News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @06:20PM (#8310791)
It's ironic how much people in the technology industry rail against monopolies, when you think how much of the fundamental technology we depend on today was invented by monopolies.

Point 1. The world of technology as we know it today was invented at Xerox PARC: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PARC_(company)#Accomplishments. The GUI, Ethernet, OOP. What wasn't invented at Xerox was invented at AT&T Bell Labs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_Labs. The transistor, major advances in semiconductors, UNIX, C.

Point 2. PARC existed on the back of Xerox's patent monopoly on copiers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xerox#1970s. Bell Labs existed on the back of the AT&T telephone monopoly.

The government initiated action against both monopolies in the 1970's: forcing Xerox to license its patent portfolio to Japanese competitors, and breaking up AT&T. It's interesting to think about whether these actions were ultimately good or bad for innovation.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by fnordfnordfnord on Friday September 12, 2014 @06:57PM (#8310929)
As sad as it makes me that Bell Labs no longer exists, I am glad that Bell was broken up. If it weren't for that we might still have only half a dozen different colors and two different shapes of telephone (rental only).

It seems that people don't even start to rail against monopolists until long after they've become obnoxious tyrants.

It also seems that there are plenty of other fine inventions in the world that weren't made by the benevolence of some monopolist.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by foobarqux on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:03PM (#8310950)
I think your list overstates the contribution of the private sector in many of those inventions. For example, the (semiconductor) transistor was patented elsewhere before IBM invented the way to produce it. OOP existed before Xerox Smalltalk.

And while C and UNIX are widely used I don't think they were extremely innovative; they were instances of a class, not a new class itself.

Finally, it is not clear how much state support was given to these labs. At least today, Xerox Parc gets 1/3 of its funding from the government.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:10PM (#8310981)
I don't think the involvement of the state negates the point. The U.S. government is the ultimate monopolist: almost totally insulated from competition. My suspicion is that the R&D sector in the U.S. has evolved into a highly-suitable structure for invention: a broad mix of government subsidy, large corporate monopolies, and small R&D firms.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by foobarqux on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:15PM (#8310994)
If the argument is that companies start research labs because of excess profits then that would be negated by the fact that those labs are largely funded by the government.

And the government is clearly sui generis, you can't compare it to private industry monopolies.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:23PM (#8311016)
I don't think either AT&T nor Xerox PARC were ever "largely funded" by the government.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by Curmudgel on Friday September 12, 2014 @06:42PM (#8310869)
Transistors and semiconductor advances were far more important than UNIX or C. You can't have modern computing without the underlying hardware, but it's not hard to envisage an alternate reality where UNIX or its descendents never became popular.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by prostoalex on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:14PM (#8311156)
There are two types of inventions: obvious and non-obvious ones.

Even if we didn't have Ethernet and OOP, we would end up with some kind of networking protocol and some kind of programming abstraction, as somebody would have come up with it.

Which is very different from discovery of, let's say, penicillin.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:37PM (#8311201)
A quote from Thomas Edison:

> None of my inventions came by accident. I see a worthwhile need to be met and I make trial after trial until it comes. What it boils down to is one per cent inspiration and ninety-nine per cent perspiration.

Inventing Ethernet isn't just a matter of writing down a protocol. Embedded in the simple abstract idea is years of experimentation to figure out how to e.g. detect and handle collissions, etc.

I used to be an engineer at an R&D outfit. You could describe our overall idea in one, somewhat long, sentence. But we spent years thinking and experimenting to work out the details. That's what the inventive process is like.

The reason monopolies are so inventive is because they have the time and money to engage in this slow, expensive process. Companies in perfect competition don't tend to.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by prostoalex on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:41PM (#8311211)
Right, you won't necessarily get a perfect implementation, but then are Ethernet and OOP perfect?

Examples of Betamax and VHS, BluRay and HD-DVD, USB and FireWire show that given market demand a technology can achieve a reasonable degree of development and maturity even without monopolistic environment.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:00PM (#8311256)
Not only might you not get a perfect implementation, you might not even get a viable implementation. When it comes to really novel technology, it can take tremendous investment just to get a technology to the level of viability.

My point isn't that every new technology requires a monopolistic environment. My point is that monopolies (or oligopolies) are particularly good at developing really fundamental new inventions, while competitive markets excel more in making better variants of well-understood technologies. Blu-Ray and HD-DVD were competing optical disc formats, but the original CD was actually a joint-venture by audio giants Sony and Panasonic.

I think a great example is the work Google is doing in self-driving cars. It can afford this sort of blue-sky R&D because of the massive profits thrown off by its advertising business. One day the technology will be mature and you'll see companies compete to refine it and make variations of it, but it will have been Google, using the profits from its near-monopoly on search, that will have done the really fundamental work.