News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by prostoalex on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:41PM (#8311211)
Right, you won't necessarily get a perfect implementation, but then are Ethernet and OOP perfect?

Examples of Betamax and VHS, BluRay and HD-DVD, USB and FireWire show that given market demand a technology can achieve a reasonable degree of development and maturity even without monopolistic environment.

Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:00PM (#8311256)
Not only might you not get a perfect implementation, you might not even get a viable implementation. When it comes to really novel technology, it can take tremendous investment just to get a technology to the level of viability.

My point isn't that every new technology requires a monopolistic environment. My point is that monopolies (or oligopolies) are particularly good at developing really fundamental new inventions, while competitive markets excel more in making better variants of well-understood technologies. Blu-Ray and HD-DVD were competing optical disc formats, but the original CD was actually a joint-venture by audio giants Sony and Panasonic.

I think a great example is the work Google is doing in self-driving cars. It can afford this sort of blue-sky R&D because of the massive profits thrown off by its advertising business. One day the technology will be mature and you'll see companies compete to refine it and make variations of it, but it will have been Google, using the profits from its near-monopoly on search, that will have done the really fundamental work.