#8327611)
Having now learned the terminology, assortative mating could indeed lead to speciation in the general case; it's just a special case of sexual selection. I find it highly unlikely that that will happen with human intelligence, though (despite the fact that it's been used in fiction more than once). The reason is that there's a limit to how big the variance can get- it doesn't grow forever, it grows until limited by other factors (i.e., there are only so many intelligence-promoting alleles that you can possibly have).

It would take intentional segregation to cut off all gene flow between the upper and lower halves of the intelligence Bell curve, thus allowing other differences to pile up between the populations, to cause speciation. And as noted elsethread, that's called eugenics and generally frowned upon in polite society.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by clarkm on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @02:13AM (#8328781)
> The reason is that there's a limit to how big the variance can get- it doesn't grow forever, it grows until limited by other factors (i.e., there are only so many intelligence-promoting alleles that you can possibly have).

What makes you think that? You could say the same thing about seed size in plants, but comparing modern corn kernels to wild type seeds provides a clear counterexample.

You should look at the type of stuff they've done in plants and animals. Here's a paper on the selective breeding of fruit flies for flight speed. The results are astounding:

"The mean apparent flying speed of both lines increased from approximately 2 to 170 cm/sec and continued to respond at diminishing rates, without reaching a plateau, for 100 generations. Competitive fitness tests in generations 50 and 85 showed minimal or no fitness loss in selected lines compared to controls."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8878686

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by sfbsfbsfb on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:20PM (#8327658)
Interestingly, the current mating and segregation trends, to the extent they exist, appear to be completely "natural" and lacking in premeditation. Can't help but wonder if modern humans are not the result of a process that left the Neanderthals ( pre-modern humans, whoever they were) behind. I'm no expert, but I don't think a complete lack of gene flow between groups is thought to be required for the process of speciation.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by eru on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:43PM (#8327885)
Neanderthals at least had bigger brains than modern humans.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by cle on Thursday September 18, 2014 @12:07PM (#8335954)
From a cursory glance at this post, I don't see how your conclusion follows. I'd believe it if I saw the model and some data that supports it. It depends on how populations along the intelligence distribution reproduce, and what the variance of intelligence is of offspring along the continuum. If everyone reproduces at the same rate, and the intelligence variance of offspring is constant across the population, then I would expect the intelligence distribution of the overall population to remain the same. It seems like, given those constraints (which may or may not be true), the variance would remain the same--neither evening out nor diverging.

Let me know if I'm mistaken...honestly I've only read part of the article and I only have a lay understanding of this stuff.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by fossuser on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:50PM (#8327742)
I would suspect that physical looks/features would throw a wrench into this - or at least correct things a bit.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by peripitea on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:08PM (#8327801)
I don't follow. How would that affect this phenomenon? Given that the cited correlation refers strictly to intelligence, looks (and for that matter, all other factors) are presumably already accounted for.
Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by fossuser on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @08:28PM (#8327854)
It was more a response to the parent comment. I was suggesting that an intelligent person may choose a mate that's less intelligent because they're prettier which would help resist some of the divergence.

They mention assortative mating is greater for intelligence compared to physical aspects like height and weight, but 'prettiness' is a more subjective harder to quantify measure that I would guess plays a larger role in mate selection than just height and weight. This is ignoring the fact that height and weight are probably opposite anyway (women wanting taller men, men wanting shorter women) - so there are some issues there too.

Re:Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings by trhway on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:59PM (#8327774)
yep, until gap becomes too big so the species divergence begins as physical looks/features play role for both processes - help keep a species together as well as to help distinguish between subspecies once the divergence has started thus speeding up the divergence.