News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by mattkrea on Saturday September 06, 2014 @12:21PM (#8278690)
Did you remove the analytics piece the review seems to be complaining about? If so I can imagine that someone might be upset that they couldn't disable it.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by sanchitml on Saturday September 06, 2014 @12:34PM (#8278718)
Yes, removed it ages ago. Was trying this new analytics startup, never worked out though.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by tokenizerrr on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:35PM (#8278884)
I just installed your extension and looked at the source. The Google tracking/analytics code appears to still be there at least, both in popup.js (referenced by popup.html) and in jquery.js (which is apparently more than just jquery?). At least it seems that all you're tracking is behavioral info, but still it seems a bit much. Especially for an extension that calls itself private and secure.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by sanchitml on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:52PM (#8278951)
How should I mention that private & secure is about the 'note data', not how much time menu item was opened.

Also I enquired about the privacy issue in Google Analytics, only thing I got was: - "Google tracks that visit via the user's IP address in order to determine the user's approximate geographic location."

I am using is custom events. Lets say I do not use Google-Analytics but my own server who just record custom events (anonymized IP Addresses) then the app will be considered private and secure.

Read Privacy Issue section on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Analytics#Privacy_issues.

What I feel from all these is - it is justified to call the app secure as its about the user data, not anonymized behaviour analysis. That is only for app improvement, and independent of a particular person (ie. privacy).

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by tokenizerrr on Saturday September 06, 2014 @02:56PM (#8279138)
What I'm saying is that an app which claims to be secure & private should not be running any kind of analytics on user behavior in their browser.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by eps on Sunday September 07, 2014 @05:57AM (#8280690)
> Lets say I do not use Google-Analytics but my own server who just record custom events (anonymized IP Addresses) then the app will be considered private and secure.

Hahaha... No, of course it will not be. No app with phone-home analytics is private.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by ankitml on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:09AM (#8281326)
An app promising keeping your notes and note data private doesnt necessarily need to avoid analytics. Analytics and aggregate user data cant be avoided if a developer wants to improve user experience. Keeping users and their experience at the center isnt a bad thing. Your note data isnt logged to any servers in this app.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by tokenizerrr on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:28AM (#8281395)
I would not consider it private, at all, though. It's not privacy if every click you make is being monitored and analyzed.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by sanchitml on Sunday September 07, 2014 @12:38PM (#8281633)
Gathering aggregated and anonymized 'doesnot' hamper privacy.

If we look at any authentic reference (Ex: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Analytics#Privacy_issues) we will find only when an app associates behaviour-analytics with attributes such as IP Addresses and Geolocation data, it may debate privacy issues, otherwise not.

If you see the word 'privacy', it only activates when an individual is being talked about. There are no specific users on this app, no email id, no unique id. All requests are considered similar irrespective of origin.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by tokenizerrr on Sunday September 07, 2014 @12:55PM (#8281690)
Look, you're welcome to think what you think, but I've read the source code of your app and I am not comfortable using it, so I won't. Furthermore Google Analytics has access to the user's IP address, and even though it may not display it to you, Google still gets that information.

As for your claim of "no unique id", this is simply false. Google Analytics keeps track of an unique id for each user, they can tell you the count of unique visitors after all.

When you're boasting about privacy, do not track your users. What else are you meaning to imply with "privacy"? That the notes are not being sent to your server? Well, I goddamn hope so. Is there anything that makes your app more private than any other?

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by eps on Sunday September 07, 2014 @02:24PM (#8281938)
> Gathering aggregated and anonymized 'doesnot' hamper privacy.

To put it bluntly, I don't give a flying f%ck about this. You said "private" and then your app phoned home behind my back - you outright lied to me. There's one definition of privacy, doubly so for people who actually care about it, and it doesn't come with weasel caveats like yours. So that one star you got is wholly justified and you should really listen to what people here are telling you, because that's exactly the feedback you are not getting from people giving you 1 star in the Chrome store.

In the end it's all really simple - either remove analytics from the app or remove "private" from its description.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by hamster_nipples on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @06:07PM (#8293575)
> Your note data isnt logged to any servers in this app.

Analytics aggregate data are just the strawman. Note data WAS in fact being recorded from individual users and sent to Inspectlet servers.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by hamster_nipples on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @06:02PM (#8293546)
Your app is neither private nor secure. I saved the original version before you read my review. DevTools clearly shows it recording keystroke events. Just out of curiosity, why did your app also open a websocket connection to herokuapp.com?
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by samsheen on Saturday September 06, 2014 @03:03PM (#8279165)
I've seen loads of extensions that use Google Analytics to track user behavior. They of course post this on the details page with a link to the Opt-Out.

Could you tell us more about the "new analytics startup"? It seems like that's the code the reviewer was referring to (which you have said is no longer there in the extension)

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by sanchitml on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:01PM (#8278789)
I understand your apriori response, but there is a huge difference between analytics and keylogging. Analytics in app is a tool with which we provide better and better software to the end user. This has nothing to do with privacy.

Just like 10 out of 1000 people click on this button so I should remove it. 400 out of 1000 people use this feature, so I should improve it.

How about educating end users on the analytics vs privacy part.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by danprime on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:32PM (#8278875)
I noticed that Google has updated their privacy policy on using analytics https://developer.chrome.com/apps/analytics#privacy

It USED to read that you had to ask for opt-in permission BEFORE you began tracking (which is the current pattern my app follows, but how many other apps/extensions have I seen do this?.... 0).

In my app, upon install/launch it prompts the user with a popup asking if they would like to help the developer out by sending anonymous data. I made it opt-in (the user had to explicitly check the box). Out of a daily 4500 Active Users, I only have 4 people who opted in (it's less than 0.1% for those who don't want to do the math).

With the old policy of requiring user's permission to opt-in, it makes it really difficult for any developer (who follows the rules) to get any valid feedback. I've posted on the Google Group and Stack Overflow and the question is basically ignored because it's an open secret that most people simply treat it like any website analytics as in they embed the code to track and move on.

I currently follow the Firefox pattern/language choice:

[ ] Share performance, usage, hardware and customization data anonymously with the developer to help make ___ better. <<Learn More About Data Collected>>

TLDR; You'll get 0.1% compliance if you make data collection opt-in and you're upfront about data collection... it sucks because it makes the whole "Collect/Analyze Data" part of Development very difficult.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by goblin89 on Saturday September 06, 2014 @03:13PM (#8279187)
> I currently follow the Firefox pattern/language choice:

> [ ] Share performance, usage, hardware and customization data anonymously with the developer to help make ___ better. <<Learn More About Data Collected>>

IMO the wording is really important here. If I were to write this section of user preferences, I'd go for something like:

▸ Help improve X

Click on which expands the panel:

□ Allow collecting anonymized information about the usage of the application. It will be used for <reasons>. Only the following data will be sent to us over encrypted connection: <easy-to-understand list>. <<Learn more>>

(I know it's easy to give advice, though, and I don't have my own product on which to test copy ideas yet.)

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by gazarsgo on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:12PM (#8278822)
Fact: Recording user behavior most certainly is a privacy issue...

My opinion: ...and it should be both disclosed and opt-in.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by goblin89 on Saturday September 06, 2014 @03:03PM (#8279162)
> Fact: Recording user behavior most certainly is a privacy issue...

> My opinion: ...and it should be both disclosed and opt-in.

And, perhaps, avoided completely–once your shop has resources to spare for in-house testing and usability research.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by jdong on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:35PM (#8278880)
Fact: Recording user behavior is extremely common...

My opinion: ...and users shouldn't act surprised by it.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by ankitml on Saturday September 06, 2014 @02:15PM (#8279017)
Almost all websites have analytics these days. Agreed, it should be disclosed but making it opt-in would render analytics useless as less than 1% people would agree to it. Most analytics is not even a privacy issue as clickthroughs and bounce rates do not carry any personal fingerprints.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by aw3c2 on Saturday September 06, 2014 @03:01PM (#8279155)
i consider my IP address a personal detail as well as all the browser information that gets used as a fingerprint. The web would be a nicer place without all the analytics, I miss the 90s.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by findjashua on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:19PM (#8278844)
While analytics is pretty standard, I'd specify what information the app is sending home, and that it's a standard practice (as in almost every app/site sends this data).

I installed your extension, and it's fantastic - here's my 5 star review!

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by mrottenkolber on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:32AM (#8281417)
Analytics in a web browser extension... its just not a thing I can tolerate. Sorry.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by sanchitml on Sunday September 07, 2014 @12:56PM (#8281695)
It is as same as being in Mobile, you tolerate that?

IMHO all static websites have analytics, yes the HTML one's too. Browser extension need tools like analytics 100x more.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by mrottenkolber on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:29PM (#8282308)
No I don't tolerate analytics on my phone (thats just insane!).

None of my websites have analytics, and I feel violated by the ones that do. Especially newspaper websites are big offenders. I even go as far that my custom build web server does not have a log. I don't want to know who visits my website, in fact if I had a log I'd get rid of it like it was the plague.

Why don't you just ask your customers what they want? That's what I do, I believe I also get more accurate information that way.

Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by findjashua on Saturday September 06, 2014 @01:16PM (#8278835)
I don't think analytics is what you think it means. Analytics is NOT a key/screenshot logger. It's just sending data about what parts of the app the user is using, which can help you improve the app.
Re:Ask HN: My app is being bullied on Google webstore, What ... by mrottenkolber on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:35AM (#8281428)
Actually I am a software engineer. So I know pretty well what I am talking about.