News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @09:40AM (#8262923)
What happened to free market economy? How are americans totally fine with a company being denied its ability to sell its product to its end users?

What happened was: The car makers used their position of power over the dealerships - power they had as a result of the free market economy, more or less - to screw them over. The dealers fought back with custom legislation.

It's been this way for 70+ years now. The "free market economy," then as now, turns out to be its own worst enemy.

http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/09/04/dealers-choice-...

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by ericcope on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @10:56AM (#8263274)
The dealers chose to enact legislation rather than quit a business model that was being squeezed by their supplier. Find me a business that doesn't squeeze suppliers and vendors to increase their bottom line. The worst enemy of the free market isn't itself, its the crony capitalism that takes place when government gets involved. Its rare (if ever) that the intentions become the outcomes.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by sliverstorm on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @05:53PM (#8265679)
Find me a business that doesn't squeeze suppliers and vendors to increase their bottom line

Are you saying the dealers were not within their rights to fight back and defend their piece of the supply chain? Or are you saying that using legislation was "cheating"? I'm a little confused.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @11:32AM (#8263489)
I'd say this is an almost perfect example of intentions becoming outcomes, actually.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by randyrand on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:53PM (#8263964)
huh?
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @03:01PM (#8264663)
The intention was to suppress competition, and it worked.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by randyrand on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:45PM (#8263901)
> It's been this way for 70+ years now. The "free market economy," then as now, turns out to be its own worst enemy.

You have it backwards. The problem that we have today is a result of not letting the free market be free 70+ years ago. The article you link to says GM "forced" dealers into buying their cars during recessions despite having little chance of selling them. Bologna! They didn't force anything! The dealers had zero obligation to buy their cars. What should have happened is we should have let the free market destroy those dealers. Destroy the dealers that bought cars without being able to sell them.

And you know what? You know what would have happened if all of GM's dealers went out of business after being "forced" to buy their cars. GM would die! Good! GM needed it's dealers to sell their cars. It's a balancing act that the free market easily could have handled but the dealers and legislators took the selfish way out. We would have had direct car sales decades ago if it wasn't for anti-free-market legislation.

The moral of the story, let the free market be free and avoid the shit show that will always without fail happen as a result. (See: Uber)

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @01:12PM (#8264086)
You have it backwards. The problem that we have today is a result of not letting the free market be free 70+ years ago.

Well, okay, but absent a time machine, you can't fix that. Any solution that starts with "well you should have thought of that before" has already failed. Mistakes happen; a system that can't tolerate mistakes is a system designed to fail.

And in this case, it was the actors within the market (the dealers) that decided to make the market less free. They did it out of their own perfectly rational self-interest, and damn the consequences. Something like that is always happening, will always be happening. The "free market" is always full of actors working to make it less free.

Bologna! They didn't force anything! ... GM needed it's dealers to sell their cars.

"Do what I want, or face an existential threat" is pretty much the dictionary definition of "force." The big auto makers were able to do this sort of cram-down because they apparently didn't value their dealers.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by randyrand on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @02:17PM (#8264442)
Well, okay, but absent a time machine, you can't fix that. Any solution that starts with "well you should have thought of that before" has already failed. Mistakes happen; a system that can't tolerate mistakes is a system designed to fail.

Sounds like a great ad for more free-market solutions ;)

"Do what I want, or face an existential threat" is pretty much the dictionary definition of "force."

I'll concede that point, but the whole point of a free market is that you can't force anyone to do anything. If a deal isn't mutually beneficial then people don't agree to it. Simple as that. I use "force" everyday when I continue to not buy products from companies I don't like and help drive them towards change or extinction.

Sure, some people have more leverage than others, that is always the case. But that doesn't matter.

You're biggest mistake is thinking that it is bad when one party has a lot of say over another party (like McDonald's over their cashiers). It's not. That's called cutting out the middle man. If I can continue to do business without the little guys, or only need a few little guys anymore, I'm going to negotiate a less favorable deal with them or cut them out entirely. This is what drives progress. Eventually the big guy no longer needs the little guy, great! Cheaper products for everyone! As the big guy has more say, and it becomes worse to be a little guy, the little guys leave. A balance is reached. This is how free-markets operate. Creative destruction always hurts some people, but in the end we all prosper (when robots take all our jobs social assistance is necessary but the point stands)

Do you think GM would have negotiated such a bad deal with the dealers if the tables weren't beginning to turn in GM's favor? Of course not!

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @03:51PM (#8265017)
...the whole point of a free market is that you can't force anyone to do anything ... That's called cutting out the middle man.

But not forcing out the middle man, no, never that.

Sure, some people have more leverage than others, that is always the case. But that doesn't matter.

Why would a rational adherent to free-market principles lift a finger to obtain the leverage in the first place, if it "doesn't matter?"

Do you think GM would have negotiated such a bad deal with the dealers...

Not sure what deal you're talking about. The dealership franchise laws were not a "deal" that was "negotiated." They were, ahem, something the dealers forced on the auto makers.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by randyrand on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @04:45PM (#8265373)
1. meh, semantics. Unless they force them out by law, which is no longer a free market by definition. Also, for clarification, the dealers are the middle men. They were not forced out. Quite the opposite. They are now forced in.

2. Doesn't matter in terms of morality, not in terms of best business practices.

3. The deal that said "buy our cars now in the recession or we won't sell anymore to you in the future." not the law that resulted: "manufacturers must by law sell to any official dealer and cannot sell directly"

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @02:22PM (#8264461)
> Creative destruction always hurts some people, but in the end we all prosper.

Er, no. The first and second parts of this sentence contradict each other. The people that are hurt -- often fatally -- do not prosper.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @01:53PM (#8264322)
> "Do what I want, or face an existential threat" is pretty much the dictionary definition of "force."

No person faced an existential threat from that. Businesses on the other hand face existential threats all the time. Every time you don't buy something from a business you are, by you definition using "force" against them because they could go out of business without customers.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @03:23PM (#8264780)
No person faced an existential threat from that.

Corporations are people, my friend.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by kordless on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @10:55AM (#8263269)
I believe 'levers of power' arise by entities exploiting simple liberties which are given and assumed in a free economy. Once those liberties are hedged and protected from use by others, we scramble around trying to figure out how to get the lever away from the entity who holds it.

Monkeys with sticks and rocks, if you will.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by ericcope on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @11:13AM (#8263375)
I like the metaphor... whats interesting is the people complaining about the monkeys with sticks and rocks were the ones who gave the monkeys the sticks and rocks and now are sore about it.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by dmix on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @10:57AM (#8263278)
The problem is the state is for sale to the mega-corporations at the top of each industry. Laws and protection rackets are instated as you can see in the car dealer industry which is heavily regulated.

This isn't free markets eating itself, it's the dangerous hazards of mixing free markets with an over-bearing state, that modern economies have chosen as the primary operating model. Aka Neoliberalism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism

It ultimately results in: you can have a free market, but after you get to a certain size you have to have friends within the state.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by WalterSear on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @11:46AM (#8263565)
The solution to the entrenchment that comes, in time, to every free market, is more free market. Got it.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @01:56PM (#8264337)
Your comment sounds sarcastic, but I don't see anything strange about the statement that the solution to problems of a constrained market is to make it more free.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by WalterSear on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @05:28PM (#8265565)
Entrenchment is, to unfettered capitalism, what the tragedy of the commons is to libertarianism.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @11:39AM (#8263522)
This isn't free markets eating itself, it's the dangerous hazards of mixing free markets with an over-bearing state, that modern economies have chosen...

Dude. You've just described free markets eating themselves.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @02:19PM (#8264452)
Most people don't consider government intervention an act of the free market.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @03:44PM (#8264941)
In this case the "intervention" was at the behest of the actors within the market itself. But somehow it magically doesn't count as an act of the market?
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @04:17PM (#8265218)
Behest is the key word there. We are not talking actions of actors within the market, but about government interfering with market forces. That does not cease to be the case just because someone asked them to do it.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by sliverstorm on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @05:57PM (#8265704)
But if the government was formed by the market actors, and is composed of market actors, and is directed by market actors, are the actions of the government not the market acting on itself?
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @10:13PM (#8266453)
The government is not part of the market. We do not choose whether or not the government has authority over us, it just does. There is no competition, no _market_ there. Without that distinction I cannot think of anything that would qualify as outside of the market and the term would become meaningless.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by randyrand on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:59PM (#8263997)
mixing free markets with an over-bearing state

That is by definition not a free market. A pure free market has no regulation. Free markets don't exist in the United States.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by dredmorbius on Saturday September 06, 2014 @12:03PM (#8278638)
Many, you really are your own self-parody, aren't you.

Have you even read Smith?

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by Lagged2Death on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @03:56PM (#8265073)
Free markets don't exist in the United States.

Well hey now there's always the crystal meth market.

Crystal meth being the vile stuff that no true Scotsman would ever use.

Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by seanflyon on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @05:19PM (#8265519)
The illegal drug market is dramatically constrained by government interference.
Re:Georgia dealers want Tesla store shuttered for selling to... by angersock on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:32PM (#8263826)
No, that's not quite it. Read it again.