News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by bennesvig on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:02PM (#8311126)
It's bizarre that it's legal to fly a drone/quadcopter as a hobby, but not if you charge for the services. If there were laws about flying above a certain height or over people in well populated areas, that would make more sense than just banning commercial use.

There are going to be a lot of drone-based businesses soon. I got a DJI Phantom 2 last month and have been amazed at the quality of footage that it can capture with a GoPro. The learning curve is much easier than hand-held stabilizers I've used, like the Glidecam.

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by bigiain on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:05PM (#8311423)
I don't think it's "bizarre" at all - getting paid _fundamentally_ changes things.

Although the "ban commercial use completely" approach is a pretty big hammer to use - as a hobbyist RC pilot who's flown with a camera aboard for some time (http://bigiain.com/Mini-Swift-RC-plane) I've had _many_ requests to take photos/video for other people, many of whom have offered money for it, and almost _all_ of which would require me to make safety compromises that I probably wouldn't choose to make "just doing it for kicks". And the more money on offer, the more tempting it is and the bigger the risks that might get taken.

While _I_ think the risks I take flying that plane in the linked video are reasonable (it weighs ~125g all up, and puts a maximum of about 55W into spinning the prop), I've seen people fly multicopters weighing over 6kg with eight 2000W motors spinning 14inch carbon fiber props in _way_ more public and crowded places than that. I certainly wouldn't choose to do that. And Youtube is full of clips which make me say "Really? You chose to do _that_ _there_? Are you insane?"

I think the "easier learning curve" on things like DJI's gear, coupled with it's accessible price - but _also_ coupled with a bunch of people who either haven't thought through the possible consequences, don't care about the consequences, or who think the money they're making means the risk is worth taking - will inevitably lead to bad decisions being made.

On the more optimistic side, at least _some_ places (here in Australia, for example), it seems like the authorities (CASA in my case) are trying to take account of the differing nature of different "drones", and at least proposing a graduated approach - a sub 500g craft probably isn't going to need to abide by the came rules as a 6kg+ one. (And, if the lower-bound in their current ruleset stays, sub 100g craft will be classified still as "toys" and not covered by these rules.)

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by lotsofmangos on Saturday September 13, 2014 @09:03AM (#8312253)
If you will drop your own safety standards for money, that isn't a problem with drones.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by ams6110 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:10PM (#8313246)
Where did he say he would? He said getting paid changes things for many people, and many people will take stupid risks either with their own safety or that of others if there is a paycheck in it. And I don't think one can reasonably say that isn't true.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by locusm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:20AM (#8311628)
Ive heard through a friend of a friend that CASA charges around $5K to certify a quad for flying commercially plus you need to pass your PPL theory exam.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by baddox on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:21PM (#8311449)
> many of whom have offered money for it, and almost _all_ of which would require me to make safety compromises that I probably wouldn't choose to make "just doing it for kicks".

And because of that, you're advocating that all commercial drone usage be prohibited? To me, that doesn't follow.

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by ams6110 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:12PM (#8313253)
He didn't advocate that at all.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by dragonwriter on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:19PM (#8311310)
> It's bizarre that it's legal to fly a drone/quadcopter as a hobby, but not if you charge for the services.

It is also legal to have sex as a hobby, but not -- in (most of) the U.S., and much of the rest of the world -- if you charge for the services.

Actually, there are a lot of things that are legal to do if you aren't charging for a service, but illegal, or at least much more tightly regulated, if you are charging for a service.

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by Wingman4l7 on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:47PM (#8311387)
Brewing beer or wine also comes to mind.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by baddox on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:22PM (#8311450)
I oppose all those instances.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by Yardlink on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:09AM (#8311684)
Cooking too? Food safety has bigger risks if you're making 10000 donuts than 1. Restricting everyone equally would put an unreasonable burden on everyday life. Scale is a big reason why there's a difference. Unrestricted commercial drone flights would be much more common than hobby, and would therefore cause much more accidents.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by baddox on Saturday September 13, 2014 @05:07AM (#8311928)
Scale is completely separate from the legal ban of commercial drone operations. I can legally build a dozen quadcopters with 26" propellers and set them flying formations for fun. I cannot legally charge $5 to take extremely low quality photos of a field with a 20 gram.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by dragonwriter on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:24AM (#8312444)
> Scale is completely separate from the legal ban of commercial drone operations.

Its actually not. While the limit on commercial application doesn't directly limit scale, there is a very big difference in the overall expected scale when something can only be done for personal enjoyment vs. when it can be both done for that and for commercial purposes.

One can argue that prohibiting commercial use isn't the most desirable way to influence overall scale, but one cannot -- without willful blindness -- argue that banning commercial use has no impact on expected overall scale, even if it does nothing to directly limit either overall scale or the scale of any particular operation.

> I can legally build a dozen quadcopters with 26" propellers and set them flying formations for fun.

Yes, but how many people will vs. how many will when they can do it for fun or profit?

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by baddox on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:06PM (#8313235)
> there is a very big difference in the overall expected scale when something can only be done for personal enjoyment vs. when it can be both done for that and for commercial purposes.

That only serves as an argument for regulating large scale drone operations (commercial or not). It doesn't work as an argument for prohibiting all commercial drone operations regardless of scale.

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by dragonwriter on Monday September 15, 2014 @11:25AM (#8319426)
Its not about the scale of an individual drone operation, its about the aggregate scale of all drone operations when commercial operations are allowed vs. when they are not.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by kourt on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:35PM (#8311359)
It's very typical to more strictly regulate commercial use of the sky than non-commercial. For human aviators, the progression in licenses is Private Pilot (cannot even charge passengers more than their pro-rata share of expenses), Commercial Pilot (can get paid for banner towing, crop dusting, and aerial photography), and Airline Transport Pilot. Aircraft themselves are subject to increasing regulatory burdens regarding maintenance intervals and documentation depending on whether they are for private use (Part 91), Part 135 (charter), or Part 121 (airline).

In broadcasting, amateur radio operators ("hams") are allowed to use the airwaves much more easily than commercial broadcasters.

Perhaps this principle does not translate perfectly to drone operations, but the general goal seems to be to protect both individual liberty and consumers of for-profit service providers.

(Note that contrary to political rhetoric "government regulation hurts business", the viability of the airline industry depends on safety standards: the market has to be larger than "hardcore daredevils" to justify a fleet of 737's.)

Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by notatoad on Friday September 12, 2014 @11:29PM (#8311563)
if the goal of the commercial use ban is to simply limit the number of things flying around the sky, it makes perfect sense. as soon as you allow drones to be used for commercial purposes, the number of them will skyrocket. a couple of hobbyists flying their toys around isn't going to cause problems, the tacocopter lunch rush could be a big problem.
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by johan_larson on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:18AM (#8312182)
You had me at "tacocopter".
Re:Drone-based businesses soar in Canada, as FAA grounds US ... by evanriley on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:32PM (#8311189)
I'm hoping its temporary and a better solution can be found soon. I think most of the fear is the sky being filled with commercial drones, which I think can be solved pretty easily.