Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers
by rayiner on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:10PM
(#8310981)
I don't think the involvement of the state negates the point. The U.S. government is the ultimate monopolist: almost totally insulated from competition. My suspicion is that the R&D sector in the U.S. has evolved into a highly-suitable structure for invention: a broad mix of government subsidy, large corporate monopolies, and small R&D firms.
Re:Peter Thiel: Competition is for losers
by foobarqux on Friday September 12, 2014 @07:15PM
(#8310994)
If the argument is that companies start research labs because of excess profits then that would be negated by the fact that those labs are largely funded by the government.
And the government is clearly sui generis, you can't compare it to private industry monopolies.
And while C and UNIX are widely used I don't think they were extremely innovative; they were instances of a class, not a new class itself.
Finally, it is not clear how much state support was given to these labs. At least today, Xerox Parc gets 1/3 of its funding from the government.