News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by exceptione on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:08PM (#8299811)
I don't quite get it. Normally, both the applicant and the employer take a risk when the latter decides to hire. You could argue that an employer takes the biggest risk.

In this system al the burden and risk is shifted solely on the applicant. So what does he or she gets in return? It's not clear from the article. I would expect that in order to attract applicants they must

- either be desperate,

- or have a salary offer in sight more than 2.5 times the market's average.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by donw on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:14PM (#8299845)
Provided that the "solid consulting rate" isn't pure bullshit, then I don't see the problem here.

In a traditional hiring process, you'd be hired, not work out in the first month, and then get fired. No unemployment or ongoing insurance for the employee, and a lot of paperwork and the possibility of a wrongful termination lawsuit for the employer.

By starting things off on a contract, both the employer and the employee have a chance to evaluate one another. It's really exactly the same as the traditional hire-fire process, but with less paperwork, and clear expectations on both sides.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by kourt on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:14PM (#8300078)
Automattic, the creator of WordPress, the blog and website tool. Still, every hire, without exception, goes through a two- to six-week contract period, and is paid the standard rate of $25 an hour.

$25/hour: seriously?

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by jurassic on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:56PM (#8300256)
That seems ridiculously low for any software job. I've known design interns making almost double that in SF.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by exceptione on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:22PM (#8300109)
I don't have a very sharp view of the practices in the US. In The Netherlands it is possible that the employer and the applicant agree to a proof period of maximally 2 months in which both sides are able to terminate the contract.

It is also possible here to offer the applicant a temporary contract which can be renewed two times (for the same contract period). Both parties needs to keep to this contract, they can only end it on pre-negotiated terms. After two renewals of the contract the employer needs to let you go or your contract changes in a normal, non-temporary one.

I think these measures are more appropriate to deal with uncertainties about possible misfits? It makes sure both parties make a commitment for trying to make it fit as I see it.

I read something completely opposite here:

«Candidates get about three weeks of work to complete in a week — and not much guidance. “It’s ‘Here’s your desk and some people you should know,’ ” Mr. Rusenko said.»

I wonder if they could not improve their interviewing skills.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by nerfhammer on Thursday September 11, 2014 @10:46AM (#8302866)
> “We tell people to take a vacation, and we pay them,” he said. That way, if it does not work out, “you have one less week of vacation, but the next time you take a vacation it can be a nicer one.”

If I had 7 weeks vacation, maybe. Much less that you can basically only do a trial like this once a year, but spending half of your two weeks vacation a year might be worth a lot more than money.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by FLUX-YOU on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:20PM (#8299866)
>By starting things off on a contract, both the employer and the employee have a chance to evaluate one another. It's really exactly the same as the traditional hire-fire process, but with less paperwork, and clear expectations on both sides.

That's got to be compensation for New York not being a right-to-work state

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by FLUX-YOU on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:18PM (#8299860)
They make you do 3 weeks of work in the span of 1 week. Getting the work done is a hard criteria, so even if you only end up getting 2.5 weeks of work done, the company is still WAY ahead, and you've just spent your vacation time and the company spent a tiny amount of money. It would be one thing if they were testing you with work they've already done (build a module from scratch similar to what we did), but I have a feeling they're taking mostly completed stuff from the failures and using it in production. This is pretty much zero risk to the employer because at worse, they're just spending cash as if they were hiring a (more expensive) contractor

I think they're interested in actually hiring people, but it's a nice side effect that they get some low-cost work done (the article doesn't mention the pay, but I doubt they are compensating you what you make at your current position + intangibles for taking your vacation to work there). Another metric to look at would be whether this company is actually investing in their employees (paid training, conferences, new productivity tools, etc.). The trial period, supposed workload, and the hard criteria that you MUST complete the work is a huge red flag.

I guess it's a bit of cash in pocket for the unemployed though.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:21PM (#8299873)
Slightly offtopic: If you can abuse the working populace with this (due to economic conditions), its time for a basic income.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by FLUX-YOU on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:30PM (#8299907)
Slightly drunk offtopic: I'd rather just nuke my passport and head to some other less-insane country than try to fight for basic income in this country. Fans of basic income have some very optimistic hopes.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:36PM (#8299933)
Social security is a essentially an age-tested basic income. With enough software, robotics, and clean energy, its easily done (from a technical perspective).

Keywords for more research: "post scarcity", "historical productivity to wages"

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by georgemcbay on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:57PM (#8300016)
"Social security is a essentially an age-tested basic income."

Kind of irrelevant to the point regardless of whether the statement is correct because social security, if it did not already exist (but all other things were somehow still the same) would (incredibly unfortunately, IMO) have absolutely no hope of being instituted in this country either.

The US of 2014 is not the US of 1935.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by curun1r on Thursday September 11, 2014 @04:53PM (#8305077)
The US of 2014 doesn't have 25% unemployment. When we get back to that point, I think we'll develop more tolerance for socialist policies. And just in case anyone doesn't think our unemployment will get that high, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:01PM (#8300032)
Agreed.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:49PM (#8299980)
> Social security is a essentially an age-tested basic income.

No, its not. Benefit eligibility is driven primarily by previous contributions (either yours or, if you are relying on survivors benefits, someone else's), with various qualifying events. Its not (even leaving out the "age test") anything like BI, except in the extremely distant way any way that the government gives you money is "like" BI.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:52PM (#8299991)
Can you exhaust your social security? Is it an account? Or is it an entitlement that you have to qualify for (credits over a number of years) and then can continue to draw until death?
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:03PM (#8300036)
> Can you exhaust your social security?

No, no more than you can exhaust a purchased annuity. Which is also not like an age-tested BI.

> Or is it an entitlement that you have to qualify for (credits over a number of years) and then can continue to draw until death?

Right, so, exactly not like BI, which is equal and unconditional (even excluding consideration of the influence of age, since its specifically based on the amount of contributions, adjusted by the the wage index from the time they were earned, and then adjusted by the CPI from the time benefits started being drawn.

In a sense, its more of a retrospective reverse-means-tested benefit program, which makes it about as far from BI as you can be and still be a government benefit program at all.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by Afforess on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:29PM (#8299900)
Those two ideas are not even closely related.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:35PM (#8299927)
Perhaps I made a leap, as its a long discussion that could be had.

Would an employer be able to squeeze 3 weeks of work out of a potential candidate on their vacation unless the employee had no other choice? That to me is not how a labor market should function in a first-world country.

edit: /u/dismal2 said it much better

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by dismal2 on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:40PM (#8299952)
they are in the sense that with the way things are going, more and more risk, uncertainty, and costs are offloaded from employers to labor without ever giving anything in return
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by nostrademons on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:29PM (#8299899)
A bad fit between company and employee is a risk for both of them. If you institute a system that reduces the risk of such an outcome, it helps both of them, in proportion to how much they were risking in the first place. If it helps the employer more than the employee, it's because the employer was risking more in the first place. (Something I'm not sure of - I've turned down cofounder positions with startups because after working with them for a week I realized I didn't really like the other founders, and then ended up doing far better than the startup did.)

The main problems I see with it are:

1.) How to recruit from companies with restrictive IP covenants or moonlighting clauses. There's no way Google would've let me do something like this when I was working for them, for example, and most companies would like the option of hiring ex-Googlers if they're interested.

2.) It eliminates the ability to check out many options in parallel, which is essential for negotiating a fair wage as an employee. A company can "test drive" many possible employees at once; a person can generally only work for one effectively.

Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by arenaninja on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:20PM (#8299869)
I also don't get it. Don't most companies already apply a 3-month period where if you don't cut it you're fired? Every company I've worked for has, and only one failed to fire people (because no one wanted to work there and they'd rather have bad workers than no workers)
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by tobinfricke on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:25PM (#8299888)
Is a probationary period really meaningful in the context of at-will employment?
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by kyllo on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:37PM (#8299937)
Yeah, oftentimes you don't start getting benefits until it's over.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by rgrieselhuber on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:17PM (#8300090)
You'd be surprised at the amount of drama that occurs, regardless.
Re:Uncertain About Hiring, Some Companies Try ‘Test Drives’ by notJim on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:14PM (#8299846)
Yeah this seems really anti-worker to me. Sadly, the direction things seem to be predominantly going lately.